Colin Kaepernick Is Unemployed. Is It Because of His Arm, or His Knee?

Mar 27, 2017 · 130 comments
Travis (Toronto, Canada)
The decision to not stand was unpopular with racists. Acting as if there is a more complex reason to this is simply intellectually dishonest.
Ceadan (New Jersey)
Media reports of professional athletes physically assaulting women, taking PEDs, misbehaving in night clubs and driving drunk don't make people think too deeply, if at all, and thus pose no threat to corporate profits or to the status quo of institutionalized racism. Taking a knee during the national anthem during a nationally televised game makes people think, and THAT is why Colin Kaepernick is unemployed.
Sean (Ft. Lee. N.J.)
Blood curdling dogfighting generates less blowback than kneeling down instead of saluting a flag (made in China).
Aunt Nancy Loves Reefer (Hillsborough, NJ)
A millionaire quarterback whose baggage isn't outweighed by his abilities anymore. I wouldn't want him on my team either.
Leslie Prufrock (41deg n)
Maybe its just that he comes across as a show off. He is entitled to his opinions but he isn't satisfied with that , I guess and insists on a large helping of publicity for his cause du jour. Just play the game - nobody cares until you flaunt it!
kjd (taunton, mass.)
It's all about the money. Didn't Kaepernick leave $16 million on the table when he left San Francisco? Did any of the qb's who already found spots leave anything on the table? Of course not. The often injured Kaepernick has badly misjudged the market as Adrian Peterson has. They will both finally sign with teams, but not for the money they expected.
Joker (New Mexico)
Jus saying he has his views which are wrong like kneeling during The National Anthem but he talks about oppression. He sure has no problem cashing his checks that he gets from the NFL. Also you never hear him doing anything to help out his community.
Bronzi (Earth)
There is plenty he does with his money that has been written. Simple Google will show you several examples. We should not slander people without due diligence.

Aid to Somolia
Meals on Wheels

Just 2 recent examples of those that made the news in the past 2-4 weeks.
JP (Portland)
This is the best news that I've heard in a long time. This punk should pay a price for his narcissistic clown like behavior. It sounds like he is and that makes me happy.
Ricardo de la O (Montevideo)
NFL teams have the most power over contracts. He could be signed and then cut anytime for any reason. He is a distraction, however. This article just adds to his problem. He'll be in Canada before long.
Conflicted (Madison)
He was and is being "Blackballed". It's a shame, but it comes with the territory. Protest is never popular. I supported his stance on the Pledge, but he lost my respect when he didn't bother to vote, after all that. Our people got their heads broken for the right, and he showed serious disrespect for the blood sweat and tears it took to give him the opportunities he had by doing that.
George Santangelo (NYC)
Very understandable that a public business wouldn't want to take on a social issue which could detract from its product. It's all about the bucks.
Teams are making the decision that Kaepernick costs them money. Players whose business it is to be popular with the public have to realize the consequences of their actions. I agree with Kaepernick but I also agree with the owners. As a backup QB he doesn't add that much to the success of the team. But as a social commentator he could be a major distraction to the team and a drag on profits.
WAH (Vermont)
It is his hubris that gets him into trouble!
jeff (mass)
maybe a stint in Canada would be good for him to let this thing die down and so can learn how to learn pass coverages.
Leslie Prufrock (41deg n)
north of the Arctic circle, please.
Maniehols (Ponte Vedra Beach, FL)
Our sports teams in America, I believe, were meant to give us relief and entertainment from the normal pressures of everyday life; a temporary distraction from our normal life. Any athlete disrespecting this country in a public forum deserves what he or she gets.
There are proper forums for dissent and protest; our past time and entertainment events, designed to take us away from the everyday mundane living is not the place!
Woon (Berkeley)
"That decision was unpopular with a segment of N.F.L. fans, and perhaps a larger segment of traditionally conservative N.F.L. owners." The decision was unpopular with me. And I am neither. I know about the writing of the Star Spangled Banner during the War of 1812. I like the first verse - the one we sing over and over. I like what it doesn't say. Nothing about God (god) saving anybody. I like that the whole thing is a question - does the flag still fly in spite of the battle. We as a country are often in some seemingly catastrophic upheaval and wondering if we as a country are going to make it through one more time - and it is never certain. And we question - are we making it through? The flag is our symbol and the anthem is our acknowledgment of our worry and our hope too. And, who we are as a country, how we define ourselves what we aspire to reduces down to freedom and bravery. No worshiping, no required allegiances to anyone or anything. And that whole "home of the free" thing points to the Bill of Rights. And bravery - country needs bravery to keep those freedoms. Just the most basic stuff. So Kapernick can kneel during the anthem - or turn his back on the flag or burn it or spit on it or walk on it. His right. He's free to do so. No law against it, nor should there ever be. But he can't pretend he isn't in some way repudiating (despising?) what the anthem is about and what the flag stands for for the rest of us.
Joe (Connecticut)
I mean Good Lord, we see Sanchez, Glennon, Hoyer and wait for it ....wait ....McCown signed by the Jets .... McCown! A hundred year old journeyman quarterback with a losing record. And gee, we wonder if Colin K. hasn't been signed because of his political stance? Really now. Of course that's why no one has signed him!
SBaylor (USA)
He's mediocre. He doesn't do very well in the pocket. He opted out of his contract.

So, if I'm an average employee at my job and then I put more effort and focus in tackling social issues instead of my job AND quit my job BEFORE I have a new one.... I'd be unemployed as well.

Why is he different from the average person in America?
Zen Dad (Los Angeles, California)
The unfortunate truth for Mr. Kaepernick is he experienced some brief, early success in his career and struggled to build upon that. He is viewed as a "mobile" quarterback with an inaccurate arm and shaky pocket presence. If he were a humble person, he would be interested in any opportunity. He insists he should be a starter with a salary of $9-10 million.

