There is a proverb,"Where there is a will,there is a way",and it has worked well in this story. The young people took up the challenge,and they have met with success. Hats off to them. This story has said that only lucky few have good childhood. I have seen poverty and living in a wretched house during my childhood. I fought it and educated myself and found a job. Suicides do not solve any problem. It is difficult to fight the companies with money power. But the people have proved it otherwise. It is a very moving story,and inspires people to fight for a cause.
1
As I read the story I was thinking about multiple challenges different teens in Jersey City would face growing up in a typical household.This article made me realize that not everyone has a really good childhood. As I continued to read I realized how much of an effort a teenager can make when they're trying to do a good cause. In the article it states “ But now she was home, amid a new plague of suicides, and she wanted to do whatever she could to help other teenagers on the reservation. Together with White Eyes and their friend, Trenton Casillas-Bakeberg, she formed a youth group.”This young girl helped make a statement in her reservation she gave people a sense of hope and eventually the youth group expanded to a more political cause and inspired others across the nation.This is why i believe teenagers can make a difference in the world , when we are determined we create a movement and inspire others to join our cause and help make a difference that can help change the lives of different people.
The standing rock movement was an inspirational movement that shocked the nation when they realized how native Americans to this day are still being mistreated it states in the article”After weeks at the Standing Rock camp with minimal tribal support, the young people decided that they needed to carry out some sort of public action.” This proves teens really can change the world when they're determined to make a difference.
The standing rock movement was an inspirational movement that shocked the nation when they realized how native Americans to this day are still being mistreated it states in the article”After weeks at the Standing Rock camp with minimal tribal support, the young people decided that they needed to carry out some sort of public action.” This proves teens really can change the world when they're determined to make a difference.
5
This nation has never treated Indigenous People with justice, honesty, and respect. Their response to their country is and has been patriotic. These young people have taken up a cause for all Americans, time for us to join them in cleansing our Mother Earth.
10
Thanks so much for this inspiring story of self-empowerment in the face of despair. Indigenous spirituality and tradition, respect for nature from which we descend, and which sustains our existence, caring about something greater than ourselves, about generations to come, these are the true heritage of America. Those of us who believe so must organize and resist the greed that consumes and pollutes our environment and lives. If you are not part of the solution, you are part of the problem (complacency).
7
Outstanding article, appreciate the insight and history lesson of how the Standing Rock movement was started and has continued to grow globally.
6
Having just seen a screening of I Am Not Your Negro and now reading this, I can only hope that we can break down the media divide so more Americans of every political faction get closer to the stories of their American sisters and brothers. In the words of James Baldwin, it is entirely up to us as Americans whether or not we are going to face, and deal with, and embrace this stranger whom they maligned so long.
Thank you for this article and please continue to publish these American stories.
Thank you for this article and please continue to publish these American stories.
8
Congratulations to the Youth Groups.......launching anything with any degree of complications is a very difficult thing in this generation, especially if Super Ego Trump is involved. Perhaps there is still hope for America if the youth do not give up in the early stages..........but the Trump Group is a constantly changing group - like clouds in the sky on a windy day.....
1
"The thing for the young people that they have to really try to do, is to understand that this is not ordinary. This is a totally extraordinary situation that we are in. It is not supposed to be this way. And that they are justified in being strong political activists and, anybody they have any influence over, to hold his feet to the fire to try to make him do right. And this is okay for the young people to do that. And they need to know that they need to start doing it when they’re young." (Stephen Gaskin, Caravan, annotated, 2005)
3
After 30 years of reporting on suicide of young women in a, historically, warrior society in the Amazon which is also facing accelerated loss of territory and deterioration of water quality due to oil exploration, among other pressures, I do not recommend to cast the indigenous struggle, now embodied in Standing Rock, as a zero-sum victory or failure proposition.
Looking at the state of affairs in the US and around the world, indigenous people, small farmers and poor people caught up in cities are likely to see, apart from some specific successes, a relentless onslaught on their environments and many of the battles will be lost.
The forced and traumatic loss of sacred land and resources should be forcefully encountered, but territory is not the only thing that binds people and gives them identity. That's why we should be encouraged by these young people who are recovering and developing relationships, an internal, social territory, so to speak, that will sustain them and generations to come in the face of adversity. This is very important resource, comparable to water, over which they exercise full control.
Looking at the state of affairs in the US and around the world, indigenous people, small farmers and poor people caught up in cities are likely to see, apart from some specific successes, a relentless onslaught on their environments and many of the battles will be lost.
