Dignity, grace, intelligence, warmth, depth of soul, character, an open mind, and yes, the fabulous smile. I paid attention when she spoke, she did't waste our time and hers with filler talk. Serious, but with a sparkling eye.
May she rest in peace.
May she rest in peace.
47
That's was lovely, David. The person you describe is just the way I imagined her to be. I'm so sorry for the loss of your friend. We will all miss her.
40
David, thank you.
18
A beautiful piece, Mr. Brooks.
35
I am so very, very sorry, David. Gwen was a class act and was symbolic to me of PBS, news with integrity.
50
Thank you, David.
Our loss of Gwen Ifill is like the loss of a close family member. Her smile and presence had that effect.
Our loss of Gwen Ifill is like the loss of a close family member. Her smile and presence had that effect.
34
One of the best, will be missed and is a loss for us all...ebullient is how she cane across as well. Thanks for sharing this
27
I can't remember how I heard---I think I was crossing the living room---it was late afternoon. I sat down and just came apart. Thank you Gwen, for your wisdom, for your life, for your soul.
51
There could not be a more perfect tribute for someone we all loved and admired from afar.
55
Thank you for this beautifully written tribute to a beautiful life.
51
Thank you for sharing your memories, David. You described the person we all feel we knew. Watching her interactions on NewsHour and on Washington Week, I always felt she must be a great and caring friend because she was certainly a great and caring journalist. We will all miss her voice and spirit and my sympathies go out to you who knew her personally.
57
Thank you, David. You said it well. Gwen will be missed.
61
Thank you for this tribute. Her passing is especially hard to take this week.
116
Thank you Mr. Brooks beautifully said.
109
What a beautiful and moving tribute to Gwen Ifill. Her brilliant incandescence seemed to leap though the television screen and into our family rooms nightly. I will miss her reasoned reporting immensely. I will also miss admiring her lovely and interesting jewelry she wore with each broadcast. My sincerest sympathies to her family and colleagues.
84
I was in total shock when I heard it yesterday. When Gwen was absent for few weeks and then she came back with a new hairdo and had lost some weight, I attributed it to contract negotiations and a new makeover. I had no idea she had been sick.
RIP Gwen, you will be really really missed, your smile with that contagious sparkle in your eyes were unique, you were way too young to leave us.
RIP Gwen, you will be really really missed, your smile with that contagious sparkle in your eyes were unique, you were way too young to leave us.
85
A News Award should be established in honor of her virtues so that we may have someone like her to follow.
105
A close friend of mine was a big Gwen Ifill fan, so years ago I tried to listen closely to her and see what I could find. Then I tried to recall memorable things she said or poignant questions she raised and I couldn’t. So while I thought she was a fair enough reporter and seemed to be even tempered I always thought the attention she got was kind of patronizing.
I felt that PBS news under her stewardship had become achingly boring. Long stretches of interviews that seemed like curtains drawn across air time filled with endless meaningless dissections. In fact the only time I watch that news now is for the repartee of Brooks and Shields.
About one other little observation you made – ‘she worked for low money at PBS’. Aa hmm, what is low money for you is a lot of money for the rest of us.
I don’t mean to pound on her, but when I watch that news program it is like watching paint dry. What was suppose to have been an hour of in depth analysis turned into endless dribble.
Take the subject of immigrants who have criminal records. Bernie Sanders was asked about it on PBS and said he had no idea how many immigrants legal or illegal have committed crimes, or what kind of crimes they have committed. (is it 2 – 4 million? He had no idea.
Those are the kind of fact an in depth news department should investigate. As well as why he didn't know.
Gwen didn’t give us that nor does PBS.
I felt that PBS news under her stewardship had become achingly boring. Long stretches of interviews that seemed like curtains drawn across air time filled with endless meaningless dissections. In fact the only time I watch that news now is for the repartee of Brooks and Shields.
About one other little observation you made – ‘she worked for low money at PBS’. Aa hmm, what is low money for you is a lot of money for the rest of us.
I don’t mean to pound on her, but when I watch that news program it is like watching paint dry. What was suppose to have been an hour of in depth analysis turned into endless dribble.
Take the subject of immigrants who have criminal records. Bernie Sanders was asked about it on PBS and said he had no idea how many immigrants legal or illegal have committed crimes, or what kind of crimes they have committed. (is it 2 – 4 million? He had no idea.
Those are the kind of fact an in depth news department should investigate. As well as why he didn't know.
Gwen didn’t give us that nor does PBS.
24
I trusted Ms. Ifill more than anyone on liberal media.
I will miss her.
I will miss her.
85
If we can't fill Gwen's space, we can still follow her lead. Smile, keep our heads down, keep writing... I will put on the "Nasty Woman" pin a friend gave me and keep fighting.
84
Gwen was "family" to this 74 year old white guy. I can't believe how much I miss her!
20
Mr Brooks,
What a beautiful column, and magnificent tribute to Ms. Ifill.
Thank you.
What a beautiful column, and magnificent tribute to Ms. Ifill.
Thank you.
13
Thank you David, for a beautiful remembrance of a wonderful person.
12
Thank you for your column on the passing of Gwen Ifill. Aside from your admiration of her, it is obvious that you were great friends.
9
Thank you, David Brooks, for this beautiful and heartfelt tribute to an extraordinary woman of grace, intelligence, and substance. I am particularly moved by the acknowledgement that Ms. Ifill was a woman of deep faith, which no doubt was a source of strength in a profession that could truly try one's soul. As a longtime viewer of The Newshour, the loss of Ms. Ifill's presence and steady voice will take a very long time to get over, if ever.
17
Thank you, David for your beautiful tribute to Gwen Ifill. When my daughter told me the news yesterday, I burst into tears. I told her my heart was broken. I imagine that was a metaphor for all that has gone on this week. When Tim Russert died, my mother cried to me on the phone. I was a bit puzzled by her sadness. Now I truly get it. I watch the Newshour every night. You are part of our family. And now it feels like there has been a death in it.
23
Thank you, David. So many of us feel at a loss, thank you for giving us words. Where do we look to find her humor, wisdom, intellect, grace, and shining smile now?
Thank you for your voice, your steady hand, steady head. We have rough waters ahead.
Thank you for your voice, your steady hand, steady head. We have rough waters ahead.
19
David....
Regrettably...the old adage is validated once again...only the good die young!
People of faith and goodwill will react and respond accordingly....they rededicate themselves to refining and improving their craft. The torch is now passed to you...we're supremely confident that you'll take it to the next level. If not ..Gwen will come back and kick you in the a**.
Her light may have been dimmed but her indomitable spirit lives on...through all those she inspired and/or touched.
Regrettably...the old adage is validated once again...only the good die young!
People of faith and goodwill will react and respond accordingly....they rededicate themselves to refining and improving their craft. The torch is now passed to you...we're supremely confident that you'll take it to the next level. If not ..Gwen will come back and kick you in the a**.
Her light may have been dimmed but her indomitable spirit lives on...through all those she inspired and/or touched.
12
I did not know Gwen Ifill well, but a friend of mine made it his business to watch and report on whatever she said and did. As a result, I felt I did get to know her through his adoration and respect for her. I regret that I did not take the time to check out this phenomenal woman and person. I do remember that the first time I laid eyes on her, I instantly thought of Barbara Jordan, who was another great person who served our country as one of the first Southern African-American female U.S Representative. Ironically, Jordan was also about the same age (59) as Ifill when she died. Thank you, Ms. Ifill, for your contributions to our nation's history; may you rest in peace.
20
Beautiful, David. Though just a NewsHour viewer, I will miss Gwen very much: after so long, as sometimes happens with the best of those we know only from TV or print, she seemed part of the extended family: a journalist to the core, with a scintillating personality, a winning smile, and that occasional look that told you that you were with her on the in-side of the joke.
David, your loss is so much greater my mine. To you and your colleagues at The NewsHour, my sincere condolences.
Thank you.
David, your loss is so much greater my mine. To you and your colleagues at The NewsHour, my sincere condolences.
Thank you.
20
I'm with you today, Brooks.
There is her passing, and there is this election. But both of them?
I've been watching this show since I was a child. Dad's regular news program was McNeil/Lehrer. When it became "Ifill and Woodruff", I hollered and clapped like a dolphin. It is, regretfully, the last of its kind. Watching her colleagues' elegies last night got to me.
In her honor, and out of respect for her existence and efforts: I beg that you, personally, and your colleagues dig down, retrench and become the People's watchdogs, as you all once were.
Some fight with fists, some fight with guns, some fight with bombs. You fight with your words and desire for truth. Winter is not coming, it's here.
There is her passing, and there is this election. But both of them?