Stats and the naked eye confirm he is not worth that, and if signing him as a backup means he would be pouting and crying racism (!) on social media, then it's a no-brainer to steer clear of his drama.
Rick (Summit)
He has the most value to the 49ers and should resign with them. They know his skills and abilities and he has many fans in the Bay Area. He's much less known elsewhere and his 1-10 record last year is a turnoff. The 49ers could use him as a back up or as an ambassador to go to schools to talk about racial injustice and kneeling as a form of protest.
MattNg (NY, NY)
I have no dispute with his kneeling in protest, that's what America is all about: free speech (and let's hope it remains as such with this current president).

I think he suffered from Big Contract Syndrome as his play started to regress after he signed that huge contract with a large amount of guaranteed money.

That and the fact that the NFL will find flaws in every quarterback after a year or two.

Should he be unemployed? If some of the QBs referenced in the article are employed, Kaepernick should have a job.

Is he being blackballed? Without a doubt...
Paul (Virginia Beach)
K was an employee, a member/represetative of both a team and a franchise. He was in uniform when he staged is protests. It was foolish, selfish and damaging; the team paid a price for it...and now K is, too. Tough luck. Actions have consequences and any sentient being would think about those beforehand. I have no sympathy for K; he's a distraction and in a competitive business like the NFL there is NO room for such distractions.
European American (Midwest)
When wearing a uniform, 'bout any uniform, there are certain protest actions that are, de facto if not de jure, just verboten and near unforgivable, in many a humble opinion. Refusing to show proper homage, regardless of our internal problems, to the country by failing to stand up during its anthem is right up there near, if not at, the top of the list. It's near issuing a slap across the face to those who are or have served, civilian and military, and a disrespect to those who died for our country, civilian and military...but I'm a dotty old baby boomer clinging to the patriotic ethos instilled in my youth.
Mac (USA)
Longtime 49ers fan here. All of you who say it's due to his play on the field either don't know a thing about football or are viewing Kaepernick through your political lens. The 49ers were devoid of talent on offense last year and the problem wasn't Kaepernick. He wasn't the solution either, but he was coming off injury, generally got better after he got some games in, and as the article says his numbers were NFL average (again, not great but not terrible). Everyone knows that the 49ers were historically bad due to now-fired GM Trent Baalke, not Kaepernick.

Take away the protest and there's a ton of teams out there who sign him as a back-up and as someone who could compete for the starting job on about 15 teams. You don't have to like him or his protest (I didn't, though I didn't really care all that much either way), but you're fooling yourself if you think politics aren't part of this.

Oh, and the part of the article that said he opted out of his contract to look for a better situation was wrong. The 49ers were going to release him anyway so he opted out to get the process started sooner. This isn't just speculation: new GM John Lynch publicly said that they would have released him.
WL (PA)
Actually, people who follow football will understand that it's because he simply isn't that good of a QB compared to the rest of the market. Let's remember that he couldn't beat out Gabbert in training camp last year.

Here's a simple test: would you like him as your QB?
ACJ (Chicago)
As a Bears fan, I can't get excited about the a quarterback not standing for the national anthem, when for the last decade I have watched our quarterbacks spend most of their time being laid out on the playing field. Should add, please Bear's management, hire this guy.
Walt Bennett (Harrisburg PA)
I believe that anyone who sees this as on-the-field related is deluding themselves. Of course the reason he's not signed is that he became a flashpoint last year, and for all we know he plans to do it again this year.

Mr. Kapernick did a very brave thing and he deserves credit for it, because this was the exact chance he was taking both by "taking a knee" and by declining the option on his contract.

I do see him getting picked up by a team that suddenly finds itself rudderless at QB, especially if he promises no more sideline demonstrations.

He made his point last year, and if the terms for getting signed are to declare his protest "mission accomplished", he may wind up resurrecting his career.
Anna Lucia DeDe-Panken (Fayetteville, AR)
If CK is not acceptable as an NFL player, but G Hardy is still earning a massive salary and Joe Mixon gets drafted in the top 3 rounds (as predicted).....
Joanna Gilbert (Wellesley, MA)
Kaepernick played great in SF during that one season. His more recent performances have been dismal. Why would anyone take him as a starting QB with the current state of his ability and the political baggage that he carries? It he played like Tom Brady, he'd have been snapped up long ago. And I am a longtime (and sadly disappointed) Niners fan transplanted in Pats territory. It is also possible that there is a curse on him and the rest of the Niners having left SF and Candlestick behind for Silicon Valley.
Mellifluos (Jerusalem)
No mistake, Kaepernick is suffering the consequences of his actions. As an educator if I decided to sit during the Pledge of Allegiance I would be disciplined. (and I belong to a union). NFL players are not union protected and should not expect any job protections when they cannot follow the directions of their employers. It is no mistake that Mr. Kaepernick has a girlfriend who supports radical Islam as a talk radio host. It he chooses to advocate an anti-American position he has every right. And his employers have every right not to hire him. The burden of proof is on Kaepernick to prove it is a case of discrimination.
JLJ (Boston)
If ever there was a false conflation of cause and effect as well as our "victim" culture, this article is a good example. Kaep was a "gimmick" QB when he started playing, and at the outset was a challenge to defend by opposing teams. But he has never been steady in the pocket, and nowadays NFL teams know how to play him. The stats speak for themselves. This isn't about politics, it's about talent.
Jack (Austin, TX)
I love my country and love football
Can two coincide peacefully... he did nothing wrong in the eyes of the law as much as I disagree with his politics...
But on the other hand business is business... he knew it and now has to face it...
Not your fan Kaepo and you being dealt what you may have bargained for...
Being a rebel comes with being an outcast
Hook 'em Horns
TMK (New York, NY)
Tattoos, excess God in public, other useless symbolism, and mediocre football. Ok let's give him some credit: he did crop his Afro, thank goodness.