The forced and traumatic loss of sacred land and resources should be forcefully encountered, but territory is not the only thing that binds people and gives them identity. That's why we should be encouraged by these young people who are recovering and developing relationships, an internal, social territory, so to speak, that will sustain them and generations to come in the face of adversity. This is very important resource, comparable to water, over which they exercise full control.
8
Thank you Saul for this heart inspiring reporting! Every winter I struggle with depression especially since my husbands death more than four years ago followed by abandonment by family. This story bears witness to these young people living the lessons of not just surviving but growing beyond suffering and despair. I will remember their perseverance and creativity and carry it with me as a reminder and beacon. Please keep writing about them! Hope you are planning a book.
7
A simply amazing story. Tragedy, bravery, hope, need - both personal and cosmic - all coraled by the Spirit to inspire and lead. I stand in awe.
2
Here we sit, in a region where European Settlement is within memory of my great grandparents, and after decades of 'white-lash' against them, we see the beginnings of a revival in the only communities that can help any of us. We're proud and supportive, and we've already shipped you care packages for winter. Our whole watershed depends on this movement, since the Dakota Pipeline crosses all of our water supply rivers here too -- thousands of people depend on this fight.
9
An incredible, galvanizing story. I wept the whole time. What an inspiration in a time of despondency; I plan to stand with these Lakota in whatever resistance movement lies ahead, whether at pipelines or not.
5
A nice story, I am sure, but where's the victory? The Times is completely missing the reality that a seeming victory has been overwhelmingly overturned and that atrocities against the protestors has resumed, full force, at all levels of government. Wake up, please.
1
Yes but the story ain't over yet. And now is exactly the time when the groups ability to accept tax deductible donations as 501(c)3 is crucial to their putting a long term foundation under their feet. The next time they run relay to DC it could be on front page. There are a lot of people looking for a way of pushing back at the rollback of environmental protections this administration has launched.
3
I think you missed the point that the victory was in the achievements of these young people in finding in themselves the courage, love, determination and empowerment to assume positions of leadership for their generation. DAPL/Standing Rock was merely the background for the larger story of this group's growth and experiences, like a training ground. And because of what they learned about themselves and what they can accomplish, they can now launch a movement of newfound hope and purpose among the tribes. That is the victory.
7
The story wasn't about the pipeline.
The victory is found in one young person who decides not to commit suicide and in the other young person who prays with him.
The victory is found in one young person who decides not to commit suicide and in the other young person who prays with him.
3
The united power of youth can radiate outwards
and change this world.
The prayers of the aborigine elders can
allow the power of love conquer selfishness
and greed.
Speak Up For Standing Rock.
and change this world.
The prayers of the aborigine elders can
allow the power of love conquer selfishness
and greed.
Speak Up For Standing Rock.
3
What what what a great story, I have to come back and write a comment. I'm just stunned!
1
Dear Jasilyn and other courageous young people,
Reading this story, and also watching with horror and anguish the recent abuses of our Water Protectors at Standing Rock, has forced me to ask; "Where is the Love of God in all of this?" What I recognize is that each of you, who are putting your life on the line for the good of all, are that Love. The anguish and horror of watching innocent one's at Standing Rock being put in prison and suffering abuses, is like witnessing Jesus being crucified.
So, with all of my heart, thank you for your courage and endurance. Please do not resort to violence to yourselves or to others. Know that many are holding you in prayer.
With Great Respect and Love, Kimarie
Reading this story, and also watching with horror and anguish the recent abuses of our Water Protectors at Standing Rock, has forced me to ask; "Where is the Love of God in all of this?" What I recognize is that each of you, who are putting your life on the line for the good of all, are that Love. The anguish and horror of watching innocent one's at Standing Rock being put in prison and suffering abuses, is like witnessing Jesus being crucified.
So, with all of my heart, thank you for your courage and endurance. Please do not resort to violence to yourselves or to others. Know that many are holding you in prayer.
With Great Respect and Love, Kimarie
7
We are proudly co-hosting the runners from Standing Rock that are featured in this article this Sunday, February 5th at 12:00 PM. They are running over the Golden Gate bridge and we are having a Global Wopida Ceremony. You can find out more here https://www.facebook.com/events/1632171753754812/
7
Congratulations to the author(s) of this article for prize worthy journalism. It is encouraging to hear that the young people are taking the initiative as that is where there is always the energy for major change. It is also giving meaning to young lives that have been scarred by family and colonial abuse.
To the older people - treat your children well. Whatever you have endured there is no excuse for neglecting or abusing children. Following their lead in this is one way to start to bring the community together but those who have mistreated children have to be held accountable and acknowledge what they have done - that is an important part of the suicide prevention.
