Canned Artichokes Deserve Your Respect

Feb 10, 2020 · 44 comments
Jerrie (Leawood)
I thought this was delicious ! I think a key is to thoroughly cook the onion and then the artichoke hearts so to,brown them in the pan before you add the wine and then chicken . We thought it was very flavorful !
Victoria (US)
I added lemon juice and had to bake the chicken 15-20 minutes longer than recipe said.
Kathy Miller (NYC)
Frozen artichoke hearts are best, jarred work if you can’t get frozen. Add some crumbled sausage with the chicken, it makes the sauce even richer. And throw in some halved small potatoes for a complete meal in one dish.
Pat (Colorado Springs CO)
No sane person needs to trim an artichoke. You just steam them and pull off the tougher leaves. Serve with lemon butter, or in my case, curried mayonnaise. I occasionally buy jarred artichokes. Good Heavens, not canned.
James Franco (USA)
@Pat We LOVE artichokes, but the canned artichokes just taste like, well, the can. Its a very unnatural chemical taste.
Jeannie (San Antonio,TX)
I used to trim the leaves on fresh artichokes. Then while at my brother's home, he just boiled them as is. The thorns softened and were not even noticeable. I like your recipe and will try it this coming week. I prefer frozen artichokes, as they are crunchier and less likely to fall apart than canned ones. Thanks for sharing.
Melissa (Boston)
Huh. I have never felt a need to trim an artichoke. I buy the freshest, heaviest-looking looking ones -- often they're great at this time of year -- and just cut the stem to about 1 inch. I put them stem down in a pot that's the right size to keep them all standing upright. I use a coffee cup in the middle if necessary to keep them standing up around the sides. I put water in the pot to reach 1/3 of the way up the artichokes, put a lid on, and simmer them for about 45 minutes or an hour, until a fork plunged up into the middle of the stem goes in very easily. I drain them upside down. When cool, we start with the outside leaves, pluck them, dip them in a rich balsamic vinaigrette, and scrape the meat off each leaf with our teeth. Remove the choke, dip the stem, and consider yourself lucky! It could not be simpler.
Pat (Colorado Springs CO)
@Melissa That is a totally excellent recipe.
Chuck (Florida)
Respect? Please. They don't even taste like artichokes. If you want taste keep a few packages of the frozen artichoke hearts in the freezer and use them. You'll enjoy them much more.
Eric (Toledo)
Trader Joe’s has jarred grilled artichokes that are delicious. You can use them in so many different ways and the oil they are packed in can be used as well.
Wordsworth from Wadsworth (Mesa, Arizona)
You know, "out of a can" turns off some gourmands. But the canning process is an advantage sometimes in regards to artichokes, pumpkin, beans, etc. The heat of canning takes away some of the stringy fiber, toughness, etc. I like fresh, but go with canned things sometimes. However, as others have mentioned, the Trader Joe's frozen artichokes are superior. I don't know why their purveyors are better than most of corporate America with its wretched food supply, but it is so. People grow artichokes in gardens here in Arizona. Sometimes there is too much heat, not enough water. You have to be lucky with the timing. One year my girlfriend's garden yielded a nice-sized, tender artichoke. It was the absolute best vegetal matter ever to hit my palate.
Paulette (San Juan Islands, WA)
This sounded so good, I made it last night. The sauce was a bit bland, maybe because of the canned artichokes, which fell apart and turned mushy. Will try frozen next time. I added whole garlic cloves precooked in a little chicken broth, and a small chunk of feta which disappeared into the sauce and brightened the whole thing up. Quite good.
CTNYC (CT)
Look for artichoke bottoms.