This guy needs serious therapy first. Pass.
pirranha (philadelphia pa)
why is this even worthy of an article, I'm sure it has to deal with his stance. So what? This is America. We have freedom of Speech and Freedom of Association. Kaepernick has a right to protest and the NFL has the right not to employ him because he exercised the right. The NFL is not the government, it's a private business enterprise whose goal is mutual profit. Kapernucks protest is a disgrace to a great many fans, they have a right to express their offense by not spending their money on the NFL. Hence, why should it surprise anybody he remains unsigned.
beldarcone (las pulgas, nm)
As with Olympians John Carlos and Tommie Smith, who raised their black-gloved fists on the medal stand, and subsequently had more than their fair share of problems, Colin Kapernick is doomed to fail.

While I defend his right to free speech, Mr. Kapernick may learn a couple of lessons in the process: that it’s not all about being right; and the Freedom of Speech on a national stage is not necessarily going to be perceived as “License” by his employers, who also belong to another American institution of sorts, the National Football League.

If you want an example of a patriotic and most-successful American athlete, check out 1968 Olympic Heavyweight Boxing Champion, George Foreman. While exhausted after nearly destroying his Russian opponent in the final bout, Mr. Foreman circled the ring waving an American flag. He's never lost outside the ring since doing so.
Jack Belicic (Santa Mira)
There are hundreds of folks actually competing for NFL spots and Kap's game collapsed the past 2 seasons; so, he is passed up in favor of better prospects. End of the real story. He tried to save himself by becoming an activist symbol and has obviously attracted various folks to his employment-victimization narrative, but as we know the NFL will only overlook most personal defects and distraction if the player is good.
M Vargus (Somewhere, CA)
The reason Kaepernick isn't getting offers is partly due to his protest, but the bigger reason is that he's not the right type of QB for the NFL.

Kaepernick ran a "pistol option" offense in college. It relied as much on his running ability as his arm. He was not expected to stand in the pocket and find open receivers. Harbaugh knew this and when he had Kaepernick guide the 49ers to the Super Bowl he relied on Kaepernick's ability as well as the fact that few teams knew much about the young QB.

However, teams adjusted and soon they figured out how to take away the running that makes Kaepernick dangerous. His 7.2 adjusted yards per pass hides the fact that Kaepernick abandons the pocket too often and as a result is injury prone.

Teams don't like the trajectory of his performance and really don't want to anger the working class fans they have by hiring someone who so openly disrespected the National Anthem. He also was overpaid by the 49ers and appears to want a similarly high salary elsewhere, which reduces his appeal.

And as for Michael Sam. The man failed to get onto a team because he was too slow to play linebacker in the NFL, but wasn't big and powerful enough to play DE. This was known before he came out by scouts who pointed out that his big games that made him SEC CO-defensive player of the year all occurred against not Power 5 conference teams. Once he was up against SEC offensive lines he disappeared from the stat sheets.
Protest Manager (NYC)
Gosh, what a shame. Kaepernick decided to play politics, and now it's costing him. Cry me a river.

How many people have been fired for saying or doing something leftists don't like? Enjoy the world you've created
Brian (Virginia)
How many teams need read-option QB who brings a self-inflicted controversy with him?
Keli (USA)
Disrespecting the American anthem, while being paid scandalous amounts for a game that is distinctly American, whose fan base is usually very patriotic, and again, Americans, was probably not a smart move on his part.
Mark (Long Beach, Ca)
It looks like football is going to follow boxing in it's slowly fading popularity,....too many injuries, and generally too boring for people accustomed to more exciting games.
FromTheWest (California)
Football is big business. Everyone in the corporate world knows that, if you're going to get away with having an outsize personality, you'd better be an outstanding performer. Ultimately, that's all that counts. The football team owner takes the risks and gets to decide which risks to take, how much unusual behavior to accept from employees. The better the performer, the more unusual nonfootball-related behavior the owner may accept. It's a a balance. The big paycheck does not make a star football player an owner. I think the players forget that sometimes.
Carl Steefel (Berkeley, CA)
I am not expert on football, but it seems he was underperforming.

However, otherwise I admit that I was glad to see him go for reasons other than his sports prowess. No, not the National Anthem--he could not even be bothered to vote, which is why I say "Good Riddance".
Jack (Poughkeepsie)
Were I an NFL GM, I would sign him at the league minimum to cover kickoffs and punts. He is certainly athletic enough for that. Nothing to lose there.
Conservative Democrat (WV)
Get this through your heads- the NFL is a business and IF you can help a team win NFL games, you will get a contract regardless of your politics. It really is that simple, to everyone except the conspiracy crowd.
bocheball (NYC)
Reading some of these comments I"m disgusted to be a football fan.
Kaepernick has the right to express his political opinions without being blackballed, no pun intended. The NFL is a very conservative organization and that's why no one will sign him. Tim Tebow, was preaching his religion non stop when he played, but no one had a big problem with that. It's what Kaepernick is saying and doing that is rubbing the owners and many of the fans the wrong way.
For me, I was proud that he had the courage to make a statement, about the systematic murder of black men by the police and even citizens. He was a thinking man's athlete. All power to him. It's a rare quality.