To the older people - treat your children well. Whatever you have endured there is no excuse for neglecting or abusing children. Following their lead in this is one way to start to bring the community together but those who have mistreated children have to be held accountable and acknowledge what they have done - that is an important part of the suicide prevention.
5
An incredible story, stunningly well told. Thank you Mr. Elbein and
NY Times.
NY Times.
7
Thank you for the artful way in which this story is told. And thank you to the brave people that have forged this movement. It really has fascinating implications for how we think about the health and resilience of individuals, communities, and our planet. I feel hopeful after reading this beautiful story and will be sharing it widely.
5
Thank you for telling this story. These youth have taught me so much about courage, peace and non-violent action. This is the most important movement of this generation. Water is life.
1
Life without a cause is just existence, so what's new. But I don't suppose it wasn't too depressing for the kids to see their parents and grandparents stuck in a perpetual time warp. I'm sure the prospect of their parents expecting them to live in the past forever on must have given them a lot of hope for their future otherwise.
1
We haven't even begun to right the wrongs this country has inflicted upon Native/First Americans (some of which are mentioned in the story) - and the abuse continues to this day. The story of these young people (members of the One Mind/I.I.Y.C) is inspirational. In a very short time they managed to turn their community from one of death and deprivation to one of spiritual healing and purpose - and in the process they just might be saving the planet for all of us. I don't know if the Nobel Peace Prize is for this kind of thing - but it should be - and they should get it.
26
I am greatly saddened by the mistreatment of our Native Americans and I have been for as long as I can remember. I want to look into ways that I can help financially.
Please NYTimes - stay interested in this.
Please NYTimes - stay interested in this.
12
Hello JMM.
So am I. And it continues...
Please take a look at Fragilepeace.org
We are starting new projects on Monday, the 5th with the Navajo and Pueblo Tribes. We work to help them find new answers to their struggles. One ongoing project is with the Inuit in Northern Quebec, very far north. They have also struggled with suicide and you will find a brilliant film they did on our website. It is haunting and heartbreaking but it is above all, human.
Peter Frantz , Founder, FragilePeace.
So am I. And it continues...
Please take a look at Fragilepeace.org
We are starting new projects on Monday, the 5th with the Navajo and Pueblo Tribes. We work to help them find new answers to their struggles. One ongoing project is with the Inuit in Northern Quebec, very far north. They have also struggled with suicide and you will find a brilliant film they did on our website. It is haunting and heartbreaking but it is above all, human.
Peter Frantz , Founder, FragilePeace.
4
How sad. The young people would be better off spending time in school.
2
obviously you haven't been on a reservation
6
Amy,
Don't be an ostrich, this is school.
Don't be an ostrich, this is school.
9
No they would not! They are learning about life, helping each other, the community and setting wonderful example to people in general! They have actually stood up to be counted, and more power to them! Maybe this is what the world needs to save the earth - before mankind destroys it totally!!!
3
This is America. This is why America is already great. I am so proud of these people. My family donated to the Water Protectors, and I hope they can keep up the fight in the face of the Trump administration.
Fight on One Mind! Keep this purpose and expand it! We in the West are so proud of your work. Regardless of race, water is the liquid that all of us require to exist. Without water, we are nothing.
Fight on One Mind! Keep this purpose and expand it! We in the West are so proud of your work. Regardless of race, water is the liquid that all of us require to exist. Without water, we are nothing.
17
Their servant leadership has taught them much. Would that it could teach those whose sole motivation is profit.
These youth, so long ignored, deserve our attention and our appreciation.
And our support. Although the small-handed white child in the White House will not listen...and seems incapable of learning...let each of us raise our voices to support these noble young people.
These youth, so long ignored, deserve our attention and our appreciation.
And our support. Although the small-handed white child in the White House will not listen...and seems incapable of learning...let each of us raise our voices to support these noble young people.
9
But America was built on greatness:
Native Americans were the first slaves of colonized US. When the scalping program instituted by 16th New England governors could not differentiate the bloody heads of men, women, and children- the program evolved to keeping Native children alive…to sell.
Native Americans holocaust is the largest in human history yet the media year after year gives primacy to another.
Native Americans were the first refugees; a US military tradition of taking Indian land by any means possible. We see this in DAPL and the state and federal government’s response of extreme violence unequal to the peaceful civil disobedience of the Native people there. Equally brutalized by the silence of the representatives in all branches of government.
Native Americans were the first to be discriminated against because of their religions. They were not given religious freedom until 1978. Yet Sen. Schumer cried for the Muslims who were barred from entering the US because of who they are what they represent. He has yet to take a stand for the human rights violation of the Natives at Standing Rock.