Carmela Sanford (Niagara Falls, New York)
I love artichokes, but I always joke that I don’t like a food that fights back. Fresh artichokes are a pain to pare. I switched to frozen artichokes some years ago. I use either Whole Foods 365 brand or Trader Joe’s, although I prefer the Whole Foods selection. The chokes are firmer and fresher tasting. I use artichokes two ways. One way is in a quick pasta sauce made with olive oil, a couple of anchovies, and fresh cut-up fennel. The only seasoning is Italian sea salt and chopped fennel fronds. I boil the chopped fennel to slightly soften it. I use that fennel water as part of the pot of the pasta water. I never over-salt pasta water, adding only a pinch of sea salt. I never use kosher salt as it’s overrated and only ubiquitous because of a professional marketing campaign that is absurd. Kosher salt is for TV chefs. Too much salt is also for TV chefs, especially that bubbly small New York woman with a syndicated morning show and her own line of colorful cookware. Her excessive use of salt in everything is dangerous to your health. To add some color, I finely chop a few inches of yellow bell pepper and add them to the cooking process. I also make chicken with white wine and artichokes. It’s cooked in the oven. I use split skinless, boneless breasts. For fat, I add some dabs of unsalted butter. A pinch or two of sea salt enhances the flavor of this 5-ingredient dish.
Ayse Gilbert (Anchorage)
Ok. I grew up in artichoke country. Monterey. No no no on canned. Search out frozen. I stack them like cordwood in the freezer and when the craving hits for these little mineral bombs they are ready to use. But I agree that the recipe sounds great.
Amy
How very disappointing! Canned artichokes are absolutely awful, mushy and taste only of the can. If you can't be bothered with fresh ones, frozen artichokes are a much better option.
mm (SoCal)
@Amy Rinse them first.
Ancient (Western NY)
Precious beans? Have I missed a new fad?
Emma (Denis)
I was asking myself the exact same question !
CTNYC (CT)
Could you substitute canned artichoke bottoms? They aren’t as easy to find. They are my new go to for risotto and salads. Bet it would be as good here.
persona (New York)
There are three foods that, for unknown reasons, I will suddenly and unaccountably be seized by an intense craving for. Dried seaweed, chopped chicken liver, and artichoke hearts. Individually, and not in a dish. These cravings arose over a space of a few years, and it took a while to identify the objects. Now that I've identified them, I keep them on hand. The first is easy. I always have a bag of dried seaweed in the cabinet. Artichoke is available canned or as marinated hearts, pate or spread. Chopped chicken liver requires a little prior planning, but I live in NYC so no problem. There are many things I love more (eg, avocados, apples with cheese, pad thai). But I've never had a visceral craving for them. I wonder if it's something chemical.
Miss Dovey (Oregon Coast)
Awesome. Just the excuse I need to buy canned / jarred artichokes and a bottle of white wine ;-) Already have some thighs in the fridge. We have used both canned and frozen artichokes. Canned are useful due to long shelf life and limited freezer storage. They are great on a pizza or even in a composed salad. Also, chicken fat, schmicken fat -- it's all schmaltz to me!
Tuvw Xyz (Evanston, Illinois)
@ Miss Dovey Oregon Coast As an addict of fresh artichokes, I wonder what are the advantages of canned or jarred? We have ours boiled, the petals or bracts detached by hand, and then dipped into a mix of mayonnaise, a bit of olive oil, a pinch of mustard, and black pepper.
Paul G (Portland OR)
Anything canned should be avoided. If not fresh then maybe frozen. But can interior coatings are harmful to your endocrine system. Corporate industry scientists will tell you there’s no more BPA. But BPA’s replacement(s) are showing much the same harm. It’s the phenols. Do Not Believe Corporate Scientists!
David Currier (Hawaii)
@Paul G I think you are probably right. The headlines of our papers are full of stories about tens of thousands of Americans dying last week from eating commercially canned food.
Bruce (Detroit)
Artichokes are one of the few canned vegetables (along with tomatoes) that I use. I keep a few cans in my pantry. I use them often in fritattas, but the recipe in this article looks very good too.
Rob D (Rob D NJ)
Frozen artichokes are the way to go
Amanda (Alexandria, VA)
I'm a big fan of artichokes in glass jars. Especially really, really big jars.
James (San Francisco)
Absolutely NO WAY on canned artichokes. Frozen are superior for pantry cooking. The metallic flavor of the can and the liquid in the can are not acceptable.
brutallyfrank (New York, NY)
@James I agree. Why use canned when there are frozen. They are so much better and so reasonable at Trader Joe's.