He played on a lousy team last year and that's why his numbers are down.
Until Ryan Fitzgerald came along last year the NY Jets had been saddled with some of the sorriest QB play on the planet. 4 years of Sanchez followed up by his clone Geno Smith-non stop turnover machines. I would bet their turnovers led to more points than their positive plays. Why don't the JET sign him? He's far better than what we've got.
Peter S (Western Canada)
He should try the CFL--he won't have to worry about the national anthem or a lot of other distractions associated with the NFL. He'd get to pass more, and find it a faster game. The fans are great, but by the time of the Gray Cup, the weather isn't exactly wonderful...well, there is a downside to everything.
Haim (NYC)
I strongly agree with a number of commenters who think Kaepernick is being judged on his true playing ability. But, even if he is being judged on his politics, I doubt it is for the reason the NY Times implies.

You see, football is a team sport. And Colin Kaepernick seems not to be a team player. And, this actually matters.
olivia (New York City)
Kaepernick is unemployed because he was a so-so player, not because he disrespected our country and our flag by refusing to stand for the anthem. The NFL should have fired him for that, but what do you expect from an organization that allows Michael Vic, wife beaters, and other criminals to continue to play.
John D (San Diego)
When I was playing high school football in 1969, my head coach answered this question perfectly. Two guys were messing around during a chalk talk. He looked at one and said, "You're not the making the trip this week." He then pointed to the other and said, "If you weren't first string you wouldn't be going either."

Lesson learned and remembered, coach. I've always endeavored to be first string.
Chris (Florida)
Bottom line: NFL owners would readily sign Satan if it would help them win. Kap is trying, but he's no Satan.
Chris (Florida)
His career is plainly on the down swing. The fact that he's a self-important punk is merely an additional incentive not to sign him.
smalldive (montana)
To say that Kaepernick led the 49ers to the Super Bowl devalues Smith's much more substantial contribution. Benching Smith for the remainder of the season after his concussion probably cost the 49ers the Super Bowl, and arguably cost them much more than that. Not Kaepernick's fault, of course, but he wasn't ready for a starting role in a top flight team. Hopefully he can find a team with a coaching staff that can bring the best out of him. I don't care if he kneels for the Anthem, but he doesn't seem to have an especially coherent way of explaining his reasoning. And the NFL is big business, not very welcoming to highly paid protesters.
charles178 (Southampton Ontario Canada)
Kaepernick had every right to kneel for the national anthem. His action was a form of free speech. But his explanation for doing so left me the impression that it was not a clearly thought through deeply personal position. He seemed to be simply parroting what he had read somewhere. I know it's not a fair comparison but, In my opinion, the guy is not the kind of highly intelligent, articulate and principled person that Jackie Robinson was. I would hope that teams are not turning away from him because he protested. It's my view that they are turning away from him because he is not a very good quarterback. He appears to be a poor decision maker who has regressed at the quarterback position. This may be an unfair assessment but from a distance that's the way I see it.
William Earley (Merion Station, Pennsylvania)
It's only football folks! The most popular sport in Amerika, and let us note that if Mr. Kaepernick won a few games this year, the owners wouldn't care if he devoured small children for lunch. However, he can't win. So who cares?
Nobody because, despite his political persuasion or sense of social justice, he cannot move the ball down the field. So, he must be a bad guy, standing, sitting, or kneeling.
Straight Furrow (Norfolk, VA)
Gee, actions have consequences?

You don't say...
Yetanothervoice (Washington DC)
I think he is a marginal talent that would be employed if he had stood during the anthem. When you protest, however, it has to come with the risk of a sacrifice, or it is just a publicity stunt. This is the sacrifice; a shortened career.
Is it fair? No. But the NFL is a (in theory) private business that does not have to hire him. Actually, the NFL is a small group of coddled multimillionaires subsidized by taxpayers, but that's a different article. I didn't mind his protesting personally, though I suspect it caused some team friction. It was his right. I did mind his not voting, saying they were both racists, and it didn't matter which one won. I think that was and is stupid.
Rick McGahey (New York)
Kapernick didn't just kneel down, he actively discouraged voting (and didn't vote in the presidential election.) After one presidential debate he said comparing Clinton and Trump "It was embarrassing to watch that these are our two candidates. Both are proven liars and it almost seems like they’re trying to debate who’s less racist. And at this point … you have to pick the lesser of two evils. But in the end, it’s still evil.” Of course he is entitled to his opinions, clearly deeply felt. But he isn't some sort of progressive hero.
Greg (MA)
Department stores boycott Ivanka Trump's clothing line, and Times-reading liberals cheer. NFL owners boycott Colin Kaepernick, and Times-reading liberals go crazy with outrage. Actions have consequences.
Hattmann (California)
It was brave of him to take the knee. But remember when he did that he extended his middle finger to a large percentage of his company's customers. In the end it's business.
Len (Manhattan)
Basically it is because he is a lousy quarterback, doesn't stay in the pocket, does not make the downfield throws. Andy Benoit did the excellent analysis on kap and RG3 to explain why they have none the future in the NFL. What he tells -the defense job is to blow up the carefully planned and designed offensive play called by the OC -Kap does this for them as he is quick to bail, the line knows not where he is and the receivers know not when, if, and where the ball may come to them. Basically he has degenerated into a lousy QB, period, paragraph, end of story.
Rickibobbi (CA)
This is obvious, the NFL is corrupt, whether it's head injuries, team owners demanding ridiculous conditions from cities, or this kind of censoring. They don't want any interruptions in their narrative, which includes military fly overs, "supporting our troops ' etc
Dewey (Long Island)
I tip my hat to Kaep for having the courage and conviction to express his beliefs concerning the injustice in America. Give him credit for achieving his objective to aim a spotlight on American institutional racism. We can all disagree about his stance,but he is definitely no sell out like many of our other professional athletes. Finally, this guy clearly has some good games left in the tank. It would be a shame if we don't get a chance to see them. Even though the Jets are starving for a good QB, I knew Trump's buddy Woody, wouldn't allow him anywhere near the meadowlands.
David H. Eisenberg (Smithtown, NY)
Of course not. Maybe more football fans disliked his message than liked it, but we have a very divided society about these things. The real reason he isn't getting picked up is because he stopped performing two seasons ago. You notice Denis Rodman found employment despite his problems. Why do you think? Maybe because he was awesome. When he stopped playing, it wasn't because of his behavior. Do you think that a back up would not have gotten benched if he did the things OBJ did recently? Do you think Richie Incognito would be playing again if he wasn't good? I'm not saying CK's divisiveness helped him. It hurt. But none of it would matter if he won games or his qualities outshone the failures of his team. Johnny Football? Ray Rice? Gone because they can't play that well. Peterson was welcomed back because it was thought he could - and now, if he isn't picked up - it's not because he spanked his kid. Come to think of it, would Charlie Sheen had lasted as long on Two and a Half Men if he wasn't a cash cow? It's about money. And in the NFL money usually comes with performance.
Casey L. (Tallahassee, FL)
This is hilarious. In the Times comment section when Kaepernick first started his protest, I said it was a good excuse for his inevitable failure in the NFL. And here we are.
Blue Dog (Hartford, Ct)
Kap's behind the eight ball because of his head. And because he's a looser. Fact that he chose to co -opt the platform given to him by the NFL for reasons totally unrelated to his political grandstanding didn't help, either. Dumb decisions have consequences. Deal with it.
DTOM (CA)
Colin was only decent his first season. After his mentor, Jim Harbaugh left, he was finished as an NFL QB.
The Storm (California)
There is little doubt that Kaepernick is being blackballed for his political stance. His numbers are good enough for a starter on a good chunk of the NFL's teams, and it's a no-brainer that he would otherwise be sought by many teams as a backup.