I've been watching this show since I was a child. Dad's regular news program was McNeil/Lehrer. When it became "Ifill and Woodruff", I hollered and clapped like a dolphin. It is, regretfully, the last of its kind. Watching her colleagues' elegies last night got to me.
In her honor, and out of respect for her existence and efforts: I beg that you, personally, and your colleagues dig down, retrench and become the People's watchdogs, as you all once were.
Some fight with fists, some fight with guns, some fight with bombs. You fight with your words and desire for truth. Winter is not coming, it's here.
42
I'm still grieving for Molly Ivins, Now I have to add Gwyn Ifill to that list.
Too much.
Too much.
27
Thank you for this heartfelt tribute to a woman who represented the best in journalism.
23
What a lovely piece David Brooks -- thank you and thanks to Gwen Ifill for sharing her honest, fair and pure journalism with all of us. RIP
21
I usually never disagree with Mr. Brooks completely -- he seeks the truth and abstract concepts and tries to put into column form -- but this article was beautiful. Politics intrudes on so much now that Trump is ascendant -- but it gives so much solace to know that on the Conservative side, people still stand by the good and decent. By writing about Ms. Ifill Mr. Brooks does that.
32
Like viewers of the '60s and 70's had Uncle Walt, we had Gwen. She will be missed....
14
Thank you for that. I've admired Gwen, feared that she was gravely ill these last few months when she disappeared from the Newshour, but clearly I did not know her as you did. So thanks for sharing a piece of her with your readers.
17
How I will miss Gwen! Her sharp mind went along with her beautifully bright colored clothes against your satiny skin. She made such an impression on my heart and mind...and I, too, cried when I heard the news yesterday.
16
Thank you, David, for your tribute.
I will miss Gwen Ifill.
The NewsHour has been a "must" on my daily agenda since 1975 & the Ifill/Woodruff team since their beginning.
Gwen Ifill spoke on Nantucket in 2008, as part of the Geschke Lecture Series & I went to admire her there.
Danny Schecter (in his "Weapons of Mass Deception"), gave the PBS NewsHour the highest marks for reporting accuracy.
I will miss Gwen Ifill.
The NewsHour has been a "must" on my daily agenda since 1975 & the Ifill/Woodruff team since their beginning.
Gwen Ifill spoke on Nantucket in 2008, as part of the Geschke Lecture Series & I went to admire her there.
Danny Schecter (in his "Weapons of Mass Deception"), gave the PBS NewsHour the highest marks for reporting accuracy.
17
Thank you, David Brooks for this lovely and insightful tribute.
30
I have decided Gwen Ifill is a modern Saint. I anoint her as such. A Saint we need right now. She is no longer here to give us the news. But I pray she is somehow able to shape it now.
Pray for us, dear Gwen!
May you Rest In Peace. May you share that Peace with us.
Pray for us, dear Gwen!
May you Rest In Peace. May you share that Peace with us.
37
Great work!
14
Dear Mr. Brooks, You are the reason I yesterday signed on for he digital New York Times. I never realized my first letter to you would be about the loss of Gwen Ifill. She was won of the many reasons PBS was my sole source of TV news. I will miss her greatly. Please continue her work in making this country the center of liberty and decency I have enjoyed for 86 years. I do not expect to see another presidential election so I rely on you carry on the task of telling the truth. Thank you. Chuck Monell
106
About five years ago after hiking over West Maroon Pass from our little mountain berg of Crested Butte (an old coal mining town) to Aspen (an old gold and silver mining town), my wife and I bumped into Gwen Ifill who was in town for the Aspen Ideas Festival. Star-struck, I went up to her and said that my wife and I always anticipated, and never-missed, our Friday night PBS line-up: The NewsHour (including Brooks and Shields), Colorado State of Mind, McLauglin Group and Washington Week. She smiled warmly and gave us some sage advice: 'get a life'. I have a pretty darn good life as I hike, ski, travel frequently, but she was right----too much MSNBC or being over wrought about politics isn't healthy. E. B. White famously said something like, "each day i wake up torn between a desire to save the world or savior the world'......in the despair of Trump's election, I will remember Gwen's friendly advice.
142
I know I and millions of others feel endless gratitude for the treasure of Gwen Ifill...we had the treasure of her luminous presence, and I believe we knew how to cherish it. But now, to the pain we feel in an election that enshrined hatred, we must add the pain of a world made so much less by her untimely absence. Thank you, thank you, thank you, Gwen, for the gift of yourself you gave to all of us.
17
[[Gwen was ebullient, as I’ve mentioned, but she was not soft. She was authoritative, an executive and confident.]]
I real elsewhere that she had no desire to run for office, but the qualities you describe are what people look for in a candidate.
I real elsewhere that she had no desire to run for office, but the qualities you describe are what people look for in a candidate.
5
I'll miss Gwen on the Newshour even more on Friday now that the banter between you, Mark Shields and her won't ever be. Civil way to end the week unlike what passes for news on cable.
9
This is a lovely and perfect tribute. Thank you.
14
Thank you, David, for this heartfelt remembrance of Gwen Ifill. We'll all miss her. Just by continuing to play your own part in keeping honest journalism alive--and the Bannons of our world under close watch--you'll honor her memory.
6
Thanks you for this tribute to Gwen.
4
Thank you, David for your thoughtful remembrance of Gwen Ifill. I really knew little about her life story (which is so inspiring) but my, how I enjoyed watching the News Hour with Judy and Gwen!
Though you and I come from different places on the political spectrum, I've always enjoyed your columns. Please persevere and continue shining your original perspective and commentary during this turbulent and frankly depressing time in our history. So sorry for your loss, our loss, ... yes, the nation's loss.
Though you and I come from different places on the political spectrum, I've always enjoyed your columns. Please persevere and continue shining your original perspective and commentary during this turbulent and frankly depressing time in our history. So sorry for your loss, our loss, ... yes, the nation's loss.
13
Thank you thank you thank you David.
You are my brother in spirit and word.
Bless us in our thanksgiving for who we knew and our grief in who we have lost.
You are my brother in spirit and word.
Bless us in our thanksgiving for who we knew and our grief in who we have lost.
7
A nice tribute, David. I hope the style and methods Gwen practiced can withstand the new so-called news and its different tenor, pace, innuendo, and hysteria.
5
What a wonderful column Mr. Brooks. You have brilliantly captured both Ms. Ifill's life-spirit and essence, and the gaping hole she has left behind.
8
Well said, David Brooks!
5
Condolences on the loss of your friend, and thanks for your heartfelt remembrance.
5
Thank you for this heartfelt tribute. Having Gwen on PBS made the world a better place.
11
Thank you Mr. Brooks for your wonderful tribute to Gwen. All of us who watched and listened to her are so sorry to hear of her untimely death. I, for one, would love to see the photos you cited in your column. She was a treasure and won't be forgotten.
5
Gwen was one of my heroines and examples as a young journalism student at the University of Oregon. I watched her on both Washington Week and the NewsHour growing up. Her presence was so electric, you could feel it on the other side of the screen. My heart goes out to you, David, and the NewsHour family who knew her personally. I applaude your stength in writing this piece at a time when your spirit must feel so low. Gwen would be honored and proud. Take care of each other and let us fight on.
10
What a lovely tribute Mr. Brooks. She will be missed.
8
Thank you for this lovely tribute to your friend and colleague. I'm so sorry you have lost your dear friend.
8
Beautifully put, David. Thank you!
10
Thank you Mr. Brooks for this piece on your colleague and friend Gwen Ifill. Her journalism integrity can not be compared. I loved watching her and I will miss her presence in reporting the news. God Bless her!
2
Thank you David. I am an eighty year old man who wept as I read your column today. I wept because you captured the true Gwen so perfectly and I wept for the nation's loss and your loss and my loss of an outstanding journalist. This house whole watches PBS World News Tonight almost daily. Though I never met her face to face, she was my friend and I trusted her. Thank you for sharing your grief with all of us.
10
Thank you for this beautiful tribute to a remarkable and most courageous woman, journalist, human being.
3
Thank you for this kind note. She deserves it.
5
She was a 'superpower' in the best sense of the word.....and her Journalistic integrity is so badly needed right now. What a tremendous loss to us all.
7
Thank you David! I'd hoped that you'd talk about Gwen today. PBS Newshour is the only US news program left that is not a 'show'. Newshour's reporting\opinions were top notch. I think that, this team particularly, has strong uncompromised values, and it shows. You encouraged each other to be respectful and honest. It comes through, just like your appreciation for her talents and friendship came through here.
5
Thank you for that beautiful tribute to Ms. Ifill. I always looked forward to watching Washington Week and the NewsHour on PBS. Somehow Ms. Ifill had a way of making me feel safe. I would tune in and know that she had taken the time to investigate, ask the right questions and tell me what the real story was. I will always look to the NewsHour and Washington Week for my news but I know nobody will ever fill her chair.