Suzanne F (Upper Upper Manhattan)
@James, @brutallyfrank Maybe frozen artichokes are reasonably priced at Trader Joe's, but TJ is not everywhere: only in 42 states plus DC, and in many of those states in only one or a small number of the big cities. Should people drive hundreds of miles just for frozen artichokes? Even here in NYC, I have trouble finding frozen artichokes in major supermarkets, and it's a trek via subway to a TJ. But canned foods, even with their faults, are ubiquitous. And with the other flavorful ingredients, I daresay few people would be able to taste the difference.
Heidi Menocal (Annapolis, MD)
My local grocery store(s) stopped carrying frozen artichokes about 2 years ago. I have no choice but canned.
Toni (NJ)
Ali, I am kind of obsessed with artichokes. And I love, love, love the canned variety. When I'm feeling decadent, I'll make almost this exact dish and add a little lemon and heavy cream with extra garlic. Heaven! But hear me out - frozen artichokes are the bomb. The texture is more like the real thing (Im sure you know this already) and I recently discovered roasting them with a little olive oil, salt and pepper until crispy and then dipping them in a balsamic mayo dip. Thanks for bringing the the oft-considered-fussy artichoke to the conversation today!
Miami MIch (Miami)
This looks delicious! but why do all chicken recipes have to have chicken thighs and/or chicken with the skin on? This makes the dish less healthy. I'd love to see how to make a chicken breast juicy and delicious!
A (W)
@Miami MIch Recipes almost always call for chicken with fat because chicken without fat isn't nearly as tasty. FWIW, it doesn't actually make it any less "healthy," though it does add to the calories obviously. Usually making chicken breast tasty involves adding fat, at which point the question becomes why not just start with the tasty chicken fat instead of replacing it?
Randy (SF, NM)
@Miami MIch If you want it juicy and delicious, you'll want to leave the skin on. Or buy a sous vide. I nearly always cook skin-on, but I never eat it.
Bruce (Detroit)
@Miami MIch Medical research has shown that animal fat is generally healthy. Some types of animal fat raise Pattern A LDL cholesterol, but Pattern B LDL is the type associated with cardiovascular disease. There are some issues with omega-6 fatty acids that are found in poultry, and you might want to consume plenty of omega-3 fatty acids (found in fatty fish, egg yolks, walnuts, and flax seeds) to balance out the omega-6 fatty acids in the chicken.
Tuvw Xyz (Evanston, Illinois)
Thanks to Ms. Roman for reminding the readers of the importance of wine in cooking. Any meat made with wine is better than one made without it, even petestrian-proletarian chicken.
Rich (mn)
@Tuvw Xyz I beg to differ. A dry-aged rib-eye, grilled medium rare over a charcoal or wood fire, needs nothing more than a little salt and maybe pepper. Though we use a lot of wine when cooking, sometimes less is more.
Marge Keller (Midwest)
I am always on the lookout for a quick yet delicious and nutritious evening meal, especially after working 10 hour days every week. This article and recipe for “Wine-Braised Chicken With Artichoke Hearts” seems perfect for what I am looking for. The photos included are so captivating, I can practically smell those fragrant artichoke hearts and onions sizzling in the pan while the wine and thyme are slowly added. Thanks for the suggestion Ms. Roman!
Tuvw Xyz (Evanston, Illinois)
Hmm ... Canned artichokes? I always laugh that in the 21st century two foods have to be still handled with the fingers: detaching the petals or bracts of big boiled artichokes, and shelling shrimp cooked in the shells.
Robert (Mexico)
I very much enjoy finding recipes in my on-line subscription to the New York Times. This is one that I would like to try but, alas, the New York Times, for which I already pay a subscription price and, if it were a news-paper I would have the recipe in my hand, wants to charge me an EXTRA $5 per month to read a recipe.
Gale W (New Haven)
@Robert And I just received a email from the NYT that they are raising the digital subscription rate by $8/month - which I will pay because I cannot imagine life w/o the Times - but also paying another $5 for Cooking? May have to rethink it.
Elaine (Washington DC)
@Gale W Check and see if your local library has a subscription to the digital edition. I guess newspapers are getting like healthcare. Apparently my feet, eyes and teeth are not part of my body and need their own insurance plan :(