Donald Trump bragged about how Kaepernick was out of a job because of his political position, making it clear that he, the now-President, considered it to be appropriate payback by the leagues owners. The problem is, that also makes it illegal and a violation of the owners' agreement with the players' union. From the mouth of the President to the jury's ears.
bob karp (new Jersey)
I am as liberal as liberal gets, but, this guy deserves to be unemployed. As a matter of fact, the NFL should have either fired him, or be boycotted. I have not watched a single game, since he started his "protest". He believes he's entitled to antagonize the fans, the people that pay his salary and get away with it. And we all know that his freedom of speech rights are not trampled. He protest all he wants, while he's unemployed. But, when he works for a corporation, that corporation has every right to have rules in place, that represent their paying customers. I am a business owner. I have a strict rule that none of my employees express any political sentiments, while on duty. Kaeprenick desrves to be on the unemployment line
Mark C McDonald (Atlanta)
I know from personal experience that there is always a price to be paid for dissent in this country. We say that freedom of speech is a core value of our nation, but that does not apply to speaking against the entrenched establishment.
Uscentral (Chicago)
Football is an unforgiving game
And the NFL is an unforgiving league
That's why we love it

There is no issue here
There are some great unsigned players at this point in the season
Kaepernick will find his place
William (ND)
Kaepernick's sack percentage is the worst in the league. He can give you the big play, but he takes the big sack more often than anyone else. In baseball analogy, you need to hit doubles, maybe a triple at times, with the occasional home run. He gives you the occasional big play, but can't give a consistent effort to move the ball down the field. If Kaepernick's skill set was higher, it would not matter if he knelt during the anthem, did not pay child support and abused his significant other (just examples for the latter two, not known for those) -- teams would pay him despite those shortcomings. He needs to improve his skill set to find his way back. The anthem does not help his cause, but it is not the sole issue here.
cmxsmitty (San Francisco)
I'm a lifelong San Franciscan. We are the most tolerant city in the U.S. and welcome different viewpoints that may not be mainstream. Kaepernick got canned because he turned over the ball way to many times and couldn't lead a team to a win. Period.
O'Brien (Airstrip One)
Kaepernick taking his knee this past dreadful season for the 49ers reminded me of a "D" student protesting microaggressions in the reading passages on an English exam. First show you can do what is asked of you. Then, protest. I wouldn't put him on my team even if the only other option was Ryan Leaf (who, incidentally, has turned out to be a pretty great guy).
Gene W. (Richland)
The fact that Kaepernick's not standing during the national anthem is even being considered is why I find major league sports so diminishing. Why in the world do they think they need to play the national anthem before a stupid football game? Really, I'm wondering! I tend to think that having that lofty moment, with hands over hearts etc, somehow elevates the nonsense of the game that follows. Yes, I'm being sharp-edged, but I find the insistence on "getting in line" for the national anthem or the pledge of allegiance is just meaningless rote patriotism. Before a football game? Every single day in our schools? Do the country a favor and simply stop with the faux patriotism and play the stupid game, and let kids learn what patriotism actually is - it's not just standing erect, facing the flag, and mumbling. Hmm, that was sharp-edged, but deserved I think.
John F. Harrington (Out West)
Kap will be off to Canada. They play a crazy, wide open game up there with no jet fighter flyovers every week to remind everyone that a NFL football game is supposed to be a display of patriotic silliness, instead of, well, a football game.

In Canada, it's just a game and the third one on the list behind hockey and lacrosse - and maybe even curling coming in third.

Run and gun 12 man football with four guys in forward motion on plays. Perfect. Ask Doug Flutie and Warren Moon. And - none of this fake patriotic, militaristic parading before every game. The NFL milks that strictly for the money.
Denise (NYC)
As the article does state and my own eyeball test as a NFL fan, there are QBs that have been signed that are not great.at.all. Even Geno Smith is the backup for the NY Giants. Geno, who thankfully may never get to play a down. It does seem odd that someone with his abilities would not be signed, even as a back up. The NY Jets, NEED a QB. Denver needs a QB, and a backup.I know they have their eye on Romo, who is as banged up as it gets. Seattle needs a back up as a of today, if the reports are correct. Colin Kaepernick still has a lot left in the tank. I mean sheesh, how many times did Vick land on a team as a backup when he could hardly play an entire quarter. Something is off, and they don't want the attention.
Sal D'Agostino (Hoboken, NJ)
Kaepernick's skills have eroded well past the point that his contribution outweighs his baggage. Lots of other players don't stand for the anthem and don't have Kaepernick's employment problems.
DesertRose (Phoenix, Arizona)
Interesting that players who get a DUI or are involved in domestic violence will still get another chance. I guess Kaepernick with his controversial stance is just too much of a hot potato for any team to take a risk on?
MDCooks8 (West of the Hudson)
Okay, he played in the Super Bowl but the 49ers lost that game with him as quarterback and from there he played up to his level: mediocre at best. He definitely did not play to any level to justify the contract amount he signed for especially from the little playing history he had at the time.

The NFL is a sports entertainment business and not a sideshow to promote any agenda. Granted, he took a stance which was his right being a citizen of the US, however perhaps the owners are now exercising their rights.
Spike (Florence OR)
The Niners' organization is a total mess, and some point to the ownership not being football people. Niners went from Superbowl to stink overnight. Kaepernick is a very good QB, just ask coach Jim Harbaugh, who dumped starter Alex Smith in a nanosecond to play K. Distraction is not the issue--just ask Bears star Jim McMahon. K. has that great combo you rarely see: a good-passer who can run like a deer. But the confused Niners didn't want to pay his price, the ownership believes the psychobabble of no distraction, and K. is still mentally very young, real naive. Some club will pick him up, pay him cheap, and really score.
G nichols (San Diego, CA)
It was a uniquely maladroit protest. When Tommie Smith and John Carlos raised arms at the 1968 Olympics they were definitively the best in the world, no one could ask if made they should have payed more attention to the sprint rather than a protest. They were not being payed a million dollars a week to sit on a bench. In spite of what many 30 year old authorities on race relations say when they go on the radio these days this is not the worst it has ever been. The conditions Smith and Carlos were protesting were not nuanced. How do I know that? Actually I do not know it but we can compare the millions of dollars that Kaepernick continued to receive with Wheaties box that Smith and Carlos were not on.
Trump won the vote in Wisconsin by less than the number of white males that attend Packer games and normally do not vote. An unrelated fake news item.

Kaep was a exciting performer, at one point in the top 10 in the job that every boy wants. An incredible achievement. But he has been barely average recently (that is, average among outstanding athletes) and if you are the GM that hires him and you do not go to the division championship, you will be fired.
marksv (MA)
He is free to express his opinions how he wishes. And potential employers are equally free to evaluate the potential value of candidate. Seems pretty simple to me.
David (Stamford)
We will never know precisely why....but it shouldn't matter to him or us. He made lots of money and chose a certain way to make a point. The rest is noise. It's just a game.
Christina (Minnesota)
Kaepernick isn't a consistent player, and NFL coaches and owners are holding out to see what happens with Tony Romo (retirement or Houston). I'm sure that his social activism is a consideration, but not as much as people would think.
Arthur Gallegos (Madera, CA)
Of course Colin Kaepernick is being black balled. Sadly, people speak of freedoms yet everyone is expected to act like sheep. Colin took a knee. I salute him for taking a stand in something he believes in. It's better than being a un-involved athlete in larger social issues. His football stats don't lie. He definitely should be employed, and like many QBs, put in an offense that plays to his strengths. The quality of the offensive line as well as other offensive talent is a significant factor in whether the QB will have stellar stats.
Mmm (Nyc)
Kapernick's protest was so misguided it is no surprise it triggered a backlash.

Disrespecting the observance of our national anthem was obviously not a smart PR move. What business--let alone an NFL team--would want to be associated with that?
BD (SD)
Look folks, any NFL team would pickup Adolf Hitler if it guaranteed a Super Bowl. Kapernick doesn't have a job because he over values himself relative to reality. He stinks. Send him to the Canadian League.
Dennis (Westport, CT)
I like Kap ... the football player and person from day one. I hope he gets a chance to play again.
Patrick (Ashland, Oregon)
Not everything is about race, even in this country. If he were still productive, NFL owners, conservative or not, would be lining up to sign him.

As others here pointed out, CK makes some awful decisions on the playing field. Like Brett Favre, he seems to think that his athletic ability will always bail him out.
BearBoy (St Paul, MN)
Kaepernick has not been signed by a team because his numerous remarks regarding his socio-ideological beliefs revealed him to be an imbecile. He identified closely with Black Lives Matter, an virulent anti-cop movement built on a lie ("hands up don't shoot"). Furthermore, after the Presidential election he admitted that he did not even bother to vote!

You can't change the world if you're too disinterested to even try. So it is his attitude and judgement that are seriously in question here. I hope he has saved his money because he has probably played his last down in the NFL.
an apple a day (new york, ny)
In America we celebrate our first amendment right of free speech. But free speech has consequences, as Kaepernick is finding out.
WL (PA)
So does not being good enough to play in the NFL.
Hal (Chicago)
Not to mention that our right of free speech applies only to our relationship with our government. If I did something that was thought to be embarrassing to my employer, he would be within his rights to dismiss me.
Paul (White Plains)
Kaepernick is a punk. And a phony to boot. He parlayed a single good season into a big payroll, and then proceeded to take the 49'ers into the tank. Anyone who kisses his own arm shows himself to be what he really is. The great franchise of Montana and Rice that produced multiple Super Bowl winners deteriorated into a semblance of its former self under Kaepernick's leadership. He thought he could resurrect his star power by disrespecting the American flag and our national anthem. Of course it did not work to his advantage. That's what happens with punks.
Steve Crawford (Ramsey NJ)
These are separate issues. His political beliefs and his athletic ability. He had every right to protest the national anthem but his declining skills have contributed and are the real reason a team like the Jets won't take a chance on him.
megachulo (New York)
If he was great, this would not be at all an issue.

An average QB (at best) who questions authority. Not surprising hes at home watching his telephone.
Sam (Minneapolis)
It's fair to wonder if Kaepernick really is good enough to be a backup QB in the NFL. The NFL is a business and Kaepernick's jersey sales exploded last year after claiming his stance. That merch sale goes to the team and NFL pocket book. He gets attention and that creates revenue for teams. Perhaps it isn't enough, but it is significant. The fact that no team wants his services then may be more indicative of his performance than of his beliefs.

It's also fair to wonder if Kaepernick just lacks so much charm and public savvy that team's pursue other options. He made repeated gaffes last year while claiming his stance that made it seem genuinely hollow to some. Wearing the Castro shirt was a toe-stub, but then also saying he didn't vote seemed like an all-out stumble. Someone shouting for change that chooses not to vote just seems so shallow.

Maybe Kaepernick is being treated unfairly for his views. More likely, given the evidence of his play, what we know of the NFL, and what we know of other players that have succeeded in the NFL, is that his contract situation is due to a combination of these factors, and not due to simply to a civil rights stance.
c-c-g (New Orleans)
If I were an NFL GM, I would let Kap near my team. Yes we all have freedom of speech, but to disrespect the National Anthem while playing a game where he made about $14 million last yr. alone is ridiculous. So he made his point and showed what a human cancer he's become so now he's unemployed. Just goes to prove again -" what goes around comes around". I hope he never takes another snap in the NFL again. Good riddance.
Gothamite (New York, NY)
Have to agree with Spike Lee, something is mad fishy here. There are a lot less accomplished back-ups that are still employed. Matt Barkley? Nick Foles is now a backup after two years of disaster. Last year the Niners had Chip Kelly at the helm, so it's hard to blame the miserable season on just Colin. He's not worth $14 million, but if he was willing to take much less I think he would be a viable backup.
Rei Maida (Kanazawa, Japan)
Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis. Chronic Traumatic Encepholopathy. Dementia.
Life long pain from injuries. Presumably the man has earned his several millions of dollars and saved some of them. The powers that be in the NFL are doing
Colin Kaepernick a big favor by blackballing him.
Const (NY)
A typical NYT's article that tries to find a racial reason for no NFL team picking up Kaepernick so far. The NFL is a cold business and if any team thought he was worth the salary he wants, he would already be signed.

As others have said, there are plenty of examples of players that have committed all sorts of heinous acts who teams are happy to hire. Kaepernick's protest, which the media blew out of proportion, is not the reason he is sitting at home waiting for the phone to rink. Soon enough, a team will find itself in need of an experienced quarterback and he'll be back on the field.
From a Giants Fan (10001)
More told, Ray Rice. KO's a women. & there are the Countless wife beaters, murderers, drug addicts, gang bangers...

It was his arm.
Thinkingperson (New Jersey)
That only proves that the NFL (and society at large) has a much greater tolerance for domestic violence than nonviolent protest against oppression.
Stenta (Atlanta)
NFL players have very short careers, Kaepernick is no different
Anthony Gharib (CA)
In my opinion, he stills deserves a shot. Sign him, tell him you want no distractions and see if he can put up with it and still contribute. If he doesn't, let him go and then he'll realize teams are not playing around.
Richard (Texas)
Yep, can't have a pesky citizen standing up for what he believes in. No sir, not on your life. Not in the good old U. S. of A. He must be wrong since Donald Trump, the new President extraordinaire, says so.
Come on Kaepernick, get with the program. This is America. Love it or leave it!
You can't go against all those super patriotic, flag waving fanatic redneck fans out there. What's the matter with you, anyway? Get with the program.
Mellifluos (Jerusalem)
He has every right to free speech but not when it interferes with his job performance. He could have written a book or gone out on a speaking tour. By using the tactic of grandstanding to promote his ideals he is no different than Trump.
The Old Netminder (chicago)
Could you invoke a few other worn-out liberal cliches? Your smug is showing.
Nyalman (New York)
Were you expressing those same viewpoints when "open minded progressives" have denied Charles Murray and Milo's right to free speech?
ek swen (Brevard, Fl)
For all the Sam Bradford haters, he just set an NFL completions record of over 71% behind a sandlot level offensive line. The Vikings did not tank last year because of Sam Bradford. They had zero running game and a non-existent offensive line. As to Colin Kapernick, he is not a starting level NFL quarterback, so if he ever plays in the NFL again he will have to take a huge paycut, but why would anyone want the negative baggage. Some say Tim Tebow had baggage but it was all positive, as he worked harder than any player and was a tremendously positive locker room presence. Not to mention the money he brought to teams from jersey sales. Just ask the NY Mets.
Ramon Reiser (Seattle)
The Seahawks suddenly need a good backup! Get him.
Jay (Mercer Island)
His politics are probably a good fit in Seattle also.
Hard Truth (Washington Dc)
I know its hard for many to swallow, but Colin Kaepernick isn't employed by an NFL team because he isn't that great (or consistent) at football. I don't think its because of sitting down. People in the NFL have literally killed people and have still been picked up by teams. Colin was a 2-3 season type player and his time has came and gone. Sorry dude, I know the truth can be a painful thing...
Mike (Aurora, IL)
"Looking at the other players who found spots, Sanchez has never exceeded 7.1 in adjusted yards per pass in his career and has been mostly in the 5s. Glennon, also signed by the Bears, has a lifetime figure of 6.4, and McCown, signed by the Jets, is at 6.0. Osweiler had a disastrous season with the Texans at a big salary, posting a 5.0, but found employment with the Browns. Manuel, now with the Raiders, regularly puts up 5s and 6s."

Did you miss this paragraph? How can you explain these quarterbacks being signed and Kaepernick not being signed?
M Vargus (Somewhere, CA)
Mike, the thing you are ignoring is that those other QBs are more traditional pocket passer types than Kaepernick.

The thing that made Kaepernick a star for a couple of seasons was his size and running ability. The truth is that he is more of a running back than a passer. He played in one of the first "pistol option" offenses in college and was lauded for the fact that his rushing yards per game was almost as good as his passing yards.

But that hid the fact that his arm was not nearly as powerful as the average NFL QB is. His ability relied on a good offensive line and a workman RB that could pull attention from him. In college he could win 1v1 battles with most linebackers and run over many DBs. He can't do that in the pro ranks where the linebackers and DBs are often much bigger than he is. Coaches at the NFL level don't like to see the QB run because the position is too important and the hits add up.

Think about the other option QBs who have come to the NFL, few last more than 3-4 seasons before they can't find a job. A few even get converted to WR because while they have athletic ability, they just can't perform at an NFL level at QB.

Kaepernick's best season came with Jim Harbaugh as the head coach. It was also his first full season, when teams didn't know his play and had not figured out how quick he is or that he'd much rather run than stand in the pocket and look for an open receiver. This gave him a huge advantage. That is now gone.
Mike (Cali)
Zero distractions from a back up. So if his controversy was over a more typical NFL issue ( pick one), a. Steroid use b. Spousal abuse
c. carrying a loaded weapon, would he of been treated the same?
Laura (Ontario)
Not to mention d) dog fighting
ac (California)
He's not blackballed. It's because he made bad decisions on the field, and whereas 4 years ago he had swagger and could pull off saving drives with crazy runs and throws on the run, he is now gun shy about leaving the pocket (probably because of the coaching staff) and is forced to rely on his arm which is strong but not accurate. The niners have doomed another season by choosing Hoyer. I would have kept Kaep if that was their only choice. I'm hopeful for John Lynch and Shanahan Jr. but the root of the problem for the niners is not a self-doubting QB or a bad defense (although those are HUGE contributors), it is ownership that is trying to manufacture a world class team with bottom basement prices and fringe picks. Kaep will be fine, he'll hook up with a team and he'll get another shot and get his swagger back. Really, look at Alex Smith at Arizona. Its a wonder what better coaching and committed ownership can do.
Mike (Denver, CO)
I agree that the more interesting and provocative story is the National Anthem flap. While I don’t agree with his strategy, I likewise don’t argue the larger point he was trying to address. He took a hard and expensive path.

His declining productivity is nevertheless the primary (but not the exclusive) reason he's not working; the Super Bowl was now a long, long time ago. Is the Anthem story a huge distraction? Yup. Have there been other NFL players allowed to play that are straight up felons? Yup. But right or wrong (clearly wrong), they are delivering results and when you deliver results in a business where winning is the whole point, stupid actions from reckless players are regularly overlooked by owners. If he was winning AND kneeling, then he’d still be wearing red and gold.

Of course, there are others that fall into a similar statistical and performance column (Elway rolled up Brock without batting an eye; he's got ice running through his veins) but as the story cites, those other players have always been mostly mediocre whereas Kap was once an ace but is now actively engulfed in flames and losing altitude at alarming speed.
Jed Leland (Washington DC)
What has Kaepernick done to further the cause of fighting injustice in the US since taking a knee during the National Anthem? One attention seeking stunt does not a dissenter make.
Andrew (Orange County)
He has given a hell of a lot of his money and time to organization that fight injustice, aside from taking a knee. At least do some cursory research before you further malign the guy
Connie Stetson (Boca Raton)
You're joking right? He's done a lot.
Google: Colin Kaepernick youth outreach or Colin Kaepernick Somalia relief.
He's putting his money where his heart is.
He's my hero.
mpound (USA)
Since NFL teams have cheerfully signed players who beat and sexually assault women, drive under the influence, are involved in bar room brawls and the like, I rather doubt that Kapernick - who is a solid citizen off the field - is being blackballed because of his politics. No, he turns the ball over too much, has injury issues and most of all, loses football games. That's the only thing that counts to NFL teams and their fans. Period.
HRM911 (Virginia)
Your right. The NFl doesn't car abou kneeling or assault or other criminal activities. They care about return on investment. If the return isn't good the players are gone regardless of how nice they are such as Tebow. The only thin that motivates then is the US dollar,$$$
George (Florida)
Ha! And you probably think that class is an imaginary distinction. Nationalism is still the most powerful force in the world, largely thanks to people who don't understand the difference between failing to present proper aplomb for the national anthem and criminal behavior.
Fred Norman (Stockton CA)
And he gets sacked too often because of indecision,doesn't see second or third receivers, and as already said, doesn't win games.
MMF (Manhattan)
He was right to protest but he picked the wrong platform. The national anthem is a poem written about the defense of Baltimore against the British invasion in the war of 1812. Written in 1814, it's message of hope are as important as the words written underneath the statue of liberty. He's no better than trump to forget these ideals no matter what. I certainly wish Trump wasn't the quarter back...
George Santangelo (NYC)
The British didn't invade the US in the War of 1812. The US invaded Canada seeking to make part of the US and got its comeuppance when the Canadians and Brits defended themselves burning Washington and driving the US out of Canada. So our anthem is based on a battle during an aggressive war that we started and lost.