6
Thank you once again, David Brooks. You and Gwen have brought human decency to journalism. No one owns you or owned Gwen.
6
She would have fit well in your book on Character. Thank you for this article, and for being you... watching you and Mark, and Amy Walter, Judy, Gwen - it's been a privilege and an inspiration. I wanted all my life to be surrounded by such people, but am not, and can end up acting not as my higher self, but my lower. I often say to myself: What would David Brooks say (and with what tone), and now What would Gwen say?
53
Thank you.
9
Except, now I feel even lower.
Deep sigh.
Deep sigh.
2
Amen.
5
Beautiful tribute and well deserved; Gwen will be greatly missed....especially in these terrible times.
6
Thank you, Mr. Brooks, or your powerful, loving tribute to Gen Ifill. I'm deeply sorry for the loss of her to all of us, especially as we proceed through this treacherous time in our history. For you, however, it's personal, and must make your work harder and your heart heavier. Keep up your thoughtful, carefully wrought essays. We need you.
7
She was sunshine, warmth, faith and truth. What a shock that someone so good can be taken so young. I cried when I heard of her death.
8
Thank you David Brooks. We only knew Gwen Ifill from the PBS New Hour and Washington Week, and we cried in our house when we heard the news of her death. She touched millions through her radiant smile, genuine warmth, courageous journalism and clear love of this country with all its messy problems.
11
If all news reporters were like Gwen Ifill the world would be a much better place and maybe the out come of the election would have been different.
Sadly I think Gwen was just too intelligent, too classy and to dignified for many people.
When I saw "Stephen K. Bannon, rising in power, and Gwen, who is passing from this world, I wanted to throw up. This is not progress and this is not good news." DITTO
Sadly I think Gwen was just too intelligent, too classy and to dignified for many people.
When I saw "Stephen K. Bannon, rising in power, and Gwen, who is passing from this world, I wanted to throw up. This is not progress and this is not good news." DITTO
7
Thank you for honoring Gwen. And, thank you for not writing about Trump.
3
Thank you for the beautiful words about your friend. You allow me to reflect on all that is positive in the world and all that holds promise for the future.
You are my friend.... A NATIONAL TREASURE.
You are my friend.... A NATIONAL TREASURE.
3
Thank you for this personal and human remembrance.
4
Beautiful piece, David. When I saw the news I knew that an era of fair and informative reporting had passed away with her and I too felt like puking at that very same image on the cover of the NY Times. Thank you for sharing your stories of Gwen.
5
"Ambition for quality" is not something people are aspiring to anymore......maybe that's the best way to honor Gwen's memory. Let's try adopting her ambition for quality.
8
Until now the story has never been about Gwen--the mark of an old-school journalist.
Thank you David, your article moved me to tears.
Thank you David, your article moved me to tears.
3
What a wonderful tribute , Mr Brooks !
3
Thank you, Mr. Brooks, for such a beautifully written piece about Gwen Ifill. She was a remarkable journalist.
I remember an interview she conducted on PBS with former Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert. It was subtle, yet direct, intelligent and informed. I imagine that he might have been a little uncomfortable with her directness, but he responded with good humor, and she made be believe, at that moment, that she was a great journalist.
I remember an interview she conducted on PBS with former Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert. It was subtle, yet direct, intelligent and informed. I imagine that he might have been a little uncomfortable with her directness, but he responded with good humor, and she made be believe, at that moment, that she was a great journalist.
5
Thank you, she will be sorely missed just when we need her voice most.
7
Thank you, David Brooks. I was in Ms. Ifill's Washington Week audience here in Cleveland just before the RNC convention when she must have been quite ill. Despite that, her humor was abundant and her serious approach to the news shone through.
4
Thank you Mr. Brooks, I hope everyone reads you today.
3
I regularly watch the PBS Newshour (it is the only American news program I regularly watch). So I knew who Gwen Ifill was.
Or at least I thought I did.
When someone passes away, no one talks about how 'mean' or 'grumpy' or 'grasping' or 'full of themselves' they were.
Kindness, a sense of humour and a determination to do good work go a long way.
Lesson for us all.
I'm sure she'll be waiting at the other side of the Pearly Gates for you, David, to fill you in on 'how things work up here'.
Or at least I thought I did.
When someone passes away, no one talks about how 'mean' or 'grumpy' or 'grasping' or 'full of themselves' they were.
Kindness, a sense of humour and a determination to do good work go a long way.
Lesson for us all.
I'm sure she'll be waiting at the other side of the Pearly Gates for you, David, to fill you in on 'how things work up here'.
2
Gwen has graced our living room religiously on weeknights. She made the news worth watching because of her integrity as a journalist. We are saddened by her loss. This article and the touching and heartfelt tribute to her last night on the NewsHour tells us that we are in good company-Ms.Ifill you will be sorely missed. A shining Washington exception.
5
It has been such a pleasure just to see her almost every day at PBS evening news. Her smile , her well crafted remarks and pointed questions. Today after reading you David i will not go on reading the NYT depressing news, i will keep remembering what a pleasant page you have written about her
r
r
6
Thank you, David, for such a touching tribute to a great journalist. I had hoped you might be on the PBS Newshour last night, but, after reading this, I should have known- you wished to put your remembrance into words that others can read. Again, thank you.
6
I too was shocked and saddened by this unexpected news. The Newshour will not be the same without her, and it is hard to imagine anyone filling her shoes. She was a strong, articulate black women and a first class journalist. We lost her far too soon.
5
Than You David, a wonderful tribute of a beautiful person, enjoy your articles and your Friday nites on NPR. Will miss Gwen and that beautiful SMILE!!
3
A great life well lived. I feel the same void as when we lost Peter Jennings.
5
Thank you, David.
1
Thank you. The contrast with the biography of Stephen Bannon is particularly telling.
3
David, I loved this column, and so enjoy your writing in general, and reflective, yet blunt commentary on the news, even when I disagree with you. Brooks & Shields on Friday's PBS is a highlight of my week. Please don't go anywhere. We suffered enough losses lately.
3
Grace doesn't even begin to describe her. She was honest, brilliant and brought joy to the job she obviously loved. It was a privilege to turn on the News Hour every night and get the story from Gwen Ifill.
3
The tribute to Gwen last night on PBS was inspiring. She said she always wanted to bring light and not heat to illuminate and inform, and she did just that. What a loss to her friends and family, to journalism, and to America.
2
David,
I'm sorry for your loss & the national loss. Please don't ever put your pen down. Zofran is a wonderful antiemetic...you may want to stock up given the landscape we must survive within over the next four years....maybe The Almighty gave Gwen an exit to spare her four years of sordidness.
I'm sorry for your loss & the national loss. Please don't ever put your pen down. Zofran is a wonderful antiemetic...you may want to stock up given the landscape we must survive within over the next four years....maybe The Almighty gave Gwen an exit to spare her four years of sordidness.
3
Thank you, David. Just--thank you. She has left a hole in all our hearts, and in our defense against the tide of racism and hate on the rise in our country.
2
David
Beautifully written and yet so personal. Thank you for sharing.
You are in a position most of us (99%) are not. Why don't you help us all by searching for the next "Gwen" and encouraging them to step up?
M
Beautifully written and yet so personal. Thank you for sharing.
You are in a position most of us (99%) are not. Why don't you help us all by searching for the next "Gwen" and encouraging them to step up?
M
What a beautiful heartfelt tribute to your colleague and friend. Thank you for providing we who watched her religiously with memories of that other Gwen that we should have been so graced to know. God Bless Her.
DD
Manhattan
DD
Manhattan
1
Thank you David Brooks. Your words are comforting and uplifting at a time when any additional sadnesses and Gwen Ifill's passing is a indeed a sadness for all.
3
Thank you for that David. I've always enjoyed your columns as a sane and compassionate conservative and your take of things on PBS. Needless to say, I enjoy the PBS Newshour because it is the best in Television News.
1
My ex-husband and I parted marital ways, but we continued to meet for the evening news on PBS to adore Judy and Gwen. Saw she was loosing weight, hoped it was on purpose.....Someone we will always respect and have a laugh at the fun we had watching her...Betcha God is glad to have her news reports now.
3
I am so sad to hear about Gwen Ifill's death. I trusted her reporting, and insights and never missed Washington Week, and the Newshour.
2
The past eight years of corporate news has soured me. It's "truthiness" bothered me. Lies are lies. You don't get that from Newshour, and never got that from Gwen Ifill. I miss her doggedness and honesty.
And David, the fact that you are part of that family, is what keeps me reading your column week after week. You are of the same caliber though I often disagree with you - at least you are real, like Gwen was. And thank you for that.