Thank God for these Native youths. After all, they’ve given more for us than we would for them.
Native Americans were the first slaves of colonized US. When the scalping program instituted by 16th New England governors could not differentiate the bloody heads of men, women, and children- the program evolved to keeping Native children alive…to sell.
Native Americans holocaust is the largest in human history yet the media year after year gives primacy to another.
Native Americans were the first refugees; a US military tradition of taking Indian land by any means possible. We see this in DAPL and the state and federal government’s response of extreme violence unequal to the peaceful civil disobedience of the Native people there. Equally brutalized by the silence of the representatives in all branches of government.
Native Americans were the first to be discriminated against because of their religions. They were not given religious freedom until 1978. Yet Sen. Schumer cried for the Muslims who were barred from entering the US because of who they are what they represent. He has yet to take a stand for the human rights violation of the Natives at Standing Rock.
Thank God for these Native youths. After all, they’ve given more for us than we would for them.
23
This is a beautiful and yes painful story. Filled with deep connection, hope and love. If only we could see the world through their eyes and through their ears, I believe we all would be better. The trappings of the industrial world vision needs to move over and shrink, so that community and meaning can emerge. Thank you Mr. Elbein for documenting your "listening voice."
7
These brave youth a trying to not only protect and heal their land, but to heal the trauma that has been passed down through the generations for over 120 years. The non-native people who stole their land and committed genocide, and those of us who have stood idly by while present-day forms of genocide (poverty, alcoholism, etc.) persist, are as responsible for the healing as is the Sioux Nation itself. This is not a Sioux problem, this is an American problem and an American responsibility. May we all do that we can to let these youth and their elders know we not only support them, we believe in their larger cause of healing.
14
It's about time we all start recognizing first nations people, first.
The suffering and poverty is unimaginable to most.
They need our equal support as we would towards immigrants.
Sadly, they are like refugees within their own land.
Why do most look the other way when it comes to supporting those in need here?
The suffering and poverty is unimaginable to most.
They need our equal support as we would towards immigrants.
Sadly, they are like refugees within their own land.
Why do most look the other way when it comes to supporting those in need here?
13
Please be aware (as I was not) that there is a GoFundMe page for this group who could use any support they can get.
6
There is a knotty problem here. In the most general terms, a preindustrial culture is colliding with a high-tech industrial culture. How to resolve it? I am pessimistic. Historically then the more advanced culture collides with the less advanced culture, the less advanced culture is wiped out. I hope it does not come to this, but I am not feeling any great surge of hope, after reading about it. If oil or gas is needed to keep factories running and homes warm, then it will be extracted and ship to consumers one way or another.
On the two reservations, the Cheyenne and the Lakota- Sioux reservations they are affected by environmental racism, racism in the educational system, and harassment and discrimination by the sheriff of Morton County; a rural form of stop and frisk.The water protectors are leading us in environmental rights, in indigenous and civil rights. They are thinking ahead, and trying to protect their drinking water for their grand children and great grandchildren. It's not as analytical and stereotypical as you think in your very analytical comment. Their religion and community are very spiritual and grounded. As a Quaker I was so moved by their prayer ceremonies at sunrise, and their committee meetings also had a prayer introduction and closing. The elders and these youth leaders are amazing.
5
What you are referring to is intentional genocide and slavery- not cultural supremacy over another. That's is the problem with your problem. Read the papal bull of 1493 and the Treaty of Tordesillas. Therein you will find the golden percolation of white supremacy in which genocide, slavery, and colonization was justified worldwide. And if you look deeper, you'll find the root of how we've been brainwashed. Personally, any culture that does not resort to murder to get what they want is 'most' enlightened.
6
Consider the possibility that an ancient culture offering such strong spiritual strength and valued even to youth unsupported by elders may prove the more advanced in the end.
1
The victory is in the action, the building of new community, and the recovery of the sacred ways. Big victories have been achieved. More are coming.
11
The New York Times needs a county full of Pulitzers. The Standing Rock Controversy is a microcosm for the cancerous growth at the center of America. The ecosystem concerns & the tribal heritage concerns are vital to meditate upon. They need not be frozen in time as polar as the Standing Rock location. The spiritual phenomena at the essence of Native American's souls must be addressed. Innovative, multidimensional, enlightened dramatists should take up this cause. It is symbolic of primal imagery underneath the show business of our daily living now. Standing Rock is hard core naturalism in the face of a reality TV consciousness.
18
I'm glad that these young people have found a cause that has given meaning to their lives, that's keeping them alive, but I was not nearly as enamored of this article as every other commenter appears to have been.
