Flush With Cash, Pete Buttigieg Bets His Campaign on a Breakthrough in Iowa

Oct 03, 2019 · 235 comments
Bob (Portland)
So a gay Midwestern mayor is doing well in Iowa! They say America is resistant to change...........maybe not.
Sue (California)
There are currently many young leaders of nations in the world -- New Zealand, France, Ireland, and Canada. They are doing pretty well (aside from a few scandals) and their lack of prior experience in government hasn't hurt them. It's probably a good thing to not have been in politics for long -- reduces corruptibility! Good leadership comes from smart ideas and a judicious selection of cabinet members to delegate your authority. Your experience as a senator or a congressman only proves electability and a knack for getting nothing done!!
Pat Boice (Idaho Falls, ID)
Buttigieg has had my vote for months now. Listening to his town hall Q&A's, his foreign policy speech at Indiana University, and other public appearances did the trick for me. Buttigieg is the only candidate who stresses the #1 priority of restoring our democracy and democratic institutions. He's brilliant and being the youngest candidate in the group it is all the more interesting that he possesses such leadership qualities.
SeekingAnswers (Hawaii)
Everyone should Google "what are the qualities of a great president" and then choose. How great presidents lead: ...guided by a sense of moral purpose. At moments of great challenge, all sought to heal divisions, to bring various parts of the country together, to summon the citizenry to a sense of common purpose. They were able to use their talents to enlarge the opportunities and lives of others. Traits of a great president: ...humility, empathy, resilience, courage; the ability to replenish energy, listen to diverse opinions, control negative impulses, connect with all manner of people, communicate through stories and keep one's word. A choice justified by such qualities are hard to argue. It's also very telling to measure Trump based on the above qualities. My choice for the person who best displays the above traits is Mayor Pete Buttigieg.
Daryl (Vancouver)
I'm a Canadian and a gay atheist and rarely wish I was an American. But if I was right now, I would be working day and night to get Mayor Pete elected. He is bright promise of a future where everyone has equal access to a quality education, good health care and economic success! Good luck Pete!
Ray (Port St. Lucie Fls.)
@Daryl I'm a hetro American agnostic and I agree with my Canadian cousin. Good Luck to Mayor Pete !
Evelyn (Boise)
There are a lot of things that I like about Mayor Buttigieg. I am a veteran and appreciate his service especially since he certainly did not have to serve as a way to pay for college or escape a less than desirable upbringing, as is common for some service members (myself included). I read his book though, and almost every woman mentioned in the book is either a mom or an administrative assistant. No mention of women colleagues or women that he admires or respects or even consults with on important issues. Combine that with his record with the police department and the black community in South Bend and I’m afraid we have just another white privileged man. I was really disappointed because I wanted to believe that he could represent everyone. I don’t think he can. I’m sticking with Elizabeth Warren.
Greg (Los Angeles)
@Evelyn His campaign manager is a woman. 40% of his staff are minority/people of color and that number rises every day. White man of privilege was not works until we announce our sexuality and then our jobs, homes, and peace of mind no longer sit with that class.
cl (ny)
@Evelyn His big racial issue is a police chief that is still under investigation with the FBI. Under those circumstances, Pete could not see keeping him on. I sorry you want a candidate who represents everyone. You are not going to get one. I like Warren as well, but she doesn't resonate with the Black community any more than Pete, probably even less.
AZSusan (Tucson)
@Greg No, his campaign manager is Mike Schmuhl. They've known each other since high school. You're thinking of Lis Smith, who is his communications director. I think he's now at about 60% women/LGBTQ/minority/POC on his staff.
Jean (New York)
Buttigieg is a slick, carefully packaged (with help from the corporate media) corporate candidate. I hope you'll read this article (and many others you can find) for a more careful consideration of Buttigieg beyond the platitudes: https://www.currentaffairs.org/2019/03/all-about-pete
Evidence Guy (Rochester,NY)
Flush with cash from where?
Lambros Balatsias (Charlotte, NC)
I voted for Obama, Bill Clinton, both Bush presidents, Ronald Reagan and yes Trump. 2016 was an election between two of the worst candidates ever put forth. 2020 will be worse, as Hillary was superior to every Democrat currently running. Democrats were once the Big Tent party, open to all. Now they pander to the tiniest segments of society. A large tent with poor support will collapse upon those under it! Medicare for all will lead to healthcare for none. Eliminate student debt? Checks are in the mail! Reparations? Check. Open borders? Check. Our $22 trillion debt will be $50 trillion by 2030, Green Deal or not. Not one candidate is tackling the issues behind the soaring costs. Think colleges are expensive now? Wait until athletes can start monetizing themselves. Bigger, more luxurious facilities must be built, education be damned! Climate change? Not one candidate is asking if Tesla can make airplanes, or more efficient air conditioners. It was almost 99 degrees in Charlotte on OCTOBER 3RD! Any candidate pushing trade or vocational schools? What good are 10,000 liberal arts majors when no one can install or fix an air conditioner? Why build air conditioners in Indiana for $25 an hour when you can build them in Mexico for $3 an hour? Shocker! A capitalist society pursues cheap labor and higher profits, which means more Americans losing more jobs. A company that employs 6 people at $10/hour will employ 4 at $15/hour. The labor costs are the same but now 2 are unemployed!
sorges (Portola Valley, CA)
@Lambros Balatsias so if a capitalist society pursuing cheap labor means more Americans are losing more jobs, what type of society are you proposing? Look more closely at the proposals being put forward by the Democrats, then do your research. Every other developed country (and many developing countries) in this world has some sort of healthcare for all. Nobody is without care. The statistics show that the cost per capita is MUCH LESS than what we pay in the US. The people who lose in this scenario are the big insurance companies who are making huge amounts of money, and they have spent a lot of money scaring you and others into thinking healthcare for all will be a disaster. Every single statistic supports it over the current system - do your research!
Janet Clark (Bay Area)
If you doubt that Pete's experience as mayor hasn't given him incredible problem solving experience--take time to read his book. As military and as mayor, Pete has finely tuned an ability to get citizens to be part of the solution. I'm from CA and could not be more impressed. Pete is what my children's future needs. He's already got my vote. Read his book. It's fascinating.
mikekev56 (Drexel Hill PA)
Sorry, Pete. You’re cool, but completely unelectable.
Miss M (Calif)
I’m amazed at the enthusiasm expressed here for a man who is gay. Have we evolved this much? I have always hoped we would, but it seems to have come so quickly. Color me surprised.
Barrie Grenell (San Francisco)
How 'bout a Nerd Ticket of Mayor Pete and Andrew Yang?
Sage (California)
No Pete for me, at this juncture. While Pete is very bright, emotionally stable and understands governance--being the Mayor of a small city is not enough experience to lead a country--a country that has been horribly damaged by Mafia-Don and his unsavory Syndicate. Pete is not ready for Prime Time...yet. Senator Warren has my vote!
Ross Ivanhoe (Western Mass)
@Sage I fail to understand why people think Senators who vote on laws and argue with each other are more equipped to set policy, make important decisions and deal with world leaders than a mayor or governor. Senators aren’t executives like mayors and governors are. Also troubled by folks who act like because Pete hasn’t eliminated racism in a troubled city, he’s not ready. Can you tell me someone who has?
I (Los Angeles, CA)
Do they give Buttigieg supporters scripts? You sound like clones. I don't get the appeal. I voted for Obama in 2008 and I'm sorry that was completely different and truly was a generational moment. It's 2018. I think we need someone like Bernie or Warren. Warren as president would truly be an important and inspiring moment.
Lee H (Australia)
Looking in from afar and reading all the articles and watching on PBS Newshour(we get that here in Aus) all the discussion and interviews of candidates for the Dems...Mayor Pete just sticks out like a brightly flashing light in the darkness. I like Biden and Sanders they're decent men and Warren and Harris are decent women the former are just too old and the latter just don't quite have the all round appeal that Mayor Pete does. He's thoughtful, he's able to dissect a question and explain in simple terms his views, his answers and his ideas. He's already led an extraordinary life and he's only 37!! What a complete breath of fresh air he would be in the now tainted Whitehouse, he would bring decency, honesty and I believe trust back to the institution. He's no East/West coast urban functionary, he has a instantly recognizable 'common' touch. What a turn around it would be for this great nation that has sunk so far in the world's eyes and I'm sure your own to put someone who is the complete opposite of Trump in almost everything into the highest office in the land and indeed in the free world. Trump would then become an inhabitant of the dustbin of history and good riddance. Go Mayor Pete!
William Perrigo (Germany (U.S. Citizen))
This is the quote alright: “In order to settle the question of electability, the best thing you can do is perform well in an actual election. Iowa’s of course the first. And so that’s where a lot of our focus is going to go.” For Iowa this is a position of quick and easy state income and with it they get to influence the focus of the voting nation. What a sham! This would be like watching the exact same Super Bowl commercial year after year! Herein lies the convoluted way our voting system is set up. If anything, Iowa should be dead last this year...after all the other states have decided. That would be a system based on fairness, equality, justice, nobility, humility, correctness, high morality, etc. They all talk about change this and change that but in reality it’s just business as usual. The only thing that hasn’t changed is you have to make sure you don’t step in it!
CKathes (Seattle)
Much like Beto O'Rourke, Pete's a talented politician with potentially a great future, but he's way too young and untested to be running for president. Especially after Trump, we will need someone with a long and distinguished record of quality public service, who has the experience, connections and know-how to start fixing things on Day One. Pete is just not that person, not this time around. Maybe in another decade or two. Right now I'd be delighted to support him for Congress. Otherwise he should stay in South Bend and focus on being a good mayor for a while longer.
Bob (Chicago)
I've been a Pete can since I learned he taught himself Nordic to read a boo k - truly the most non triumphant thing you can do. I think he's struggling because he's a non front runner who isn't controversial, doesn't pick fights, so he gets no oxygen in debates. But he has great favorability with Iowans, they love positive messages. He might have some below the surface movement going.
Barbara Mohon (Santa Fe, NM)
From the first Ted Talks that I saw of Mayor Pete, through watching his campaign grow, I could instantly tell that he would become a healing force for our Country and ultimately the world. He has it all right. His plans are detailed and well explained. But it is more than his intelligence and plans. It is his integrity and compassion. It is a perfect time for Mayor Pete. Don’t find excuses. Vote for the right candidate.
GB (Cambridge)
I have never previously donated to any candidate in a primary. Only once have I made a modest donation in the presidential general election. For Pete, I maxed out for his primary run. Why? His talent and discipline to frame even the most contentious issues of the day to allow even the most liberal and conservative to step gracefully to his view. They may not all get there, but he offers a the welcome path by putting in terms of American values we all share. His biography and service-to-country reinforce those lived values like no other. I feel his rivals are drawing too much upon Trump's villains and victims playbook, and counting on divisiveness and anger. I passionately believe we need a talented and disciplined uniter at this critical moment in our Republic. For me, Pete is the only one up to this historical challenge, not just for the country but for the world.
Len (Pennsylvania)
Pete Buttigieg is Young Smart Compassionate Humble - and sincerely so A Veteran Stable Multi-lingual Honorable In short, all of the things that the present person occupying the White House is not. He may be a long shot to win the Democratic nomination, but he has my support both politically and financially. In American presidential politics, it is common for the nation to elect a person who has the exact opposite traits of the president he/she will replace. I cannot think of a more stark difference between Donald Trump and Pete Buttigieg. I wish him godspeed.
Anne-Marie Hislop (Chicago)
Iowa has generally long been a purple state having in the early 2000s one GOP and one Dem Senator as well as narrowly swinging in POTUS elections. That said, I lived in Davenport from 2001-2009. Driving around during election seasons there was a clear urban-rural divide. Within Davenport, Iowa City, and Cedar Rapids, I saw many Democratic lawn signs, but get out in farm country or small rural towns and the signs were all for the GOP candidate. The shifts back and forth in Iowa had generally been subtle until Trump's win. Whether some of that had to do with a conservative antipathy to Hillary (including her being a woman) is impossible to know for sure. That said, it will be harder to win rural Iowa in Nov 2020 with the farther Dem left candidates on offer.
Fullonfog (San Francisco)
I’m all in for Pete. I suspect many of my fellow Californians will agree and deliver a strong showing for him on Super Tuesday. Here in the Bay Area/Silicon Valley I suspect he’s gong to do very well. I hope the rest of America sees what we see and gives him their votes to send him to the general election for victory in 2020. Smart, principled, and forward looking. He is what America needs right now.
Cathy Lane (Blountville TN)
I feel that Mayor Pete Buttigieg is a once in a lifetime candidate. He is brilliant, kind, insightful and gives you a calmness at just hearing him speak. He is the polar opposite of what we’ve had to deal with since the 2016 election. We need this young man with his ideas and heart and willingness to restore America to our former dignity. I have never contributed to a campaign before nor have I purchased shirts and bumper stickers but I have done all 3 for Mayor Pete. He is the real deal and I am with him all the way.
Ronn (Seoul)
This candidate has been nothing but impressive. America could do much better with his leadership and strong sense of ethics.
Craig H. (California)
Pete's a possibility but I would like to hear more about policy.
Jessiekitty (Chicago)
You can see several of his very detailed policies/proposals on his campaign website at PeteforAmerica.com Look on the main menu for Issues. In addition to those you will see less detailed information about a whole range of topics. He continues to publish more fully explained and referenced policy papers fairly often, and most likely will do that around the time of the next debate. Also you can search Meet Pete (on his website); it's a large collection of videos of his speeches and interviews that you can search by keyword to see what he has said on a wide range of issues.
Lark (Midwest)
@Craig H. If you are interested in learning about Buttigieg’s policy proposals, they are covered at peteforamerica.com Here is a link to the Issues section, where there are links to videos in which Buttigieg answers policy related questions. https://ask.peteforamerica.com/?_gl=1*1cec588*_gcl_aw*R0NMLjE1NzAxOTgxMjAuRUFJYUlRb2JDaE1JbjgzRTJPT0M1UUlWU19fakJ4MU8wZ2NSRUFBWUFTQUJFZ0ptLWZEX0J3RQ..
Barbara Mohon (Santa Fe, NM)
You can find it all on his web site.
MLH (Rural America)
An admirable candidate and as a conservative the one I'm most afraid of but in a nice way. Rhodes scholar, military service, midwesterner from a red state, excellent and thoughtful speaker unsullied by Washington rot and corruption. Hopefully he represents the next generation of Democrats and in a sense a throwback to the midwestern progressive tradition of the party. I wish him well in his endeavors.
1blueheron (Wisconsin)
A Veteran who knows what is wrong with our wars. Someone who knows that the Electoral College needs to go. Brighter than the average politician. A good model for the world - nations can start raising up thinking people, instead of dictators. A strong contrast to where we are now. For those of us who need it - here's Pete.
dressmaker (USA)
@1blueheron How about a Warren-Buttigieg ticket?Nice balance of ages, logic, charm, religion, sexes, ideas. Seems like it might be an appealing package.
Pat Boice (Idaho Falls, ID)
@dressmaker - Love both of them, but I would prefer a Buttigieg/Warren.
CP (NYC)
I love Pete’s moral clarity and reasonable decision-making. He would be such a levelheaded and respectable leader, completely the opposite of the current reprehensible disgrace. Would that our next president actually stand for the best of ourselves rather than our basest impulses.
Mr Robert (Sacramento, CA)
@CP Pete's an empty suit w/o a policy portfolio so there's no way he will advance even with all of his campaign money.
William F (Minnesota)
It certainly would be a reassuring reasoned voice in DC.
Steve Bolger (New York City)
@CP: Mayor Pete is even a religious guy. But many people have to give up preconceptions of what God purportedly thinks about sex to risk their promised afterlives to vote for him.
Bobbie (Oregon)
This is the first candidate that I have seriously supported. I have given to other campaigns at lower levels but I feel this is the candidate of my lifetime (I'm 63) who could inspire the kinds of changes that FDR did. He will do it for a similar reason, because he knows how to speak to people where they are and inspire their better selves. I have seen amazing grass roots support for this candidate here in Oregon and all over the country because he does inspire. We are doing everything we can even here in Oregon where we have little possible effect in the primary. I also think he's the best candidate to beat Trump. He's unflappable, won't tangle or get defensive from Trump tweet torpedoes. The toughest thing for him is overcoming his relatively lower name recognition in the primaries. I think if Iowa will vote for him, the rest of the country will take a more serious look and be Amazed!
Susan (Texas)
I live in a rural part of Texas and work in Houston, so I've met all types of voters. Not a single person that I've met supports Biden. Of course DJT wants to go up against him; the former VP would wither and fumble in a debate and I've grown suspicious about any media outlet that claims he's a frontrunner. I've been a fan of Mayor Pete since before he announced and he's the perfect foil in contrast to those who've been sullied by Washington's taint. Brilliant, cool and calm, and I would be proud to have him represent the U.S. internationally and domestically.
B.Sharp (Cinciknnati)
@Susan I agree...wish Biden would drop out and stop suffocating us with his soft ball response in debates. And now this trump’s manipulative attacks on Biden is sucking all the air out of 2020 election. I am into Pete Buttigieg from the get go and want to wish him all the success in life.
Jim (Abita Springs)
@Susan - Texas is not a swing state democrats are counting on. Win back the blue wall rust belt and Biden wins. The country isn't ready for mayor Pete. FTR, it was Biden who moved Obama to the left on gay marriage and other related issues. Without the minorities vote in many states, you just can't win. I'm a big Texas man being a UT graduate but other then Austin, your analysis is moot.
Fullonfog (San Francisco)
@Susan Pete is as different a contrast in character as Carter was to Nixon. America needs a palate cleanser. I’m voting for Pete to win not just this election, but to win the era. America needs smart, kind, principled and forward looking leadership.
Charles Ross (Portland, Oregon)
I'm 68 years old. I've never contributed money to any presidential campaign. I've made three small donations to Pete Buttigieg's effort in recent months. I recently read his autobiography 'The Way Back Home'. It's a mature and thoughtful effort that belies his 37 years. When I hear him speak and interact with interviewers, he has an insightful way of dissecting questions and getting to the heart of what is being asked. I don't hear him engaging in the platitudes and campaign slogans that several other of the candidates employ. I'm really impressed with Mayor Pete.
jessiekitty (Chicago, IL)
@Charles Ross hope you don't mind the correction. His autobiography is called "Shortest Way Home."
Jamie (Oregon)
@Charles Ross I'm 75, and you wrote my mind.
Paul Leddy (Florida)
Hear, all ye good people, hear what this brilliant and eloquent speaker has to say!”
Chris M. (Seattle, WA)
I love Mayor Pete. I truly do. He has my full support.
Jamie (Los Angeles)
Love Mayor Peter. Will he capture the black or middle America vote? I hope so. He's a brilliant man, capable of leading a nation.
Doris Keyes (Washington, DC)
I find Mayor Pete to be a phony - greatly exaggerates his military experience and just rather bland and too vanilla. He copied Obama with the lofty speeches but little else. He doesn’t strike me as fit to be president. I have heard nothing from him that convinces me to put my life and that of my family in his hands. He is just a nothing.
Carol-Ann (Pioneer Valley)
@Doris Keyes Feel better now? Either you haven't been listening, or you've chosen not to read nor listen. Pete was one of the first candidates out there with solid plans. He has a program to make health care work, with the people getting to choose, not having it dictated; an education plan that recognizes that education can not be "free," but can be made affordable; his stand on gun violence prevention is solid and sensible. So maybe the issue is something else. Maybe it has nothing to do with his platforms, maybe it has something to do with who he is and what he stands for. By the way, you do know he has had to tackle a lot of these issues on a regular basis? He is an elected mayor and he is the only one running who grapples with these issues. So I don't know where your comment about "lofty speeches and little else" comes from. He isn't president, but he does run a mid-sized city. Are you talking about the Mayor Buttigieg who is running for president? I don' think so.
karen (bay area)
California voter here. My vote goes to... A ham sandwich. Since our largest state, biggest economy does not count, I go for for whomever can rid us of this disaster a tiny minority brought us.
Deanna (NY)
I’ll be voting for Buttigieg or Warren. Not sure which one yet.
BW (Canada)
Isn't it nice to hear a politician with a brain speak? Makes you realize how dumbed down the conversation has become with Trump tweeting instead of leading.
Fred (New York)
Buttigieg/Abrams will do it.
PL (ny)
@Fred -- that would lose black AND working class white voters. Stacy Abrams came across as a sore loser in her no-concession speech. Blue collar whites will have enough trouble working up enthusiasm for the elite Pete, but an Angry Black Woman would be a bridge too far.
SMS (Wisconsin)
Pete remains the only candidate who is truly presidential and able to get get us to the future we need. I wish the bottom 5 candidates would graciously exit the race so voters can better assess their choices.
Linda (NYC)
Love this candidate. Read his book and you too will know why he can be president! Donating my heart out every month. Sorry Liz. Free anything is a nowhere ride.
Stanley Jones (Oregon)
I'm not interested in him being a nice man. Or that he seems to speak eloquently, even though both of those traits are nice to have. I also don't care too much about whether or not he looks presidential. What I want to know is what is this man going to specifically do that directly affects my choice? Is he going to improve the economy, if so how? Lessen inequality, if so how? Student debt, if so how? Immigration, if so how? And how does he plan to appease those tens of millions not liking the idea of a gay President?
David John (Columbus, Oh)
“And how does he plan to appease those voters who don’t like the idea of a gay President” So what exactly do you want him to do? Suddenly say he’s really heterosexual now? What you are saying is he’s supposed to “appease” homophobia. Would you have asked Barrack Obama back in ‘08 how does he plan on appeasing those voters who don’t like the idea of a black President? The answer to both is be the best genuine you, which Obama did and Mayor Pete seems to be doing well.
Barbara Mohon (Santa Fe, NM)
Go to his website and read. You will find the thorough and thoughtful answers to your questions. Or listen to what he is stating.
Ronn (Seoul)
@Stanley Jones I honestly don't think about or care about the "gay" bit. That is not what makes a leader or a better policy for leadership goals and considering the many vices of those in leadership positions today, the man is a saint.
mpound (USA)
"Mr. Tully, 24, who was a caucus organizer in 2016 for Hillary Clinton, declared Mr. Buttigieg his top candidate." I nearly fell off my seat after reading this sentence. After looking at the photos of nothing but elderly white voters in Iowa with this article, I had absolutely no idea that Iowa has a resident as young as 24 years old. Please stop the insanity and change the nominating process - we can do better than allowing such a limited and racially uniform demographic in a small rural state have such power in determining the fate of presidential candidates. Enough is enough.
David Parsons (San Francisco)
I am a supporter of Mayor Pete Buttigieg, and believe his message will resonate with the vast center. I also think he is smart enough to pivot beyond a simple label. Our country has been "led" by an ignorant fool for years, so it will feel like pure enlightenment and strength to once again have intellect, strategy and integrity in leadership. He would be a fine combination with Senator Warren, and that ticket over Trump Pence would be indomitable. Senator Warren understands how the country needs to change. But in 2020, if Trump is not disqualified for his multiple violations of the Constitution, I would seek a candidate that will win all corners hands down. Right now, if down to one candidate, I would say Pete Buttigieg. He just needs to lock down the senior citizen vote.
Alan Levitan (Cambridge, MA)
@David Parsons "He just has to lock down the senior citizen vote." Hey, I'm a senior citizen, and he's locked down mine. So too for many other senior citizens I know. But I guess that's Massachusetts for you.
Wiltontraveler (Florida)
There's much to be said for Mayor Buttigieg: he's smart, a war veteran, he's a thoughtful moderate, and he has good ideas. As a gay man, I root for him. He might have trouble in the present climate of vituperation running against the most crassly insulting president who's ever occupied the office. But that's not my main reservation: Buttigieg lacks experience at more than the local level. Trump had no experience either, you say? That's precisely the problem (his narcissism and dishonesty aside): Trump has no idea what he's doing, and it's catching up to him. So I would support Mayor Buttigieg to head the Veteran's administration, or for congressman, or for senator. Anything to get him national experience that might move him further in his quest for high office.
Steven Rosen (Brooklyn)
@Wiltontraveler Obama was a state senator from Illinois for 7 years, and then a US senator for 3 years. One of which was spent campaigning for president. He had no executive experience, which Pete does. He had no military experience, which Pete does. Even so, he was, in my opinion, the greatest president of modern times. Obama is insanely smart, humble, and kind. A center left politician who saved our economy, and pushed this country in a progressive direction. Out of all the candidates, Pete is the one who most reminds me of Obama. I follow him very closely. I watch all his speeches and interviews. He has never once been stumped by a question. He doesn't answer in compete sentences. He answers in complete paragraphs. His depth and breadth of knowledge is astounding. Matched with an inherent goodness, and a deep desire to serve. He is one of a kind. Visit his site to find out more. https://peteforamerica.com/issues/ https://ask.peteforamerica.com
Gwen (Oregon)
I consider myself as politically interested but not politically active. That changed with Mayor Pete. First time in my 50 years that I have given money to a political cause. I have contributed several times to his campaign. I know he's a long shot but I hold out hope he may make it.
Luke (Yonkers, NY)
Buttigieg is the sleeper in this primary. He is very well positioned for current circumstances. Sanders is losing support for several reasons, the latest being his health issues. Warren is the immediate beneficiary, but this raises the specter of "never Warren" Democrats in the business and financial community. Biden is compromised because of the impeachment inquiry -- although an eminently decent public servant, he will now be relentlessly "Hillaried" by Trump and his allies. Michael Moore just called him "the Hillary of this election cycle," and he's essentially right. Pete Buttigieg will emerge in the coming weeks as the only center-left alternative to Warren and Biden. He's the sleeper, and he's poised to leap forward.
Jaleh (Aspen)
I love him. I hope he is nominated.
Norma Lee (New York)
For those who claim he lacks "experience". Read the article again and you may realize how he has grasped the innuendos of navigating a campaign with analysis, thought and action., in an innovative, goal orientated manner. With all due respect to the Reps & Senators, how much "experience" is it to sit on committees. A war, a recession, trade , (for example) are unexpected circumstances that require the intellect, the calm and the humility to seek, and select expert advisors...and those are the qualities a President Pete offers us.
Daniel B (Granger, IN)
If Pete succeeds Trump, my main worry is how we will recover from the whiplash.
Barbara T (Swing State)
Mayor Pete is the male version of Leslie Knope from Parks and Recreation. Young, idealistic, smart, and ready to help. What's more, he's even from Indiana. Let's hope he follows Leslie Knope's trajectory -- from small city official to President of the United States.
Richard Watt (New Rochelle, NY)
I like Buttigieg, I like Warren, I like Harris. Despite whom I like, I now consider myself a yellow dog Democrat. I would vote for that yellow dog over there,rather than any Republican. They have totally debased conservatism and what it stands for. It looks like they've been sniffing too much glue.
Iced Tea-party (NY)
By focusing on how to talk with one another, rather than about policy, this school marm wrote himself outta contention
citizennotconsumer (world)
our electoral system is an obscenity.
RamS (New York)
I think Warren/Buttigieg could win and if done right could set up a 16 year run for Democrats after the Trump fiasco. That said, I think if Buttigieg did win without Warren, he'd be another Obama - a lot of lofty words but less action not necessarily his fault but still I think a lot of this is playing the game for him. I'm sure he's a decent guy but he's also a smart guy so I see a lot of parallels there. Sanders/Buttigieg would be the most honest ticket but it won't be as strong as the above two since Sanders had his chance before and I think he's not as charismatic. Unfortunately that seems to matter to American voters. Warren isn't necessarily going to be another un-Obama but I think she'll be between Sanders and Obama in terms of integrity. Any of the D candidates would be better than Trump in terms of integrity.
Mr Robert (Sacramento, CA)
@RamS I think you're giving Warren far too much credit. She and Obama were molded by very similar processes and I expect that she would be very much like Obama in all areas except for things like banking regulation and consumer protection. Those are the only areas that she really cares about or has any experience in and I expect she would govern accordingly. The well off members of this society will be given more than enough reign to maintain their stranglehold on the working class and they won't mind giving up a few bucks here and there in exchange for keeping their privileged positions. On the other hand, if Bernie Sanders gets elected along with a Democratic majority in Congress then they can kiss their fortunes goodbye and I will do what I can as a member of the working class to see that Bernie is elected as President. In the longer term, it will be best for the country and better than a replay of the French Revolution which will eventually come about unless this ship of state is righted by correcting the economic injustices that have existed since the late 1970s.
Laurence Bachmann (New York)
@RamS Warren/Buttigieg? I think you vastly underestimate the misogyny and homophobia of the American electorate. If Warren is nominated she needs to select an Af/Am male to energize that community and make sure they don't sit out 2020 as they did 2016. Buttigieg has no popularity or even credibility with Af/Am community. He's seen as an elitist white guy who fired the black police chief of South Bend. Fair or not, he isn't well regarded by them.
PL (ny)
@Laurence Bachmann -- right, and you didn't make the connection, but the Af/Am community is guilty of much of that homophobia, as the most socially conservative segment of Democrats. But since he's lost that group anyway, the reliable turnout of more tolerant voters can still put him (and Warren) over the top. Fair or not, the Democratic Party should stop chasing voters who will not support candidates who don't look like them -- that was Hillarys strategy, and she lost them anyway.
Joanne Higgins (South Carolina)
Heard him speak on a hot day in a small rural town in South Carolina and then later at a stump meeting. He is my choice now. He is articulate and calm. I listened carefully to his answer to cold questions from the audience in the first meeting and was very impressed by his answers. The group in the meeting were surprisingly very eclectic for a rural SC town. Keep moving, Pete!
Alex (Washington, DC)
Pete Buttigieg may not have the Washington experience of other candidates, but he is smart and principled. For people like me who are suspicious of career politicians, that is refreshing. I also believe that Mr. Buttigieg's Midwestern roots are appealing, as are his moderate policies. The next president needs to be able to speak to the entirety of America, not just the people who voted for him/her. Pete Buttigieg has the ability to do that. I'll be voting for Pete Buttigieg in the primary, and hopefully in the general election, too.
Bamagirl (NE Alabama)
I really love his ability to talk about religious values in a kind and consensus building way. I think he could persuade a lot of Southern and rural-suburban female voters who are ready for a more respectful approach. I would love to see a Warren-Buttigieg ticket. Her economic vision and commitment to service combined with his pragmatism and military experience would be a great combination. They are both bright and sincere and a breath of fresh air. I hope he’ll expand his ground operations more in the south. We’re similar to the Midwest, but not the same. We are having to work harder to overcome systemic poverty and corrupt leadership that has left us pretty discouraged.
Pat Boice (Idaho Falls, ID)
@Bamagirl - Buttigieg/Warren.
LesISmore (RisingBird)
Too soon for Mayor Pete; for one thing he lacks experience on the national level,and (sad but true) in Washington. However, should Warren, Harris or even Booker win, he'd make a good VP choice. He certainly could be a Cabinet pick. So far I've felt only Biden would be acceptable choice across the Democratic Party spectrum, now I'm wondering about that. A Biden-Booker or Biden-Harris pairing makes political sense; as does a Biden-Castro (but given events at last debate, I don't think that will happen.) Biden-Warren may be a non starter, but... Biden-Buttigieg doesn't cover as many ticks as may be needed; politically speaking, not enough balance on the ticket.
Carol (North Carolina)
We are in perilous times. We need a new style of leadership, and Pete fits the bill. He’s the most impressive politician I’ve seen—a great communicator but also kind and moral and thoughtful. He’s tough as nails too, and determined to maintain his composure no matter who tries to get under his skin. His demeanor could serve him well in a match-up with Trump . . . or Pence. I hope Iowa likes him as much as I do.
Mrs M (Florida)
Best and brightest news I've heard today, about a man who represents what we remember about the best and brightest of past generations. We wish him the very best as he goes forward, and would vote for him in a heartbeat. As Michael Moore said recently........"people don't vote on policy, they vote on charisma". Pete has that in an understated way, leavened with intelligence, thoughtfulness, honesty and service. Go Mayor Pete!
cl (ny)
It frustrates to no end that Iowa plays such a prominent role in our national politics. Iowa has 4 electoral votes, for crying out loud. Same goes for New Hampshire. Tiny population, mostly rural, mostly white, and in the case of New Hampshire, mostly old. Does this represent our country?
Matt (San Francisco)
@cl I share your frustration, but Iowa has 6 electoral votes. It has 4 Congressional districts, which maybe was what you were thinking.
David Bielecki (California)
Calm, thoughtful, deeply introspective and fiercely intelligent. Committed to American values and institutions. Humble. Take one look at Washington right now, then take another look at Mayor Pete. He’s got my vote.
Leigh (LaLa Land)
I've never seen him caught flat footed by a question. I love his temperament!
Joanne Higgins (South Carolina)
@Leigh Same here! Because he thinks before he speaks and speaks well and convincingly. What a concept.
Daniel James McCabe (Brooklyn, NY)
The brightest, most eminently reasonable of the Democratic candidates has determined that he’s compelled to engage with people in order to get them to vote for him. Pity no one thought of this strategic masterstroke in ‘16.
Walter mccarthy (Las Vegas, nv)
I’m left of center, maybe in 40 or 50, years will Americans elect someone who answers to his husband.
Trix (Ava)
Pete comes cross as cool (not cold ) clear thinking and in control of his communication candidate. He seems to have the ability to connect with people without alienating them with his strong intellect. With the impeachment backdrop, Democrats have to think big, bold and seize 2020 as the election that will give them a president for 8 years . Not just 4 years. Select a candidate who you think can be your president till 2028! and deliver un-interrupted on the American people's agenda .To me Pete personifies what America and Americans used to stand for -Character. Courage. Conviction.
Hal (Illinois)
November 3 2020 cannot get here quick enough. I'm still optimistic that the Democrats will enforce the Constitution and throw Criminal Trump out way before then.
Maureen R (Sacramento, CA)
Ok, maybe Pete's too young; we'll see. If not, then a Warren/Buttigieg ticket will do. I am a super duper Mayor Pete fan. He makes sense and appears to be a decent human being.
Bart (Oradell, NJ)
Interesting article but one thing's missing. How is Pete Buttigieg (or any of the other candidates) going to answer that woman who asked about prescription drugs or a better life and job security for her son??
PL (ny)
@Bart -- Don't know how Buttigieg would address the son's job security, but I do know who could: Andrew Yang and his universal basic income plan, aka Freedom Dividend. Put an extra $1000/month in people's hands, and it would free them up from depending 100% on any job. The stress relief alone would improve the health of the overall population. You think Yang doesn't stand a chance? He's been polling not far behind Buttigieg, and well ahead of Booker, Castro, Klobuchar, and O'Rourke. Buttigieg and Yang would make a refreshing, dynamic team.
blgreenie (Lawrenceville NJ)
Have never seen him in person. So, at this time, the most remarkable thing about him is his oddly spelled last name. He's yet to discover how to stick out from the crowd. A nice guy in a world of sharks.
Joanne Higgins (South Carolina)
@blgreenie You need to see him in person. You will be impressed.
Dennis Sopczynski (San Mateo, California)
@blgreenie I have met met him twice this year. And in early September when I made a trip to my hometown of South Bend, Indiana among the people with whom I had conversations about Mayor Pete aside from family were his mother and Julie Chismar. We happened to have crossed paths.
Maria Holland (Washington DC)
Too bad he takes corporate money - hence his war chest. While he speak out against money in policy. It’s a shame.
Jessiekitty (Chicago)
Not true. He takes no money from corporations, corporate lobbyists, PACs, or anyone affiliated with the fossil fuel industry. The average donation to his campaign is $32.00. He has hundreds of thousands of individual donors. No donor, no matter how wealthy, may give more than $2800.00 total. He also has the lowest income and net worth of all the candidates, by far, and his household has a 6-figure student loan debt. The top 4 candidates are all millionaires. Senators have access to a lot of funding from their previous campaigns, and some like Sanders and Warten have amassed a great deal. And not every dollar was earned in little donations. So your argument the Pete Buttigieg is somehow sullied by having raised a lot of money is a purity test that ignores the immense amount of money needed to run a campaign.
Joanne Higgins (South Carolina)
@Maria Holland Not true. He is grassroots. He has my money and my friends' money.
Kate (NH)
@Jessiekitty You are mistaken, Maria Holland is correct. He is the only candidate in top 4 tier taking money from Washington lobbyists. Plus, he takes corporate money. Just google donations to Buttigieg, or go to open secrets.com, which has a list of his corporate donors.
Aerys (Long Island)
He should have changed his last name to "Butte" or similar a while back - a brand that's not easy to pronounce always has a handicap. Could he end the hype-rpartisinship and save the nation? Seems possible No one's mentioned the elephant in the room though: how many Americans won't vote for a man simply because he's gay?
kb (new london, ct)
@Aerys His surname isn't a "brand."
PL (ny)
@Aerys -- Anyone who wouldn't vote for him because he's gay wouldn't vote for a Dem in any case. There are plenty of openly gay Republicans. It's a non-issue. His last name isnt that hard to pronounce, either, and once you learn it, it just trips off the tongue. Having studied the comments section for months, I'm convinced he's everyones favorite vice president.
Eric (San Francisco)
@Aerys more than anyone will acknowledge is my bet.
Southern Hope (Chicago)
“Picture a presidency where when you turn on the news and see the White House, your blood pressure goes down.” -- Mayor Pete
Cindy Gersony (Great Falls, VA)
I was at a couple of Pete Buttigieg events in Iowa a little over a week ago, including one mentioned in this article. I like him for a lot of reasons, but two stand out. One, pointed out several times, is that he has a whole lot of very interesting ideas, the kind where you think, "I hadn't thought of that, but that could work", whether on the environment or health care or jobs. The other is that he not only talks about what a Buttigieg administration would do for Americans, but he has a national service plan, and moreover, gives the feeling that we all have a role to play, that we are in this together, sort of an updated version of "ask not what your country can do for you, but what you can do for your country." Pete Buttigieg is obviously not only very smart, but a very decent man, the type of person we do not currently have in the White House.
Eric (Wyoming)
I find it very odd how Pete Buttigieg bases his campaign around "generational change" but yet his policies are pretty much upholding the status quo. You can't push for generational change unless you are willing to address the fundamental issues. Not to mention not taking money from corporate fundraisers and high dollar bundlers.
Eric T (Richmond, VA)
@Eric You couldn't be more incorrect. As mentioned above, he takes no money from corporations, corporate lobbyists, PACs, or anyone affiliated with the fossil fuel industry. The average donation to his campaign is $32.00. And if you take the time to read his proposals, they are light years away from being status quo.
OldEngineer (SE Michigan)
Mayor Pete is a well-spoken man. Inspiring, but a bit green and shy of the resume of the ideal leader of the western world. I could be convinced.
simon sez (Maryland)
I send him money monthly. Biden is going down. Bernie is self destructing. Warren is attempting to drag our party to the left and therefore is incapable of winning a general election. Mayor Pete will take us to the White House. Wait for the dust to settle and you will see. He never gives up.
Pat Boice (Idaho Falls, ID)
@simon sez - I donate to him monthly also.
jessiekitty (Chicago, IL)
After years fraught with hatred, bombast, deliberate ignorance, bigotry, lying, duplicity, greed, incitement to violence, and a lust for destruction of people, animals, and all life on this planet, I believe we are in great need of what Pete Buttigieg offers: brilliance, kindness, stability, vision, inclusion, restoration, authenticity, flexibility, open-mindedness, connection, ethics, decency, generosity, and understanding, as well as a genuine vision toward and for the future. Those who want noise and a big ego will look elsewhere. I for one will be grateful to vote for Pete Buttigieg for President in 2020. We need him. I believe he will restore international respect for the United States and will build diplomatic bridges, honoring the worth of all human beings. Pete Buttigieg and his extraordinary husband Chasten fill me with hope in these dark days. Let's work together for a much better, saner, more just and thoughtful future with the leadership of President Buttigieg.
Carl (Philadelphia)
Pete should go home, get more experience, actually do something (not fact career), and come back in 10-12 years.
Christa (New Mexico)
@Carl I agree with this. Pete is obviously a very smart guy and says good things. But he has not solved the problems at home, in a relatively small town. Let him resolve these problems which are representative of the problems of the country, and then let him come forward, show what he has accomplished. At that point I'll vote for him. Not yet.
AR (Manhattan)
Huh? What have Senators done except make speeches? They haven’t solved a single thing!
RS (Alabama)
@Carl Unfortunately a Democrat can’t win statewide office in Indiana. An appointment to a cabinet post would be his best way to building a national profile for a future candidacy. I imagine he’s looking to his future with that (or a cable show) on his mind.
John Doe (Johnstown)
It’s always struck me as odd that such a whip-smart candidate needs so much cash. What good are brains then?
Hortencia (Charlottesville)
@John Doe, EVERY candidate needs lots of cash! Not a single one can run a major campaign without a bunch a dough....!
cl (ny)
@John Doe Because, especially in this day and age all candidates need lots of money. It's just an ugly fact of political life.
Eddie Lew (NYC)
@John Doe, ask the somnolent Americans why they don't pay attention and need so many ads to get their information. A few viewings of Mayor Pete on TV tells me so much about his platform and decency; I don't need to be bombarded with ads. Newspapers fill the rest.
jhanzel (Glenview)
For those who scream about Pete taking $$ from big donors, read the NYT article: Big Donors, Small Donors: Pete Buttigieg Has Courted Them All — Successfully And the REALITY is that tanks to Citizens United, once a candidate is chosen, it will take a billion $$ or more per side. Personally I like the ticket of Ms. Warren and Mr. Buttigieg. Can you imagine Trump campaigning ][tweeting] against Pocahontas and a gay man?
Laurence Bachmann (New York)
@jhanzel I can imagine him tweeting and I can imagine it being really successful. As a gay man I have lots of good wishes for the guy, but let's live in the real world. Buttigieg didn't come out until 3 years ago when he was 34. He didn't come out until he had already been elected once. That's because he knew being gay mattered--even in a more liberal university town. Being gay matters in lots of places in the USA. If Warren is nominated she should pick a black male running mate. It helps her with AfAms which she needs and provides gender balance, which helps.Because along with homophobia there's still plenty of misogyny out there. At least in the America I live in.
UnionGuy (Bethesda MD)
Yes. I can imagine him trouncing that ticket in an epic landslide.
Grant (Iowa)
As an Iowan who has been following and volunteering for Democratic campaigns for years, I can't help thinking that pundits aren't quite understanding or representing the arc of Buttigieg's campaign accurately. In talking about him, "falling in the polls" the lede that's buried is the incredible fact that he's in the polls at all. He showed up this spring as a complete nobody. Out of curiosity I went and saw him in a room with about 50 other people. About a month later he came back through town, had to change a house party to a much bigger venue which then had people piled up outside the doors trying to hear. He's a rare phenomenon in a caucus campaign. I've never seen anyone go 0 to 60 that fast. And right then was when that first Register poll was taken that showed him with 15%. But he had no real campaign at that point because he was brand new. He had to basically leave the trail for the summer to go raise money and hire hundreds of staffers and start renting offices all over Iowa and New Hampshire. He only just turned the key on this operation and hit the campaign trail when the latest DMR poll was taken. He's not losing ground here. He's just getting started.
Sam (Pennsylvania)
@Grant Great insight. I love how Buttigieg is positioned going into the winter. Biden won’t survive Ukraine, Bernie’s health issues will sap his support and Warren is too far left and Trump will surely continue to hammer her. Put these factors all together and I expect good things come February.
Meg (AZ)
Atticus Finch : Scout :: Pete Buttigieg : USA
Steve Bolger (New York City)
@Meg: Scout was not a cynic. The USA is.
Meg (AZ)
@Steve Bolger I always felt that Scout was meant to synonymous with the view of the reader - she is in a sense everyone - Finch simply spoke to us all through her character. Thus, my analogy.
j (here)
he's the BO of 2020 campaign left - govern right he might get it - but let's face it, AA voters - esp. the older ones in the south will never vote for him biden is counting on those voters to pull him over the line - just like they did for hrc if PB gets it - let's hope he does a better job than bo - i want someone who governs the way they campaign
Meg (AZ)
My Heart and Conscience are with Buttigieg My Head is with Biden My Imagination is with Warren My Reason is with Klobuchar My Best Wishes are with Sanders My Battle Cry is with Harris My Hope is with Gabbard My Hero is with O'Rourke My Professor is with Booker My Environmentalist is with Steyer
LesISmore (RisingBird)
@Meg Heck of a Cabinet here
cl (ny)
@Meg Nah! Klobuchar does not inspire. O'Rourke is floundering and beginning to sound like a fool, and really should be running for the Senate again where he has set up a great foundation. Biden is getting more embarrassing by the day. Gabbard is a liability and has mixed loyalties. Harris did questionable things in her previous job and just got elected to the Senate and ought to stay there. Liz or Pete for me!
PL (ny)
@Meg -- And my vote is with Yang
Brooklyn Dog Geek (Brooklyn)
I love Buttigieg and I've contributed monthly to his war chest. I don't think this is his year, however.
Grant (Iowa)
@Brooklyn Dog Geek Don't count him out so soon. He's barely begun to campaign at this point because he came from nowhere and became a phenom with basically no organization to deal with the influx of support. While the top tier candidates had already been on the ground with fully staffed campaigns for months he had to basically leave the trail to go raise the money to build a competitive campaign. It was only in the last month or so that he's been opening offices across the early states and campaigning on the ground at his own events. He's already surpassed most of the other campaigns and he's already caught up to Sanders in Iowa and New Hampshire. It's really just Warren and Biden ahead of him at this point. That's an amazing feat for someone so new to the scene. And the fact is, Biden can't compete on the ground in Iowa against a candidate like that. Buttigieg campaigns like Obama. Biden campaigns like Biden 08 except worse. You can't win the Iowa caucuses by campaigning from a TV screen. By the time we go to caucus in February this could easily be a contest between Warren and Buttigieg. If he's giving a speech after a second place finish that night he's going to get unleashed in this race.
Jonathan (Atlanta, Georgia)
He has no chance.
Southern Hope (Chicago)
@Jonathan It's a good thing that Georgia doesn't get a chance to vote until its pretty much decided! :)
rarelypost (midwest)
@Brooklyn Dog Geek @Jonathan If anyone says, "I like so-and-so but he/she has no chance", that is buying into a self-fulfilling prophecy. How about "I love #Buttigieg and I've contributed monthly and I really really hope this is his year"? That's more hopeful and his campaign is built on hope.
FactsMatter (Utah)
@rarelypost Agree completely. With the influence of media, it seems that everyone has become a pundit. Vote for the individual who best represents your idea of a leader. For me, its Pete Buttigieg.
Teacher (Massachusetts)
I’m voting for Pete Buttigieg and I do think he will win the nomination. I believe he’ll win the presidency. As the process continues and more people actually tune in to the race, voters will get to know him. Americans are tired of the anger and division. Tired of the shouting and the finger pointing. The chaos. We want to see things get done. We want our democracy to work like it’s supposed to work. I believe we’re starved for the kind of leadership that Pete Buttigieg offers. Calm, measured, and brilliant. Eloquent, empathetic, and bold. Innovative. Unifying. His candidacy is the opportunity of a lifetime to unite as Americans for the good of the country and the planet. To right the wrongs. I think people will see that as the process unfolds.
Greg (Atlanta)
That was beautifully said and I always believed my teachers.
Christopher (Fort Collins, CO)
I've given relatively (for my means) generously to Pete and his campaign for a reason. He simply seems to be one of the most qualified to lead our nation and actually beat Trump. He is the antithesis of Trump and quite frankly one of the few candidates that I think will actually fare will in terms of general election electability. Hopefully he continues to rise in polls and gain the nomination!
Edward (Honolulu)
He has a chance with white rural voters in Iowa, but he has little appeal to blacks and Hispanics in the big Northern states and the rust belt. Gay may resonate with his major donors, but it’s appeal as a personal trait goes only so far. His bookishness doesn’t add to his appeal, either, except to a small segment of voters on campus. His major problem, however, is that he lacks clear solutions and specific programs, but seems kind of wishy-washy when it comes to policy, a weakness which he seems unable to overcome despite his large vocabulary. For me the killer is that he is already reaching to the superdelegates for their support. He is hardly the progressive he makes himself out to be.
rarelypost (midwest)
@Edward I understand what you are saying, but I disagree with your conclusion. A leader brings people together to fashion the solutions they will accept and work toward. So, Pete has vision and goals but does not want to impose solutions on people who have not come together to craft those solutions. We will all find out what is acceptable to us and what we will work for when he is our leader. It is a harder path but a more effective path.
kb (new london, ct)
@Edward Posters keep talking about Pete's "bookishness," but it's never clear what this is supposed to mean. That he reads books and occasionally refers to them? Why should this in any way diminish his appeal?
Eddie Lew (NYC)
@Edward, IMO, it looks like today's America isn't worthy of him. Sadly, that's the way I feel.
woofer (Seattle)
He would never be so blunt as to say so, but Mayor Pete is positioning himself to catch dislodged Biden voters if the VP stumbles badly or simply fades. He offers the same slightly progressive common-sense centrism in a newer, more durable package: younger, smarter, more articulate, more masterful of policy details. Biden's most loyal cohort is older African Americans who associate him fondly with Obama -- not a major Iowa constituency. It is certainly a strategy that could work, if Biden plays his part. Pete's main competitor on the Biden successor track will be Kamala Harris. Pete's advantage over Kamala is that he actually enjoys pondering difficult policy issues and, unlike her, started thinking seriously about them well before declaring his presidential candidacy. Pure style will not win the brass ring in 2020; everybody knows the problems are more urgent than that. One drawback that Pete and Kamala share is a shortage of credible relevant experience. That is why they can't hope to beat Biden unless he self-destructs or is poisoned by something toxic like the Ukrainian fallout. Both Pete and Kamala are promising, attractive fresh faces that will surely make formidable presidential candidates -- but not quite yet, maybe in 2028.
TaminoPR (NYC)
I have been backing Pete Buttigieg since the spring and will continue to do so. Although many of the other Democratic candidates have laudable attributes, only Buttigieg is a born international leader. He could also evince without difficulty a quality that has been missing from the American presidency since Barack Obama left office, but which used to be a primary component of our presidents: namely, statesmanship. Buttigieg's combination of intellectual brilliance (which in his humility he does not parade before him); military experience (which renders him more qualified than all other Democrats except Tulsi Gabbard to understand "globality"); his experience in both the private and public sectors; his Midwest roots and his consequent understanding of the plight of the working man and woman; his moral compass and genuine concern for every fellow man and woman—these qualities make him the Best Candidate.
Casey (NYC)
Pete has spent his entire life building his resume line-by-line in order to run for president. Besides having a nice resume, I’m not sure what his message is. He doesn’t resonate with me or anyone I know at all.
cl (ny)
@Casey Oh, because he does not have that "wow" factor and doesn't scream loud enough for you?
Mr Robert (Sacramento, CA)
@Casey I'll say it again Mayor Pete is an empty suit w/o a policy portfolio at a time when the American working class is looking for a progressive who can tell them what he will *do* once he's in office.
rarelypost (midwest)
@Casey So I am interested in your comment because it is a misunderstanding of Pete Buttigieg. Surely, even if you are very young, you have heard of people whose talents and attributes were just what was needed at a certain point in time. This would not be able to be planned, how could someone know ahead of time the best time to be ready? No, one develops their skills and abilities and hopes sometime they will be ready when called upon. Pete says he was "born to make himself useful" if the time presents itself. I, and hopefully you, recognize that Pete Buttigieg's time to be useful is NOW, more than ever. As far as "anyone I know", you should get out and about more. People ask me about Pete Buttigieg almost every single day.
David Weber (Clarksville, Maryland)
This won’t be his year. 2032. 2040. Maybe. Not so far away and he will still be a young man. I won’t be but maybe still around to vote for him.
BSchuch (NJ)
Buttigieg's campaign has been steady and strategic. He is thoughtful in his moves and has not attacked any fellow candidate. Because of his meteoric rise from being a no one among famous candidates, negative attacks against him are escalating. We know where and why these attacks are increasing. These will continue to escalate as he moves closer to being the nominee. But just watch how Buttigieg has not lashed out at any detractors. He has been the most emotionally mature, articulate, witty, and presidential among all the candidates. He has attracted more and more people to believe and have hope in him. He is made to be our next President.
EC (NY)
I like Pete but he is not a street fighter - and that is what the Democrats need this time around. He is trying too often to be all things to all people....to be a peacemaker, but that is not enough.
rarelypost (midwest)
@EC He will be able to meet your "streetfighter" test if needed. Keeping his powder dry!
ManhattanWilliam (New York City)
I’ve donated the maximum amount permissible to his campaign. While I greatly admire Pete’s intelligence and policy positions and maintain that he’s head and shoulders above all challengers, I’m not allowing myself to believe he’ll come out the winner in 2020. Still, he deserves my support and should he win, America would be in the enviable position of having a great man as leader of this country. I won’t even begin to compare him to the one who’s defiling our country currently.... comparing a good man to an evil one is hardly necessary.
Thomas Paine (Boston)
I like him and Kamala, and my fondness for these two disparate candidates is a born out of a yearning to listen to measured responses to some of the absurd questions they are asked. Booker as well.
SundayNiagara (Hialeah Fl)
He has even less chance than Bernie, or Liz. He may be a good guy, but the US isn't ready for him
Eddie Lew (NYC)
@SundayNiagara, sadly, that may be true.
Chris (Berkeley, California)
Mayor Pete is the president that the United States desperately needs but does not deserve. He is simply too good, too intelligent, too decent, too rational for over half of our voting population. But, miracles do happen - he can be elected! For the sake of our collective future, I am hopeful that he will come through, in spite of all the barriers that our nation has erected against his candidacy.
Michael Livingston’s (Cheltenham PA)
Buttigieg has cash because he's less liberal than the other Democrats. He has no real reason to be President, and voter realize that. Or they soon will.
kb (new london, ct)
@Michael Livingston’s "He has no real reason to be President." Can you explain what that means?
Rachel Quesnel (ontario,canada)
I am totally astounded that Mr. Buttigieg is not doing better in the polls, what I see is a man of the times, a cross-version of John F. Kennedy and his brother Robert Kennedy, Mr. Buttigieg is a man of vision, he is a man of intellect, he is someone who has fought for not only his country but for the human rights of all United States Citizens. This gentleman would be able to keep his own amongst world leaders, he is multi-lingual as well as multi-faceted, I presume due to his high intelligence he scares the average person, yet if you listen to him, truly listen he can connect to the average person, he doesn't seem to have been spoon-fed, Can you imagine having a President who seems to take the time to actually try to understand the issues and if he needed further advice he wouldn't be "full of himself" and would entertain thoughts brought to him provided they would be for the good of the United States, I would relish being able to see him debate a corrupt non-stable genius called Donald Trump, by the time the second question would be asked, Trump would still be trying to figure out the answer given by Mayor Pete, I am not African-American so I cant understand the conflict between Mayor Pete and that demographic but I do understand and see an individual who would do his best for ALL the people he governs but here is something for everyone to think about 2018 years ago, there was a Prince born in a manger we believed without knowing him, why can't you believe in Pete B.?
kb (new london, ct)
@Rachel Quesnel "I presume due to his high intelligence he scares the average person." This sadly underestimates "the average person" (whatever that label might mean).
PeteNorCal. (California)
@Rachel Quesnel JFK served as a Congressman AND US Senator before running for President...Mayor of South Bend is not an equal resume. Perhaps in 10 years, Pete will be ready to be a national candidate, but it’s doubtful he’ll be elected to higher office in Indiana (and it’s their loss).
Pat Boice (Idaho Falls, ID)
@PeteNorCal. - Many of us believe that being a mayor is a better resume' than being in Congress. Representatives and Senators have very little management experience. Look at the current Congress and see a perfect example.
Steve Bolger (New York City)
A caucus is a public event where people gather into groups representing their purportedly preferred candidate. An election is a secret ballot where people may or may not tell the truth to exit-pollsters who ask how they voted.
Mr Robert (Sacramento, CA)
This is the last hurrah for Mayor Pete. There's no way a Wall Street and Silicon Valley sponsored shill without a policy portfolio can possibly complete. Time to fold your cards and spend time on the board of one of your sponsors.
Jule (Seattle)
@Mr Robert If you would like to read Mr. Buttigieg's policy portfolio, please take a moment to peruse peteforamerica.com/issues. From affordable housing to voting rights, there are enough detailed proposals to suffocate any further desire for "more details"!
rarelypost (midwest)
@Mr Robert He has a robust policy portfolio, see Peteforamerica.com and he has experience on the ground dealing with difficult issues that Senators only opine bout.
kb (new london, ct)
@Mr Robert You seem to have missed his detailed array of policy proposals---readily available on his website.
John S. (Pittsburgh)
I really respect Pete Buttigieg. He has a deep understanding of domestic issues and world affairs. He communicates effectively. His ego is not bloated. He is presidential. He is the only one who I feel comfortable voting for.
Jack (Middletown, Connecticut)
Buttigieg or Gabbard are the only two Democrats who should be considered. Both are young and smart. If the Democrats are crazy enough to nominate Biden they could very well lose. I think anyone could beat Trump today but why take a chance.
Heysus (Mt. Vernon)
While I wish Pete well, and potentially a win, I am so distraught over the amount of money thrown at political campaigns. Imagine what good it could do elsewhere. Disgusting.
JW (MA)
Finally, coverage of someone other than Biden. Thank you! Mayor Buttigieg isn’t taking money from PACs so of course he sends those annoying fundraising emails. The NYTs and other media judge the success of a campaign on how much money it raises, which is a sad commentary on our culture and political discourse, but until we have publicly sponsored campaigns, candidates will have to get the $ from private donors. As far as I’m concerned, he’s the best candidate. Bernie and Biden should serve as advisors and Warren needs to lighten up on the Botox.
Kate (NH)
@JW He takes money from corporations and Washington lobbyists. Lots and lots of money.
Lark (Midwest)
@Kate Not true!
Matthias Turner (Wells, Maine)
I am originally from a small rural town in Kansas, with family members that mostly live in small communities in the N/S axis from Minnesota to Texas and Arkansas. One of my nephews -- with a college degree -- is earning less than I made part-time when I was a college student in 1978. (And I bought a new car in 1976 for less than $3K, including tax). At my family reunion this summer many of my family members expressed support for Pete Buttigieg, including (surprising to me) some of my most conservative and older relatives. They see him as honest, smart, and caring about people like them, including issues on how young people don't have the same opportunities I did.
rarelypost (midwest)
@Matthias Turner This is apparently not an unusual reaction to Pete Buttigieg. His campaign symbol is a Bridge, signifying that he desires to, and can, bring people from many perspectives together to work on a common future built on common values of Freedom, security, democracy.
Public Servant (Maryland)
Finally! Democrats acknowledge that they must address rural America. The key to 2020 victory for Democrats is to show up in rural America and offer sensible policies that rural voters can be for. There are plenty: stopping tariff wars; rewriting the Farm Bill for farmers, not corporate agribusiness; producing healthful food to combat obesity and diabetes; conserving precious topsoil; addressing rural health access. Democrats can compete on these issues if they only show up and offer what rural America needs. Plenty of people in rural America are looking for an alternative to Trump.
Alasdair (California)
@Public Servant - To a degree. Only 20% of Americans live in rural areas (as defined by the census bureau), and that data is from 2010. Democrats have far more to gain by making inroads with the 50% of Americans in suburban and small-metro areas.
jhanzel (Glenview)
@Alasdair ~ Actually, as seen in 2016, those rural areas can affect the Electoral College, but even more significantly, are responsible for the GOP controlling the Senate for so long.
Laurence Bachmann (New York)
@Alasdair True but rural voters matter in swing states like IA< WI>MI
stewarjt (all up in there some where)
Hmmmmmmmmm. Where did Mr. Buttigieg get all that cash? I bet you most of it was from wealthy donor fundraisers and not as Bernie Sanders does it. Mayor Pete is bought and paid for and it isn't for the good.
Laurence Bachmann (New York)
@stewarjt Wherever Bernie gets his money, he should send it back. His campaign is kaput due to his recent health scare.
Baruch S (Palo Alto)
@stewarjt Mostly small donors. Like Bernie, Pete mobilizes people. Remarkably interesting candidate.
BSchuch (NJ)
@stewarjt You should cite your sources. If you are a Dem rooting for another candidate, you are creating discord among Democrats and giving the nation a poor look at the party. If you are a Republican troll spreading unsubstantiated stories, then you are reflecting the desperation of your party. Either way, you should think of what you are doing to America before you post things that further divide the country. If anything, Pete Buttigieg is a unifier, real grassroots mobilizer and a dynamic and enigmatic leader. He does not stoop his values down to the soles of your shoes.
David Jacobson (San Francisco, Ca.)
He is the most thoughtful and articulate candidate. Very fast and calm in discourse and would make a fool of trump (if trump survives this impeachment, which I doubt he will). I would happily vote for him.
Roget T (NYC)
Buttigieg's open path is to be nominated for VP to balance a ticket. He's unpopular among minority voters and moderate Democrats. His only hope in Iowa is that Sanders drops out and cuts down the number of legitimate caucus competitors to Warren and Biden. I'm not sure whether Mayor Pete or Beto come the closest to the Robert Redford character Bill McKay in the the movie The Candidate. And I hope we never find out.
John (Alexandria VA)
@Roget T I'm a moderate Democrat and a minority voter who plans on voting for Buttigieg in my primary. What's more, I'm also a retired senior citizen. Should Sanders get the nomination, I'll write in Buttegieg's name on my ballot.
Laurence Bachmann (New York)
@Roget T You're half right. He's not popular with minorities. The police commissioner thing is an albatross that's gonna weigh him down with the AA community. Moderates like him a lot though. He's shlepping through Iowa now going to all the counties Trump won and drawing big, big crowds. Whether he's VP depends on whose the nominee. If it's Warren, never! A woman AND a gay married man would never fly. If it's Biden (though that seems less likely) he's a good pick--contrasts well to the Grandpa Joe issue.
Brooklyn Dog Geek (Brooklyn)
@Roget T I think he's immensely popular with moderates. It's progressives that don't love him. But I agree--Warren should ask him to be her VP now. They'd balance each other's weaknesses and I think would be a slam dunk ticket.
gio (west jersey)
Mayor Pete is going to be a tough out for the "mainstream" Dems. He may be too rational for his own good, but his ability to answer complex questions with thoughtful, immediate responses is an attribute Nobody ahead of him in the polls (on either side) possesses. He will also play well to young and LBGTQ voters, while being religious enough not to scare conservatives. I think the cards may fall his way over the next 13 months.
dressmaker (USA)
@gio Too religious for this voter.
rarelypost (midwest)
@dressmaker He says he will represent those of any religious faith as well as no religious faith. for all Americans.
Jean (New York)
@dressmaker I agree. His religious pandering is offensive and inappropriate in political discussions.
Mary O'Neill (Cedar)
I hope he wins. Time for a new era. A generational change.
Sydney (Chicago)
Pete has my total support. He's the most genuine, best leader/policy maker that has happened in America for decades. Plus, he's drama-free.
Cousy (New England)
@Sydney I like Pete too, but not all Black residents of South Bend would consider him to be “drama free”.
Sydney (Chicago)
@Cousy Not issue free, but definitely drama free. One can't run a city and have zero problems. I think if one researches Pete's handling of the matter, his reflections on that handling, as well as his subsequent outreach not only to the Black community in So Bend but other areas, you will find that he has admitted it wasn't done perfectly, that he has learned much form the controversy and it has informed/enhanced his policy making for the future, without drama - at least not from him.
Nicholas (Orono)
Pete is basically there so that if Biden messes up enough, he’ll be another safe choice for corporations and the wealthiest Americans to hedge their bets on. If you’re looking for lukewarm policies that will simply rearrange the furniture and not make any structural changes, the guy who worked at the Machiavellian McKinsey & Company is going to serve you well.
Baruch S (Palo Alto)
@Nicholas Rearranging the furniture in the realm of civil rights, human rights, climate change etc. etc. while the current incumbent is destroying the nation may not be so bad after all.
Nicholas (Orono)
@Baruch S I find it interesting that your dichotomy consists of either having Trump or another corporate Democrat. Why does it need to consist of solely these two options? Y’know, I think I remember some candidate whose almost sole credentials were also “I’m not Trump”. What was their name again? Can’t remember anymore, the news cycle goes fairly fast for my small brain.
Corbin (Minneapolis)
The fact that he is “flush with cash” should give everyone pause. Closed door meetings with big donors is a major turn-off for potential democratic voters. I.E. the 2016 election.
JPF (Michigan)
Listen carefully to Mayor Pete. He is reasonable, articulate, intelligent, engaging, thoughtful, and measured. He has ideas to move our country forward. He has a strong background and in a match against Trump he would win, hands down. A Buttigieg/Warren ticket would be ideal.
Jamie (Oregon)
@JPF I agree completely. The one word I hear most often is "authentic". For anyone that hasn't been introduced to him, I recommend searching his name in YouTube. You'll find lots of interviews and several "town halls" (which give you the most information. No link, you can find it for yourself. Whichever one you watch, it doesn't matter. He's consistently thoughtful and smart - and a great communicator. Always answers the question directly.
Pascale Luse (South Carolina)
Pete is one of my top pick. He is Smart. Very smart. Accomplished. Knowledgeable. Likable. Honest. Sees the urgency in acting to reduce global warming. Respects science. Married. And, let’s not forget that he is a Christian ( unfortunately in 2020 America anything else is a disqualification).
Joseph B (Stanford)
Mayor Pete is the antithesis of Trump, smart articulate, calm, with practical ideas for moving America forward. Please no more 70 year old plus candidates, America needs a generational change.
B.Sharp (Cinciknnati)
I am fascinated with the Mayor Pete Buttigieg . A highly intellectual , descent Man, and want to see where He goes from being a Presidential Candidate. He might not be the nominee, but is there any chance someone will choose Him as a running mate I wonder . Pete`s intellectuality comes through, in debates. Mayor does not scream or attack anyone but always states his point. Countey is now at a juncture of screaming, old men who does not believe in climate issues. Why ? They will be long gone when the disaster sets in.
Practical Thoughts (East Coast)
The citizens of this country, especially baby boomers, are not nearly as mature or progressive enough to vote Pete in 2020. The simple fact that Trump still has a good shot at re-election despite his law breaking and incompetence is all the proof you need. Pete will have to give it a go in 2028 or 2032.
AJBF (NYC)
@Practical Thoughts My husband and I are baby boomers and we are voting for Pete. And so are many baby boomers we know.
Hortencia (Charlottesville)
Pete is irresistibly likable, expresses himself clearly, is confident without bravado, is smart as a tack, has sound & workable ideas for the country, is spot-on quick with a comeback without being rude, has a sense of humor!, energizes a room, doesn’t need to perform, speaks truthfully while conveying hope, has been a military leader, has been in the trenches, knows what it’s like to face and openly discuss a personal struggle and emerge a stronger person, and last but not least, has a loving spouse. He’s one impressive dude. Our country needs him.
AJBF (NYC)
Pete Buttigieg has my vote. He is brilliant, decent, warm and cares deeply about people and this country. In terms of raw political talent he’s one in a generation. As far as him having an African American vote “problem”, that is true of all the candidates not named Biden. Pete’s Douglas Plan to address racial inequity is the most comprehensive and intelligent of any candidate. My guess is that as Biden falters and more African Americans get to know Pete, their support of him will grow exponentially.
Barbara Fisher (Stl)
I’m still supporting Mayor Pete. If he doesn’t win this time, I hope there’s a next time. Every time I see/hear him I’m impressed. Wonderful temperament too.
Marc (New York)
I’ll be voting for Mayor Pete in the New York primary. He is the smartest, most articulate and most capable candidate among the bunch. It’s unlikely he’ll get the nomination this time, but he’ll be around a long time and will have other chances.
Hortencia (Charlottesville)
@Mark in NYC: I’m with you on the support! But never say never. Obama was nobody at about this time during his first foray...and we all know that outcome! Cheers.
Cousy (New England)
@Marc By the time of the NY primary (April 28), it will be abundantly clear that Elizabeth Warren is the nominee. (I’m happy with that). Sadly, New York’s primary is too late to matter.
Laurence Bachmann (New York)
@Cousy I wouldn't be too sure NY won't matter. Warren is gaining traction but wait til the south starts to vote--ovewhelmingly AfAm voters and overwhelmingly for Biden. This is going to the convention unless Bernie drops out and supports Warren. Otherwise, a dog fight.
Cousy (New England)
Mayor Pete is a good guy. I'm glad the nation has been introduced to him. His talk of midwestern life, progressive faith and political civility has been valuable. He won't be elected this time around: among other things, he is unlikely to quickly increase his favorability among Black voters, a crucial voting block. But that doesn't mean that he doesn't have a bright future. Looking forward to keeping up to date with Buttigieg after this election is over.
Michelle (Vista)
@Cousy How do you know this? And what "other things?"
Hortencia (Charlottesville)
@Dennis in San Mateo, Thank you! I just knew it! Your comment bolsters my feelings about Pete.
db (Baltimore)
@Cousy Regarding "other things" (or reasons he might not win the presidency this time around), I would argue that "Medicare For All Who Want It" is to health care akin to "Right To Work" is to unions; it simply doesn't work without sufficient collective bargaining power. That being said, he's charismatic, genuine, smart, an ethical, inclusive religious man and I think he'd make a marvelous governor for Indiana.