And David, the fact that you are part of that family, is what keeps me reading your column week after week. You are of the same caliber though I often disagree with you - at least you are real, like Gwen was. And thank you for that.
6
Thank you David Brooks for this lovely piece. I will miss Gwen Ifill too !!
Although I obviously never had the pleasure to meet her , I feel like I know her too ..
We could use someone with Gwen's insights and experience to light our way through the tuff times that await us in our country!!
And thank you too for your wise insights and honesty!! Although I disagree with you at times , your honesty and integrity shine through as well
thank you !!
loyal NewsHour listener,
jon norris
Blue Mounds Wisconin
Although I obviously never had the pleasure to meet her , I feel like I know her too ..
We could use someone with Gwen's insights and experience to light our way through the tuff times that await us in our country!!
And thank you too for your wise insights and honesty!! Although I disagree with you at times , your honesty and integrity shine through as well
thank you !!
loyal NewsHour listener,
jon norris
Blue Mounds Wisconin
2
Wow. Sometimes you don't know who your heros are until you read their obituary. I'm stunned and saddened that I will not be seeing Gwen on Friday nights. Mr Brooks, you are indeed a lucky man for having such a great friend
and I am very sorry for your loss. I'm sure she's sending you love at this very moment.
and I am very sorry for your loss. I'm sure she's sending you love at this very moment.
4
A wonderful column and tribute, David, to a fine journalist and a magnificent human being. We must keep Gwen Ifill's magnanimous spirit alive and well during the darkening days ahead.
Tom Cuddihy
Tom Cuddihy
5
I'm sorry for your loss, the world's loss. Thank you for sharing.
1
YES!
2
David Brooks , how fortunate you were to know Gwen Ifill personally. My husband and I were great admirers knowing her only as a class act on PBS newshour. My heart is breaking for our loss. Keep up your insightful reporting we will still be watching.
2
David, please take care of yourself. We will need voices like yours even more in the dark days that are coming. God bless Gwen.
2
God Bless the handmaiden of God, Gwen Ifill, and keep her in His Memory Eternal. Gwen Ifill was the best of us whose beauty and love spoke to truth so all of us can be better people. Thank you, David Brooks, for you thoughts about your colleague and our heroine.
1
Never like you Mr. Brooks. The fact that you started breaking away from the Darkside with the rise of Donald Trump got my attention. This tribute makes you human and caring. Kindness and persistence are within your grasp.
8
Thank you David, for sharing your memories of Gwen. She has long been a personal hero of mine. In remembering her work, words like integrity and truth come to mind -- concepts that currently seem to be in hiding. We are diminished by her death, but we are greater for having had her spirit and wisdom in our public discourse. Although it was apparent she had been ill, I was looking forward to her bringing the best of journalism to this time we are in and will sorely miss her presence. When so much that is reprehensible in our country and world is now taking even more power, we could have benefited from her insight and honesty. In her absence and in her memory we must work that much harder to bring some light into the darkness.
4
Perfect, human, true.
1
I'm so sorry.
Mr. Brooks:
thank you for this timely column.
while a bright candle has departed this terra firm,
a new constellation of even brighter stars has been added to our heavens - -
whenever we chose to see and to share and to wonder.
we are all far-better people for Ms. Ifill's innumerable contributions.
and she will forever be a one-of-a-kind,
brilliantly delivered.
peace and love
3
A few weeks ago, my wife noticed Gwen's absence from the News Hour, so she asked me if I had seen any news about this. I googled all I could and found nothing, so I said maybe she is doing reporting so not on TV.
Reassured, she did not mention it again.
Of course now we know, Gwen Ifill was dying.
So sad for all of us.
Reassured, she did not mention it again.
Of course now we know, Gwen Ifill was dying.
So sad for all of us.
6
I was just thinking about her the day before she passed, thinking that at least I'm glad we have Gwen Ifill. As a consumer, it's hard to find those journalists you love, trust and admire, like a confidant. Gwen was that for me, and it's such a terrible time for her to leave us. rip
2
The Bannon - Ifill juxtaposition is a jarring, disturbing thing. Gwen's passing at this moment in time seems an ominous portent.
7
I wonder how Gwen Ifill would have reported on Trump's new Senior Counsel Steven K. Bannon who will be an "equal partner" with Reince Priebus, Trump's Chief of Staff? Bannon has a well documented history of anti-Semitic, misogynist, and racist views and behavior.
Maybe David Brooks can report on Bannon in depth for his readers?
Maybe David Brooks can report on Bannon in depth for his readers?
3
Nausea describes it. Do we simply channel Sartre, or do we wipe our mouth, sip black tea, nibble saltines, and survive?
5
Well done, David. This has been one ghastly week, hasn't it?
12
David, thank you for some personal insight into your friendship with Gwen. As a Canadian who is always interested in US events, PBS is the goto place for an honest perspective. Gwen and Judy, amongst all the great professionals at PBS, were a comforting buffer against the tide of the current discourse and slanted journalism of America right now. She will be a great loss, not to just yourselves, but to the rest of us in the world. You have our greatest condolences.
5
I am so sad Gwen Ifill has passed away. She inspired me to always reach high while keeping a solid personal integrity. Thank you, Gwen for blessing all of us with your amazing person and life.
1
Gwen's folks may have made their way from another land, but she was an American and the pride of Buffalo, New York.
4
She was definitely a class act.
3
Thanks. I too wanted to throw when I " saw a photo of Stephen K. Bannon, on leave from Breitbart as chairman and rising in power, and then underneath it a photo of Gwen, who is passing from this world," and for exactly the same reasons.
7
There must be a word for a stranger becoming a family member. Gwen Ifill was the best kind of family member to so many—100% trusted, consistent, welcoming in her personal presentation. In the very style of her probing, she was someone to turn to for perspective in a roiling world. A superb broadcast journalist. Millions were lucky to have her in their living rooms. Thank you, David Brooks, for your deeply-felt reflections on her.
10
I had not known that Gwen Ifill had been stricken with cancer but had noticed and lamented her recent, continuing absence for the PBS Newshour and Washington Week. I assumed she was working on another assignment and felt surprised, given the magnitude of the election story. So it was a huge shock to learn that she had died. I have never before cried on hearing news of a journalist's death, but cry I did. And marvel at her courage in continuing to do her job while combating a mortal disease. She is irreplaceable, and will be grievously missed not only by Americans but by your neighbours too.
9
While we feel the sadness of Gwen's departure, I'm sorry for your bigger loss, Mr. Brooks. You were lucky enough to have known her as a colleague and a friend.The screen separated us from that intimacy. Yet we felt the warmth of her smile, her conviviality toward her colleagues and the joy for her work. She was a most professional journalist, and I'm sure many beginners benefited from her example and wisdom. My heart goes to you and her colleagues at The News Hour. That program will not be the same without her radiant presence.
6
Heartfelt piece, and although the loss of Gwen Ifill is so sad, I thank God for the professional person is was, and the influence she had on others. She set the bar high, and we are all better for that. We need to cherish those who seek truth and integrity in reporting news. I know we will need her guidance and exposure more than ever with this next administration. I hope more journalist are encouraged to step up to fill the need / chasm. Rest in Peace and Thanks You Dearly for your honesty, love and devotion to all that matters!
1
I watched the PBS News Hour last night and recommend it to anyone who is hurting about Gwen. She has moderated conversations for years. Last night, the conversations were about her. I missed her so much on election night. I will miss her brilliant insights and ability to bring forth the insights of others as we try to make sense of this moment in history. That smile! That talent and grace and generosity.
David, I'm sorry for your loss. You and Mark Shields and you and E.J. Dionne also have conversations that I treasure and look forward to every Friday. Thanks for sharing a few of your memories about Gwen.
David, I'm sorry for your loss. You and Mark Shields and you and E.J. Dionne also have conversations that I treasure and look forward to every Friday. Thanks for sharing a few of your memories about Gwen.
123
I always thought of Gwen Ifill as a reincarnation of Walter Cronkite, except that she did broadcast journalism dancing backwards and in heels.
199
Thank you for sharing your memories of Gwen Ifill. What a wonderful person! A lovely voice and a fantastic smile.
1
PBS should replace her with journalist Donna Barzil!
1
David,
Nice tribute to her.
I am a Washington Week in Review junkie because of Gwen.
Her intelligence, her skill, her credibility and her grace!
It's not fair and yes, America has lost its way for the moment.
I fear for the republic.....
Nice tribute to her.
I am a Washington Week in Review junkie because of Gwen.
Her intelligence, her skill, her credibility and her grace!
It's not fair and yes, America has lost its way for the moment.
I fear for the republic.....
