Sorry, but I don't see a path forward for Bernie with these new health problems.
396
@Joe
One path forward would be to back out and throw his support to another candidate instead of prolonging the divisions within the party. Some of his supporters did not get behind Clinton after he lost the nomination. If he gets out now, there is a chance that they will support someone else and not sit at home allowing Trump to win again.
38
@ExPatMX: Ah yes, the persistent myth of the recalcitrant Sanders voters. Look back at the news from 2016. You will see that over 58% of Trump voters did not support him, they just voted for him to eliminate the return of the Clintons. That, as you may recall, was the choice.
Further, all polls showed that any republican would have beaten Clinton. It just happened to be Trump. This time, Trump is not running against a Clinton so if democrats get it together they have a solid shot at the White House. And Trump must know it.
But keep on blaming the Sanders voters and see what that gets you.
https://emcphd.wordpress.com
23
@Joe
I totally trust Bernie's judgment.
I know people going strong twenty years after a heart attack and stents.
I hope Bernie chooses to remain a candidate.
He is the only candidate I trust not to cave to Establishment pressures.
23
Stay in the race long enough to get a few more summer homes, Bernie.
2
@Season smith
Are you completely unaware of the income and net worth of the other candidates (and other Senators)? Bernie stands out, in comparison... but not in the way you're implying.
5
And now Sanders says he won't slow down.
https://www.nytimes.com/aponline/2019/10/09/us/politics/ap-us-election-2020-sanders.html
After a heart attack? Brilliant. Sounds like he doesn't have sense enough to come in out of the rain.
https://emcphd.wordpress.com
1
If Bernie is willing to go out with a bang who are we to say, "No, Pops, you need to take care of yourself and maximize your chance of living as long as medically possible." IMO, Bernie and others like him are genuinely concerned about the welfare of MANY people - concern for personal risk floats away, as it often does for parents. And isn't this is a good thing?
4
He's still got my vote! I hope he finds an even more radical VP candidate and not a centrist to "balance" the ticket. Keep going Bernie!
2
@Adam Benedetto
Right on. A centrist with views acceptable to BOTH the democratic and republican party establishments would be a horrible choice in America today, where about half the voting public is affiliated with neither one. IMO, the country is actually looking for someone who is not acceptable to EITHER party, like Bernie... or Tulsi Gabbard.
2
I will not change my vote for Bernie. BTW his doctor said it wasn't a heart attack it was angina caused by a blockage in a artery. The stents will take care of that problem and if he keeps a less grueling pace he will be fine.
Dick Chaney is still going strong and he had several real heart attacks.
2
Whatever he ultimately decides, I hope he takes the time he needs for himself and to mourn the death in his family and be with loved ones.
2
And who better to present a balanced narrative on Bernie Sanders, the hero of the working class, Sydney Ember of course, the daughter of Hollywood royalty married to a financier whose father is CEO of Bain Capital and who was herself an employee of Blackstone. I’m sure it will be presented in its usual condescending manner and I’m equally sure this won’t get posted.
6
@Ted
They only posted it to prove your last sentence wrong. But they can't do much about the rest of it, being facts and all.
3
I am a conservative and would not vote for Senator Sanders or any other Democratic candidate. I am writing as someone who has had two stents without any heart attack in the course of fifteen years.
Senator Sanders, at seventy-nine or eighty, is too old to assume the presidency. Moreover, the public currently has no knowledge of how much myocardial damage Senator Sanders may or may not have sustained.
Many people minimize or ignore cardiac symptoms, and these unwitting self-deceptions lead cause them to have heart attacks. Chest or arm pain or severe shortness of breath on minimal exertion never should be discounted until thoroughly investigated.
The Democrats are a study in political disaster. They all thought they could get away with a flawed, unappealing candidate running a sloppy campaign against an inexperienced buffoon in 2016. No need to revisit that debacle, though some may wish for it. Their front-runner now either can’t remember exactly what he stands for or doesn’t want us to remember. The alternatives are socialists who promise higher taxes to pay for things most Americans don’t want or a crowd of wanna-bees who have only relative youth and self-proclaimed achievement to recommend them. Not that the Republicans are any better. They’re making this a horse race by clinging to Trump in the vain hope he will turn out to be what they hoped for in ‘16, despite manifest evidence to the contrary. I fear we’re in for four more years of destructive leadership, no matter which side wins.
3
I would take Bernie with a health risk and a solid VP (certain to be younger and more progressive and full of fire than any other candidates or their VPs) over any of the others, any day- Because of what he stands for, health care as a human right, and his understanding of power trumping any "plan", which is why you need to build a movement not a brand. And many feel the same.
4
Sanders is a good guy; however, I hope he turns his support over to someone we can be confident in completing the term. I believe the choice of VP is important for all the leading Candidates. Hope it isn't Booker. Should be someone who can turn a Red State.
1
I'm curious what percentage of the people who never intended to vote for Bernie and who are now deeply concerned about his welfare are being disingenuous to the point of fooling themselves. It's easier to deal with people who know they're being phony, say, like Trump.
3
@carl bumba
So having compassion is being disingenuous? I can have concern for someone even though I'm not voting for them. I can respect Bernie's contributions even though I don't think he's right for the presidency. Some of us have more more complex views. We aren't so cynical as to question the motives of people, just because they aren't voting the way we do. And you want denial? My Bernie supporting friends think a 78-year old man having a heart attack is no big deal, and he'll just bounce back. The funny part is I seem to be more worried about Senator Sanders' health than my friends who support him. All they want is for him to get back in the race.
@ajbown
No. If I thought is was 100% why would I be curious? I'm guessing about half the people here who don't intend to vote for him are genuinely concerned about his welfare. It's the other half expressing condolences a little too enthusiastically that worry me.
Do you really think you are more sympathetic with this man than most of those who would like him as their president? If not, why bring up the few that have odd personal motives?
2
I wonder when DJT is going to sharpen his knives and start attacking. The fact that he hasn't already done so indicates he's got other things on his mind.
Sanders and Biden are too old. Period. Warren is not. She'll get the nomination, including Sanders' endorsement (and Biden's, eventually). Next time (2024), age will be an issue for Warren too, but it's not this time (2020). Age is an issue this time for Sanders and Biden, however: They're just too old. That was clear a year ago, and it's true now.
2
Warren would be older than Biden is now if she were elected, by her 4th year in office.
God forbid anyone actually talks about the significant difference between Sanders, Warren and Biden.
73 and over too old! 70-74 just fine!
1
@Jen
Good point. They should at least say Bernie WILL be too old. (But this is probably not the real issue.)
2
As highly as I think of this brave warrior Bernie Sanders, I think more highly of saving his life.
As such, I feel he should consider his family, his loved ones, his supporters and most of all HIS OWN LIFE ... and call it a day!
5
I don't really see what the problem is here. Even if things take a turn for the worse, it's not like Bernie is going to pick a VP that doesn't agree with him...
4
Senator Sanders is a man of parts:
> He is a Healer in spirit, deeply troubled by the deceptions that promote the dysfunctions in our culture and committed to combating those maladies.
> He is a Teacher from the Socratic school, challenging us to acknowledge the facts of reality, and draw upon our better instincts to pass judgement on the blatant deceptions that infect us.
But most impressive is what he is NOT; a politician in any of the usual characteristics and practices of that role. He does campaign but instead of promoting himself, he talks about the rights and wrongs of critical issues, seeking the peoples' support for rational cultural cohesion. He rails against and rejects the favor of big shots, big money and the quid pro quo corruptions that involves.
And, throughout his long track record, I've sensed the very unique, counter-intuitive nature of his ambition. I don't believe he has ever expected - or wanted - to become President. His candidacy has simply served to expand the forum for his message; to restore our bond as One People, with Liberty and Justice for all. Statistical results indicate that is working.
Now, with the heartfelt thanks of an awakening people, the good Senator has earned a restful, restorative retirement as friend and emeritus counselor to those good souls who will carry on.
2
Berney, drop out now! You can't win.
All you will do is split the vote like you did last time and give trump four more years to solidify his status as dictator for life who is above the law.
Berney, if you love this country endorse one of the other candidates and move to the sidelines so we can win this and save American democracy.
1
@Daisy
Huh...he did just that last primary didn't he.
He set a record for a primary candidate stumping on behalf of the nominee. 41 events across the nation, in more states and cities than HRC did for herself. Over 80% of his primary voters went over to HRC; despite her and her supporters (such as yourself?) saying she didn't need them. Of the 12% that went to Trump, less than 5% were Dems, the others being Repub, or Indys leaning Red studies tell us. 3% stayed home. All of those numbers are better than Dems over all in the general. Where some 92 million stayed home. That was HRC, her campaign and the DNC's job; to GET OUT THE VOTE~! She, they failed at that. Over 10 million Dems/DINO's flipped to Trump. A number vastly larger than the 5% of Sanders primary flippers. Yet you and your ilk never mention them. How come?
Easier to blame and punch down and Left?! Rather than dare look to your own/Right?!
Tell you what, just like last time, Sanders polls better head to head against Trump than most other candidates. How about they all drop out for the good of the country?~! How about YOU compromise for once in....ever?!
Sanders has the most small donors, the most individual donations and the largest cadre of volunteers and the most diverse cohort.
Seems a huge active base thinks Sanders CAN win.
Just like last time.
If you love this country, endorse Sanders and move the other candidates to the sidelines so we can win this and save American Democracy.
Hmm...?
3
I am grateful for the concern that some of Bernie's supporters have in wanting him to quit. However heart problems are very transparent and now he has a clean bill of health. The last four Presidents, including this one, have had health issues, histories, concerns or habits that the media has rightfully put under the microscope. At least Bernie didn't lie about his height to cover an obesity issue.
1
I will continue to support Bernie. He's amazing, and I continue to believe the only candidate that can beat Trump. Besides, this is why the VP pick is so important ... none of us are guaranteed tomorrow
2
Sanders at 75% is probably like the others at 100% - and this is only quantitative.
3
My guess: Hillary Clinton will emerge to try again. I thought this last year and the year before, and last month, and I think it now.
The thought was predicated on something happening to dim the chances of Biden (in my view.) So I'd not be surprised to see Clinton pull back the stage curtain and march into the limelight.
And, when you boo the idea, please don't blame me. But what could be more dramatic than the avenging candidate redux?
3
Are you aware there were no presidential elections last year and the year before? Stop obsessing about Clinton as if she were some kind of boogeyman. She said she's done and she is. Give the poor woman a break.
@hotGumption
I would not be in the least bit shocked if she decided to get in—especially if Biden’s health, both mental and physical continue to raise questions. Ambition like hers does not die easily.
Elizabeth Warren is anathema to the power elite as is Bernie Sanders. The rest of the field have not proven their fealty to the masters of the universe.
I hope she doesn’t get in but there are plenty of people many of them very influential who would see her as a safer bet than say Buttigieg or Klobuchar.
3
@Brooklyncowgirl
Agree! With all you say!
And I've been a big fan of Klobuchar.
1
Whatever happens from here, let's stop for a moment and acknowledge the debt of gratitude America owes to Senator Sanders. His 2016 campaign woke America up to the corruption and lack of fairness that permeates government and society. Without question, Sanders pave the way for Elizabeth Warren's success. Sanders has been a much-needed example of a genuine politician who fights for everyday Americans. During his 2016 campaign, all those videos started to surface of Sanders raking people like corporate executives and regulators over the coals with barely anyone watching or reporting about it. He was not putting on a show for the cameras. He was standing up for Americans. And just watch this video of Bernie and rapper Killer Mike: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EHps9UsJsko. I wish things had turned out different.
5
HRC was famously a 'no-show' on the campaign trail the last six months before election day, especially having disappeared from said trail, post-convention. Bernie and Michelle Obama were out daily and weekly stumping for the MIA candidate. There are worse things than a post-cardiac, elderly candidate.
3
Please please please drop out now and back another viable candidate. You are done -- folks will be looking at your VP to replace you. Please don't do what you did in the last and hang on like a spoiled child and refuse to back Hillary and thus send your supporters to Trump. Please leave now and resume your Senatorial work where you can do the most good.
2
@BlackJackJacques
As if a politician has control over what and who voters chose?! That makes zero sense. It also denies the 41 record rallies/stumps Sanders held on behalf of HRC. In more states and cities than HRC did for herself in that time period.
Sanders admitted that after the April 26 primaries that he was mathematically eliminated (the Dem practice of allowing formally unpledged superdelegates to vote for a nominee makes such determinations inexact), dropping out and endorsing Clinton two months later, a couple of weeks after she clinched a majority of delegates. This is typical behavior for eliminated candidates.
In the '16 R. primary Kasich was eliminated in March and Cruz was eliminated on April 19, but both stayed in the race until after Trump clinched the nomination on May 3.
In the '12 R primary both Ron Paul and Gingrich stayed in the race well after they were mathematically eliminated.
In the '08 Dem primary, Clinton herself was eliminated from winning a majority of pledged delegates sometime in early April. However, she stayed in the race through late June, endorsing Obama after he clinched the nomination on the last day of the primary season.
So, Sanders behaved exactly as many other eliminated primary challengers, including Clinton herself. Blaming a loss on normal behavior is disingenuous and, in this case, hypocritical.
By the by...do you blame Hillary for the 10 million Dems that flipped to Trump? Why not? That number is easily 10>1 over Berns.
3
The eminent psychologist Dr. Timothy Leary (yes, there was much more to him than the drug mythology) famously noted that the signals in most human communications consist of:
1) I'm still here. Are you still there?
2) The hive is proceeding as usual. Nothing has changed.
This comment section is riddled with these exact messages.
https://emcphd.wordpress.com
3
I voted for Bernie in the 2016 primaries, and entered this cycle with high hopes for Bernie yet again. However, as the race has unfolded, I have found myself drawn to Warren as well. And this issue, unfortunately, cements it for me. Although I have tremendous respect for Bernie and all he has accomplished, I believe I will be voting for Warren this time around.
2
@Brian
Before the cement dries you might want to google some of Tulsi Gabbards interviews, like with Stenen Colbert.
3
I’m a physician and I’ve really enjoyed watching Bernie and thinking of his ideas as a possibility for our future.
However, I do think it’s time for him to bow out. He may never have another cardiac event, but statistics are just not in his favor vs a candidate (of any age) that hasn’t had a recent heart attack.
I admit to discriminating against candidates based on their current health status. I’d like to see him move on and throw his support to another candidate, but that’s not ageism, it’s “healthism”.
4
@JJ
But isn't this semantics because the two are so correlated?
And, anyway, don't you mean "physical healthism". (Physicians are actually more reductionist than the scientists who give them their information.)
1
The many people suggesting that Bernie needs to just endorse someone else seem to be missing a critical point: any such actual endorsement would be for the policy agenda that other candidates have on on offer. This makes the prospect of his supporters simply switching allegiance much more complicated.
For me, no other candidate is signaling how very seriously the collective re-investment of resources needs to be, if we are to actually have some hope of restoring the ecological balance required to stave off unimaginable catastrophe in our ongoing Climate Crisis.
I actually have shopped around a bit with the entire Democratic primary field, and after viewing Mayor Pete's stark lack of legislative record and Senator Warren's applause for the bloated military budget and dovetailed focus on "greening" the military, only Bernie remains as the candidate who apologetically speaks to the mass movement of people and capital needed to re-orient our vision and actions toward actual viability.
Does it not send an even clearer message, that so many young people are still ready to trust this esteemed elder as the one who respects and will enable their generational aspirations?
9
He will not be the nominee, now, but he will not have a voice in the way that he has if he quits campaigning. It looks like the money will determine when he drops out, now.
2
I thought it in '16 and I think it now: Bernie Sanders cannot win the presidency. He's too intelligent, too intense, too progressive, and now, unfortunately, too old. As Democrats, we can't afford to put a candidate who may have limited national appeal against the Republican candidate in 2020. It's too much of a risk, and one we cannot afford to take.
3
limited national appeal, as in the over 1 million individual people that have donated to his campaign? I don't think any other candidate has that kind of appeal. it looks like Warren does but truth be told, shes still a far ways out from his level of support... see the nyt voter donor maps from a couple months ago. Bernie commanded his very own. it's a people powered campaign, just like our democracy is supposed to be, not held up by corporate conveniences like other candidates depend on...
5
@DB
The same then applies now. The GENERAL election is the whole point - and Bernie pairs against Trump far better than Warren does or all the others, except Biden (where they're about the same.) The polls don't lie here. Remember, there are FAR more independent and non-affiliated voters in America than either democrats or republicans - and they can feel the Bern to.
3
Bernie Sanders is a stellar individual and fierce fighter for what he believes. Yes, anyone can experience a heart attack, at any age.
But why expose yourself -- whoever you are -- to extreme stressors at the latter part of any life that has been rich and full and fun, and has drawn respect and love from so many people.
There's a time to be rowdy 24/7 with one's life, there's a time to step back, amble, contemplate, contribute and be grateful.
It's not about giving up, it's about gathering in and potentially extending the wonderful time on this earth which is more than politics. Bernie has much to give, but there are many ways to do that beyond pursuing and/or stepping into a killer job. Period.
3
God Bless Bernie. In his photo, he looks like he is going to collapse any minute.
Running a Primary race and a Presidential election, while recovering from a heart attack, especially at his age, it not possible. Not to mention, he already has a full-time job as the Senator to VT.
Medical professionals weighing in on this issue in this forum claiming their patients have recovered, have NEVER had a candidate as a patient, who was a Senator, running a brutal primary race, followed by a Presidential election, and a Presidency. You cannot compare Bernie to the average patient because he is far from the average patient considering the physical and emotional stress he is under. The traveling alone would put him at great risk.
4
Bernie also looks really old. He needs to pull out. The signs are there.
2
I am convinced by many of the comments that if Bernie actually died, these people would still say he’s a viable candidate.
6
@David G.
If it were 2016, I'd agree with that.
3
Following his heart attack — at his age of high risk for another perhaps fatal one —Senator Sanders might tell us whether he would recommend a heart surgeon his age at risk of a second heart attack to perform his next cardiac surgery? Would Sanders pick him over healthy cardiac surgeons, not only for his next heart attack, but for his family members and for his neighbors, for their heart attacks?
3
@Bayou Houma
Why not? What's the chance of a surgeon with higher risk of have a heart attack DURING a procedure? You're better off just arguing that Bernie's odds of completing his term, especially the second one, are getting slim. (But I'll take Bernie with those odds any day.)