For one thing, it seems to have been posted before being properly edited (there were several missing commas). For another, if the oil that would have flowed through this pipeline is instead transported by rail, the victory for the environmental movement cheered by the writer of this piece is very likely to be Pyrrhic. And last, I wonder if writer would take the same loving, reverential approach to describing the religious rites of a group of young white evangelicals as he does to describing those of these young Native Americans.
For one thing, it seems to have been posted before being properly edited (there were several missing commas). For another, if the oil that would have flowed through this pipeline is instead transported by rail, the victory for the environmental movement cheered by the writer of this piece is very likely to be Pyrrhic. And last, I wonder if writer would take the same loving, reverential approach to describing the religious rites of a group of young white evangelicals as he does to describing those of these young Native Americans.
5
Yeah, those missing commas really bothered me. I almost didn't notice how heroically and courageously these young people have behaved.
And, I too, really tried to force this story through the prism of race, wondering why there was no shout-out to "White Evangelicals"; but the anecdotes regarding how the group handled violence made me realize, maybe, these young leaders are here to teach all of us. And, maybe, save all of us. It is usually pretty difficult to learn when you are keeping track of who gets the attention, and who gets the credit.
I don't think group has reached that stage. I hope they never will.
And, I too, really tried to force this story through the prism of race, wondering why there was no shout-out to "White Evangelicals"; but the anecdotes regarding how the group handled violence made me realize, maybe, these young leaders are here to teach all of us. And, maybe, save all of us. It is usually pretty difficult to learn when you are keeping track of who gets the attention, and who gets the credit.
I don't think group has reached that stage. I hope they never will.
16
Pyrrihic, perhaps, but your binary is a false one. Our only choices are not dirty oil by rail or dirty oil by pipe. These Lakota youth have demonstrated that they can think outside the consumerist box. Can we?
9
I think the real issue has to do with whether or not we are encouraging alternate sources of energy and getting away from fossil fuels. Do we really need this pipeline?
5
Hoka Hey!
In the spirit of their mighty brave honorable Hunkpapa Lakota ancestors Sitting Bull, Gall, Low Dog, Crow King, Running Antelope, White Bull, Black Moon and Rain-in-the Face.
And the Oglala Lakota paladins Red Cloud and Crazy Horse.
In the spirit of their mighty brave honorable Hunkpapa Lakota ancestors Sitting Bull, Gall, Low Dog, Crow King, Running Antelope, White Bull, Black Moon and Rain-in-the Face.
And the Oglala Lakota paladins Red Cloud and Crazy Horse.
7
Great article. I have great respect for these young people and, yes, love also.
7
So beautiful. These kids are our leaders
3
Galvanizing victory?
They lost.
the pipeline will be built, and with not that much delay.
They lost.
the pipeline will be built, and with not that much delay.
3
The Army Corps of Engineers is in the process of doing an EIS, Environmental Impact Statement. This will continue, and comments are being accepted until February 20th. Alternative routes are considered, as well as treaty rights to water fishing, etc. The sovereign nation and the boundaries of the original treaty lands are also being considered, The Fort Laramie Treaty of 1851 and 1868. The Lake Oahe was flooded by the US government, with no compensation to the Standing Rock Sioux who owned farmland there. (see NY Times article, 2016) This pipeline may not be finished. Energy Transfer Partners are still missing the permit for going beneath the river. They tried to skip consultation with the Tribe and getting all their permits ahead of time. They also claimed they did not need an EIS.
4
Help the toddler in the White House by paying attention to the children of Standing Rock.
4
Now, more than ever:
Standing Rock!
Resist!
We stand together, for a better future
Standing Rock!
Resist!
We stand together, for a better future
16
Thank you NYT, you know you were slow to appreciate this story and movement, especially when Bernie was so involved and Hilary refused to commit support for so long! I am so happy to see it covered so well now. Keep it up. Again, wish you'd done so earlier... I'll bet you do too!
11
correct.
1
Very good reading. It seems important to find something to fight for, something greater than yourself, something that you can hope in. I struggle with suicidal ideations currently. Maybe I need something to fight for too, something to put some anger toward rather than turning inward.
11
There are many injustices in this world to fight against. Find one that is meaningful to you, on a personal or societal level. Good luck.
6
There is no better group to be awarded the Nobel Peace Prize next year. I hope the New York Times counts among the institutions that can nominate candidates or it helps campaign on its behalf.