5
I don't often agree with Mr. Brooks' take on political issues. But this tribute to Gwen Iffel is beautiful, humane, and eloquent. Perhaps the best thing you have ever written, sir.
5
David your post said all the things I have been thinking since I heard of Gwen's passing. I never met her like you, but somehow felt she was someone I knew and enjoyed knowing. It is a testament to her love of what she did that she worked so hard to NOT let us her fans know that she was slipping away from us and the end was near.
Like you I will miss her, miss that smile, her probing niceness, and that wonderful voice. I only wish she had let us know so we could have let her know just how much she meant to us.
Like you I will miss her, miss that smile, her probing niceness, and that wonderful voice. I only wish she had let us know so we could have let her know just how much she meant to us.
3
Gwen brought a quiet sanity and decency to news reporting. Something that is very hard to find today.
7
Your loss, and our loss. Such a class act. Such a role model. I will miss her when I watch the news every night. I have to say, even though she was younger than I am, I looked up to her. Her poignant questions, her cool head, her laugh, she will be sorely missed by me. Safe journey Ms Ifill, where you go, I hope to follow.
4
Thank you for this outstanding tribute to Gwen Ifill. I have tears in my eyes and only regret I did not know her personally.
4
Gwen's loss means all of us will have to walk a little taller, and our shoulders will have to be a little wider. To take on the weight she so ably carried for all of us.
God speed, Gwen.
God speed, Gwen.
3
Gwen Ifill gave me hope. She was a shining light of purity and excellence in journalism. She exuded a love for her profession that seemed infectious to those around her. We need more people like Gwen in this world.
78
Mr. Brooks, sir, the one thing I most admired and liked about Gwen Ifill was that she would face up to the truth, no matter what. She's one of the few people I've ever heard who admitted that being African-American and female (a "two-fer" in her words) had helped her get hired over more qualified journalists a couple of times. Ordinarily, just about anyone would go through all kinds of verbal contortions to keep from owning up to that. But Ms. Ifill had too much integrity to avoid facing even difficult truths, that might fly in the face of more "politically correct" ides.
She was a great one, and will be missed.
She was a great one, and will be missed.
1
A class act. An excellent journalist and a nice person. My condolences to her family and friends for this tragic loss.
1
I love Geen. She was one classy lady.
I remember a few years ago there was flack over a radio host (cannot remember his name, and need not either) comments about a black gurls sports accomplishmens. They were very derogatory. She did not comment publically until other media members started to defend him In her own suttle but strong way she questioned the appropriateness of the defence of such language without condemning the speaker or his defenders.
We still need her especially now.
I remember a few years ago there was flack over a radio host (cannot remember his name, and need not either) comments about a black gurls sports accomplishmens. They were very derogatory. She did not comment publically until other media members started to defend him In her own suttle but strong way she questioned the appropriateness of the defence of such language without condemning the speaker or his defenders.
We still need her especially now.
3
Thank you, Mr. Brooks, for your moving tribute to Gwen Ifill. Her intelligence and integrity were outstanding, and I hope that someone can organize a fund to create a course in journalistic integrity in her name and in her honor. Her career was inspirational, and set an example of what good journalism should be.
1
My wife and I were very saddened by the passing of Gwen Ifill. She was a rare class act with great presentation. Gwen was truly a blessed person and we were blessed by her presence. She had that rock steady reassuring conversation, which she finnished off with that beautiful smile.
The loss of such a beloved friend and colleague must have made this very difficult to write. Ms. Ifill was fortunate to have earned your profound reverence and admiration, Mr. Brooks. Thank you for sharing this.
1
I did not know Gwen Ifill personally but I do know her from following her career through the years. I feel as though I have a lost a close family member. She was one year younger than my brother and she died 9 years almost to day of my only sister.
Thank you for making this terrible loss hit home, Mr. Brooks. I'm 32 and grew up outside of D.C.. I recall seeing Gwen on t.v. in the evenings early on in my life, and began watching her earnestly once I started taking an interest in the real world. She offered us listeners journalistic legitimacy, and the knowledge that talent and decency can succeed in broadcasting. Let's not allow her life's work to be in vane. Thankfully, we know she is in a better place now. My deepest condolences.
1
An exceptional person with a pure heart is hard to find but Gwen Ifill seemed to be a person like that. She made people like her just by being not just a good broadcast journalist but by seeming to be a good person at the same time.
My tears are flowing after reading your beautiful tribute and all of the beautiful responses from people around the country. I will deeply miss her. Her example will give me courage to face the grim days ahead.
4
I admired her tremendously. I enjoyed her work and her personality — especially on Washington Week. I never knew her personally, of course, but she was one of the bright, good things in my life. With the Trump night descending on us now, the cheer and hope she radiated will be missed.
3
She will be missed. She is a woman who most people respected. My sympathy goes out to her family. It's a sad day in America. We lost one our best journalist.
1
From Florence Italy: I appreciate David Brooks' salute to the wonderful Gwen. She will be sorely missed but her memory and especially her accomplishments will inspire other
fair minded people to keep up her good works.
fair minded people to keep up her good works.
Thank you so much for your thoughts on the life of Gwen Ifill. It is overwhelmingly sad that she was taken at a time with such terrible strife. She was a calm and peaceful presence under all circumstances. Heaven has definitely gained a wonderful soul and we have lost such a kind, generous and authentic person. Eternal peace to Gwen and my condolences to Gwen's family and friends.
I was saddened by the news of Ms. Ifill's death. I always liked her. As a physician, I immediately wondered if disease could have been cured. I fight death for a living, until the patient is too sick and then death is my partner. I heard that Ms. Ifill died of endometrial cancer, which, like many cancers, is very treatable if diagnosed early. The five year survival rate for Stage I disease is 80-90%. I wonder if Ms. Ifill had symptoms for many months before she sought medical attention. Delaying seeing a doctor is still common in the African American population (and some others). To be honest, it makes me angry.
3
Beyond sad and so frightening a loss at a time when we needed her calm directness so badly. Thank you David for your words. I think you are also a calm voice and can help ameliorate some of the pain we feel by continuing on with your own insights and observations that I've come to rely on.
3
Thank you for the brilliant commentary about the life and times of Gwenn Ifill.
To keep her spirit alive, we all must be strong and vigilant in the face of the despot named Trump. Don't throw up - just continue to expose Trump, Banon. And the whole collection of fools who would tear up the Constituion.
To keep her spirit alive, we all must be strong and vigilant in the face of the despot named Trump. Don't throw up - just continue to expose Trump, Banon. And the whole collection of fools who would tear up the Constituion.
1
She was exceptionally grounded as a journalist and a person.
Her excellence as a TV journalist owed a lot to her start as a print journalist, akin to the start of Cronkite, Huntley, Brinkley, and others who entered TV journalism in its first decades.
The trust she engendered maybe owed a lot to family and deep faith.
I think of her as a visibly joyful Cronkite.
Her excellence as a TV journalist owed a lot to her start as a print journalist, akin to the start of Cronkite, Huntley, Brinkley, and others who entered TV journalism in its first decades.
The trust she engendered maybe owed a lot to family and deep faith.
I think of her as a visibly joyful Cronkite.
3
Thanks, David. Unfortunately for some of us in journalism and other forms of our craft, we can only appreciate tributes like yours anonymously to a person as so many here have had once and only brief personal encounters. All that I recall of her is that Gwen Ifill and I, one Fall evening, shared a common interest in a rising black conservative on a media bus decades ago to hear him speak at a college. And we discussed his political prospects seated next to one another on the bus ride from our different backgrounds, political as well as personal. Although I was never in her professional or personal circle of contacts or friends, I consider her passing at a relatively young age a great loss to American journalism. My deepest condolences to you and others who also mourn her.
Gwen Ifill was a class act in a city that desperately needs class acts. It's rare these days to find an intelligent journalist who can provide even-handed, respectful news reporting without making it all about themselves and their outsized egos. The PBS Newshour was the only program I trusted during this election debacle and we will sorely miss Gwen as we endure four years of Trumpmania. Rest in peace, Gwen - a new light in heaven.
2
What a wonderful column for the memory of a wonderful person.
I worked with Gwen Ifill at the Boston Herald and Evening Sun in Baltimore in the early 1980s. I went to Reuters for 24 years in New York, London, Berlin and Hong Kong, she went to the Washington Post, New York Times and PBS. David's tribute reflects the mature Gwen. I knew the young, just starting out Gwen. All the elements he mentions were there - she was ambitious but in the quietest way. As a young black woman reporter, in the gritty South End newsroom of the Herald, she stood out from the old-time mostly white, male street reporters who smoked up a storm, had an occasional bottle in their desk drawer and often phoned in their stories to dictate to rewrite men typing notes with a phone crooked in their neck and cigarette ash burning and it fell and they would light another. She was quiet and persistent, covering the tail end of the forced busing crisis in Boston. I never asked her how she felt then covering a racially divided city for the more conservative Herald than the more liberal Globe. She possessed a broad grasp of social issues, her comments about daily events ran deeper than the traditional "spot news" instincts of a street reporter. She was warm, shy and soft-spoken. A year or two later, when she joined me and Rick Berke as newcomers to the Evening Sun, we all relished the broader tableau of national and social issues resonating in the same newsroom where columnist H L Mencken said journalists ride and deride the world. I am stunned by her loss.