3
@carl bumba
Presidents propose, but only Congress disposes what the President proposes. There’s a reason why we have our Constitution’s 25th Amendment to enable Cabinet officials and Congress to act to remove a physically or mentally incapacitated President from office. If Sanders faces potential incapacitation from another heart attack while in the campaign primary, yet he insists on staying in the race, what kind of President would he be if he had then the same attitude after another heart attack? Why should Americans risk him?
@Bayou Houma
You make is sound like he's Evil Knievel. His odds for cancer are probably even higher than a second, debilitating heart attack... that might be a better line of attack.
1
Maybe it's time for him to drop out and really support another candidate. He's great in the Senate where feisty fighters are desperately needed. He's seen by many as too far left and may once again hurt the Democrats because some of his fans are so fanatical that they can't vote for anyone else despite the consequences of that choice. Personally I plan to vote for the Democratic nominee regardless of who that is and I hope most people will feel that way. I think all the Democratic candidates are good.
7
@getGar
So...you're saying he's "too far Left" that others won't vote for him?
You blame his base, yet ignore what you just implied about all the others?! That THEY won't vote for him.
Is that not hypocritical?!
EVERY primary and general there are abstainers and crossovers. EVERY election. Sanders voters are no different that Dems, Indy's or Repubs. As Hillary's PUMA's demonstrated by defecting in numbers easily double of Sanders in her other loss to Pres. O.
He's too far Left, others are too centrist, too Right leaning. How about we let the primaries play out and have the nominee do their job of getting out the votes and winning those votes.
This scapegoating and vilification is mind boggling.
Maybe we shouldn't have primary's if our candidates are so weak and fragile. Lets just have coronations and let the smoky backrooms decide for us. What could go wrong?!
Lol...lord knows we don't want active and fired up supporters. They all should just act like it doesn't matter. People are dying and our country is going down the commode, but these "fanatical" Sanders fans are too much. We need the dead and bought Biden's.
Maybe Warrens White, Wealthy, Wine voters are better eh?! Maybe Buttigieg's 32 billionaire buddies?
Anybody but Bernie!
We get it.
Good luck with that.
See ya at the convention.
1
The candidates ages are "just a number." It's amazing these days how many between 70 and 80 appear so much younger. Every single person I have known that has experienced a heart attack or even a stroke, has lived many, many more years.
I had no idea Warren was 70, but regardless Bernie will be just fine. He's not my first choice thank goodness we have so many great choices. Especially compared to that thing in our White House right now.
5
While I appreciate people's concerns about his age and health, as someone of the same age group I know it doesn't have to incapacitate him. I just hope if he's nominated, he makes a very good choice of vice presidential candidate. That'll be critical to his success.
5
@DBA
Yes. I'm hoping he'll turn to Tulsi Gabbard. They have to lead the whole country, not just the Democratic party. She is a true anti-war candidate who will have broad popular appeal.
3
She does not appeal to democrats. Look at the polls. She is barely scraping by. I expect her to drop out soon. She won't qualify for the next debate.
@Daisy
Yes, the electability argument. They tried that on Bernie and Trump, Obama ... Howard Dean, etc.. She does not appeal the democratic party establishment. But that's not the people.
Tulsi was THE most googled candidate after the two debates she was in - and will probably be again after the next debate. When she qualified this time the papers gave her false praise for managing 2%. They failed to mention in that poll more than half of the other candidates did WORSE than her. The bias against her, like Bernie, is profound.
1
Walking through a crowd and climbing the steps up to the stage is not cardio rehab. Campaign food is not heart healthy. If people care about him, they should encourage him to slow down and find a different role in politics. Perhaps campaign for Warren.
6
@Joe Barnett
I absolutely agree. Most of the comments here seem self-serving ... c'mon Bernie, we need you to keep going! But if you really like him, it's a time to encourage him to enjoy the Senate, keep speaking out but also put his feet up once in a while and just relax in ways the campaign and persidency will never allow. In other words, extend your life Bernie.
2
Bernie has (some) good ideas but he is too old for the work load of the Presidency, especially if unlike Donald you travel a lot and don't spend our money playing golf. He should influence policy making and ask his supporters to vote for Elizabeth Warren.
3
@luca.navigator
Tulsi Gabbard has his back (or Nina Turner, who's not running). We saw who Warren was for in 2016... her policies are getting good though.
3
Bernie is now a figurehead for the progressives only. His running days are past.
5
Don’t worry, Sanders can govern as President from a wheelchair. Roosevelt did.
7
Mr. Sanders, with all due respect, enjoy life and take it easy. You are the longest serving Independent in Congress. You have done a remarkable job.
Let Elizabeth take up the mantle. She knows and understands your position on most matters. We will help her.
So take a step back, announce to your supporters that Ms. Warren will be carrying the weight for us now and to give her your support.
We could not have done it without you Bernie. Take care of your heart, your body, your mind, and spirit.
We’ve got this. Trump is going down hard and we’ll remember everything you’ve done.
Good job Senator. Well done.
12
@PC Liz is many good things but she is no Bernie, she will not push for single payer and the reason corporate media is behind her is the DNC feels she will come around on most issues near and dear to their hearts as did Obama, especially the continual wars and protecting private healthcare, both trillion dollar bets that the corporations will lose if Bernie is elected.
5
@PC
Bernie greatest strength is his honesty and integrity. Tulsi Gabbard, not Elizabeth Warren, seems to be following in his footsteps.
Democrats are far more tolerant of academics who spin their early experiences to advance themselves, compared to the other 3/4 of the voting public.
3
@PC
You and others don't seem to get it.
This IS what Sanders enjoys; fighting wrongs and making rights! He could have retired at anytime in the past decades. He hasn't and won't.
Ms. Warren may "know and understand" but she's already signaling her pivot with her waffling, weaseling answers and "plans". Everything is watered down. Everything less than and already compromised.
Sure, she MIGHT be better than many other candidates. You and others seem to trust her and think so. Bully for you and her.
Sorry, many of us DON'T.
How about Warren drops out and endorses the great senator you so ingratiating praised?!
The Real Deal. Not an almost or a substitution.
Unlike how she failed to do in '15. Secretly signing an affirmation to HCR before Hillary even announced her Pres. run. Withholding her backing throughout the primary. Selling her soul for a chance VP spot. Calling the primary rigged...until is suddenly wasn't.
Sorry. I hope Bernie doesn't quit or endorse.
But he is his own man. He'll do what he feels is right. Just as we all must and did.
Without a Sanders in the race applying real pressure from the Left, that whole agenda is gone.
We've seen it time after time with establishment Dems.
You know, those that advise, tutor, staff and donate and secretly meet with your Warren.
How about we let the primary's play out.
Lets let the voters decide.
May the best wo/man win.
See ya at the convention.
1
It is pure selfish arrogance to continue a campaign at age 78 after a heart attack. Wasting millions of dollars needed to defeat Donald Trump.
The arrogance is staggering.
45
@Will. Sorry. There is nothing arrogant about running for office and millions supporting his run. This is a democracy, this is what it looks like. If you think it is arrogance, please move to some other country.
6
BERNIE is funded by millions of individual small donors, not big money. He's the best illustration of how our democracy should work. As long as he has the support of so many people he has a right, and I'd say, a responsibility to finish what he started.
5
@Will.
Assuming everyone has a giant ego is sort of a Republican thing, I thought.
If there is one candidate here who is not doing this for his or her own glory it would be Bernie Sanders. Forty years of commitment in a closely-knit state like VT cannot be faked.
2
My vote will be for whomever the Democrats nominate, I am voting country over party something that both the Democrats and Republicans seem to have forgotten. ANYONE BUT TRUMP 2020.
12
I supported Bernie financially (not much, according to my circumstances) in the last election and this time. But as Elizabeth Warren has put forward her ideas which are almost the same, I wondered do we need Bernie's gravitas against Trump or can she go all the way?
Well, maybe that's been decided by fate. If Bernie throws his weight behind Liz, she'll have the entire progressive wing of the democrat party behind her. I realize Wall St. and the big money will be against her, but we have another year to convince some of them they'll still be okay and the country and the world will be much better off.
8
@betty durso Liz is not 100% aboard for single payer, an “option” absolutely won’t work for the simple reason that Doctors won’t take what are the equivalent of Medicare rates as payment when they have the option of taking larger albeit cherry picked fees from private insurance, anyone with Medicate now has surely experienced being made to feel like a second class citizen, no matter how good your secondary. Bernie is the only one who is honest enough to admit that the entire system must be dismantled to make Single Payer work. The ACA was proof enough, as soon as it passed healthcare stocks went on a ten year tear straight up, along with premiums, RX costs and the denying of services for reasons other than pre existing conditions. This is an all out war with insurance companies and Wall Street owned medical care which is too say most of it. Is it any wonder the corporations would be behind the slanted reporting a Wall Street product like Sydney Ember.
3
It seems to me a bit premature to call on Sanders to drop out long before a single vote has been cast.
Sanders seems to have dealt with the question of his age by keeping up a schedule that would exhaust a much younger man. This approach nearly put him in an early grave. He's going to have to be much smarter in the coming months. He will also have to talk about himself, something he has always been loathe to do. Can he do it? We will see. The grumpy old man does have a softer side, you know.
I will be watching him closely in the next debates and so will everyone else. Any sign of weakness, mental or physical, will be damaging. In the end he may very well end up as a king or queen maker and not a king. As a supporter I can live with that.
9
It’s tough for Bernie. However, his health is not good enough to warrant the job of president. It’s time to bow out and take care of yourself. It’s amazing that some of these commenters would still vote for him.
7
@Lisa Murphy Bernie is in great health physically mentally despite usual wear and tear. Trump, despite being a president, is obese and mentally quite unstable. His good habits would put kids to shame.
4
"Democrats are overwhelmingly focused on finding a candidate they believe can defeat Mr. Trump, having made clear in surveys that ousting a president they loathe is their top priority."
Defeating Trump is only tangentially related to Democrats' "loathing." He and Fox News pundits would have us all believe the next election is solely about retribution for the 2016 race, and sadly their inane repetitions have influenced this rather misleading take. Many voters are motivated to eject Trump, yes, but the race Sanders and Warren are running is based on ensuring a fair future for all Americans regardless of the previous administration.
7
I hope everyone remembers Dick Cheney served 8 years as Vice President (some would say actual president), with more heart procedures than I can count.
6
@Marian Feinberg and he Cheney was a nasty man, too. Horrible. Because of one guy Cheney, poor George W attacked an innocent country, while his father Bush senior, watched helpless, ashamed.
4
Bernie Sanders should drop out for obvious reasons of his very serious health issues compounded with his age. It would be decent and right of him to endorse Elizabeth Warren. Let's hope he does the right thing rather than just hang on.
4
The sooner Sanders drops out the better. It's a real shame as he was one of the first to demand the changes we need today, well before most Democrats.
I wish him well and don't believe his age/condition should preclude his election, but it will once the Republican/Trump hate machine put's him in solely in their cross hairs.
4
I'm 70YO. I look younger (much, if I do say so myself) than Bernie, Joe and the misfit now disgracing the Oval Office and our country and a 'world' of our allies. (I don't think I can 'rightly' make comparison of myself with Ms. Warren.)
Yet I'm retired (from the 'practice' of law), and retirement is what I not only enjoy most but am most 'fit' for.
Bernie and Joe should retire. trump should be in jail. Ms. Warren appears to be sharp as a tack and fit-as-a-fiddle (to 'engage' two 'measures of speech' older than all of us) -- but, 'for me,' she's too old, too (for service as our president, that is).
In any case, if the Democratic Party's 2020 presidential nomination goes to Bernie (who I don't much like 'at any age'), I will vote for him in 'The General' even if he is dead by then -- so, too, 'for Joe' (who I also don't much like, 'regardless of age'), should he be the "D" nominee.
Ms. Warren is my clear preference if my only 'real' choice is to vote for someone as old as I, thus to remove the stain of the donald (to the most immediate extent possible … given the given that his Senate sycophants will not have followed any impeachment with a conviction of the creep).
3
The ageism stench in some of these comments is disgusting. Senator Sanders has a serious health issue for sure, which is IMO the only reason he should drop out. But, tagging him as too old, and Senator Warren as “elderly” is endemic of the last allowable taboo in this country, while we have an impaired dangerous narcissist bully in the White House now who lounges in his bathrobe all morning listening to TV sycophants sing his praises.
Sanders and Warren have done more good for society in the way of genuine service and policies that help real people. Biden is just running on the entitlement ticket, and don’t get me started on “I, Me, Myself for Iowa” Kamala Harris. Warren gets my vote, and I pray for Bernie’s health because Bernie as a second chair adviser is eons better than the infant we now have in a high chair/playpen making deals with countries that do not have respect for the U.S., let alone any mutual interests.
7
I was going to vote for Bernie Sanders. But now with all this, I will switch to Trump again.
6
No fan of Sanders I would still not worry about his health as president. Anyone can die any minute. Look at William Henry Harrison!
4
Wishing Bernie well, but amused to see that in this article he and Elizabeth Warren are referred to as “liberals” and Biden as a “moderate”. Just the other day, the former two were the “progressives” and Biden was the ‘liberal.” But Bernie openly refers to being a democratic socialist and, by all measures, all three of them support liberal principles, although two of them are more to the “left” than the (not “right”) Biden, who has noted his ability to get along with “conservatives.” Am I just confused or is this labeling a mess?
5
Maybe Sen. Sanders should share his cardiologist’s report with the public.
3
I'll take my chances with the guy that has half a heart over the one we presently have who doesn't have one at all. Go Bernie!
8
Now is the time to bow out gracefully and campaign for the democratic candidate for the White House (unlike last time) and help elect Democrats for the Senate, otherwise he will come across as an old stubborn man.
4
It’s done for Bernie.
Warren or Biden.
4
This is just sad. I’m not a doctor or nurse. I do know that a 78 year old man who just had a heart attack who already has an elected office running for the highest office in the land looks selfish. Particularly when he already got the party and the nation to move toward him. The next president should bring stability and longevity to the nation. A 78 year old who just had a heart attack doesn’t seem to be that person. It would be more dignified to endorse warren or someone else and then continue his job as senator. This smells of the kind of self interest and vanity we should seek to cleanse from the White House. This is of course only my opinion but just drop out bro. Enough is enough.
9
Bernie knows that the campaign is more than just a run for the White House. It's also about our values and our communities. That's how he ran in the 2016 Democratic primary, and he was very good at articulating a positive vision for America. He pulled Hillary left on some platforms, and that pull arguably gave her a better chance to win.
I have the feeling my senator, Elizabeth Warren, will win the primary. That said, whoever wins the primary will need strong allies in both houses of Congress to introduce legislation. Bernie and Elizabeth would be an excellent power team for positive liberal values in different branches.
7
Darn it Bernie. Give it up. Support someone else this time.
I still blame your stubborn attitude and your stubborn supporters who declared war on Hillary Clinton for her loss. And what did we get? Donald Trump, who has all but ruined this country.
Be realistic. Stay your Senator self and support the Democratic candidate - not yourself! Be a gentleman, be fair, be just. Be a Dem supporter, not a Dem candidate.
Let the Sanders enormous voice lead the way....for someone else.
The heart was a warning! An omen! Don’t be selfish. This time really campaign for another candidate. Think of the power a Sanders pull would do!
8
Bernie Sanders had a mild heart attack, which happen to anyone at any age.
Dick Cheney, a "heartbeat away" from the presidency - had no heart at all, literally.
DJT is an eighty year old, sleep-deprived, morbidly obese, hypertensive, likely diabetic narcissist clearly in the early stages of dementia. And 40 million Americans think he'd be just swell in a second term.
Except in the media, Bernie's current health a non-issue. Thst said...
Vote Blue - No Matter Who
10
Whether I plan to vote for this man or not, I love him for his honesty. He made a forthright statement that he wants to be sure he has the stamina to do the job that he aspires to do.
5
Whatever happens next, Bernie Sanders is an American hero the likes of which we don’t see often (if ever). Despite my own doubts about his ability to win the presidency, he has effectively moved the conversation away from Neoliberalism and inspired many young Americans in a positive way. It’s not a matter of “if” but “when” many of his policy ideas will become the law of the land.
6
"Mr. Sanders’s campaign aides were heartened that the first polls since his hospitalization did not show a significant drop in his support."
"Heartened"? Intentional or not, such a pun seems in poor taste. The Senator's heart attack is no joking matter. He has been a tireless champion of a more equitable and efficient health care system, calling out the greed of a monopolistic industry that continues to value profits over people. Perhaps his fight has, in some measure, come at the expense of his own health.
Should Sanders eventually opt to bow out of his campaign, he would likely endorse Elizabeth Warren, a fellow champion of America's working class. Their combined supporters might very well exceed those of Joe Biden and ensure the nomination of a progressive candidate to face the regressive and transgressive Donald Trump next year. That is a match that many of us desire.
Regardless, I have faith that Mr. Sanders will ultimately do what he deems best not only for himself and his family but for this nation and its future prospects. I wish him well.
2
Dear Mr. Sanders: Carefully choose your running (political) mate. Like most everyone else here I can freely make that comment; but as far as advice on the activity of physical running (jogging), that I'm no qualified to do.
1
In the end, there is still tremendous need in this country. If you are in need of health care, health insurance, are up to your ears in debt, can't scrape together $400 for an emergency Bernie's health doesn't matter. Getting people who are suffering to get out and vote is the problem. Since they don't, it doesn't matter to the majority of these candidates. This may be our last chance for a candidate who is unbought.
5
I understand why many people are devoted to Bernie, why they want him to stay in the race. But these folks, and Bernie himself, need to consider the consequences.
If he were to win the nomination, Democrats who are determined to beat Trump would be forced to vote for a man who, quite conceivably, Is now not up to the rigors of campaigning against Trump, and whose age and physical condition would be used against him in that fight.
If Bernie truly cares about what’s best for the country, now is the time for him to withdraw his candidacy and throw his support behind someone with similar goals, like Elizabeth Warren.
2
@Jane vote blue doesn’t matter who.
5
The Baby Boom candidates are just too old and Bernie's heart attack proves it. A candidate needs to be vigorous for the strenuous eight years in office. Now do the math. Sanders, Biden and Warren will be in their 80s during the eight years starting in 2021. Harris is about the right age while Buttigieg is too young to have the necessary experience.
"When Sanders ran for president in 2016, he was the not-Hillary Clinton candidate"
Actually, Bernie led his own grass roots campaign that inspired millions to "Feel the Bern" and rethink what government could be. Only someone who voted for Hillary and knew before the election they were going to, would call him the "not-Hillary Clinton candidate"
8
Bernie has been the hardest working man in politics and government for the past 5 years. He was the most active supporter of Democratic candidates for Congress in 2018. He crisscrossed the country relentlessly to appear at campaign events. Soon after the 2016 he was in Mississippi supporting union organizing event for auto workers. Would that we had a President who works so hard to promote good policies that benefit the poor, the working poor and the middle class. May he enjoy good health and electoral success in the near future!
6
I haven't decided who will get my vote, but I care about intelligence, wisdom, experience, compassion and leadership. Enough with this ageism. If Senator Sanders had broken a leg, we'd expect that he'd use get his messages across via technology until he'd recovered. And how about letting all the candidates sit down during the debate.
4
It’s unfortunate to see his health deteriorate. It’s time for senator Sanders to put the country before him and throw his support behind another candidate.
I used to think senator Sanders had good judgment until he put his nose into Kashmir issue without demonstrating that he understands the history and reasons behind the violence in the region.
If he doesn’t have good judgment to surround himself with those who does and fails to ask common sense questions about an issue he doesn’t have a good grasp of, I don’t believe he can make a good president.
2
As long as Bernie is alive I will vote for him. I hope the strength of his philosophy lives forever, I will always vote for that philosophy, it is not just a political platform.
Sydney, of course, will be voting for a corporational government and for inequality, probably someone like Trump. At least for Trump tax cuts. Business first, an accomplished successful woman.
If only we all viewed the world like Bernie, how could anyone turn his back on the humanity of
this planet? Life would be so simple, more joy than sorrow.
5
I definitely won't vote for Bernie after his heart attack. (To be fair, I probably wouldn't have voted for him before, either.) We are really voting for whoever he names as his VP, because it's likely that person will have to step in at some point during Bernie's presidency. It's not just Bernie, either. These old guys who are nearing 80 are just too old. (and, I'm almost 70 myself!) But, c'mon. Bernie's heart. We see Biden practically forgetting where he is. Trump is blathering and falling apart day by day. Even Warren, who seems healthy and spry, must feel the strain. And, the real strain starts once they assume office. No, I hope one of the younger candidates gets the nomination. I think as I have aged myself I do realize more that age plays a part in processing information, dealing with stress, and decision making. And, whoever comes after Trump will have so much to do to just clean up the messes he's made that that alone could take the full 4 years. It is a massive undertaking and needs a young, fresh mind to deal with it.
1
Bernie is simply too old. By the time we vote in November 2020, he will be 79 years old.
I'm not talking about "ageism," I'm talking about health and mortality. It's just too likely that he would have serious health problems, or a creeping senescence, while in office.
Joe Biden is too old, too.
It would be better for people if Bernie just dropped out now. The longer he stays in, the more he helps Trump, just like 2016.
6
I'm glad he's taking his health into account despite all the pressure not to from the campaign. Taking time to care for yourself shows incredible wisdom especially when the whole nation is watching.
2
If Bernie really wants to have a positive impact in this cycle, it might be a wise move for him to drop out and immediately endorse Elizabeth Warren. That would consolidate the progressive wing behind one candidate, and that would likely move Warren to the clear front runner status.
But, I saw what happened last time, and how, despite the mathematical situation, he just couldn’t let it go. Even at the convention, his supporters were still vilifying Hillary Clinton. When he did eventually endorse Clinton, it certainly wasn’t from the heart.
While I despise ageism, the reality is that the man is 78, and just had a heart attack. Right or wrong, that will be an albatross which the GOP will use against him.
For once, be pragmatic, Bernie. You moved the conversation. You had an impact. But reality is what it is.
I am not saying that I am a Warren supporter - I have yet to make up my mind, as my #1 priority is to get Trump out of the White House. It from a political POV, it would be wise to join forces with the candidate who most aligns with his views. That is Warren.
2
I live a hundred miles from Burlington. The old Senator should take a few weeks of and take advantage of the fabulous fall foliage. A few weeks to reflect on his future.
In my humble opinion, dear Senator, time has come to hang up your skates.
2
Bernie’s time was in 2016, but the Democrat establishment did everything it could to stop him (in retrospect, a very bad as well as despicable decision). In 2019, everyone in the Presidential field is a Bernie and so he blends into the pack now—except for the fact he is much older than the others who share his views. Add to that his recent heart attack, and Bernie is almost certain to fade in the polls.
1
Why are some people so eager for Sanders to bow out? Or any candidate for that matter at this stage, before we've had a single primary vote? Are they hoping that without Sanders in the campaign Warren will drift right and the DNC can proceed with its typical milquetoast centrist campaign? Why narrow the number of targets for Trump and the GOP so early?
3
How about “Biden/Sanders: the old white male ticket”? Sheesh. While I like them both to some extent, they both have problems that may be more important than age. For one thing, they are both way off on how they view women—very old school. Bernie always appears angry, doesn’t seem to have many legislative accomplishments given how long he’s been in office, and he’s not even a Democrat—he’s just taking advantage of party apparatus and it’s a bit galling.
Biden really doesn’t sound sharp, a big problem going against Trump. Whoever faces Trump can’t be stumbling over his or her words, because they’ll be run over, making them stumble even more. Part of winning is (sorry to say) looking strong. He doesn’t, in more ways than one. Not to mention his positions aren’t too inspiring.
Time for them both to use their energy to support one of the other candidates, any one of whom would pose a solid threat to Trump.
2
Given his age, he should consider withdrawing from the race. He did have a heart attack after all. Usually 8 weeks rest is called for even for a mild event. But he had blockage so he needed stents. His contribution to the political dialogue has been very meaningful. Healthcare for all and working wages are all issues that need fixing. The US is far behind in social justice matters and it is only getting worse under trump. Do take care Senator Sanders!
1
This might be a good opportunity for Sen Sanders to bring in a new policy topic. Where are our medications being manufactured. Where are his meds made? Having just faced this issue (ie, Losartan), it might be another instance when socialist ideas solve a problem. Should the government make, subsidize, encourage, drug manufacturing in the U.S.?
I don’t have a problem with socialist solutions to problems capitalism can’t, won’t, address. As has been pointed out...repeatedly, the profit motive is great for some things- not everything.
And I have to laugh at the idea that being president will be more stressful than this crazy marathon process of running for office; yeah, those golf games, travel on AirForce One....would wear anyone down. The state dinners....imagine the president having to organize, write all those invitations....
But sitting in front of that fireplace, greeting foreign dignitaries- I’m not sure even a 20-year old could do that.
I'm 80. It's different from being 78 and my arteries are clean. Bernie's arteries that supply the heart muscle have plaque inside.
That means that arteries to his brain also have plaque inside. He might be NOW a candidate for carotid surgery to prevent strokes.
I would advise Bernie to take over a very needed role: senior advisor to liberal candidates for office at all levels. He should embrace all the Democratic candidates. He should be our senior statesman. He should use his still formidable energy to support access to medical care for every American. He should put his thumb on the scale and embrace us all.
2
I will be voting for anyone running against Trump on the ticket, not because I hold liberal views by default, but because it is the right thing to do.
I apologize in advance for those who many not agree, but this may be a blessing in disguise for the Democratic race. I think that many young(er) voters like myself have become so caught up in the Bernie movement (and it is a good one) that they forget that his policy proposals are not nearly as palatable for older generations (even Democrats). Though I would vote for Bernie if he wins the primary, I would fear that his policies would polarize too many American voters to Trump's benefit.
Biden is probably the most palatable from a policy perspective, but represents more of the status quo and his campaign has its own issues neither of which are in his favor among many voters.
Warren seems to be the best bet at the moment, somewhere in between Biden and Sanders on the political spectrum (closer to Sanders) and she is running a smooth campaign.
I will vote for whomever wins the Dem primary, but I fear that for many voters, their decision is far more conditional, and if the wrong one wins, its far from inconceivable that we could have another four years of Trump. Time will tell...
The issue for me, a very progressive Democrat, is: Can Sen. Sanders handle the extremely "grueling" job of being President, especially when there is in, Sen. Elizabeth Warren, an equally progressive alternative? No, I'm not a physician, but why take a risk, especially when there's a clear alternative who is already ahead of Sanders in the polls. I am, however, a health researcher and Sanders now has at least a 20 percent risk of another heart attack during his first term and the data indicate his life expectancy has been shortened. Warren-Castro 2020
If the comments here—split between encouraging Senator Sanders to run and to step aside—are a prediction of the election, it would be prudent for him to bow out. America is facing its most consequential election in its history, and with so many Democrats unsure of Bernie’s ability to win and govern, it’s too risky to take a chance. I hope he shifts his support to Senator Warren, for the good of the democracy he’s long fought for.
1
Yes, and if he does that he can continue to participate in policy discussions, remain a hero to the far left of the party, have a significant cabinet post, and live to enjoy the result: a highly intelligent, seasoned president with the ability to persuade, unite, and inspire a rehopedul nation.
@NYCtoMalibu
Warren/Sanders
Strong Win
1
I haven't noticed much attention focused on the delay caused by Sanders' staff first taking him to an Urgent Care Ctr., rather than directly to a Hospital ED. They should have known that no Urgent Care facility can definitively assess or treat a myocardial infarction. One wonders re: just how much of Sanders' myocardial function was lost by his staff's initial inaction.
3
@HM
Is this True?
Who made this Decision?
Mr. Sanders may have resisted going to an ER. Speculation about what happened isn’t going to enlighten us at this point.
1
@Rea Howarth
It WILL enlighten others, who incorrectly believe that Urgent Care Ctrs. are the correct places for evaluation and treatment of ischemic heart disease.
Imagine Sanders running not as a candidate for himself, but for his ideas. He could throw his support behind the candidate or candidates that best espouse his views.
Imagine a joint Warren/Sanders campaign stop. Or Buttigieg/Warren. Envision the crowds. He could expect to influence greatly the eventual Democratic platform. He could give a keynote address at the Convention.
Sanders would make his mark as the factor that guarantees Trump’s 2020 defeat.
16
@Max
OK.
And can you imagine a Bernie/Tulsi ticket that would lead to 16 years of TRULY transformative changes in America? I can.
If nothing else, we know Bernie. Most Americans don't know what they're in for with Tulsi. Two selfless adults who truly want to help the American people will be hard to improve upon.
2
@Max
Imagine!
Bernie and Liz have all the money from the most people, equals the most votes.
Why not vote with all the people?
Bernie for VP.
Endorse and bow out gracefully. If he really wants to help change things he needs to do what he did not do (and should have) last time. Fully support a candidate and tell his supporters to do the same. It is time to stand down and do what is best for the country. Can he do it this time?
24
The question is not if Bernie will be "fine" the qusrtion is will he be fine not only for the rigors of a primary and general election campaign but will he be fine for the stresses of being president.
And the biggest question is how will the voters perceive his health.
I love Bernie, gave him money, in 2016, had his bumper sticker on our car had the unique experience of people in Trump country tell they liked my sticker and Bernie. But he has had damage to his heart and Democrats do not need a candidate with those vulnerabilities. This election is too important.
It is time for Bernie to pass the torch. It happens to all of us. It happened to me and it has happened to Bernie.
15
Given the vast field of candidates, many of whom share his general views, Senator Sanders’ refusal to bow out with grace in the light of these developments comes across as prideful, stubborn and even greedy. He is not the only one who can take corporate America, and his time to do so was anytime in the past 50 years, and yet he was nowhere to be seen. We do not need another leader with a messiah complex, and we certainly do not need one who has arrived so late to the party that he is literally on death’s doorstep.
18
I was a Bernie supporter, donor, and phonathon hoster the first time he ran. He is the best of them, but a heart attack was just waiting. I could see it coming in him when he came to NYC a few years ago. If I were one of his advisors, I'd tell him to get behind Warren and influence her platform as much as possible. I want him to LIVE and keep influencing things, rather than die in office due to the known and obvious stressors fo the job.
21
@LE
Thanks. I think he wants to keep going, despite the added risk, knowing how much positive influence his presidential campaigns are bringing.
Bernie/Tulsi 2020
2
Compared to Biden, Senator Bernie Sanders is in near perfect health, after having a couple tiny stents inserted into an artery. All other arteries checked out OK. He toured the country all summer advocating Medicare For All, and for five years has sometimes hosted multiple events across multiple states, when he's not at work in the Senate. No other candidate up til now has kept up this pace.
MEANWHILE: Biden, who is 76, has an irregular heartbeat. It has already been reported that he battles with asthma and allergies, and, like Trump, takes a prescription drug to lower his cholesterol. Biden also has taken medication for an enlarged prostate and had his gallbladder removed in 2003. Biden's most serious health issues happened more than 30 years ago, when he had an aneurysm that burst and caused him to undergo emergency surgery. Months later, surgeons clipped a second aneurysm before it burst. If Biden is on blood thinners, it wouldn't be on account of his aneurysms, as the two are not related. Blood thinners help to prevent strokes, while aneurysms happen when the walls of an artery become weak, causing them to bulge and sometimes burst. More recently, Biden's verbal blunders have drawn headlines. He said poor kids are "just as bright" as white kids, claimed he was vice president in 2018 during the Parkland massacre, mixed up Iowa and Vermont, and referred to Margaret Thatcher, who left office in 1990 and died in 2013, as British prime minister instead of Theresa May.
10
@mjpezzi
... and Elizabeth Warren doesn't apparently have any medical excuses for her twisted memory of her past. How she explained it in great detail as an academic is not how she now explains it as a presidential candidate - it's just not.
6
“Change the nature” of his campaign? Because being president will cause much pressure? No disrespect to Sanders, but it’s OVER! Take care of your health. Live the rest of your life. But there’s zero chance of being elected post heart-attack.
13
This is absurd. The level of stress will only increase ten fold as POTUS. But of course he will soldier on until he creates another chaotic primary kerfuffle instead of supporting a better candidate.
11
An 80 year old man who just had a heart attack is running for President. He does not inspire confidence. He looks frail. Game over.
11
Three unhealthy things from Vermont, Ben & Jerries, Cheese and Bernie. All bad for us.
7
@Tammy
don't forget maple syrup !!
Bernie Sanders's shot at living out Andy Warhol's famous, oft-misspoken expression 'everyone will be famous for fifteen minutes', is over. With his grabbing at that issue of relieving 'student-loan-debt' still hanging like the low hanging fruit it was.
He looks beat, not just old, but old and beat. The optics are there for all to see, especially his donors, with their probable, knee-jerk reaction coming, their monies should back a winner, a ticket with some pizzaz to it, like Warren/Booker.
8
We invest to much of ourselves in “leaders”, in this we are no different than our opposition. Its hubris & magical thinking that the “right” leader can solve our problems and make the world whole again. Bernie Sanders is just a man who has some good ideas and some not so good. Several of the other candidates have equally good values and ideas and perhaps an even better chance of implementing them. To place all our hopes in one person is to court failure and disappointment as experience shows us again and again. Obama didn’t meet our expectations, Trump will never meet his supporters either. I’m not saying they are the same only that we who look for some sort of messiah are misguided and negating our own responsibility to act in humanity’s and the world’s best interests. No leader can ever meet the level of political power necessary to force change without descending into tyranny. Trump is showing us this in real time and its a lesson we better learn soon.
5
How true. And, imagine how much money could be saved if people on the same side didn’t have to compete against each other. Band together, pick a leader and become a formidable force.
I had four stents put in heart ten years ago in
2009 / blocked arteries- CAD/ diagnosis 2009 at age 59. I was walking around for years without any symptoms, proof that heart disease is a silent killer. I am 69 now and still here.
My cardiologists tell me I don’t even look sick. I am fine. The technology is amazing.
Good luck and good health Bernie.
9
@old lady cook
20 years younger than Bernie
1
The health condition pretty much ends his candidacy. I’m being realistic- I am still undecided and I’ve eliminated him. Not sure why all of these politicians in their 70’s are so popular - they’re mostly out of touch with mainstream America. They all try appealing to young people with their progressive agendas, but fall far short of convincing them. They need to seriously consider retiring - but they won’t - they all seek power and fame. They’ll do anything, say anything and go anywhere for a vote.
Warren - 70
Sanders - 78
Trump - 73
Biden - 76
Pelosi - 79
3
In my generation we said don’t trust anyone over 30.
Today’s millennials flock to their grandfather.
What’s wrong with this picture?
2
Bernie's voice has helped to shape the Party. He has also ceaselessly attacked the most vile president in our history. But the time has come for him to recognize reality for the good of the Party. While he may now be even stronger and healthier than before the heart attack, the number of voters who questioned his fitness for the job will now increase. He can use this event to throw his support to another candidate, reducing the current excess of candidates, and work towards the prime objective- defeating Trump.
8
Yes: Bernie Sanders is "changing the nature" of his campaign from operating at a super-human pace (4 rallies per day!!) to a normal pace, comparable to that of other candidates. Fair enough. That's my spin.
8
As a lifelong Republican who can no longer support his party due to its support for DT, I would like to see a Democrat win in 2020. Think of a relay race, and it’s the time to pass the baton where the goal is for the team and not the individual to win.
To truly help the Democratic causes that Sanders supports, he should step back and endorse another candidate very soon and not dilute the eventual nominee’s support. The Democrats will need every vote in 2020. He can continue to further his causes from the Senate floor.
As an aside, every time I see him speak at debates, rallies, etc, he scowls, seems angry and even hot tempered (? overly passionate). It’s a distinct contrast to the other potential nominees and it’s hard to ignore.
22
He should just settle for a cabinet post this point.
4
I know your die hard supporters think this is 'nothing' to worry about, but as an unbaised voter who has studdied (and appreciates your positions), you are not the person to see them to fruition.
You would not last your term as President, and that is clear.
If you truly Love our Country, stop; endorse whomever will see these ideas into law.
10
Bernie Sanders could be the power behind the throne - so to speak.
He perhaps should join forces with Elizabeth Warren , and she in turn could take on some of his policies, and nominate him as her running mate.
Biden will win if Sanders and Warren fight.
2
@Joe43 A few weeks ago when Biden's chances seemed better, I thought that a Biden/Warren ticket would cover the best of both worlds. Warren could be the new "Cheney" and really be the one calling the shots. This way, Biden's devout loyalty to the Democrats would be satisfied, as no gop leader would take office, and even though he may become more progressive and ruffle a few feathers, his legacy would mean something.
Oh it's a dream I know.
Mr. Sanders is in a unique position to show the public that a heart attack does not mean the end for living an active and healthy life. He is honest about his physical condition and can show how a person can continue on and respect their health at the same time having the drive and capabilities they have always had.
He can change the dialog about ageism which so far is extremely discriminatory.
10
I do like and admire Bernie very much. However, I have never considered voting for him. He is yet another candidate I would rather see stay in the Senate.
I am very concerned for his health. I wish him the best, and his choice is his.
13
Sanders remains the best choice, though it is important that he choose a strong and younger running mate -- like Warren or Gabbard. People survive decades with cardiac stents and this should not be a concern. What is most important is the future of our country. For that we need Bernie Sanders to return it to it's core values and to a citizen-first, representative republic not run by and for corporations.
4
I love the guy, but with this development, he has no chance as a candidate.
19
@Mac you seem to be biased, ageism and such. Then there are those who consider being gay, being woman, being crippled, being black, being Hispanic, being native...a disability or disqualified.
3
Bernie will continue his quest for the cause, but not for himself to be elected to the office. I think his heart attack was a reality check, and he now realizes that if he were to be elected, it could kill him.
So he will continue to draw the crowds, put out the word, but in the end, will ask his followers to throw their support to Warren, along with much of his war chest for the general election. And most of his support will transfer to her, almost seamlessly.
Bernie is the Moses of the present progressive movement. Thank you for all you have done.
10
@RM
Moses of the moment . Same way Republicans described Trump early on.
4
Stents are modern medicines marvelous success story. Stents are rapidly replacing costly and invasive cardiac bypass surgeries. Bernie will do fine and could live to 100 if he pays 100% attention to his own health.
What lessons Bernie should learn from this "heart attack"?
1) Having the best health insurance in the world; which as a US senator he has does not equal optimal health care appropriate for his age, if you are not compliant with ensuring regular annual head to toe checkups, not just with the primary care doctor but also with a cardiologist, a urologist a kidney care specialist, a neurologist, an endocrinologist, an ophthalmologist, a gastroenterologist, an oncologist, a podiatrist, a dentist, a nutritionist, a pulmunologist, geriatric specialist etc.
2) The cardiologist who treated Bernie should tell the public the extent of heart damage during the heart attack. Normally I would have said that is no one's beeswax but he running for the highest office of our land and as such there will be considerable pressure, stress and harassment from the opposition which he should be in a position to withstand.
3) Bernie has a home for every season and he should relax and rest and recoup from the stent procedure and not do any weight lifting and be on blood thinners for considerable time so that there are no clots around the stents.
4) Diabetologists will say he is not home free. If he is diabetic within a few months there could be problems related to stents. Rest.
2) Bernie
4
The frenetic pace of our marathon presidential election process has become out of control. It isn’t reasonable to ask anyone to sustain crisscrossing states in a day, showing up at multiple rallies and still doing their other jobs. It is surprising that it took this long for a candidate to have a major health scare. We can’t expect to have a really good president when the race has an element of ‘the last woman/man standing.” There should be a campaigning season (say 3-6 months) with a primary and then a general election and it should be publicly funded. We will get better candidates that way and they will all be healthier.
19
I agree. The problem is this crazy process of constant...scmoozing.....in a few, unrepresentative states. Frankly, we all need a time out, a break. More interviews, some round tables with one topic....we might get to hear more than a minute or two of ideas, positions.
2
@sara
I couldn’t agree with you more . The ridiculous campaign demands stresses your body at any age especially those that have to share their time in Congress. Even Butigieg looks tired and he’s only 36 and was in the military .
No sleep , constantly being on , traveling constantly . Anyone would be fried . It would be much better to do it as they do in France with limited campaigning time and federal funding to make it fair and square for everyone .
1
Just learned that his daughter-in-law died Saturday, a heavy burden on Senator Sanders and his family. He really needs to think deeply about whether resuming his campaign is what he should be doing.
12
@wobbly
agreed
Sanders may be fine, but it will be very difficult to convince enough voters that he can handle Trump in a one on one debate and even if he did he cannot prove that he has the stamina to be president. He would have one last time around. This time he should withdraw and give his support to the ultimate winner for the Democrats.
7
All the other candidates are ardent Capitalists, including the ex-Republican, Senator Warren. Bernie is the only Socialist candidate. As a working-class person, as long as Senator Sanders can breathe, he has my vote. Here's to the future Organizer in Chief!
14
You made reference to the "ex Republican Senator Warren". May I remind you, Senator Sanders isn't a Democrat but is using the Democratic Party AGAIN for political and personal gain.
12
Physical limitations due to age can't be denied. Whether or not Senator Bernie Sanders agrees to that fact aren't material in his run for the 46th presidency. We await the continuation of his grueling candidacy against time and trump.
All Americans who have admired and sent small donations to Bernie's campaigns starting in 2016 still admire the Senator from Vermont. We send him hosannas and kudus and await his reckoning with Father Time and the Democratic field of so many candidates vying against Donald Trump next year.
4
Sanders would be a better president then any of the other corporate hacks even if he was six feet under.
17
Heart attacks is serious stuff. I wish him well. But let's talk about Sanders Platinum Plated healthcare insurance policy that Congress voted for themselves. Meanwhile, the rest of us have to manage our daily lives and live with our mediocre, $50K deductible insurance plans.
8
@Bill Woodson Congress always looks out for itself, first. Same way with pensions. Unfortunately just about any office holder is going to make sure that is a priority.
4
It’s over Bernie. Come to the convention to get applause. But it’s over!
13
You wish.
Those who want Republican Lite to replace Trump without threatening any real policy changes are just desperate to be rid of Bernie.
And to be rid of Warren too.
Wishful thinking.
Just being a bit more careful in his scheduling is not pulling out of the race.
Reagan for example was never as active as Bernie has always been. Dubya was careful to be in bed early every night, by some reports in bed by 9:00.
Personal schedule issues are just that, personal. They do not preclude good policy, nor public desire for that good policy.
13
@Mark Thomason
nothing is " personal " running for Prez
1
I love Bernie and supported him in 2019, but if this happens next year at this time we get Trump. Time to get out of the race.
10
Roosevelt took us through the Great Depression and World War II in a wheel chair and when he died Harry Truman continued the struggle advocating many progressive programs, including a national health care system. We need Bernie to get our country back on track again and I trust his judgment in choosing a team that can continue to do good work if and when he is unable to complete the next eight years. Bernie is a voice of reason and compassion in a cluttered field of opportunists and defenders of the corporate status quo. He still has the highest favorability rating of any candidate and has more donors backing him than any other candidate in American history. No one is better prepared for defeating Trump in 2020.
13
The country cannot afford Sanders grand ideas. The country feels as old and tired as Sanders and Biden looks. It's time to give a woman a chance at controls. Either Warren or Harris have the intellect and curiosity to be a good President. I do not give much weight to what candidates toss out during the campaign that people want to hear. I am more interested in judgement, experience, knowledge of and apprecoation for Constitutional and an inspiring affect. Warren and Harris, especially, Warren are in the right place at right time. The country needs the gentle woman's touch.
3
Bernie is unfortunately one of the largest ego driven politicians of modern time obviously still producing too many varieties of testosterones' and machismo analytical skills. He is undoubtedly on anticoagulants possibly a vitamin K antagonist due to his age. His ejection fraction or muscle damage % was not reported. Notwithstanding, the data are that 1/2 of his disease cohort will experience a second episode. President campaigning and cardiac rehab are mutually exclusive. Senator Sanders needs to go home and do everything humanly possible to being a predictable healthy Senator after six months of highly focused lifestyle change, medication and though developing heart and physical stamina. By staying in the race he is robbing the Democratic party of resources that could bolster his endorsement. His judgement was bad after the previous Primary but worse now. Unluckily, the fickle finger of fate popped a myocardial infarction on poor Bernie secondary to vascular disease and possibility hyperactivity in the plasma proteins. He and cardiology needs to be truthful by saying that Senator Sanders is in an exact cohort that must rehab the heart, mind and body if you want to Improve your odds of reaching a much older age. Actuarial table shifted and from a medical perspective he is a roll-of-the-dice unless or until he goes home and fixes the known disease processes. Unfortuntly past the age when a much younger person might be able to run for president and get well.
14
@terry brady
He'll taper off and give his endorsement to Warren or someone else at the convention. Where is it this year, anyway ? I'd truly like to see a ticket of Bloomberg and General Honore'.
3
I work as a life insurance underwriter. A heart attack to a young (50ish) man is very worrisome. At Bernie's age a heart attack is less unusual, and when treated at it seems, where Bernie is up and relatively active in a short time, it may not add much to the expected mortality for someone his age. He is clearly active, not overweight. I also have not seen smoking. These are all favorable. I hope for the best.
13
Corporate Democrats desperately want Bernie and the Bernie wing of the party to go away as quickly as possible. They see this as their moment and they are going to strike with everything they’ve got. If Bernie is physically unfit for office we will see that on the trail. Until then there’s no point in speculating.
I will say this though. If he drops out there really is nowhere else to go. He is the only unvarnished progressive in the race. Elizabeth Warren, who has already taken millions from big donors and will take hundreds of millions more in the general, is not a replacement for Bernie. Not even close. She may gently tweak the system, but she has no desire to bring about the systemic change American desperately needs.
Only Bernie will fight and die on the hill of M4A. Only Bernie will travel the country campaigning against Blue Dog Democrats to build a nationwide progressive coalition. Only Bernie terrifies Wall Street (after Warren’s consistent overtures fo Wall Street in recent years). Only Bernie has a heave if stopping the war machine (not Warren who voted for Trump’s defence spending increases).
Don’t let the media fool you!
22
Bernie, we love you, you’re done. Announce your exit.
Throw your support to Warren or Biden as you will.
Accept that, regrettably, your time is past.
Be the principled elder statesmen that we need, and leave the race with dignity.
17
I like Bernie, and might have voted for him, but I simply don't think he is electable now.
Supposing Bernie won the nomination, it is guaranteed that Trump, who never is one to shy away from throwing stones in glass houses, would do his best to make it an issue. Trump is boorish, tasteless, crude bufoon....there is almost no level to which he won't stoop if he thinks it will help him. His pack just goes right along with him.
I can hear it already.....Bernie is a "loser" because he couldn't hack the pressure, so he had a heart attack. Just like Hillary Clinton had no "stamina" (not that I've ever seen Trump do any physical activity more strenuous than riding in a golf cart). The Hillary "stamina" nonsense was just that, but still, Trump milked it for what it was worth. And the fact is that a lot of people think that if you have had a heart attack, you stand a higher chance of dying in office, so therefore.....no vote.
It's not fair, it's not logical, but in Trumpworld, that's the way it will be.
I hope that Bernie gets an important position in the next Democratic administration which takes office in January, 2021. He deserves that, and he has a lot of advice to offer.
11
Bernie is a wonderful person but he needs to let the quest for the presidency go and enjoy what time he has left
15
The election process is too long and too expensive, but that is not going to change any time soon. Years ago the League of Women Voters brought reason and fairness to the process and acceptance of Public Funding as a way to run a campaign – that’s gone too. Ladies where are you when so much in need?
Bernie will pull back a bit in effort but not in content and it is the later that matters – but seldom to the media.
9
His VP pick will matter a lot more to me now.
11
"in a striking concession for a leading presidential candidate"—
"striking concession"? How about describing it as an honest (Bernie's trademark) assessment and a cutting back of the hectic pace that would exhaust an individual half Bernie's age?
16
Well, this is a tough break for Bernie Sanders. While I don't agree with any of his policies, I have always had a bit of admiration for the way he has essentially stuck to his message through the years, rather than flip-flopping with the current trends the way so many politicians do. I wish him a speedy recovery, but I suspect that this has just about guaranteed that he will not be the Democratic nominee. I think it is going to be Elizabeth Warren, partly because she is the youngest of the three leading contenders. I am more than happy for her to be the Democratic nominee because she has no chance to win the election, as her policies are way too leftist. Thanks to the Times for printing the fact that Bernie Sander's campaign raised the most money this quarter of all of the Democratic candidates. Left out was the fact that Trump's campaign raised the most money by far this quarter of all of the candidates, though.
4
Interesting opinions here, for and against Bernie continuing in the race (and of course the inevitable trolls railing against socialism, etc.).
I presume that Bernie has the common sense to step back if his doctors tell him further problems are otherwise likely. If he's cleared to continue, primary voters are entitled to decide if they still prefer him.
If he wins the nomination, he should and must pick an ideal VP (Warren, perhaps) who can keep the ship on course if he has to step down.
11
My wish is that Bernie would pass the baton and his funds on to his friend and fellow progressive, Elizabeth Warren. And then campaign for her with great enthusiasm at the pace that works best for his health. And then refocus on his important work in the Senate. Yes, Warren is 70, but U.S. women's average life expectancy is 5 years more than men's.
9
@Deb
Yes, friend and fellow progressive who didn't support him in 2016, instead hewing to the corporate and establishment Clinton machine.
[And if she had, and they had announced a Sanders/Warren ticket, there would have been no Blight of Trump upon s.]
11
"“I think we’re going to change the nature of the campaign a bit,” he added. “Make sure that I have the strength to do what I have to do.” "
I read this as Bernie saying that he can still envision himself playing a constructive role in the 2020 campaign without having to win the nomination. That means he focuses on continuing to inform the essential policy discussion. He sees his role more in terms of shaping a movement than gratifying personal ambitions. That makes him a rather unique and admirable political figure.
It also signals his comfort with Elizabeth Warren as the eventual standard bearer. Sanders would be less sanguine if he felt that no one else in the field was qualified to play the leadership role.
9
Now I just question his judgment.
Sanders has volunteered that he is unable to campaign all out.
That’s what is required in a presidential campaign.
It’s time for Sen. Sanders to take care of himself and support a candidate who can wage an all out fight for th presidency.
9
I initially dreamed of a Bernie / Warren ticket, but maybe a Warren / Bernie ticket is still doable.
I still want Bernie to run for the Presidency, but should he not win the nomination, I hope he's offered the VP slot. As happened for Dick Cheney, I don't think Bernie's health will be so polarizing or negative when its for a VP position.
3
From an outsider's perspective it's odd how a country which celebrates youth like the US, has so many elderly leading politicians.
Bernie at 78 (he would be 87 if he finished serving two terms), Biden at 76 (he'd be 85), Warren at 70 (79), Nancy Pelosi at 79, Trump at 73 (78) McConnell at 77, to name just a few. There are no other democracies like it, that I can think of. And 6 of the Supreme Court Justices are in their mid-60s or older. Two are in their 80s.
They would probably be retired already if they had chosen another profession. And it's not as if the Frontline of national politics isn't deeply physically and cognitively demanding. Trump visibly unravels more and more each week. They might not feel old, but they are old.
14
Warren winning essentially running on the same policies as Sanders because public believes she can implement those policies better than Sanders. Why take a chance with Sanders? That would be in people’s mind no doubt. His candidacy may be helped if he indicates who his potential running mate will be. In any case, people with heart attacks go on living normal lives and people without heart attacks may get one and die. It is up to the candidate to decide taking doctor’s advice. Besides, The President job is not stressful either as people think. Just look at Trump who is enjoying the authority without responsibility with added benefit of best healthcare. You can say what you want to say and if press questions, you can give alternative meaning or say you didn’t mean that. No problems. The most difficult part is to get elected and keep people believing in you.
1
Just for the record, if Bernie had a cardio exam in the last year the cardiologist would have observed the narrowing arteries and inserted the two stents.
The heart attack would have been prevented.
4
I am truly sorry that Sen. Sanders suffered a heart attack. I like what he stood for once upon a time. The fact that today, even after a heart attack, he cannot face reality proves redundantly that he is unfit to become president in more ways than one.
17
People frequently have heart attacks and keep on going. I think Dick Cheney had a couple as VP. Bernie is 78, not much older than the other three candidates, much healthier and more energetic than both Biden and Trump and mentally much sharper. The Times has always been biased against Bernie; this heart attack is just one more excuse. As far as I'm concerned he's the best person for the job and has my full support. And by the way the Presidency depends much more on mental competence than perfect physical health. It can be done from a chair, and has been.
16
@Jill Friedman
Jill I view Cheney with just as much contempt as I do DJT.
And Bush 43 for listening to him and Rumsfeld.
2
Bernie is a wonderful man who is way past his prime. He is 78 years old. He just had a heart attack. Do we really want to vote for an 80 year old President with a heart ailment? Be reasonable, folks. The Bern is way past his prime. Lets let the next generation lead us.
17
Mr. Sanders,
You are an insperation to us all. Same thing happed to me at age 46 (heart attack and 2 stents). I support you and gave donation during the last campaign. Maybe it's time to go with Ms. Warren, whom I am supporting this time (even before the heart episode). You could be her top advisor! I wish you only the best as you are a great American and person. All the best. (A pool will do wonders, walk or swim or combo is my recommendation.) There shoud be Medicare Pools for All! Laugh dear Sir.
8
Bernie Sanders is the most trustworthy of all the contenders.
18
Take care Bernie.. rest up and recover. You have one life.. and it is best to live it in the most positive manner possible.. and unfortunately that concept and politics are unreconcilable.
Any Bernie supporters that insist he needs to stay in the race and keep going.... you are being incredibly selfish here. Let Bernie and his family help him recover and enjoy life together... because the office of president is no cake walk.... even for a very fit and healthy person with no heart disease.
8
I am sticking with him.
13
First, Bernie is a great candidate. He isn't my first choice but he would be a great candidate in the general election and I'd literally vote for a potted plant over the current "President".
However, while he might still have a way forward with exactly the right choice for VP unless he can arrange that this will most likely cause him to lose the primary. Fair or unfair, given the crowded field it could easily put him out of the running.
5
I have never been a Bernie Sanders supporter, but I admire is his candor about his situation and his willingness to let the voters decide whether he should be the candor or not. Though I am not his supporter, I believed he has paved the way for a single payer health care system which I think is an idea whose time has arrived.
12
@pajaritomt except that US government may not be using single payer for their members, so they are receiving a much higher level of care than single payer could provide.
It’s amazing when politicians don’t know when to step down.
They just can’t accept that someone else can take over for them.
Bernie yelled himself into a heart attack. Now he needs to rest after making a valuable contribution to America.
16
I really wish Bernie would use his good mind and great ideas to throw support to a candidate who can go the distance. I like his ideas but he needs to acknowledge his limitations and let go of his ego. We might not be where we are today if he'd thrown full support behind Hillary and exhorted his followers to do the same.
25
Love him or hate him, the reality of Bernie's present situation is that he can't win the nomination.
16
Stick a fork in him, he's done. He wont ever survive his 1st term.
8
Let's hope that egomaniac dies before he can inflict more damage on this country. Bernie, you gave us Trump, no go. Forever. The sooner, the better.
8
Not sure how Bernie gave us Trump
6
Bernie is the furthest thing from an egomaniac in the primary, and Hillary lost to trump, not Bernie
13
Warren for Pres
Bernie for VP
3
Who would you recommend for Speaker of the House? That’s who would be president if something happened to Warren and Bernie died after taking over for her. The person who is Vice President needs to be reasonably able to out live the president.
Bernie Sanders is a great guy. I doubt if any of the candidates are more honest and have more chutzpah than Senator Sanders; however, this is not the race for him right now. Someone who just had a heart attack (especially at his age--I'm sorry, but this is true) should not be running for President. The next President is going to have to have more strength and fortitude than the vast majority of presidents before him or her in order to fix the mess that Trump has created. Senator Sanders has the fortitude, but it is questionable whether he is going to have the strength. I think that he needs to leave the race and put his support behind Elizabeth Warren, who shares similar views to his. (And I hate to say this because I like and admire Bernie Sanders!)
9
Thanks to you both, Bernie and Joe, but let's clear the way for Warren. She is ascendant now.
Let's all focus on steeling ourselves against the appalling attacks the criminal will make. He's already succeeded in taking out Biden through innuendo, insinuation and a dismal media - including the NYTimes - that repeated "trump's" propaganda exactly as he knew they would. Let's understand that he will stop at nothing. We MUST rally around Warren with passion if we want to preserve the union, the republic, this experiment in democracy.
16
Indeed he should change the nature of his campaign. Completely.
3
Some posters have legitimate concerns about Sanders age and health. I get that, but the gratuitous smears drive me nuts. If you don't think it happens, watch this video for some of what gets said and written about Bernie.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3ZhkKATtqtU
15
@Mark I think a lot of people wandered into the wrong party by mistake any number of years ago. They should have been looking for the Republican Party. Where did all the "moderate" Republicans go? They didn't just disappear, they took over the Democratic Party.
5
Time to stand with Her!
8
Meh. Stents in the arteries are common procedure for nearly 1 million Americans annually. Most are back to work in two days.
One, in fact, lost his mind 30 years ago and he’s still President!
10
Bernie, You seem like a descent guy with a few hair brained ideas, free college for one, that will never go anywhere. At this stage of your life, do you really want the scrutiny, the constant battles, the endless grave decisions that face this republic? You have worked hard for ideals you believe in, but give it a rest. You owe it to yourself and your loved ones, to enjoy the achievements you have earned so far, and enjoy these last few years in your multiple homes relaxing. Life is short and getting shorter day by day. The politics will go on just as before with its inept, untruthful, and partisan players. Don’t worry. We will survive through it all, as we always have.
3
Half the ventricles; twice the heart.
He’s still the best one for the job
21
Bernie was never going to get the nomination anyway, let alone winning the election. He's a nice old crook, but wasn't going anywhere, even if he were younger. Bye-bye Bernie
7
He’s going to win.
18
Bernie Sanders has inspired many. He is an honest man, and a loyal citizen. He is a fighter. We all value his contribution to the people and country.
I am saddened to see if he does drop off the race. It will be selfish for us to only think of politics. It is important for Mr. Sanders to really take care of his health. Right now, that should be the priority.
I wish Mr. Sanders well and good health.
5
I think Bernie's campaign is in effect over. But he will not quit if 2016 teaches us anything. He has become the conscience of the party and he is needed.
9
Thank you Bernie. It is time to retire. The country and the world will be thankful. Your presence in the campaign will only help Trump.
10
I'd rather have a Sanders who has been consistent on his major issues throughout his whole life than a Warren who is about as consistent as a chameleon.
I have to laugh when I see Warren, who was a libertarian Republican into her mid 40s trying to appeal to black voters and Biden, who opposed busing seeming to gain their support, when Sanders was protesting for equal housing over 55 years ago.
As to presidents during campaigns let us recall that JFK had Addison's disease and repeatedly lied about. He was portrayed as being young and vigorous. And we found out that W. was a recovering alcoholic. Lincoln had a history of severe depression and Andrew Jackson had suffered multiple diseases including smallpox, as did Washington, and had been shot a couple of times. I don't consider having a heart attack any worse than their health problems.
19
@Steve
Anyone who was a libertarian Republican thirty years ago would be considered a radical left Communist today.
For the record, Washington was bald and toothless by the age of thirty due to mercury poisoning. He dealt with his health problems by chugging laudanum, essentially liquid heroin. Despite all this he defeated the world's most powerful army (or at least held them off until France weighed in) with a handful of starving, frostbitten farmers. They don't make men like him anymore, and Bernie is not an exception to this fact.
6
@Steve Yes and also FDR who had polio and served as president in a wheelchair while leading our country out of the Depression and spearheading an alliance with world leaders to vanquish the Nazis.
7
He was a spoiler last time and sadly decided on another run. He should focus on giving real support to whoever is the candidate. I remain convinced his grudging support of HRC was a significant contributor to the loss. He should step down now to clear some fog from the field.
18
@DCN you got to get your facts right. Bernie wasn’t a spoiler he got more independents excited enough to vote democrat.
1
What he needs to do is bow out graciously (with Biden). He isn’t going to get the nomination. Bernie burned that option with his conduct in 2016.
11
The man's a mensch - a great American - whatever he decides.
18
As several commenters have pointed out, Bernie was doing twice as many events a day as any other candidate. So scaling back his campaign while keeping it going is the right thing to do.
I'm appalled to learn of the recent death of his daughter-in-law. How terrible and unfair my condolences and best wishes to the Sanders family.
Anyone who wants to do some volunteer work for Bernie in memory of his late daughter-in-law can find events near them at https://map.berniesanders.com.
This is a speed bump on the way to the White House, and that's where Bernie is heading.
16
Take it easy for now, Bernie. Your body needs time to recover.
Stent placement is an invasive procedure, even though they don't cut you open. You need time to adjust.
2
Sander's views are well known and do not require him to continue a campaign which will almost certainly lose the nomination and general election. One has to admire his determination and grit but larger issues are present and those are what is best for his country, his party and his policies. His prognosis is not a certainty but the possibility of further major cardiac reversals, even mortal ones, are much greater because of his age and coronary artery disease with the additional risk factor of hypercholesterolemia. Age is generally the greatest risk factor for most illnesses. He would contribute a lot by bowing out which would allow some fresh faces and others to represent the party. It's best for him as well.This is not about Bernie; this is about the United States. All that said we all wish him a full recovery and longevity.
4
We need the only candidate running who has the integrity to be unswayable by the oligarchy to get us through this catastrophic period of our national and international history.
We don’t need fresh faces. We need BERNIE.
14
@alan brown Biden should drop out so he does not guarantee another defeat for the Democrats and the country. If we want to defeat Trump, we need a candidate with integrity. We should have learned that lesson in 2016. A lot of time that should be devoted to issues like climate change, affordable health care, and inequality will be taken up whitewashing Biden's record. That process has already begun.
2
Bernie is still our best hope for serious change in Washington. However, his health will make his choice of a Vice Presidential running mate critical.
I think Bernie should break protocol and announce his choice for a VP during the campaign. Since Bernie's vision requires a break from business as usual, let's do it!
20
Better to step down from the presidential campaign, concentrate on recovery, and continue to represent us in the Senate. I hope Senator Sanders throws his support behind Elizabeth Warren. We got this. Let's go.
11
He should do what he thinks is right. However, he has a younger, healthier and more vibrant ideological soulmate in Senator Warren who has already passed Joe Biden in the polls. If it’s the policies that matter, it seems to me he should give serious consideration to stepping aside and offering his support to her.
9
If Warren was interested in what’s best for the American people, she would have endorsed Bernie last election.
That she didn’t is proof she only cares about getting in the White House, not progressive policies she claims she’s all about now, when it suits her.
3
Whatever the outcome is, he has successfully refocused us on very important questions for the future of this country that anyone with any level of honesty and integrity will have to address. For that alone we should be thankful!
12
I’m not a Bernie supporter, per se. However, I would have voted for him in the primaries because I believe he has the best chance of defeating Trump in 2020. So, I’m not so much saddened by this news as I am scared.
12
The sooner he is out the better. He cost us the last election. I hope he gets out now before he damages any of the VIABLE candidates.
6
@onlythebest No, he didn't cost "us" the last election. Hillary Clinton and her supporters cost the Democrats the election. They gave us Trump, and forgive us if we don't say thank you.
6
Hillary had 2-3 million more actual votes than Trump. Bernie should have campaigned for her after he lost the nomination. He chose not to. He should have been in Michigan, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin urging his supporters to vote for her. Instead he took his marbles and went home.
1
@Ywhynot, No, he did not. As one of his supporters, I received numerous emails from his campaign urging me to support Senator Clinton. My friends received the same "urgent" email. He conceded early, before he had to, and, in his concession speech at the convention, told the country Clinton would make "a great president." I heard it - how does it happen that you did not?He campaigned for Clinton after the convention. Why are you revising history? You seem as embittered and fact-averse as the most vitriolic Republican. I see that repeatedly on this board. What happened to Democrats? It scares me and makes me sad.
2
Thank you, Senator Sanders, you have given great service to the US & we do appreciate that given and the ideals which you espoused. You changed the tenor & raised the sights of the Democratic Party.
Now, sadly as stated by another commenter here, “I can't think of any politician more committed to his values and, alternatively, less to his ego, than Bernie. And that is why he has to now step aside and do all he can to help Elizabeth Warren to be president of the United States.”
While writing this, I inform all that I am an unpaid supporter of Senator Warren. Senators Sanders and Warren were in lock step, saying much of the same things to very similar crowds. Sen Sanders had a far larger following when the contest began but the energy and strength of the Warren Team caused the other leaders to fall back as she rose.
Indeed, we are all saddened to see the health of the energetic Bernie to now be quietened, thankfully not stopped, and wish him well.
Now, we do have to also consider the health of Mr Biden as well as his acuity. The signs of age are clearly showing. I, a very old man, can see the signs and the other items. Mr Biden, do also consider your health as well as the welfare of the country. Do what may serve you and your family as well as the US now. Do enjoy your golden years.
The people are speaking clearly through The Blue Tsunami of 2020, which is being brought in by Senator Elizabeth Warren! Catch that wave everyone, it will do all America and the world good.
4
I liked Bernie a lot and am saddened by this turn of events. For now it is clear that a presidency would be too hard on his health. I hope that he stays visible. He has had such a positive impact on democratic policies. The best to you Bernie!
3
Bernie, may you have a great next 13 months campaigning for the Democratic nominee, whoever he or she might be. And for Democratic candidates for the Senate and other offices.
1
Bernie Sanders is a good man. But being President does not have slow periods where you can take some down time. Even vacations end up being working ones.The before and after pictures of former Presidents shows this. Granted we have a President today who doesn't do his homework, spends most of his time watching Fox and tweeting, but I don't think we want a repeat performance like that. And this is too good of a weapon to hand to our current President. You see what he does with a lie think what he could do with the truth.
2
I feel the Bern but you should not be campaigning. Endorse another candidate and help out. Rest and enjoy your life. You have given the people hope. I only wish good health and happiness and also of course what you propose for our country would come true but no one needs a fatal heat attack on the trail. The rest of your life if more important. God bless. Be well
3
It's sad that people think of elections as if they were horse races. Yes, there's inevitably some of that, but if Bernie pulled out of the race tomorrow he'd still go down in history as a winner. There wouldn't be an Elizabeth Warren taken seriously as a leading candidate if Bernie hadn't succeeded in reminding Democrats of what it's supposed to mean to be a Democrat.
I have a mild preference for Sanders over Warren because he's proud to be a Socialist, whereas she's not willing to use it in describing herself. But if his health or something else should get in his way between now and the California primary I'll be perfectly happy to vote for her.
If only the DNC hadn't subverted his candidacy last time, we wouldn't have Trump in the White House now.
11
Senator Sanders getting a dose of mortality mixed with humility will do his best to see Donald Trump out of power.
Considering the age of the front runners in the Democratic race the number 2 position is more important than ever.
1
With due respect....Sanders, Trump, Biden, Warren (and anyone else who approaches 70 years of age) is in my judgment too old to serve as President. It is the toughest, most time consuming, most physically and mentally strenuous job on Earth. We need a President with new ideas and the imagination to address the challenges facing the U.S. and the world.. As the last best hope of man on earth,America needs the vigor of a John F.Kennedy and a Theodore Roosevelt. Nothing less will do.
1
Eisenhower and LBJ had heart attacks before they were elected. Even Dick Cheney—who by most accounts had no heart—served in the executive branch after multiple heart attacks.
Bernie has more heart than any candidate in modern memory. He was and continues to be the best person for the job.
12
Bernie I wish you the best. BUT, you are no longer a viable candidate. You were on the cusp non-viability it before the heart attack. Now, you're a non-starter. Please! Endorse Elizabeth Warren, turn over your campaign funds and support her as best you can. Most of all, please recover fully and live to 120. Thanks for all you have done.
3
This is why I have a problem with him, and why I have a problem with Warren, who I prefer as a candidate. Look at the before and after pictures of Clinton, Bush and Obama. The most grueling job in the world does not need to be filled with someone who is well past the end of their prime.
1
There comes a time in everyone's life when the implications of aging and the reality of physical degeneration as we age - often coupled with heart attacks, diabetes, cancers - that we have to accept these things and reformulate and reapproach. I've seen many patients give up. Worse, I've seen them pushed relentlessly by their spouses, business partners and others to not ever change or age. What more could Senator Sanders really hope to accomplish in his life? The history books will treat him kindly. There are so many other that could readily take his place. I really wish he would focus only on worker's rights, registering voters and working exclusively in red states with people to elect Democratic Senators, Governors, House members. Bernie has a wealth of experience that older people that always vote and skew right and younger people that just don't might listen and relate to. He should bring his grandchildren with him, so they get to know what a principled, honest and unique public servant he has been his entire life. Continuing his run for President is just counterproductive at this point. He has to stop collecting money, and start collecting proof that he is registering new voters! Imagine the life changing experience that anyone that meets him in a red state would have just to talk with him? Either way I wish him well. He is certainly able and has the right to decide what he is going to do. I hope he eliminates the cancer that is the GOP, though. That is killing us all.
3
Bernie, you're 78, you've been a wonderful Senator, and now a whole new generation shares your vision. There's no dishonor in passing the baton now.
2
Bernie has my backing and support as does Elizabeth Warren. Both care about the American people and they love our country.
I want candidates who will take on corporate America and expose the hypocrisy that they are engaged in
Bernie has more energy than any of these cute entitled young candidates, I bet on Bernie And Warren for the presidency because they represent the American people in every aspect.
With them in charge no one will be left behind.
4
If the “movement” is not about one man, as Bernie likes to repeatedly tell everyone, then getting off the stage should be easy for that man.
Too enfeebled and too old, Bernie is clogging up the primary as plaque clogged his artery.
1
I’m sorry to hear about his daughter in law’s death. That must be a shock to the whole family. I think it’s wise to limit his campaign activities. I’m sure he feels better than pre-surgery but he’s wise to lessen the stress. That said...I think it’s crazy to think the stress of the office of President isn’t going to be too intense for him.
At least Sanders has a heart, and it's in the right place. Unlike some other folks I could name, who are completely heartless.
Sanders has always been the best of the lot, counting both parties. His views haven't changed, his integrity is unquestioned, and he's more than a match for that clown in the White house, who isn't fit to lick Sanders' shoes. If there were any justice in this world, Sanders would be nominated and beat Trump soundly.
But there's no justice in a world where Trump could be elected president.
7
The stents did not cure him. The disease will continue to progress. He has also had two cerebral aneurysms. His candidacy has become absurd. If he is actually concerned with the nation and not just his own petty ambition he will withdraw.
5
Hoping Sanders fully recovers BUT does he really think the country should elect him PRESIDENT when he has to scale back his CAMPAIGN events? How does THAT make sense? Happy RETIREMENT, Senator Sanders. As happens to everyone eventually, your time has PASSED.
4
I've always been with Sanders, but this is it. I wish him good health and long life. It's time to give up this dream.
12
The presence of Bernie in the race is beneficial to Elizabeth Warren. By proudly declaring himself to be a democratic socialist, he allows Warren to present herself as more moderate in comparison. Without Bernie Warren would've been labelled as far left and Democratic donors would've focused their campaign ads against her.
7
I am still behind Bernie 100% with my mind, heart and money. A slowed down Bernie is still faster than any other candidate, and he can expect to live a long time.
Of course he said he would be slowing down, and admitted his health would be a factor--he is the most honest person running--but the NYT wouldn't know that.
If I have to, I will settle for Warren, but I prefer the further left policies of the social democrat. Ironically, capitalism will flourish the most under him, as it needs a huge injection of equality right now. Wealth taxes will not stop huge fortunes from growing; only slow them down a bit and give others a chance at life. It is important that Bernie continue to run. If Warren wins the nomination, she will have his enthusiastic support and his voters.
42
Bernie you are a great guy and you have accomplished an important changing of the political conversation in this country. But time is not on your side. Please take another opportunity to do the right thing and throw your support solidly behind Senator Elizabeth Warren, the next President of the United States
10
Bernie Sanders was not leading in the polls before his heart attack and would have had to stop his campaign sooner or later anyhow. His decision to do so was way too late in 2016 and I hope that the heart attack is understood by him as the turning point for his ambitions in the current race. He will not be the democratic candidate and further risking his health for a lost cause does not make any rational sense. Time for him to support one of his fellow contender and to let go.
15
@Thorsten Fleiter "A lost cause?" He renewed the faith of many of us, including young people, in the possibility of our country and our fellow citizens. He reminded us that there were still some politicians with vision and integrity. By contrast, most of the other candidates are defined by their cynicism and look old because of it, regardless of their age. A breath of fresh air. I will be forever grateful to him.
4
I like and admire Bernie. I would vote for him, despite his heart issue, if I was confident in his No.2.
18
They have been less than candid, and I don’t know if that’s the campaign staff or Bernie and his wife. The first thing I heard was that he had chest discomfort. Then he had two stents put in. After that, well actually, he had a heart attack. Then his staff tried to say that it was all very transparent. My reaction? Chest discomfort sounds pretty minor. Two stents aren’t exactly minor, but they aren’t necessarily indicative of a heart attack. Finally, what they aren’t saying is that the two stents predispose him to blood clots and possibly another heart attack. They are minimizing those possibilities when Bernie says voters likely will take the heart attack into account. Where is the transparency?
6
Bernie is both an inspiration and a cavalier, in a time, where the truth is constantly under attack, by the very people, entrusted by the Americans to lead them.
Bernie, I admire your heart and tenacity. It brings me to tears, that you continually press on to bring the issues, that matters most, their health, their freedom and their financial health.
May you live long and prosper.
#Bernie2020
23
He will still raise money, and spend it on questionable private purposes. These are the campaign laws the naive donors abet.
2
Best wishes as you rest, rehab and recoup, Senator Sanders. And deepest sympathy for your family’s loss of your son’s wife.
If you choose not to return to the campaign trail, that would be a reasonable choice, even though probably not your first inclination.
Please take better care of yourself and your health. We’re all here to make a change. You already have.
6
I love Bernie Sanders, a very courageous statesman. But it's time for him to pass the baton to Elizabeth Warren.
10
Bernie's candidacy is over. After having a heart attack. he is simply ineligible. His votes go to Elizabeth Warren. She wins. Simple arithmetic.
10
@pkbormes and yet they still accept donations. That shouldn't sit well with anyone.
2
@pkbormes
Just like LBJ was unfit to serve after his heart attack in 1955? Or Eisenhower? Or Dick Cheney...
ok, fine, I’ll give you one out of three
4
i'd like to see all of the candidates ease up....the pace is insane and the process is WAY too long....why do we need to pulvarize our candidates to be satisfied that they can be president?
10
Still 100% Sanders.
Give the Sanders family some space. Their daughter-in-law passed away today.
They have suffered life changes that batter families down.
His campaign is healthy. Not me. Us.
Send the family your love.
33
@Lizzy: Yes, the Sanders clan is the only family to suffer tragedy. I thought the Bidens patented that...
Argumentum ad Misericordiam makes a lousy campaign strategy.
https://emcphd.wordpress.com
2
A man’s got to know his limitations.
8
Two questions: does the Times keep a stock of unflattering picture of Sanders so as to have them at the ready on each and every occasion? Beyond that, Ember here goes far beyond anything any of her sources says or suggests to create the impression of some major shift in the campaign. The hatchet jobs continue.
16
Grateful for his voice and all that he brings to this national conversation. That said, I think its time for him to step back, get behind Elizabeth Warren and continue the fight for progressive values and principles from there.
7
I have friends who had the same health issues as Bernie and came back in better health and are living very productive lives. If people think Bernie should quit, then the same is true for Biden who has serious health issues, surgery, and has had visible memory lapses! I think these campaigns are ridiculously grueling and unnecessarily so. This is not 1910....this is the high tech age and we can do better. Less state fairs and in-person appearances and many more televised town-halls that allow call-ins and less scripted Q&A's from the audience. We need to change how these candidates communicate their platforms and we, the people, need to adjust how WE interact thru technology.
23
@J. G. Smith, true, but are any of your friends 78 years old and running for the highest office in the land?
Yes, voters do look at the totality of a candidate, and that goes beyond values and history. It includes the ability to survive through Election Day, the probability of being alive on Inauguration Day, and seeing through a four year term. My father had a heart attack and angioplasty (stents) at age 58, and it took him a year to recover. With all respect due him, Senator Sanders needs to put his health first and step out of the race. He can still be a strong voice for change on the sidelines and in the Senate. Better that than to be no voice at all.
4
Mr. Sanders I wish you nothing but the best. But do the right thing, get behind Ms. Sanders, it'll insure that all the hard work you've done will continue to move in the right direction.
7
@Fromjersey
sorry I meant Ms Warren.
6
Senator Sander's daughter in law just passed away. Sanders is recovering *and* in mourning. This article fails to provide a full contextual background.
Another reason the Senator is perhaps scaling back - his 46 year old daughter in law just died suddenly 2 days after being diagnosed with cancer. No mention, at all, in this article.
Thoughts and prayers to the Sanders family.
53
If there's anything about the "nature of the campaign" I would want Sanders to change, it's his rally speaking style, in a way that will probably be good for his heart and conserve energy, too. Keep your arms down. Speak more conversationally, like you speak in interviews. At this point, you don't have to fire up a crowd. Those who come to your rallies are already fired up. The ones you need to persuade now are more likely to listen if you lower the decibels and speak to them personally. The heart attack you survived is also an excellent way to connect with the millions of voters who have experienced it themselves or through a loved one and who worry about having the affordable insurance to pay the hospital and pharmacy bills. Medicare for All!
13
At the debate later this month, Bernie is certain to get asked a question as to his heart condition and his fitness for office. As if everybody in America doesn’t know that Bernie Sanders had a heart condition last week.
When the question comes, they should all threaten to walk off stage. CNN loves to dramatize, rather than substantize. We should be having a debate over American policy, not “can you get elected cause you’re gay, or you’re a woman, or you’re old, etc.”. Let’s dispense with the People Magazine, CNN recipe for belittling America’s intelligence, and stay on the issues.
12
Anybody watch Obama age under the pressure of the presidency? No reputable cardiologist would suggest he should take on the pressure of the job he is running to get. He is far too passionate to to take it easy, and far too old to be a candidate after having a heart attack. He should bow out while voters have other options. Waiting until Warren is the only candidate left, cheats Democrat voters that might support one of the current others.
7
@Jay You're right. Elizabeth Warren is the anti-thesis of Donald Trump. She holds all the qualifications that are sadly missing in the Oval Office today.
The one saving grace if and when Bernie does leave the race - not having to read any more of Sydney Ember's slanted coverage...
12
He appears to be a smart and caring person.
But his ideas are the stuff of dreams. America will never move that far left. And now is not the time to try again. Sorry he really didn't help the results of the last election by dividing the votes of the left of center supporters.
5
I am a Bernie Sanders fan and campaigned for him in 2016: he was the ideal candidate then, and I believe, could have won the election if the Democratic Party would have backed him: people were hungry for change and willing to take a risk for change: he was their perfect candidate. It was not to happen. I still back Act Blue and the progressive agenda, but consider Bernie Sanders and Joe Biden too old to be president. And so is Trump. Age aside, Trump is pathological. R.N. Speaking here: there are always exceptions, but 80 years is generally a turning point in physical and mental decline. We are still mortal beings and must respect the impact gravity has on our ecosystem. Move over and let the young people lead.
5
Being President is hard work. Period.
4
Sanders is a good man. However, if he is already slowing down now, what will happen if he is actually made president?
6
No need for four or five rallies a day. It’s the same speech. Rich people are evil and the government will pay for everything. We get it. (But as swing voters in swing states, we ain’t voting for it.)
5
Once again, Sander's narcissism puts him in the spoiler position in the election. His candidacy only siphons momentum, financial contributions and votes from Elizabeth Warren. Sanders should drop out now!
13
Bernie is still the most honest of the bunch and is tackling the root of all the issues facing us. Like the commenter above said, his “slow” pace is just as fast as the other candidates. I wouldn’t count him out yet.
313
@David Brown
This is an insult to those other candidates who also have incredible integrity. Bernie is not the Messiah, as so many of his followers seem to believe. We have the good fortune to have a bunch of good candidates, some better than others but all would be better than the president.
4
I wouldn’t consider Bernie particularly honest because he promises things that are simply not achievable in our current political culture. A majority of voters are opposed to many of his ideas once they have an understanding of what they will entail (much higher taxes, loss of private healthcare, etc.) in addition, even with massively higher taxes, the math doesn’t add up and his goals are still not achievable. Should a progressive be elected — and I sincerely hope one is — many younger voters are going to be massively disillusioned by the actual pace of change, which is slow, even in a functioning democracy, which the US isn’t at this point.
2
@nana_karina Not a Bernie fan, but this is just wrong. The numbers do add up. There is no "loss of private healthcare", there is loss of private insurance. Big difference. Stop focusing on the taxes and focus on the take-home pay...which will not decrease at all. True, the pace of change will be slower than desired, but the goal is correct and true. Bernie (as well as Warren) will adapt to this reality, even though they can't say that now without watering down the concept. They are realists.
5
As someone very familiar with recovery from cardiac events, I am glad the Senator has recognized the reality of a heart attack. I admire some of his policies, but I will not vote for him in the NY primary. Quite frankly, he has to acknowledge the reality of his age and physical limitations.
355
@Ann S Trump, who is overweight and 73, is a ticking time bomb physically and already exploding mentally and emotionally. If re-elected (God forbid) he will be 78 in his last year of office. I'll take my chances with the "reality" of Bernie Sanders over that nightmare.
40
@Ann S It's true that his heart condition makes him unlikely to be healthy enough to be president. He should drop out and stop taking money.
11
@abigail49, but Trump is not running against 20 other people for his party's nomination. It wasn't guaranteed before the heart attack, and even less so now.
7
However this works out, I am forever grateful to Bernie for his decades of consistent support of workers and changing the narrative of US politics.
675
@kat perkins
Agree. Sanders has been telling the truth about real issues for some time now. I will always appreciate him , however this works out!
76
@kat perkins Really? You're grateful to him for refusing to quit when he was losing, throw his support behind Hillary and spare us the current nightmare we're living? He's not your cute old angry grampa, he's an egoist who did this country a great deal of harm.
11
@JimBob Why didn't HC have more competition in 2016? We have a field of more than a dozen candidates now but not in 2016 - why not?
There's data/evidence to show you're wrong. If it weren't for Sanders, HC wouldn't have gotten the votes she did in the general.
How come Obama was able to win in 2008 even though MORE Clinton supporters stayed home and even voted for McCain out of spite???
16
I have admired and basically agreed with Bernie since I became aware of him, about 40 years ago. Though I admired Obama and found his win historic (for obvious reasons) my primary vote for Bernie in 2016 was the first time I felt I wasn't voting for the lesser of two evils. More than anyone, he has changed the context of American politics, and made a progressive America possible- even favored for 2020.
I can't think of any politician more committed to his values and, alternatively, less to his ego, than Bernie. And that is why he has to now step aside and do all he can to help Elizabeth Warren to be president of the United States.
While they label themselves differently (socialist/capitalist) there is next to no difference in where they want to take this country. If you looked at their policy prescriptions without their names or other identifying labels, you couldn't tell who was who. While Bernie calls himself a socialist, he is really a social democrat (or so everything he says indicates- FDR, Scandinavia), but that is a separate subject.
So now, for the sake of a future progressive America, it is time, Bernie, to pass the torch. You will remain (if we triumph) the founding father of Making America Decent (again?), who made the election of Elizabeth Warren possible.
24
@Peter Wolf So very well stated Peter. Senator Sanders changed the complete tenor of the Dem Party, setting the stage for a true win in selecting a president, not just the lesser of 2 evils.
I am black and I know that Barack was POTUS while Russia was doing its dirty deeds that should have been stopped.
That said, Bernie can only live on to win by passing the torch to Senator Warren.
3
The job of the President is a leadership job. The President does not personally do all the things he/she advocates. The President achieves goals by delegating tasks to others. Take a look, for example, at the current President, Donald the Delegator. If you think about his real task, it is delegating responsibilities to others (even nefarious tasks). The thing the President needs is a philosophical perspective to guide those he leads. Bernie Sanders has been good at articulating his goals and providing reasons why he believes a particular approach is the right way to go. Many people who crossed paths with him are inclined to stick with him. They seem to appreciate his sincere and open advocacy. He serves as a role model of how candidates can be a constructive force in bringing about an effective government. His health issues are presently treatable and should not be the only consideration that voters look at.
20
When discussing candidates’ ages, it’s important to remember that women live an average of 5 years longer than men, so Warren can be considered 65 years old.
Bernie, step back, take care of yourself, keep speaking out and moving and shaking, but endorse Warren.
4
@Alex B
Let's tread lightly with statistics. Should we add back 7 because those that self identify as Native American live 7 years less than Caucasians? Should we add 5 years to Kamala and 8 years to Booker on account of health disparities for African Americans?
1
Slow down his pace? Mr. Sanders needs to go to cardiac rehabilitation and get stronger, among other things. He will need to get used a host of new medications and their side effects. Staying in the race at 78 after an MI shows he lacks the judgment and reasoning required to be president.
9
I supported Bernie in the last election until Hillary was the nominee, then I supported Hillary.
I think that Bernie has already "won". He pushed and pushed and now many of his issues and talking points and causes have become part of the discussion of the mainstream, not "out there" ideas as they first seemed to be, for instance the right to health care etc.
At this time, I think he should continue to speak out, but bow out. He should fully recover and spend time with his family, and assist other candidates. There is no shame in that. And I'd like to think that the "Bernie Bros" would have the compassion and intelligence to understand his decision and get behind whoever does become the nominee.
4
i do not agree with anything he says but he clearly believes it and I respect him for it. His time has passed and he should move on
2
Bernie,
Get well, enjoy the rest of your life, and assist whoever will face Trump.
All the best!
8
Sorry but you’re finished . Resign your campaign. You put up a great fight and did this country proud .
4
just turn it in already.
2
Please drop Medicare for all so I can vote for you
1
Sanders and Warren are splitting the progressive vote. For one of them to win, one of them has to step down. And, frankly, it's time for Sanders to step aside.
Otherwise, they are clearing the way for a moderate Biden win.
10
I have been following the Sanders campaign and he has been doing way more events than any other candidate. Good for him that he is slowing down. If this keeps him healthy than he'll remain my candidate.
41
Vanity is at work. It's hard to give up the spotlight. A 78 year old with a fresh heart attack is not going to be elected to the White House. Sentimentality will not win this election. His ideas resonate with some but turn off too many. A statesman would show his gratitude for a long and significant career in public service and declare his support for one of the other candidates, issuing a vow to work for that person.
97
@blgreenie he is the least vain person in the world, he has said over and over again " It is not me, it is us" He has fought 40 years for us. And what a laugh his ideas which in any other civilized country would be considered normal do not turn off people. Look at the polls with regular people, all of his ideas poll way over 50 percent. Stop listening to the corporate dems and all the republican talking points that are pure propaganda and have hoodwinked people into thinking we can not have inexpensive health care for all and a New green deal which will save the planet and create good jobs and so on. He is a giant and he is the last person to crave any spotlight except to help regular people. What a pity you can not see who he really is. I think you are projecting your own need for attention on him. And I am going to vote for him and so are lots of others are going to vote for him. So there.
29
@cheerful dramatist
"Least vain"??
Dear God.
Look over his rhetoric of the last two plus years. Bernie radiates the "I was right.." ethos more than anyone.
@blgreenie I completely agree. The MI absolutely disqualifies him from taking one of the most stressful jobs on the planet, and I am a physician that specializes in the heart.
You would not be getting four years of Bernie, but be voting for his VP - Remember FDR and the cabal that decided the next president when they selected Truman as his veep. Happily Truman was a decent president, but his choice was not the will of the people who had no idea how gravely ill FDR was.
As far as vanity, I still lay much of the blame on Bernie for Trump. When it was obvious he would not win, a grown up would have said to his supporters, it is too important to throw away your vote on a protest vote and that they should support Hillary.
What other than ego kept him in the race to give Trump the presidency?
2
Clearly Bernie has to bow out soon. Hopefully Amy Klobuchar will get some traction. Progressive Minnesotan that can speak in full paragraphs on any issue. Democrats win from top to bottom with Amy. In the general no Democrats will want to distance themselves. In the general a nominee gets known. Furthermore strong state and local candidates can grow symbiotically with a Democratic candidate that spans the full spectrum from center to left. Leaving Trump and the Republicans boxed in the right. And extreme right at that.
10
@Bananahead Amy is one of the most corrupt and mean spirited people in the world and who are you to say Bernie clearly needs to bow out. If he feels his health will stop him he would be the first to say it. God how blind are you about Amy, look at her donors and her mean policies, she has just said she will do nothing and is begging to be bought by any big donor or oligarch, she will do noting for anyone but herself and big donors.
5
@Bananahead
She is not a nice enough person in how she treats subordinates.
I don’t like that. It’s a red flag to me. She comes off in public as very nice and even motherly, the cognitive dissonance is not encouraging.
6
@Thinking Does a woman really need to be "motherly" in and out of the spotlight? Please. Talk about a double standard.
2
President Eisenhower was re-elected after suffering a serious heart attack when he was around 65 years old and when medicine was not as advanced as it is now. I wish Senator Sanders well, and he should not imperil his health when we have Senator Warren to carry the torch.
10
@Eric Key with all due respect , I’m 70 and let me say - 65 is not 78. Bernie Sanders should think of those of us who want to vote for someone younger who is in much better health.
11
@Auria Remember that Dick Cheney had a heart attack at age 37. He's still kicking around at the same age as Bernie. My preference at the moment is a Warren/Buttigieg ticket, but Bernie should determine with his doctors whether he can do the work of president if he is elected. After all, the current president "works", what, four hours a day? On days when he is working at all? Of course, Bernie wants to be a real president, unlike this one, I know, but he would have to figure out how to govern and maintain his health, as Reagan was able to do (whether you liked his policies or not) throughout his term.
2
@Gnirol Donald Trump plays President. A really rather good article appears in the Atlantic on Trump. The article interviewed high ranking officers who had worked for Trump and what they thought of him.
https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2019/11/military-officers-trump/598360/
We already know, as evidenced by 2016 that Bernie and his supporters would rather see 4 more years of trump than do the right thing and be team players. Not us, me.
13
@Brad A team player has to be a corrupt player and will never serve regular people if that is what you want and you want your life to get worse and more tax cuts for the rich then have fun being stolen from.
2
Bernie Sanders is a statesman. He's fought the good fight against power and the complacent "don't rock the boat" Democratic establishment, hopping to put forward another "moderate" candidate. He deserves respect for his efforts, and for his honest campaign.
30
Bernie needs to drop out and support Warren. And hopefully be her right hand man / advisor if she wins. He needs to focus on his health too.
29
“I think we’re going to change the nature of the campaign a bit...Make sure that I have the strength to do what I have to do.”
Bring 100% of the Democratic Party a brokered convention? That way, all of us suffer equally, and there’s no inequality of outcome anymore.
I feel the Bern.
3
To the Sanders family, we are deeply saddened to hear of your loss. Our hearts and thoughts go out to you.
11
@J Ummm. What loss is that? Of some heart muscle?
1
His daughter in law.
@Kevin
Wow. This is what can happen when the article's author fails to provide full context. His daughter in law passed away suddenly.
1
Bernie looked haggard and sounded extremely hoarse on stage at the last debate. I remember saying to myself, “This is not a well man”. He suffered a heart attack, and that means that some of his heart muscle has died. It’s not just medications he will have to take. Won’t he have to watch his diet and hydration?? Won’t he have to complete a regimen of cardiac rehab?? Won’t he have to devote time to continued diagnostic testing and follow-up medical visits?? Right now he is in denial about the short term and long term ramifications of his heart attack, because ironically he most likely feels better post-MI than he did pre-MI. But, there will come a time when his body will tell him that it’s time to withdraw from the race. Maybe that will happen one morning when he wakes up in a hotel in Iowa. Or maybe it will happen later in Pennsylvania or Michigan, but it will happen. Bernie’s plan is simple: he’ll stay in hoping to garner greater popular voter support, and then attempt to leverage that support for a greater role in crafting the Democrat’s platform, input on the selection of the nominee’s VP candidate and the promise of a cabinet position in a Democrat administration. You heard it here first!
9
@Robertino I'm sure Biden must be thinking the same thing too. Bernie and Joe were safe picks in a crowded field. Once you knew the nominees better then you could make a choice.
@Robertino
Are you a doctor or a nurse?
My patients have all had heart attacks and stents and strokes and cardiac bypass surgery, and they're fine.
They go right on. Senator Sanders will be fine.
125
@lisa delille bolton
None of your patients are running for the office of President. You are right, if you believe that the President’s job is no more stressful than everybody else’s job. That may be the case if you look at Trump, who is enjoying the authority without responsibility with added benefit of best healthcare.
7
Thank you Bernie for your decades of courageous service. Now is the ideal time to step down and allow another to finish the fight you started (Warren and many others come to mind).
I am afraid that if you drag this candidacy out to the convention, some of your overzealous supporters will ruin the nomination process and throw another election to trump. Please don’t let that happen.
12
I plead with you, Senator Sanders, as a past supporter, fellow New Yorker at birth, and, I’d like to think, fellow mensch, to pack it in. We need your voice in the Senate. You don’t need to sacrifice yourself for the cause. You can endorse Senator Warren if you wish to, or endorse no one. But please, for the sake of your family, the people of Vermont, and for yourself, now out now.
29
His age is an issue but it will never be an issue as to why I would support him. His Congressional history and his lack of integrity are disqualifying to me.
6
Bernie looked haggard and sounded extremely hoarse on stage at the last debate. I remember saying to myself, “This is not a well man”. He suffered a heart attack, and that means that some of his heart muscle has died. It’s not just medications he will have to take. Won’t he have to watch his diet and hydration?? Won’t he have to complete a regimen of cardiac rehab?? Won’t he have to devote time to continued diagnostic testing and follow-up medical visits?? Right now he is in denial about the short term and long term ramifications of his heart attack, because ironically he most likely feels better post-MI than he did pre-MI. But, there will come a time when his body will tell him that it’s time to withdraw from the race. Maybe that will happen one morning when he wakes up in a hotel in Iowa. Or maybe it will happen later in Pennsylvania or Michigan, but it will happen. Bernie’s plan is simple: he’ll stay in hoping to garner greater popular voter support, and then attempt to leverage that support for a greater role in crafting the Democrat’s platform, input on the selection of the nominee’s VP candidate and the promise of a cabinet position in a Democrat administration. You heard it here first!
1
I’m half his age, and the idea of doing four rallies a day sounds grueling. He still has my vote. Bernie is the Democrat that speaks the most plain truth. People live for that truth in this age of lies.
19
Roosevelt spend most of his life in a wheelchair.
Reagan was in the beginning stages of Alzheimer's.
Trump arguably has some...er.. problems.
Leadership depends on a sharp mind as much as a fit body.
20
@Edward
A wheelchair is not life threatening. Alzheimer's means someone NOT elected to be President is making the decisions. To go into it with either a life threatening illness or diminished brain capacity does not bode well for the future of the country. For the President to die in office is traumatic for the entire country and possibly the world.
2
So the voters are skittish about electing a man with a physical malady, but they had no problem with one with mental problems. I think people have it backwards.
47
@Rick I think you’ve got it wrong: Most of the people who are concerned about voting for Sanders due to this issue never voted for Trump in the first place.
Senator Sanders, this only makes me admire you more and what you are trying to do for America. Simple honesty from a politician, not a bunch of spin and lies, like the traitorous criminal illegally occupying the WH at this very moment. If I could trade you for him right now I would do it in a nanosecond. Thanks for all you do, sir.
25
Just keep your hair tasseled and saying “yooge” Bernie so we still know it’s really you. All the hand waving and anger management issues was getting kind of tedious anyway, so embrace change.
2
He will probably bow out of the race sooner than later. He's a solid guy who has done more to raise key issues than most politicians in recent memory. Endorsements are for general elections, not primaries. He should trust that his supporters will do the right thing.
7
As President Bernie's schedule would be intense but less hectic.
His campaign is already doing so much good in raising awareness, shaping the debate and raising the standards of what good government should be. If he and his family and doctors feel he is fit to run then I trust his judgement. In the event that he wins it would indicate that the country is ready for the bold revolutionary plans he has been advocating. He would appoint people who would have the experience, capability and commitment to carry out those plans and every single day that he serves in office would be a worthwhile step forward in accomplishing those goals and helping the nation heal.
People do live many years after having a heart attack. And there is no guarantee for any of us. In the event that he is unable to complete his term he would have built a team and inspired the nation. As Bernie says, not me, US.
50
Of course, in the event that he steps back, or does not win, he will continue to strengthen Our Revolution and carry forward the agenda as a senator. Getting high quality universal health care, publicly funded and guaranteed as a right is within reach and it is not surprising that for this and so many other reasons he wants to stay in the fight and bring it home.
Wish him excellent health and excellent health care for all.
1
I hope Bernie is reading, or has someone on his staff reading, NYT's Comments section.
Mr. Sanders, your longevity is most definitely an issue. That being the case, your VP choice becomes as crucial as your election to the office of President. I urge you to work with those of your competitors to form a coalition, even at this early stage of the campaign. Speaking only for myself, a pairing of yourself with either Elizabeth Warren or with Pete Buttigieg has much to recommend it. And drop the mandate of Medicare for All for one of Medicare for Those Who Want It. Require any employer who offers a health care benefit to include Medicare alongside whatever private plan(s) they choose for their workers. In time, the cost effectiveness and the lack of drama inherent in Medicare will win out.
17
Mr. Sanders, please, listen to your body and follow your doctors' advice.
13
Quoting Private Hudson (Bill Paxton's character from the film, "Aliens") "Game over, man."
14
@TyroneShoelaces
Quoting from Yogi Berra
It ain’t over till it’s over
3
Not meaning to be pedantic, but when one turns 80, one is _entering_ their ninth decade, not their eighth. Which is important to consider.
6
Obama had a jump shot. Trump can rumble. Let’s pick presidents who have the vitality to be president. Biden and Sanders are in their dotage.
8
@Lance Dietrich
Trump can "rumble?" Lance, I'm the same age as Trump, 2/3 his height and weight, and I can guarantee you that, in a fair fight in a closed room, I will walk out, and he won't.
9
@Glen
When is this?
It’s Warren and Mayor Pete.
Wagers ???
10
Warren and Booker, you mean....
i would take sanders with a heart attack over trump with imaginary bone spurs any dat of the week.
44
Again, would anyone like to mention that his daughter in law died of cancer on sat leaving 3 children?
14
I will still enthusiastically cast my vote for Bernie. No one else in the field has the breadth of vision.
38
I am neither a Bernie supporter nor critic, and am surprised this article does not reference what some other news outlets have today reported: that his son’s wife just died over the weekend of cancer, which was apparently very recently diagnosed. She leaves behind three children and her husband, Bernie’s son. Those outlets may have the facts wrong, but if correct, I would think that on top of his heart attack this family loss is more than enough reason for Senator Sanders to gracefully and admirably bow out of the campaign now.
47
No, @Hillary Harrow, this development may in fact be fuel for his argument. Get all the facts before you render YOUR prognosis.
8
@Hillary Harrow -- You had me, right up to 'bow out.'
Take a little break, Bernie; no one deserves it more.
And when you came back, come back fighting. Oh, wait -- he's Always fighting for the 99%.
6
@Hillary Harrow I'm sure that didn't help Bernie's stress level. Sanders is a candidate with real clarity and passion--a lesson Democrats should (and must) learn from. That being said, it's time for him to step down, heal, serve his nation as a Senator, and enjoy the time he has left. Bernie, you've earned it.
I remain as enthusiastic about Bernie as ever.
The schedule he was keeping is one that very few people at any age could maintain.
I am also surprised at how presumptuous people are: No one is guaranteed to continue in good health for the next 5 years.
Bernie has passion, and that is what fuels him. People age very differently, and Sanders is aging incredibly well.
Biden looks much more halting and appears mentally slower than both Sanders and Trump.
Bernie also has unimpeachable integrity, he’s really in this for the good of the American people.
I have so much admiration for him.
Not me. Us.
Sanders 2020.
90
To riff on Bob Dylan, you not only don't have to be a weatherman to know which way the wind blows... you don't have to be a cardiologist to see that Bernie's health is compromised. I am not happy about this-- I wear his sticker on my car. But it has been quite apparent that he has been looking older and more tired for some months. He's old(er), male and now has a cardiac history. It is a terrible thing to have to stand aside, but he must. He is going to have more trouble now getting elected, and if he is elected, we have an excellent chance of winding up with a dead President.
4
@AS If Mr. Trump is re-elected, we will have an even better chance of ending up with a dead President. He would be 74 when he starts his second term, so he would be as old as Bernie if he lasts the four years. And Mr. Trump doesn't lead a healthy lifestyle.
2
Take care of yourself Bernie, slow it down, and get some good rest. We'll need you for the final push next year to get this country back on track.
Wishing you a speedy recovery.
52
I’m a long term admirer and have been a supporter of Senator Sanders since his presidential run in 2016. Despite this setback I still support him.
Sure, I’d prefer a candidate in his or her 40s or 50s but Sadly the Democrats have given us little choice between the gray and the green.
At least Sanders seems to have all his marbles intact—that’s more than I can say for Joe Biden—a man with his own health issues though the entire Democratic Party establishment seems united to shield him from criticism and from any real exertion. Then there’s Elizabeth Warren. In good health (until she isn’t) but someone who has trouble connecting with people who don’t have a college degree.
Harris, Booker and Klobuchar have simply failed to launch. I thought Bullock had some promise but apparently no one else did. Buttigieg is too green as is O’Rourke.
So for now I’m sticking with Bernie. Mind you I will vote for a bottle of beer if that’s what the Democrats nominate against Trump although to be honest Biden or worse yet a Hillary resurgence would test that resolution.
49
“to be honest honest Biden or a Hillary resurgence would test that resolution.”
Wow! So we still have you and your ilk to thank for Trump.
Some Democrats never learn, which is why we could face yet another Trump term again.
4
@Brooklyncowgirl you’re forgetting Yang. He is one of the few candidates who gets support from Trump voters and he has a strong vision!
4
@David G.
I also said I would vote for a glass of beer over Donald Trump. Come to think of it, that was a poor analogy since I like beer and don't like Trump. Here's something better. I would vote for a glass of putrid swamp water over Donald Trump.
For the record, after much reflection, I voted for Clinton in the general election because I could not have the election of Donald Trump on my conscience. The overwhelming majority of Sanders supporters did the same.
I assume that in the event that Sanders wins the nomination that you will vote for him despite yourhard feelings over 2016
You will, right?
Interviewed today, Sanders said he would release his medical records “at the appropriate time.” What does that mean? It's important for voters to know if his myocardial infarction was serious or mild. Color me confused.
12
@Susan
A double stint does not indicate mild.
Actually, it is better for all concerned if he dropped out now, citing (heart) health reasons.
He can legitimately claim his so-called outlandish ideas are now in the mainstream of the Democratic party. He can donate the money he collected to either Elizabeth Warren or to the DNC or equally divided between he two. He can also endorse Warren, which will be a big boost to her campaign.
I for one do not support Warren. She may not win against Donald Trump or a good Republican replacement of him.
I prefer Pete Buttigieg. He's amazingly gifted. He's quite articulate and responds to questions without fumbling. True, he's gay & looks boyish.
Joe Biden also has a baggage. He's not handling Hunter Biden's working for the Ukrainian company properly. He stumbles in responding to questions, a reflection of his age & lack of agility. He's not the same man he was in 2012. But Sanders is the same man he has been but he has been performing that way at the expense of his heart health.
9
@A.G.
If I may add, by dropping out he doesn't have to endure the embarrassment of losing in the fight to get the Democratic nomination.
If he slows down a bit, he could preserve his heart health, and be an effective senator and a powerful voice for the downtrodden, for another 10 years or longer.
Though I did not vote for him in 2016, I have been an admirer of Bernie Sanders for very many years. He could write a few more books as well. Mrs. Sanders would like that too. She knows he wouldn't listen to her, or for that matter to anyone. It happened to be his strength.
This shows a recognition of changing circumstances and a wise sense of modesty from Bernie. I like this new Bernie better.
People know what he stands for; he has been successful in changing the debate. He can continue his campaign without martyring himself.
There is an American tradition of winning the Presidency with front porch campaigns. Why not honor it?
15
We love you, Bernie, and the entire country owes you so much for your faithful dedication to the fight for economic justice. (And we know you would have won against Trump.). Thank you, Senator Sanders.
30
Sorry Bernie. I like you and your message but I can't vote for someone who isn't going to be able to withstand the enormous stress and daily pressure (WAY more than any campaign) of being president.
You have the pull and supporters to now jump on the bandwagon of another candidate, directing your supporters that way, too, making the other person that much stronger and viable in the fight to remove trump.
Take the unselfish high road. You know what's right.
6
Bernie, this is an incredible moment for you to guide your followers to Elizabeth Warren. She will carry on your vision and your legacy will never be forgotten. If this allows both Sanders and Bernie supporters to team up and move America forward, your heart attack will be a blessing in disguise. Embrace it and rest up because the fight is just ahead.
8
Bernie's done. There is no question about it.
The only questions are, will he quit gracefully and is he waiting for another water-front condo?
5
The age expectancy for men in the United States is 78. Sanders would be 79 on the day of the inauguration. The Journal of American Medical Association recently published a study that put his “4-year survival probability” at 76.8%, even after taking into account his wealth and excellent medical-care access. That number is disqualifying for me.
7
The “ nature” of his change should be to publicly state that his health will not permit him to continue the campaign or serve as president. He should tell his supporters and contributors to get behind Elizabeth Warren as the person who could best lead our nation out of the dark times.
8
Every day Bernie raises money is a day that hurts the Democrats going forward. He cannot win an election now - someone has to convince him of that so he can bow out gracefully.
22
@Ryan m If support from Walmart employees and teachers hurts the Democrats, that says more about the Democrats' ignoring the interests of working-class people than it does about Bernie.
He could take his health into account as an elder statesman and still be sure that a significant portion of his agenda could mix with Warren’s concessions to the center.
9
Bernie Sanders is the only candidate who speaks the issues of concern to working class Americans. He is the only candidate who will put *substantive* solutions on the table, not merely procedural ones. He is the only candidate who has not, does not and will not take corporate money. He is the only candidate that corporations, affluent liberals, media pundits and the DNC are afraid of. To all of these, I say, your issues and the ink you spill on them are not our issues. We know what we are about; you don't.
32
Right on.
11
Lets not forget that he has a full time job as a Senator. He cannot give his all to both. His full time paid job is Senator. He is 78 years old. That is old, I do not see much work from Senator Sanders and to run for a new job is full time work. He needs to drop out, throw his supportive arms around Pete and throw his money back to the DNC to support other Democratic candidates for offices they need to win in races all but sure to be rigged by the Republican party in some way with active Voter Suppression actions and the Gerrymandering of Voter districts which is already done. They are playing the SCOTUS like a fiddle stick bending to the Republican will and placing extreme Right leaning judges all over the country to do their bidding. It is not good. We cannot worry about Bernie Sanders, Old Joe and Warren who is too old too. We need a fresh face with thought out ideas and solutions like Pete. Lets rally around 1 candidate and eliminate the others. We need to do this sooner rather than later to have any chance at all. This way a cogent agenda, ideas and solutions can be brought to the American people and we can save our Republic for which it truly stands. Anything else is not acceptable.
6
Bernie speaks the truth no matter how inconvenient.
That's why we love you, Bernie.
38
So the intensity with which he campaigns will be more in line with other candidates (not named Biden who can disappear for as long as he likes without anyone batting an eye) but let’s bury that part in the tenth or eleventh paragraph.
22
Dear Brooklyn Bernie,
Team up with Joe or Elizabeth as Vice President.
That way you can relax a bit and have the second best job!
Best,
Bronx Jon
1
Two down (Bernie and Biden), one (Elizabeth Warren) to go. And who do we see making the rounds on the TV but Hillary Clinton.
2
@Edwin
That's not going to happen. We have other qualified candidates still standing. They will move up if they get more attention and support.
Bernie's baked. There is no question about it.
The only question is .. is he waiting for another payback like the beach condo he got last time to roll over like a puppy to the crook?
3
With all due respect and contrary to the current version of the article, at 78 Sanders is already well into his eighth decade. (At 81, I’m in my ninth decade, which is hard for me to accept).
6
Bernie is the only candidate who will truly stand up to corporate interests and fight as hard as he can for the transformative change we so desperately need. Particularly in terms of combating the devastating affects of climate change, we can no longer afford half measures. That is the message Greta Thunberg was conveying so passionately at the UN. The UN Secretary General said that Sanders Green New Deal was the only plan by one of the presidential candidates bold enough to meet the unprecedented challenge we are facing. This is more important than his age or gender. I am supporting the one candidate with the truly bold, progressive vision and a lifelong commitment to equality and justice. We should be grateful that such a courageous leader is willing to stand up to the monied interests and fight for the vast majority of the people in this country. He at least deserves more respect than I am seeing from many of the commentators here.
108
I respect his ideas but from a practical stand they are just bad policy. I feel like he is too old and his time has passed.
5
Sorry but he is not the only one. It’s a cornerstone of Pete Buttigieg’s campaign. The difference is Pete has a more doable approach and has other focuses.
11
@Gary
Buttigieg's ideas are barely adequate compared to Sander's bold ideas and vision.
10
As a member of the Medicare contingent, I’d say Bernie has some interesting ideas, but I’ve never been comfortable with his age, or Biden’s age. I think Warren is at the extreme upper end of the acceptable age limit.
Bernie, we have to get rid of Trump, but you need to be around for your family. I think the presidency might prove to be too much. Bow out now, become an elder statesman shaping the primaries and the general election. Make your mark there and be available to the ultimate victor with guidance and assistance.
If Biden or Warren win the nomination, they must choose a much younger vice presidential candidate. I know age brings experience, but too much age brings risk of death due to stress.
I hope the winner of the primaries will look to Mayor Pete, Senator Klobuchar, or Stacy Abrahms when picking a vice presidential candidate.
56
@Frank
And retire from the Senate while you are at it. Your body is whispering to you. Next it will shout out and you may not be still standing when it does. There used to be a mandatory retirement age and that was for a reason. Pilots of airplanes, age 60. Police in NYC age 62. It is not a crime to retire and enjoy the life you will have then. And take some of the others in the House and Senate with you. Anyone over the age of 62. Make room for the next generation. It has to come to pass one way or another. It should be voluntary.
5
Stacy Abrahms or Kamala Harris would both be outstanding picks for VP.
2
@Frank: Don’t forget Warren is a woman. Womens’ chances for heart disease are much lower and their life expectancy much higher than those of men of the same age.
3
Bernie Sanders does not need to be president for him to have a lasting impact on our society. His continued advocacy for Medicare for All has already changed our public conversation. While other candidates may have a differences with specific parts of his proposals, he has brought the issue to the fore, his concepts are now generally accepted throughout the Democratic party. Even the most moderate of Democrats don't really object, they simply say "Not so fast".
Given his recent slippage in the polls, along with the questions that will be raised by this health scare, he may be of greater service to the country by letting go of his candidacy and putting all of his focus and advocacy on that "Damn bill" he wrote.
32
Bernie got two stents for a clogged artery. Let's call them Ben and Jerry. :)
More seriously, he is not over, because it is not over. The it being our fight for what a democracy is. And, it's different now. It's wait and see for us. For him, it's finding the right moments, and elevating the large broadcast media moments, so they really convey and re-contextualize what is sane and what is possible. Elizabeth may now get the baton, but Bernie can call the nature of the race.
This race is about the nature of our democracy. He needs to articulate repeatedly, as he has, the need to reinvest, reclaim, and reinvigorate our democracy. He needs to keep the choice as clear and simple about our future as Lincoln and all our great presidents have. Whether he is president or not, he and his message are relevant and vital to our children and our future.
39
senator sanders should do what is best for himself and his family. as for me, if he is in the running i will vote for him.
76
Bernie, based on personal family experience, same as your experience with your heart attack and treatment, you need to withdraw to continue to be a voice and live. Not a medical professional but a mother who wanted her husband to live back in 1992 and he continues to enjoy his grandchildren today. At this point you can continue to be a force without compromising your health. Do it, please.
73
Bernie wasn't going to win anyway.
Whether it was him or his twin, Warren, America will simply not elect anyone so far left in a general election.
If we are to dump Trump and retake power we need to look to more centrist progressives like Mayor Pete.
22
@simon sez Oh, yes he will :)
1
Todays Democratic Party “centrist”s are those who left the Republican party after it swung too far to the tight. The DP centrists do not support the structural changes required to stabilize the economy for the many and to seriously reduce the enhanced power of corporations and the moneyed class. The centrists will not check the disproportionate influence of money on our system of government. I will support any candidate that is willing to take on those interests for the good of all.
Bernie
Acknowledge reality and drop out . If you can't keep a campaign schedule how on Earth do you expect to keep a president's schedule?
31
@cb It’s not so demanding being President. You get lots of executive time and you never have to answer any real questions.
Bernie’s time has passed.
I wish Hillary would run.
6
The NYT is doing more (negative) coverage of Sanders' health than his policy agenda.
Trump is morbidly obese, has a lousy diet, and does not exercise. He is a ticking time bomb for a heart attack or stroke. And his mental health has been questions by many medical experts. Yet NYT provides zero coverage of that.
378
@Bill Wolfe And, heaven forbid, if Trump wins a second term, he will be pushing 80 by the time he leaves office. The NYT did have one article where a medical professional pointed out that Trump is primed for heart trouble. Other Dem candidates said they would release their health status. I'm waiting.
27
Yet his energy level is extremely high.
4
Donald Trump is everything you say.
That said, Bernie Sanders's gesticulating and ranting -- his schtick -- were wearing thin. Time for him to stop waving his arms and shouting.
23
Bernie can take solace in the fact that he has had an influence on the Democratic Party becoming more appreciative of the needs of the people. However, he’s right. He needs to take his health into consideration and the needs of the country. After a Chaotic trump presidency, the nation doesn’t want to worry about their next president’s health. It’s time for Bernie to step down.
22
If I were to advise Bernie, I would tell him: "Don't try to downplay this or minimize it, but use it to your advantage. Emphasize that you believe in the platform you're running on, and are betting your life on it. You're giving everything you have to give".
It's like the old joke about a breakfast of bacon and eggs, and who invested more in it, the chicken or the pig: The chicken makes a big contribution, but the pig is really committed.
Bernie is committed.
56
@Kingfish52
If Bernie's the nominee
when he runs aganst trump
he'll be the only one who can claim
to actually Have a heart.
4
Bernie you were my candidate in '16 but now you need to stop. You're a great senator. Stay healthy and keep fighting the good fight.
97
If Bernie gets his wish, he will be the Democratic candidate in the general, and President Trump will point to him and say: "That's the best the Democrats could do -- older than me and he had a heart attack on the campaign trail. No way is Bernie able to do this job."
And the President who spends most of his day on "Executive Time" will be absolutely right.
Bernie, stop clogging the primary the way your artery was and get off the stage.
28
@Citizen60 Please. It's time for anyone polling under 3 percent to drop out but this doesn't apply to Bernie who is still setting the agenda for the race.
12
A President has serious stressors every minute, every hour, everyday in Office. When you have a compromised heart it is well nigh impossible to say the heart can function under severe stress. I had felt the Bern but now I think it would be more prudent for him and for Americans to withdraw from the race.He already is trying to slow down his campaign. The President's Office is way more demanding and challenging physically and mentally. I think Bernie should withdraw graciously.
14
Trump does his job, albeit badly, in bathrobe and slippers in front of his TV.
Can't we find anyone besides tired old men and young know-very-littles to run for President?
4
why aren't folks over 50 routinely checked for blockages in their hearts?
This should not, it seems to me, be a surprise happening.
3
I value Bernie for his mind and judgement. If he can do one rally a day and meetings by video, that is fine. Let him rest. FDR had polio and we elected him for four terms. There are lots who would be happy to be his foot soldiers in a Sanders Administration.
67
@macman2
Post-polio syndrome and the aftereffects of a heart attack are two very different animals...
11
I agree, but to quickly be the party pooper, almost nobody knew FDR had polio because they were worried about nearly this same situation- him being thought of as lesser because of his sickness.
1
@macman2
FDR was post polio. He did not have it in office. A wheelchair is not life threatening. A heart attack severe enough to require two stints is life threatening. This is especially true in a 78 year old man who is under tremendous stress. I do not understand why so many of his supporters want to have him risk his life. He has done his job and done it well. He still has a lot to offer but need not risk his life to do it.
5
Bernie - You helped Trump beat Clinton by siphoning votes away from her. Please drop out of the race now, before you help Trump get re-elected. You have a lot to offer, but the presidency is not going to be it.
67
@Marc-Actually Bernie recruited voters who would have never voted for Hillary anyways. The fact that Hillary Clinton ran a very flawed campaign (e.g. never held one rally in August, calling a key voting segment of America “deplorables”, etc) and the electoral college was the determining factor in her loss, not the healthy primary battle.
22
@Alex
There were numerous reasons causing Clinton's loss but it is a fact that many Sanders voters did not vote and that contributed. The numbers were close in several states. If those people had voted, it might have turned the tide. She was a flawed candidate but she was a heck of a lot better than we got as a result of her loss.
4
@Marc You appear to share Empress Inevitable's delusion that she was entitled to the Democratic nomination by birthright. She wasn't, although she was able to steal it. Once she did, Bernie campaigned hard for her, but the dogs didn't like the dog food.
7
Bernie had what is a common health scare, he got help and is doing just fine now. He will have to lead a campaign schedule similar to the other candidates now.
And even when Bernie was recovering over the weekend he came out with this-
Get Corporate Money Out of Politics
End Corruption of National Party Conventions
- an corporate contributions to the Democratic Party Convention and all related committees.
End Corruption of Presidential Inaugurations
-Corporate donors spend tremendous amounts of money on inaugural events. In 2016, Trump’s inaugural donors included AT&T, Bank of America, Boeing, Exxon Mobil, General Motors, Coca Cola, Pepsi and many more.
Public Election Reform
-In 2016, the fundraising committee for the DNC was led by an insurance executive and a Comcast executive.
Presidential Primary Debates
-Private media outlets charge outrageous sums of money to run ads during presidential primary debates. This year CNN reportedly required a commitment of $300,000 before a sponsor could buy ad time during the presidential debates, and 30 seconds of air time can cost around $110,000.
Congressional Reform
-The influence lobbyists have extends beyond contributions to National Political Parties and individual candidates.
Bernies answers to these can be found here:
https://berniesanders.com/issues/money-out-of-politics/
61
@steve
None of your statistics account for the stress of being President Of The United States.
Bernie should stop. While he can, this side of Heaven.
@steve Angina might be called a “health scare”; an m.i. is a serious event and to avoid becoming the almost 20% who have a second heart attack, Sanders will have to make major adjustments in his life style: he’ll almost certainly be on multiple medications, all of which can have complicating side effects, for the rest of his life; commit to taking more rest than he’s probably ever taken; avoid stress and outbursts of anger (good luck with that in the Oval Office).
There’s a lot of whistling past the grave from many posters here; it’s not for nothing that we have the phrase “serious as a heart attack”.
1
His daughter in law just died of cancer. This is so sad.
16
Bernie Sanders should drop out of the race. he is right, voters would take his health into account when deciding whether to support him.
In my opinion, the time has come to set a maximum age limit for the President of the United States. There is a minimum age of 35 to be the President but not a maximum age. Why not a maximum age?
Sanders and Biden will be in their 80’s before their 1st term ends, too old in my opinion.
I admit I’d be concerned about voting for someone in their late 70s, because of the well-documented effects that aging has on a person’s health
8
I have always admired Bernie Sanders and voted for him in the primary in the last election. Without Bernie Sanders the full blown humanity of the Democratic party's platform would not be where it is today. I don't know where he will go from here, but I do believe he will do the right thing and put work with whoever it is that he believes will do the best they can. Will it be to support the most likely to win the election, I cannot say. I can only wish.
7
Senator Sanders is a person of integrity and someone unusually sincere in the political realm. But he is a mortal person, like everyone else.
It just doesn’t seem plausible anymore that Sanders’ health would allow for the demands of the presidency or a campaign. He has good messages which he can continue publicizing, and, hopefully, which he can continue bringing to the Senate and through an endorsement of the eventual Democratic nominee.
21
Sanders is elderly but so are Trump, Biden and Warren. An isolated heart attack at his age does not mean he will have another, especially given that his extremely vigorous schedule probably contributed to this.
But I do suspect that Sanders - even now - won't be lying in bed until 11am watching TV and enjoying "executive time."
103
Elizabeth Warren would be 78, the age Bernie is now, at the end of her second term. I wish Bernie well and appreciate his contributions, but their ages are not comparable.
7
@Michael he has a 20% chance of a second heart attack within one year. It's a major life event and he is now considered at high risk for a heart attack.
Even so I'd happily vote to ensconce him in place of the current occupant of the White House.
1
@Michael dude in this country anyone more than 60+ is considered elderly? We started to get noticed if AARP at age 50! That’s so strange.
1
The US needs Sanders’ revolution and it’d be great if he could lead it. But a good 2nd option for him is to be around to see the revolution. The job of a President is physically exhausting and I hope he’d be able to keep up. You can scale back a campaign but probably not the job itself. I hope he takes serious stock of his health and the role he can play in determining the next POTUS. It’s great to be king and probably better in some cases to be king (or queen) maker.
5
I’m incredibly sad that this is happening but it was a graceful way and time to bow out. Rip Bernie(‘s campaign), we didn’t deserve you.
3
I would vote for a candidate with heart problems over a heartless incumbent in a heartbeat. Just pick your running mate wisely, and be well Mr. Sanders.
172
As an 83 year old I can only salute your courage, thank you, and urge you to do your damnedest. You have already contributed enormously to our cause, and Eugene Debs is probably applauding up there somewhere. Me too.
67
My guess is that most Democrats can’t say good riddance to Donald Trump quickly enough.
Well, guess what?
With language like Sanders “revolution” rest assure that The Donald will reign—and wreck more havoc in his second term.
4
trump is awful and must go.
having said that, his energy level to create chaos is phenomenal and it will take someone with tremendous energy to beat him.
just like it was said to Biden, it's time for Bernie to pass the torch and for his supporters to get on board the beat trump train.
5
How long before Donald Trump’s health catches up with him? Fast food diet, little sleep, overweight - a recipe for heart disease.
Maybe voters of both parties should take health calculations into consideration...
9
His heart may well be functionally fine, but in the short term he's going to have to adapt to the side-effects of the standard five medications given after an MI, particularly beta-blockers and blood pressure meds, if he wasn't on them already (along with a statin, aspirin, and a super-aspirin).
13
@John Must be what he's up to this weekend!
Sorry to all the Bernie supporters, but this very bad news for his campaign. He’s old, and has now had a myocardial infarction. The stress doesn’t decrease, it only gets worse. Even those who like him can’t help but worry about his health. Personally, I think he needs to step down. He can remain in the Senate and be a force there, along with some of the others.
418
And, his daughter in law died from cancer on Saturday. This poor family.
45
Completely agree. I am grateful for what he has done to move party platform to the left but he needs to end his campaign. And endorse Elizabeth Warren.
39
@VWalters I'll be content with whatever Bernie decides to do. He's had good judgement on top of good morals his entire life. I wish him the best no matter what.
169
I'd rather have a living Senator Bernie than a dead Presidential Candidate Bernie. You don't have to be President, to still have a huge impact. I had my HA 4 years ago and I am 20 years younger. Slow down, get strong, priorities sir.
439
@MD
It's Bernie's choice.
This is what gives him life.
If the man wants to die doing what he loves, for those he loves...more power to him.
3
Obviously he’s done. Time for Bernie voters to pick their new choice. There are several other choices that should meet their political ideals. Let’s be frank, any one of them will be better than the current guy in office. Heck you could randomly pick someone off the street and you’d have a decent chance of getting someone better. I personally as a liberal Democrat would agree to install, right now, a smart Republican who truly wanted to act in what they believe is the best interest of the country ( even though I may vehemently disagree with his or her views) if the current President was required to go far away with no access to social media.
27
@AJ
This race is not about political ideals. It is about survival for the next generation. It is about ending imperialism, structural racism, and reinvigorating the middle class.
6
So, Senator Sanders was vigorously pounding the pavement in this race while unknowingly having a massive blockage in his coronary artery? To be honest, I'm impressed.
127
@Lisa Mann
And an under-active thyroid!! Also, people who work with him---some decades younger---have said they had trouble keeping up with him.
31
If he can’t keep up the even excessive pace on the campaign trail, how will he keep up if there’s a major crisis while he’s in the White House? It’s time for him to bow out.
33
Not only will this sink Bernie's campaign but Biden's too and maybe Warren's. It reminds voters in the clearest possible way that they're all too old, even if they don't know it. I'm about the same age and finally, reluctantly, grudgingly accept that I've transitioned in to codgerhood.
12
At the end of her second term Warren would be the same age as Bernie is now. There is a significant age difference between them.
7
@james haynes : Trump is three years older than Warren and deteriorating mentally and physically, being very obese. Warren is sharp, healthy and energetic and as a woman, has a better life expectancy than a man her age.
3
Keep going at the slower pace but please consider throwing your support to Warren. She can carry your banner. (I say this as a fan of yours since the early nineties.)
200
Ernie needs to e realistic—and donate his campaign funds to someone who can beat corrupt Trump!
12
Bernie had his chance to found a Progressive Party in 2016 and he flunked the test. Bernie is all about Bernie. All he is doing at this point is splitting the Progressive vote. I don't like Warren. I don't like the way she stabbed Bernie in the back in 2016. But she is all we have now.
15
@Billy Glad
Warren is moving up faster than anyone in the polls.
She is attracting many supporters.
She is beating Biden who will not be the nominee. He is not a strong leader and too gaffe prone.
However, she is too far left to win a general election. If she is the nominee, which I doubt when all the primaries are done she will be, we will lose to Trump.
I am supporting more centrist progressives like Mayor Pete.
5
Bernie was stabbed in the back when the DNC decided HRC was a better candidate and froze him out of his own campaign data. Bernie could have won in 2016, and saved us from the current orange nightmare. That said, the Republicans will hammer home his ill-health with deafening, never-ending drumbeats. He no longer has a chance to win, and should withdraw and heartily endorse Warren.
6
@Steveyo
Bernie isn't a Democrat. He does not claim to be one. Yet you tar the DNC for not throwing their weight behind him. As flawed as she is, Clinton is a Democrat and they supported her because of it.
2
The headline sounds way more dire than the content of the article. Also, he’s still got my vote!
115
Good for him. He has much to offer. But I think he need to bow out.
133
Recover quickly and be well, Senator. I'd take you with a questionable heart over what we have (with his bad brain) any day.
128
@Hector ... soulless body and absence of heart to boot.
1
I love Bernie, he changed the course of the debate in this country to include income/wealth disparity as a primary issue, and higher taxes on the wealthy to rebuild the middle and working classes. But, I don't think he should risk his health and life continuing to run for president, there are other candidates, one in particular, who are equally progressive in their moral view and policy prescriptions. Even if he continues and becomes the nominee, his health will be a major issue in the general election and could cost Democrats the White House.
125
@JS
Warren is NOT Bernie. Look at their policies. How long will people continue equating the two? Perhaps enough so people actually believe it... Sadly
4
He's just not well enough to be President -- what he describes IS the job of the President, plus more, and much more stress. If he really wants a political revolution (and he isn't a Biden fan), at this point, he'd do better to drop out and direct his supporters to one or more of the other left-leaners like himself. He might be able to get some platform wins by negotiations with if he endorsed just one of them.
32
If Bernie decides he cannot continue, I wold love to see him give his platform, money and support to Bill De Blasio.
Sanders supporters were very impressed by De Blasio in the debates. And He has a solid record of delivering on progressive policies.
2
@EC
Oh yes, all of the Sanders supporters are absolutely clambering for De Blasio. No doubt. Really.
Bernie Sanders was doing more rallies and events than any of the other candidates so if he dials it back a bit during his recovery, he'll be at the same pace as the other candidates.
189
Now if that isn't a textbook example of living in delusion, I don't know what is!
69
@Jared
The number of events each candidate did in the last election is freely available on their website.
It's a fact that he did more events, in more cities than any other candidate running.
30
This is not accurate. And even if it were being president for 4 years would be even more stressful than campaigning. He is 78 and he has had a heart attack. I am grateful for all he is done. He needs to end his campaign. He should endorse Elizabeth Warren.
17