37
It goes without saying that we are having a national conversation about race and culture now. But the Native Americans are truly the forgotten people of American History. In high school and college, we talked a lot about slavery, Jim Crow, the Civil Rights Movement, MLK, Malcolm X and the like. These are all important topics and are crucial for any American studying our nation’s complicated history. The Native American story, by contrast, began with a few mentions of the meeting of the Mayflower pilgrims with the Native Americans in the 1620s and then skipped ahead nearly three centuries to the battles of the Little Bighorn and Wounded Knee. Perhaps they mentioned the “French and Indian War” as well. When I was in college in 1990, I saw, around Christmas, a brief mention on NBC Nightly News about the 100th anniversary of Wounded Knee including a very old Lakota woman who had been a baby at the time of the massacre. I’ve searched online for any mention of this woman and her story and cannot find it. I have a distant ancestor who was involved in treaty negotiations with the Modoc People of California in the 1870s, and I remember a few stories from my grandfather about that as well. But overall, I’ve head to learn about their story through the internet and my own reading. I am lucky in that my parents live in Montana near two reservations (the Blackfeet and the Salish-Kootenai) and have had the chance to visit both territories and learn about them.
11
Wonderful photographs, absorbing story.
5
No victory achieved yet. Drilling is continuing and it is very possible that pipe is being laid under the lake quite illegally. No one can get near to observe and drones are being shot down. Water protectors facing increased violence at the hands of the militarized police and national guard. No one at Standing Rock is celebrating any victory other than the magnificent coming together of hundreds of tribes for the first time ever, and the incredible support of people across the planet. Without the visit of 5,000 veterans over a few days time the violence would have continued unabated and largely ignored by the media, NY Times included.
30
Thank you Saul Elbein and NYT for this great piece of journalism. Always it is important to understand the background, motivations and character behind the news.
For those who want to know how to help, I found this web site:
http://www.nodaplarchive.com/international-indigenous-youth-council.html
To the youth council and those moved as I am:
I daily receive appeals for money from various causes. I live on a very modest income and find it difficult to know where my pittance would do the most good. But I could commit to send $5 per month to this group. If others similarly committed, they could continue this important fight for the country and themselves. They could build safe houses on all the reservations where children would have a refuge from the chaos in their lives.
My grandparents were all immigrants, but I have been touched by the lives of the original owners of this land since I first set foot on Acoma when I was 5. I have had the honor of talking with Archie Fire Lame Deer and learning the value to the Native Americans of maintaining their culture. Our American Dream was ripped from their soul. Now that dream is being threatened for all.
It is past time we joined with our Native brothers and sisters and helped each other.
For all my relations. Let us help one another.
For those who want to know how to help, I found this web site:
http://www.nodaplarchive.com/international-indigenous-youth-council.html
To the youth council and those moved as I am:
I daily receive appeals for money from various causes. I live on a very modest income and find it difficult to know where my pittance would do the most good. But I could commit to send $5 per month to this group. If others similarly committed, they could continue this important fight for the country and themselves. They could build safe houses on all the reservations where children would have a refuge from the chaos in their lives.
My grandparents were all immigrants, but I have been touched by the lives of the original owners of this land since I first set foot on Acoma when I was 5. I have had the honor of talking with Archie Fire Lame Deer and learning the value to the Native Americans of maintaining their culture. Our American Dream was ripped from their soul. Now that dream is being threatened for all.
It is past time we joined with our Native brothers and sisters and helped each other.
For all my relations. Let us help one another.
56
Such brave people, strong beyond what an "average" American citizen can comprehend. I grew up on what was known at the time as the Fort Totten Sioux reservation, counted many as friends from the best I could as a white perspective. And I knew I could never plumb the depths of their tragedy, even while knowing much of it. A horrible history of this country, yet a people filled with such courage. For all the non-connected or naysayers, I challenge you to check the Native American reservation roles of the military dead from WWII and forward...and then just try to contemplate what that means - a people who faced genocide by the same country and people, but who could put their lives on the line for democracy. It should boggle your mind, and humble you.
80
The oil companies know perfectly well how to cross rivers and aquifers with a casing which is like building a tanker with a double hull. The Chinese use direct drilling to tunnel under rivers avoiding polluting the river with dense silt. The Kalamazoo River was polluted a couple of years ago and a few crews kind of half-heartedly cleaned up some of the crude oil and left patches that still persist. If some money were spent to make pipelines leak proof it would be far less than the cost of a clean up which is never done since the oil companies own the state governments and recently the federal one.
Every Native gathering in Maine includes a large number of veterans.
To Jasilyn Charger, and to the many whose names are not printed here,
this is a love letter.
My sons live far from Standing Rock, far from the black snake which threatens the Cheyenne. They are separated from you by cultural background, and by the fact that their upbringing has not been marked by persecution as yours has. Yet their lives are inextricably linked to yours, and to the resistance you are waging. For your courage, and for the love with which you are standing for all peoples and creatures of the earth, I am humbled and forever grateful.
Yours may be the greatest generation in the history of the earth, because yours may be the one with the courage to turn the tide and ensure a future for all beings yet to come.
The science is clear: If the black snake called Keystone is allowed to drain the Athabasca Deposit in Alberta, Canada of its tar sands oil, it will send double the C02 so far released in human history into the air. And If that happens, we will perish.
if my grandchildren are to have a chance at a meaningful life, if we are going to turn this planet around in time, it will be in your lifetime. And it will be because of your courage. 'Courage' comes from the latin, meaning "with heart."
You have opened your hearts and have risen to this challenge. Now the Trump administration has doubled down. And so what you have begun will have to spread. It will have to be covered, and it will have to be supported by all of us who want better for our children.
Thank you.
this is a love letter.
My sons live far from Standing Rock, far from the black snake which threatens the Cheyenne. They are separated from you by cultural background, and by the fact that their upbringing has not been marked by persecution as yours has. Yet their lives are inextricably linked to yours, and to the resistance you are waging. For your courage, and for the love with which you are standing for all peoples and creatures of the earth, I am humbled and forever grateful.
Yours may be the greatest generation in the history of the earth, because yours may be the one with the courage to turn the tide and ensure a future for all beings yet to come.
The science is clear: If the black snake called Keystone is allowed to drain the Athabasca Deposit in Alberta, Canada of its tar sands oil, it will send double the C02 so far released in human history into the air. And If that happens, we will perish.
if my grandchildren are to have a chance at a meaningful life, if we are going to turn this planet around in time, it will be in your lifetime. And it will be because of your courage. 'Courage' comes from the latin, meaning "with heart."
You have opened your hearts and have risen to this challenge. Now the Trump administration has doubled down. And so what you have begun will have to spread. It will have to be covered, and it will have to be supported by all of us who want better for our children.
Thank you.
53
Thank you for illuminating the heart of what this story and this fight is all about and for letting the dignity of these brave activists shine through. Please keep reporting on this vital story.
23
Thank you for this story. It gives hope, and education. The way forward, especially for many people of color, lies in learning, recovering, revering, and reviving the ways of our ancestors. We have been through incredibly dark times and have the tools of resistance and resilience, while maintaining a spirit of creativity, humanity, and even joy. The people, united, will never be defeated.
17
I knew some, not all of this. This is a story that everyone should know. We donated winter coats to the cause and if there is a fundable website published we will donate more. Thank you NY Times for enlightening us and giving us some positive news to read amid the horrible political stuff which is ruining my ability to sleep at night.
10
A Great article, NYT! Relate to current state of union and unsettling questions;
Who are the "immigrants" in this country?
What does it mean, "Make America Great Again"?
Now, "America First"?
What is "America", who are "they"?
"native America" does mean something to this country? Are we the "Country of Immigrant", if not it seems this country was colonized by invaders. Now trump with immigrant wife and first gen. Kids, what is he doing?
Who are the "immigrants" in this country?
What does it mean, "Make America Great Again"?
Now, "America First"?
What is "America", who are "they"?
"native America" does mean something to this country? Are we the "Country of Immigrant", if not it seems this country was colonized by invaders. Now trump with immigrant wife and first gen. Kids, what is he doing?
8
Phenomenal story, well told. Strength and continued courage to these young people, some thing we are all going to summon in coming weeks and months.
6
Great article which tells the story of what's known as the Standing Rock movement from the beginning to now. This movement is not over. It is reaching adolescence with all its challenges and opportunities…
I have been living in camp since late October.
I have been living in camp since late October.
7
If you read only one article on Standing Rock, this enlightening back-story should be it. Millennials will inherit our messes and this story of the Seventh Generation gives me hope that they just might succeed in righting them.
23
"Though you have brutalized us, we will not brutalize you .... we want you to be healthy".
Amazing, inspirational. Equal to Gandhi.
How can we support them? We vote, but where and how can we send concrete assistance?
Amazing, inspirational. Equal to Gandhi.
How can we support them? We vote, but where and how can we send concrete assistance?
22
sacredstonecamp.org accepts donations through paypal.
Sacred Stone Camp
PO Box 1011
Fort Yates, N.D. 58538
They need firewood, oak, maple, ash, and/or money to buy it. They could also use gift cards for Lowes, Menards. (a hardware store in Bismarck, ND) They do not need clothing, or perhaps arctic subzero gear, like insulated gloves, boot sole coverings to walk on ice. (forgot name.) Thank you,
Sacred Stone Camp
PO Box 1011
Fort Yates, N.D. 58538
They need firewood, oak, maple, ash, and/or money to buy it. They could also use gift cards for Lowes, Menards. (a hardware store in Bismarck, ND) They do not need clothing, or perhaps arctic subzero gear, like insulated gloves, boot sole coverings to walk on ice. (forgot name.) Thank you,
2
When I read this article and the series on Viet Nam, I am reminded that the dominant American Culture that allowed Viet Nam, despite protests, that may yet allow the pipeline, is the culture that has weakened the national soul to the point that a demagogue, fascist like Trump and his Gestapo can slither in.
Yes blame Trump. yes blame the Republican leadership, but don't avert our eyes from our own collective complicity.
Yes blame Trump. yes blame the Republican leadership, but don't avert our eyes from our own collective complicity.
16
Trump doesn't care about the rights of our Native American Indians and he won't make any money if his pipeline investment is halted. He's all about greed.
4
What Rights? The pipeline is outside the reservation.
1
"Reservation" - the word says it all. Some Rights supersede boundaries.
What we've done to/stole from these people is our national shame.
What we've done to/stole from these people is our national shame.
This is America. Despair. And hope.
Let's revisit hope and change.
Let's revisit hope and change.
2
Amazing resurgence of meaningful live and self preservation and political & environmental activism by community building and overcoming the doom of historical trauma. The tribal young doing the right things deserve admiration and support. What an exceptional American story compared to Mr. Ignoramus and his bunch in the White House.
5
"Terribly beautiful," indeed.
2
The Times never sent a reporter when militarized police were using sound cannons, water hoses, dogs, tear gas, concussion grenades and rubber bullets against Native Americans on their own historic lands. Will they be there when the next time?
80
yes indeed --- it is truly unfortunate and amazing to me that the water cannons, etc were not part of this important story --- and why was that omitted?
2
Was there a reason, NYT, that the story doesn't cover the inhuman actions, I.e. Water cannons, dogs, etc. ?
1
I phoned and emailed the NY Times three times on the night of the water cannons in 24 degree weather in November. sigh.
4
So good to read about this bright spot amidst the general bleakness and lunacy. A lovely and important piece.
18
I've had a chance to meet some of these young people, starting this past summer as the group passed through Indianapolis. I have never seen such a motivated, courageous, and spiritually-driven group of young people. They have taken on some of our society's most difficult issues, and found a way to stand up to all of them.
64
Amazing and inspirational. The idea of getting off snapchat and facebook and really doing something real and difficult and impactful is something we all must embrace. I have been struggling how to react to the new Trumplandia -- this article will help me focus and provide motivation. Thank you to NYT and the author for writing /publishing this article.
24
Beautiful story. Thank you.
7
Thank you for this story. How can people send support to these young people? Is their non-profit up and running?
18
Good enlightening journalism like this is why I read the NYT. Thank you.
35
I just watched a documentary on this very same story on Viceland the other night and was moved to tears (Viceland produces some incredible programming). The young women that started this movement, some no older than 13, are nothing short of amazing. It shook me to my core when I heard that Native Americans cannot arrest non-native workers from the nearby oil industry who come onto their reservations and kidnap and rape young girls. That power has been stripped away. These girls have banded together with strength and dignity and have achieved things under horrendous circumstances that no man could possibly have achieved. They are my new heroes.
90
yes VICELAND Two Part film on Standing Rock, go to You Tube to find. Accurate, very current.
1
These young people have come from a history of violent hatred and exclusion from whites, to end up filling me with gratitude and pride this morning. I hope they realize that tens of thousands of people now know their story and feel the same. We need these akicita now more than ever.
110
And we must insist that the federal government uphold their treaties and honor their sovereignty.
38
Thanks for printing this article about an important environmental and social issue. It is refreshing to see this new perspective instead of the previous political pieces about “protesters” and “human shields”. I guess articles like this don’t generate enough click bait.
This issue is especially important. It is about our past (the Native American issue). It is about our planet (leaky oil pipelines placed under major rivers). It is also about control (corporate control over local law enforcement).
If the environmental impact was written about earlier, perhaps we would be leading the world in innovative energy technologies instead of lamenting about president trump’s reversal of Barack Obama’s stop order.
Then again, we probably would have just increased the fracking.
This issue is especially important. It is about our past (the Native American issue). It is about our planet (leaky oil pipelines placed under major rivers). It is also about control (corporate control over local law enforcement).
If the environmental impact was written about earlier, perhaps we would be leading the world in innovative energy technologies instead of lamenting about president trump’s reversal of Barack Obama’s stop order.
Then again, we probably would have just increased the fracking.
42