127
Amen. We will miss you, Gwen.
4
Thank you David. Your comments have allowed pent-up tears to flow - for Gwen, for our country, for the planet. What a beautiful lady.
16
A very nice tribute---a bit of a stylistic departure making it all the more beautiful and heart felt. Thank you.
8
We are all redeemable, David. Even Bannon. You never know. If "Amazing Grace" can save a slave trader, we've all got a chance at redemption.
I don't think Gwen would have publicly used your "vomiting" response, either.
Fill the chasm she left behind. Do what you can for our collective betterment and drop the puke comments.
"Amazing grace, how sweet the sound
That saved a wretch like me.
I once was lost, but now I'm found.
Was blind, but now I see."
I don't think Gwen would have publicly used your "vomiting" response, either.
Fill the chasm she left behind. Do what you can for our collective betterment and drop the puke comments.
"Amazing grace, how sweet the sound
That saved a wretch like me.
I once was lost, but now I'm found.
Was blind, but now I see."
1
Gwen was the real deal.
Hug.
Hug.
5
Thanks, David. I didn't have to read very far before I knew this was going to be a great column.
6
This is a wonderful piece to read as we grieve the death of Gwen. Thank you. My sympathies to you on the loss of your friend and colleague.
6
David, you were so fortunate to have worked with her.
I agree with your quote about Johnson. There is no tendency to fill the gap she has left behind, and that is only affirmed by the appallingly inept attempts to fill the gap left by the loss of her good friend Tim Russert.
I agree with your quote about Johnson. There is no tendency to fill the gap she has left behind, and that is only affirmed by the appallingly inept attempts to fill the gap left by the loss of her good friend Tim Russert.
4
My big manly husband was misty eyed last night as Judy Woodruff and Harry Srinavasana said goodbye. If young journalists want a role model, they cannot do better than to look to this lovely, smart, good woman.
I love you and Mark Sheilds, too, and I am always disappointed when there is a stand-in for either of you.
We misunderstand each other and we demonize and we--to use your word--"flatten" and reduce. Thank you for adding dimensions. This lovely woman left a space in the world.
I love you and Mark Sheilds, too, and I am always disappointed when there is a stand-in for either of you.
We misunderstand each other and we demonize and we--to use your word--"flatten" and reduce. Thank you for adding dimensions. This lovely woman left a space in the world.
17
You can honor her best, David, by following her example. Be, first and foremost, an outstanding journalist. Report the truth, unvarnished. Here you are writing in the Opinion section, and are free to have your interpretations, with which others may disagree; but when you provide news, make sure you provide it with the kind of integrity that would have merited Gwen Ifill's approval.
6
Doesn't David Brooks ALWAYS write in the "Opinion" section of the Times? I think of him as a regular columnist, presenting opinions, not as a reporter. Opinion writers try, with mixed success, to support their opinions with facts, but that doesn't mean they're "reporting" those facts. Other writers do that, not Brooks, and I think most readers understand that.
Lovely. I wish I had watched her more often. I knew she was a good journalist, but I didn't realize she was also a good person. May she RIP
A great column honoring a wonderful and irreplaceable colleague. Many thanks.
4
Wonderful tribute.
7
This is just wonderful. Thank you for helping me get through the loss of Ms. Ifill, which was a hard, hard blow on top of the election.
8
My heart feels the same as it did when Tim Russert died. And I didn't realize I loved Gwen Ifill as much as Russert. Glad I know now. I'll miss her unbiased reporting and her glow on my screen. God bless you Gwen Ifill.
6
A lovely tribute. Thank you for writing this kind remembrance. Now, what do you have to say about your refusal to get off the fence and advocate for Mrs. Clinton during the election? You should have. Your failure contributed to Mr. Trump's election. Live with that even as you mourn Ms. Ifill.
5
Considering the present situation here in the US it feels like God told Gwen "You have given it your all, time to come home."
9
Thank thank you Dave, for enlightening us on Gwen's spiritual foundation. Now I know where that smile came from. My heart is broken, but it's better to have known and lost Gwen than never to have known her at all.
9
Bravo, David Brooks. A wonderful tribute to this wonderful journalist, Gwen Ifill.
11
Thanks for the tribute to Gwen. Leonard Cohen, Leon Russell & Gwen Ifill all passed away in the past week - the version that they would do of "Amazing Grace", sitting around a piano together - that'd be something!
14
I've isolated myself from much of the news since last week's election. But when I heard about Gwen's passing, I made sure to check the NYT this morning to see if David had written about her for his Tuesday's column. Fortunately he did, and it's reassuring to me to know that good people are still cherished and their work celebrated.
11
A very sweet tribute, but I have to quibble, Mr. Brooks, with your use of the word "totalistic" to describe Gwen's smile. I have no idea what you meant to convey but the word totalistic doesn't have anything to do with Gwen Ifll so far as I can fathom.
1
I loved this Brooks column because I, too, loved Gwen Ifill and feel great sorrow at her passing far too soon. I also loved this column because Brooks minces no words. Many of us feel like throwing up at seeing Bannon's photo. He always appears in need of a shower. His appearance and his writing match perfectly.
12
Your column often makes me mad, and it makes me think. But this is the first time it has made me cry.
It was all to evident how much you and the rest of the team at Newshour cared for Gwen. We are all better for having known her in any capacity.
I too, saw her face under Bannon's yesterday and was incensed. Thank you for addressing that with the emotion it deserved.
And thank you for honoring Ms. Gwen with the grace she deserved.
It was all to evident how much you and the rest of the team at Newshour cared for Gwen. We are all better for having known her in any capacity.
I too, saw her face under Bannon's yesterday and was incensed. Thank you for addressing that with the emotion it deserved.
And thank you for honoring Ms. Gwen with the grace she deserved.
20
Thanks, David, for this beautiful remembrance. I cannot believe she is gone. She made me think everything, no matter how bad the news, was going to be all right.
92
Watching Gwen on Washington Week was a weekly must for me and my husband of four years quickly fell into my pattern. We both missed her when she was away and we are so saddened by her death. Thank you, David, for your column about her. In addition to Monday's NewsHour it helped ease the pain of her passing -- as did her Oct. 7 column. Thank you, Gwen, for your wonderful programs and smile, which did come through on TV!
1
And, yet Mr. Brooks, in writing of Gwen Ifill with tenderness, you reminded me of an empress and her smile, a teacher of life, on retiring from the international community, she asked for my help to put into words a farewell to her colleagues.
It is important, she added, to include in the above, a sentence that it is with regret if I have ever injured a party, or been the cause of an adverse impact on another. 'What!' I wrote back, 'you are the least likely candidate in the midst of all our children's international community to have hurt anyone anywhere, I do not understand'.
It is the custom of my country, she replied. 'All right, but keep in mind that it may be a first for the Americans among us', and off went a draft for her revisions and review. Far away she is now, safe and settling back at home after decades of living in America where her grown family, all college grads on scholarship, hard at work, is on the road to success with an ongoing love for our Country.
I miss her smile, the most beautiful one I have seen, I used to stare at her with appreciation, she continues to bring out the best in me. The days when there was a storm brewing in the Office, her high cheek-bones slightly pink. 'Can you not pray, can you not watch the news?', she once asked 'only through your eyes' was my reply 'because I find your views broader and brighter'.
Remembering Gwen, Mr. Brooks, if you listen carefully, you may still hear her asking 'how are you, dear friend?'.
It is important, she added, to include in the above, a sentence that it is with regret if I have ever injured a party, or been the cause of an adverse impact on another. 'What!' I wrote back, 'you are the least likely candidate in the midst of all our children's international community to have hurt anyone anywhere, I do not understand'.
It is the custom of my country, she replied. 'All right, but keep in mind that it may be a first for the Americans among us', and off went a draft for her revisions and review. Far away she is now, safe and settling back at home after decades of living in America where her grown family, all college grads on scholarship, hard at work, is on the road to success with an ongoing love for our Country.
I miss her smile, the most beautiful one I have seen, I used to stare at her with appreciation, she continues to bring out the best in me. The days when there was a storm brewing in the Office, her high cheek-bones slightly pink. 'Can you not pray, can you not watch the news?', she once asked 'only through your eyes' was my reply 'because I find your views broader and brighter'.
Remembering Gwen, Mr. Brooks, if you listen carefully, you may still hear her asking 'how are you, dear friend?'.
2
What a beautiful tribute to a truly beautiful lady. I will miss seeing her beautiful smile on the news hour and Washington week
Thank you, Mr. Brooks for such a lovely piece. I must wonder where all the hundreds of commenters of the last few weeks have gone. Your columns attracted so many people who truly believe that the world wants to register every thought that comes into their heads. At last count you only had 97 comments. What a shame! Perhaps they don't know who Gwen Ifill is. Pity
Thank you, Mr. Brooks for such a lovely piece. I must wonder where all the hundreds of commenters of the last few weeks have gone. Your columns attracted so many people who truly believe that the world wants to register every thought that comes into their heads. At last count you only had 97 comments. What a shame! Perhaps they don't know who Gwen Ifill is. Pity
In our house, we are avid readers of the written press, including Brooks' column. We rarely watch TV. Gwen's "Washington Week" and "PBS Newshour" were exceptions to that. We loved to hear and see Gwen address the grave problems of our political system with a smile, which left us with hope. We were shocked and saddened at her death. It felt very personal.
Dear Gwen rest in peace.
Dear Gwen rest in peace.
8
Beautiful beautiful thanks for sharing.
4
Thank you, David. These are difficult times. We have lost so much.
5
Thank you, David, for a wonderful and personal tribute to Gwen Ifill. I am so sad about her death. I have spent countless Friday nights watching the News Hour and Washington Week - an oasis of civility and of deep-dive analysis of the news. I had the privilege once to attend the News Hour live at AMU in 2007. Gwen roamed the aisles exuding courage and warmth. There was a heckler there eventually removed by security. But Gwen kept going and seemed to be moving to protect the audience as well if something untoward were to happen. She was just terrific and I will miss her every Friday night.
1
Thank you David Brooks for so eloquently saying what many of us are feeling. Gwen Ifill was one of the best ever. And your reaction to the juxtaposition of articles about her death and Bannon's appointment was harmed be me and many others as well.
2
David,
Thank you for your rich and thoughtful thoughts, an insiders view of a great mind and heart of Gwen Ifill. I am sorry for your loss, then as you said so elegantly, her passing is a loss for all of us. Personally, she was a hero of mine. I had a dream once - I was at a great awards dinner, filled with Hollywood celebrities, yet I had no interest in talking with them really. I had nothing to say. Then I looked across the room and saw Gwen. I lit up, bolted right over, words flowing out of my mouth before I even got to her. To me, she was the celebrity. I think you are right in your assessment - she will never be replaced. So I will take her advice, as did you, and I'll just keep on writing.
Thank you for your rich and thoughtful thoughts, an insiders view of a great mind and heart of Gwen Ifill. I am sorry for your loss, then as you said so elegantly, her passing is a loss for all of us. Personally, she was a hero of mine. I had a dream once - I was at a great awards dinner, filled with Hollywood celebrities, yet I had no interest in talking with them really. I had nothing to say. Then I looked across the room and saw Gwen. I lit up, bolted right over, words flowing out of my mouth before I even got to her. To me, she was the celebrity. I think you are right in your assessment - she will never be replaced. So I will take her advice, as did you, and I'll just keep on writing.
I have always admired Ms. Ifill and will miss her voice. Thank you for this moving tribute.
4
Thank you David,
We have lost an awful lot this week. I will take the cover off the mirror tomorrow.
David many of us will understand if you are unable to look in the mirror for a much longer time.
This is a time for thinking about what is gone.
We have lost an awful lot this week. I will take the cover off the mirror tomorrow.
David many of us will understand if you are unable to look in the mirror for a much longer time.
This is a time for thinking about what is gone.
5
That was a lovely tribute and I don't mean to be churlish, but why would you call her African American? Her parents were born in Barbados and Panama, from what I've read. Is that term applied to anyone of dark skin whose ancestors, at some point, came to the Americas from Africa? It just seems like a strange thing. If her parents had been born in France would you have used that term as well? I also saw it in the Washington Post, so it makes me curious. I'm not Portuguese American, or even European American, even though that's where my ancestors came from originally.
1
My mom called people like Gwen, "fixtures - permanent fixtures". Hard to lose good people.
4
Thank you for a wonderful column. I am so sorry for your loss, and for our collective loss of this human being we were all privileged to have beamed into our homes. She brightened all our days.
2
Watching the Nightly News last night I saw the content of Gwen Ifill's character revealed in the faces (and tears) of her colleagues.
6
Thank you, David Brooks, for giving us glimpses of the Gwen we didn't know to add to the picture of the Gwen we did know from her wonderful work. You bring tears to my eyes. We miss her.
I hope her family knows how much she was admired and will be missed.
My deep condolences.
I hope her family knows how much she was admired and will be missed.
My deep condolences.
6
I enjoyed watching her on PBS. She was even handed about what was being discussed on her show and you never knew what her political leanings were. Her show (and her) was really fair and balanced. She will be missed.
1
"But I confess, when I looked at the front of The Times website on Monday and saw a photo of Stephen K. Bannon, on leave from Breitbart as chairman and rising in power, and then underneath it a photo of Gwen, who is passing from this world, I wanted to throw up. This is not progress and this is not good news."
Thanks David, you nailed it.
Thanks David, you nailed it.
9
I didn't know Ms Ifill, but gosh, I loved her. Her intelligence, her wit, her warmth, her smile. I wept when I heard this news yesterday. What a terrible loss at a time when we need her. My condolences to her family and everybody who knew her and are feeling this devastating loss so personally.
4
As so many others I only "knew" Gwen Ifill in her capacity as journalist. I so enjoyed watching the News Hour and Washington Week when she was the host. I've always imagined her to be a lovely person off camera, and it is both gratifying and sad to read all the tributes that verify this. The next four years stretching out before us are dismal indeed and her journalistic skills, her professional demeanor, her ability to give a voice to women and people of color, her ability to help us to sort out the complexities of the world we live in, and of course her radiant smile, will be deeply missed.
3
Thank you David. I was missing Gwen during this last part of the election and so worried about her health. I'm sure she wouldn't have wanted to miss it, and we sure missed her. Gwen was not just someone to emulate, I also knew she'd be a great friend.
I cried through the News Hour last night. This has been a devastating week and Gwen's death has left me heartbroken.
I cried through the News Hour last night. This has been a devastating week and Gwen's death has left me heartbroken.
7
Thank you for your warm expression of the dear person I too feel is a great loss to all who watched and listened to her over the years. I mourn.
7
Thank you for this thoughtful tribute. My wife and I looked forward every week to the segment of the PBS News Hour that features Brooks and Shields with Gwen Ifill and Judy Woodruff. We will miss her as part of that engaging conversation. We will miss all of her great journalistic contributions. And, as you so eloquently said, we will miss that wonderful smile.
94
Another light and voice of reason has gone out of the world. She will be sorely missed, especially in the dark days ahead.
2
"She was ambitious for quality" - this is all we ask of our media and political leaders, and so few rise to the occasion. A beautiful beacon - and one we must honor in our own thoughts, words and deed. Thank you for everything, Gwen.
2
Oh, Mr Brooks, I read your columns with such fervor and this one has moved me to tears. It's been a hard week--it seems like a year- and it ended in the death of a remarkable woman of journalism who embodied the best of America. I was always impressed with her calm demeanor and those bright eyes told you that she was catching every nuance. Thank you for this tribute. She should have been the first big picture in the news, but she would be the first to understand politics in America.
4
Gwen always maintained the highest journalistic standards. She was thorough, fair-minded, and honest. And when it mattered, courageous.
PBS Newshour is watched by just over a million viewers each evening. There are over 200 million Facebook users in the U.S. Facebook is the ultimate echo chamber. Too often what appears on one's feed is vile, dishonest, and unfair.
We are about to experience our first Twitter president, who is unbound by the high standards that guided Gwen's life. So America, which path is it?
PBS Newshour is watched by just over a million viewers each evening. There are over 200 million Facebook users in the U.S. Facebook is the ultimate echo chamber. Too often what appears on one's feed is vile, dishonest, and unfair.
We are about to experience our first Twitter president, who is unbound by the high standards that guided Gwen's life. So America, which path is it?
4
Sad, very sad. What sanity, levelheadedness, cheerfulness, courage, unflappability. I've never missed Washington Week through the years because I knew I could trust it as objective and sane—and I remember her, as a guest years ago on Wait Wait Don't Tell Me, singing. I don't remember what it was, but it was beautiful, and just another amazing thing about her.
1
I realize how heavy my heart is when I burst into tears upon hearing this sad news about Gwen.
Then to really confirm my despair, at a Chorale(!?!) practice a fellow tenor said he was glad she died because she was liberal. This is what it has come to. I was genuinely taken aback and told him so.
The floodgates are wide open with hate and T-rump saying "Stop it" is another really bad indicator of how he will "lead".
Bannon as Chief Strategist!?!...the bar has gone so low into longer is visible.
Very sad indeed.
Then to really confirm my despair, at a Chorale(!?!) practice a fellow tenor said he was glad she died because she was liberal. This is what it has come to. I was genuinely taken aback and told him so.
The floodgates are wide open with hate and T-rump saying "Stop it" is another really bad indicator of how he will "lead".
Bannon as Chief Strategist!?!...the bar has gone so low into longer is visible.
Very sad indeed.
2
This is such a beautiful piece of work. I think Gwen would be very much moved by it. Thank you.
1
Thank you, Mr. Brooks. One of the very finest people that we and the world have is gone. My wife and I wept as we watched the PBS Newshour tribute to Ms. Ifill last night. Along with millions of others, we offer our deepest sympathies to her family and friends.
3
Thank you for writing about Gwen. We were shocked and saddened by her death. We watch Washington Week regularly and have done so for years. She will be missed. Was wondering where she was recently. Was hoping she was on a trip or vacation. Not so. Now that I know the truth, I wanted to write PBS a sympathy note expressing sadness for the loss of their colleague and friend. Indirectly your appreciation has given me that opportunity. Gwen was an amazing woman and journalist. We will miss her.
2
Perhaps Gwen's good work could be carried on through a scholarship program established in her memory? Or, better yet, perhaps our nation's leading newspapers, PBS, NPR, the ALA, League of Women Voters, social media companies, and journalism schools might contribute to a clever, thoughtful national media lit program for adults and young adults that developed the skills & thinking Gwen valued: how to ask good questions and listen to answers; how to recognize persuasive techniques/rhetorical devices; how to dig up facts and fact check; how to identify fake news; how to follow an argument/discussion and organize data & information, etc. etc. (Perhaps using the effective short program "The 30-Second Candidate" on PBS several years ago as a model/example. Once you see something like that, you don't forget it.) I'll miss Gwen. I hope we can maintain what she held dear.
3
There was something in Gwen ifill that kept you glued to TV when she was on. You knew there will be straight talk and no non sense. If she ever belonged to any TV network she belonged to PBS where she knew there would be no pressure from anywhere.
One of the few journalist I will miss especially after seeing what went with the just finished campaign where journalist caved in.
One of the few journalist I will miss especially after seeing what went with the just finished campaign where journalist caved in.
2
I will miss Gwen Ifill very much. The News Hour and Washington Week will never be the same. I still miss Molly Ivins and now Gwen. The world just keeps getting sadder and sadder.
5
Such a lovely tribute. Thank you. We will all miss her presence, resolve and smile.
3
Gwen Ifill was the best. I will miss her terribly.
1
Thank you for this beautifully written piece in honor of Gwen Ifill. She was one of the journalists I deeply admired. I grieve over her passing. We need her so much at this point in or history. Again, deep thanks for the way you have captured her and her gifts.
5
It came as a news flash while I was reading another article. I could not hold back the tears. I've watched the PBS News Hour for so many years it seems as if everyone, and especially Gwen, was a friend. Mr. Brooks is so right about her smile as it always seemed to be directed just to the individuals watching her, it felt so warm and kind.
We lose the best and brightest and are left with the dross far too often.
We lose the best and brightest and are left with the dross far too often.
4
In our house, Gwen Ifill and David Brooks are two journalists we admire and respect to help us make sense of our world. After Gwen's death, I read many heartfelt tributes, most very moving and appreciated, but I awaited yours especially because I needed to read your thoughts the most. Thank you for sharing these thoughts about Gwen; it makes it a little easier to feel such a loss. My condolences to you.
5
Ms. Ifill was a totally class act in a world of pseudo journalists.
3
I'm not the crying type. But by the time I finished reading your thoughtful and moving article about the life and passing of Gwen Ifill, I had tears in my eyes.
Thank you, David Brooks. I don't always agree with what you have to say, but you were 100% right this one time.
We have lost a beacon of light and a champion for humanity, at a time when we need one the most.
Rest in Peace, Ms. Ifill.
Thank you, David Brooks. I don't always agree with what you have to say, but you were 100% right this one time.
We have lost a beacon of light and a champion for humanity, at a time when we need one the most.
Rest in Peace, Ms. Ifill.
7
Thank you, Mr. Brooks, for your beautiful tribute to your colleague Gwen Ifill. You have said precisely what so many of us are feeling on this sad day. Ms. Ifill was, without ever uttering a partisan word on the air, a voice of decency, reason, and, yes, good humor, in this deeply troubled time. She was irreplaceable, and, as so many other commenters have noted, she will be greatly missed. My condolences to her family and to you and her other colleagues.
8
I will miss Gwen. I watch the podcast everyday from Spain and on my travels around the world. Thanks for sharing!
38
David, I wonder if you would be willing (and able) to share some of those photos with all of us. Based on all the heartfelt responses to the announcement yesterday about Gwen Ifill's death as well as to your column today, clearly there are many, many of us who are missing her.
86
Like many of you, Gwen Ifill's passing is a shocking and bad moment; however, I am heartened to see Mr Brooks's tribute and many of the readers' concurrence. Because there are indeed common grounds. Just imagine, there are many Gwens out there, who can be right, left or in between. Yet, like this Gwen, they are also genuine people doing moderation and bringing people together, as she did on the NewsHour. We need to see people as they are, not just their political philosophy, past, future or present
Gwen was amazing. I looked forward to seeing her every evening next to Judy and to knowing that aside from the troubling clutter of a frustrating election's unchallenged lies and half-truths, I could count on Gwen's steady demeanor and penetrating reporting to help me feel back in the real world again.
We will miss you so Gwen Ifill, rest in peace.
We will miss you so Gwen Ifill, rest in peace.
3
I heard all sorts of "TMZ-ish" speculations about Gwen's absence. Off camera personal conflicts? Not likely. They all radiate respect for each other. A hard earned righteous refusal to inform us about yet another police murder of an unarmed African-American? I should have known better. This woman was a paragon of informed and informative professionalism. A better offer from Fox News? That is libelous.
There has to be a very special hereafter for the likes of Gwen, David Carr and Tim Russert. The world, as I've come to know it after 83 years here, has just
been hugely diminished. God! How she will be missed.
There has to be a very special hereafter for the likes of Gwen, David Carr and Tim Russert. The world, as I've come to know it after 83 years here, has just
been hugely diminished. God! How she will be missed.
1
Gwen Ifill was one of the most honest, good-natured person to report news. She had an altruistic streak and always tried to help her friends. She would go to great lengths, (unknown to those for whom she would do this for) to help someone who had helped her. Rare quality in any person. Thank you Gwen Ifill for being the person you were.
1
How heartening to read your tribute to the pricelessly humane, incandescently warm, and brilliant Gwen Ifill, but devastating to know with painful certainty that we will never see her again. I missed her dearly on the night of the election as I watched the Electoral College votes horrifyingly mount up for Trump. I wish she had not lived to see Hillary Clinton's defeat, but I am sure that her faith enabled her to surmount despair--the despair that millions of us are trying so hard to keep at bay.
3
Ifill's down to earth, centered and warm presence will be greatly missed by this ritualistic News Hour viewer. I do make an association between Ifill and Brooks. Both are likeable, first of all. And both care about journalism, truth, and good-naturedness. Her bright black eyes conveyed a great deal of information to me.
1
David, I look forward to reading your columns as well as enjoying - and learning from - your Friday conversations on the News Hour with Mr. Shields. But, oh, how I will miss Gwen. As a woman, I was so proud to be a part of hers and Judy's audience daily. Two dynamic women and an example of how two different races can joyfully work and live together, and be friends. She exemplified intelligence, professionalism, dedication, and, above all, strength and goodness of character. You pointed out the placement of the news of her passing close to that of Mr. Bannon's recent appointment. Do not fret. After all, it was accidentally a poignant reminder to us readers of the people who really count in this world and make a difference for the good of all.
4
How sad this loss. From what I had seen of her over the years, she consistently exhibited cool and class, and class is becoming ever a rarer thing in journalism, where barbie-dolls and gumps prevail. She had more grace, poise and professionalism than any ten figures from CNN put together. What a loss.
1
Let's start a drive to get more people to vote in our country, and let's name that drive for Gwen.
6
This year started out with such hope and it ends with such despair. Sic transit gloria mundi.
5
Gwen Ifill saw it coming as did others. