Iran Finally Let Her See Her Husband. He Was Dead.

Feb 22, 2018 · 43 comments
AJ (Trump Towers Basement)
Tragic as it is, and it is tragic, it seems far better than what we subject inmates in Guantanamo and their families too. If this article is meant to highlight Iranian disgrace, there should be no let up in highlighting our very own disgrace and arrogance - "we can kidnap anyone, anywhere and imprison them for as long as we want, maybe forever, without letting them have access to family and friends, while subjecting them to physical and psychological torture." Maybe our Israeli "allies" find this completely normal and acceptable. The civilized world does not.
Chris (La Jolla)
He was of Iranian descent, went to Iran, a country known for its views and policies. He landed in jail. Hs widow, also Iranian, weeps. And we are supposed to do what? Interfere with Iran's policies and sovereign rights because this person very knowingly put himself in danger?
Melquiades (Athens, GA)
Sure, we've all heard stories, some true, some only in stories, about dastardly governments, making up lies to justify abusing their political opponents, and that's the narrative here. But, while I won't be shocked if it ends up proving out, I note that there are some real strange pieces: "Mr. Seyed Emami was an unexpected target of the hard-liners. Softspoken, he always preferred to cooperate rather than challenge the authorities. " So, this is who they decide to murder??? "Instead of being taken to see her husband she was closeted in a room with a prosecutor and four intelligence agents from the Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps and interrogated for several hours." "A day after the arrest, the Seyed Emamis’ house in Tehran was raided by at least 30 agents who spent eight hours ransacking the place." Those two sound to me like: those government people REALLY STRONGLY BELIEVED HE WAS A SPY!!!! Not that it justifies murder, and in the middle about whether it explains suicide, I can't see anything that proves he was NOT in fact a spy...which, you recall, we Americans have decided to hang sometimes
Keitr (USA)
I'm curious, does the Times cover every suspicious death of a foreign environmentalist or just the one's in a country where the administration and the usual suspects are ginning up for war.
Miriam (NYC)
I fear that the NY Times is starting the inevitable drumbeat of a war with Iran. This is the third article you've had this week chronicling the atrocities committed by that country. However, I haven't seen one recent article about what horrors the Saudis, our allies, and Iran's rival in the Middle East, are doing in Yemen eg. the bombing of civilians, the hunger etc. I realize that you can't cover every tragic hot spot every week. But when you only cover one side of a story, and one point of view, and the bad guys are the country our current president is itching to attack, I think a more nuanced coverage is necessary. After all, the Saudis were the ones behind 9/11, 19 of the attackers were from Saudi Arabia, yet we ended up attacked Iraq, not because of they were erroneously accused at first of being behind the attack and then, but because the were, again erroneously, accused of having WMDs. Your paper was behind the war in Iraq and all the disastrous consequences. I would think you would use a little more caution this time around.
F (NYC)
NYT needs to obey the Israel lobby, otherwise they may go out of business.
dietmar sigl (germany)
I believe Mr Emami as a man of open discourse did have the mental strenght in his passion to find comfort in the fact that those who weep for him can always be comforted by his believe in truth.
retired guy (Alexandria)
"In many respects, Mr. Seyed Emami was an unexpected target of the hard-liners." On the contrary, the hard-liners would be particularly interested in a man like him: inside the regime (in the sense of teaching at a "conservative" university), but telling his students and others to work within the system for change. Probably had some ties to the people in the Rouhani government, at least those on the far reformist end of the Rouhani spectrum. And with citizenship in a western democracy, to boot. He is precisely the sort of man the hard-liners would worry about. That NYT's man in Tehran doesn't understand this is disheartening.
Hucklecatt (Hawaii)
How the youth of Iran can put up with this I just do not understand. The cost in blood to overcome this primordial, religious-based dictatorship will be significant. My heart goes out to the young people of Iran to find their lives spent so cheaply in support of such corruption and greed.
EagleFee LLC (Brunswick, Maine)
How can humans treat one another this way?
F (NYC)
We have GTMO, Israel and Iran have their jails. What is wrong with that?
Elsie (New York City )
A good time to donate to the Persian Wildlife Heritage Foundation.
Ruth (Australia)
What a tragic story. This family deserve better and they certainly deserve more than the ignorant comments below about pallets of cash (actually Iran's own money) being 'handed' to the Iranian government. As its clear in the piece Iran is in a struggle between extremists and moderates. Reversing the Obama administration's minor steps to restoring a relationship, as your current oafish White House are doing, hands the extremists a victory. Meanwhile Iranian citizens like the Emami's suffer. Horrible.
Toronto (Toronto)
A martyr for the Earth and its natural beauty. "On the earth are signs for the certain in faith" (Quran 51:20). His faith was greater than that of the rulers of his country.
MAC (Mass)
Iran traded the murderous Shah for for a religious mafia, with hit men on every corner. Most Iranians are nice people, but lambs to the slaughter.
Charlotte (Winston Salem,NC)
They probably told him to kill himself or they would kill his family. Very sad.
Daniel K (NYC)
I love how the world and the UN reserve there animosity for Israel and the US yet trip over themselves to kiss the feet of the Mullahs.
WestSider (Manhattan)
This story has been on the front page for over 24 hours now as if the lack of comments (total 15) hasn't given NYT a clue that readers are sick of their Iran bashing dressed as news.
F (NYC)
My comment was not posted by NYT, I supposer there are comments from other readers that have not been posted either. NYT was a tool for Israel when it lobbied for war on Iraq, once again it is a tool for war, but this time against Iran.
Martin (San Juan, Puerto Rico)
This article really exposes what happens when morons start to rule.
EB (New Mexico)
Truly a sad and tragic end for a good man. My deepest condolences to his family, friends and colleagues.
Mr. Moderate (Cleveland, OH)
Is there a more despicable bunch of paranoids than the government of Iran? Maybe ISIS is more cruel, but not by much. It's time for the Iranian people to rise up - again. Maybe next time we'll give them some support.
matty (boston ma)
Its all about religion: Despicable, and paranoid. Suspicious of anyone who doesnt think, act, and believe like them.
Alan Dean Foster (Prescott, Arizona)
Actually, it's (as it usually is) about money, and power. Religion, is this instance, is just a sideshow.
James Rhyee (Clarkston, Michigan)
Obama wanted to restore the relationship with Iran during his last years in the White House, but to no avail, as it turns out, and now than ever the regime proves to be more anti USA by means of making close association militarily and diplomatically with Russia, diametrically acting opposite, in Iraq and Syria, of what we perceive to be our interest. They nicely took our good intent which was designed to extract reciprocity in kind, but that's it. All we witnessed is baring of our naivete, a la Obama/Kelly's amateurish endeavor. We were once the major player in the Middle East, but now Russia and Iran run the show with resulting intense anxiety among the Sunni nations in the region, not to mention Israel. The tragic death of Mr. Emami reminds me of Mr. Warmbier's similar fate following the imprisonment in North Korea. With one country, Iran, we anxiously wanted to and so to speak succeeded the restoration of the diplomatic relationship. And now the outcome; we are wondering when Iran is going to successfully proceed with the nuclear tests and when and if it would make, following the North Korea's fashion, similar threats to its neighbors including Israel, which it time and again threatened to wipe out of its existence. So here comes Trump, a new sheriff in town, a bravado, who, despite his childish words and conduct, ironically may be able to contain Iran. In the world politics, I guess, the only thing that matters seems to be always the strength and willingness to use it.
Sarah Carroll (London)
Donald Trump, Bibi Netanyahu and Mohammad Bin Salman have done nothing but play straight into the hands of the paranoiac hardliners. You appear to be following them -- right into the trap.
Mohammad Khan (Rasht, Iran)
The US has no business being in the Mid east! Mid East is Iran's back yard and not too far from Russia they both have national interest in being there. Iran is the only country which has been invited to be in the Syria. US, Turkey and Israel are occupying force. Why US does not help to solve her own problem in stopping gun violence. The problem is not gun or single kid with mental problem, the problem is bigger than that and needs to be solved.
Renee Hack (New Paltz, NY)
One more event to add to the already overflowing number of violence against good and hopeful people. Iran had a chance at democracy which my own country managed to destroy. Now Iran itself is staining its country with horrific and bloody policies. Perhaps this will end and Iran will move toward a more enlightened foundation. There is a book whose author I recently came across in a book about photography of people in Mexico who discovered their Jewish ancestry. The author is Ori Z Soltes who, in 2011, wrote the book "Untangling The Web. A Thinking Person's Guide to Why the Middle East Is A Mess And always Has Been. Admittedly, 20
John (Tel Aviv)
Wow - it is so upsetting that there are places in this world where this things happen. It is a shameful aspect of the human kind that the nations who uprise against one dictator always choose another one in its place. The current iranian state in its hate for other nations and its own people when they do not fall in line is a medieval mirage that spreads hate in the places where love is most needed. I hope that against all ods and the lessons of history, the end of this tyranny will not be accompanied by numerous meaningless deaths
Mohammad Khan (Rasht, Iran)
Iranians seeing the news about school shooting in Florida are asking themselves the same question. How in the name of the god a 18 years old kid can buy a gun and kill 18 people??!! Only in America!! Before getting bogged down in Iranian problem, Americans should solve their own problem first! That mass shooting in Florida school can never happen in Iran!
S (NY)
Stories like these are very commonplace in Iran. I'm thankful this one made it to Western media.
Mohammad Khan (Rasht, Iran)
Not defending the regime, this one smells fishy, the man has a phony degree in sociology?? But is a well known environmentalist, and an anti-Shah activist teaching in an ultra conservative religious school!! Most Iranians hate people who started this revolution, so when such a tragic thing happens people get happy, because this bum started the thing to begin with!! So he deserved what he got!!
Magicwalnuts (New York)
Sad, but a stark example of how antagonizing Iran only gives hardliners more ammunition to clamp down on local political opposition. Wondering where the similar stories about Saudi Arabia are?
Ultramayan (Texas)
The current regime ruling Iran is a corrupt, infantile, repressed, ignorant, theocracy. They only want to hang on to power, and like other corrupt governments will do whatever it takes to remain in power. The young people of Iran must rise up and take their county back.
rjon (Mahomet Illinois)
Conscience is the bedrock of human living together and the government of Iran has shown only fear and cowardice in the face of the conscience of Seyed Emami. The shame on Iran defiles it. Those who acquiesce in this state action are culpable.
John Gaguine (Juneau, Alaska)
Surely there is something in the Koran that condemns this sort of political murder. I wonder how Supreme Leader Khamenei is justifying acts like this to Allah, himself, and the Iranian people.
Mohammad Khan (Rasht, Iran)
Not defending the regime, but most people you call westerners in Iranian jails are really Iranians with dual citizenship and they all entered Iran by Iranian passport. As Mr. Trump would call them they are fake Americans or Canadians!! I am sorry for death of this gentleman but he was a professor at the Imam Sadiq University!! Did the writer of this article bother to search what kind of university this this?? This is an ultra conservative religious university!! Why a Canadian with the right mind would associate himself with this kind of university? Average Iranian would not!! There is something fishy here!
Keyvan (Los Angeles)
He did mention it's a conservative university. Most Iranian would work anywhere to make a living and still make a difference.
Joshua Schwartz (Ramat-Gan, Israel)
Surprisingly the article makes no mention of Canada's response. Perhaps because there has not been much of one.
HTB (New York)
Shame on Obama for giving this regime billions in CASH without getting anything in return. The government continues to act in this horrific manner. My heart goes out to this family.
Chas (Indiana)
Obama did not give them billions in CASH. What they did get was their own money that had been frozen. In exchange, they agreed to put their nuclear program on freeze with regular inspections to guarantee it. Not just Obama, but also our major allies in the western world. Despite what we do as a country, Iran, like all countries, has a degree of sovereignty that make their actions and behavior out of our reach. My heart goes out to his family, too.
Daniel K (NYC)
they deserved none of it.
GWBear (Florida)
Why doesn't the mainline media tell this basic essential fact? We gave Iran NOTHING that wasn't already theirs! Obama did not give money to Iran! Also, the International Community has largely agreed that Iran is: 1) Holding to the Nuclear Agreement. 2) Was a leader in the fight against ISIS. The US has unnecessarily made Iran an adversary, simply because of tensions between Iran and Israel. It also is worth reminding the US reader one other simple fact: There IS a Nuclear Power in the Mideast. It's Israel.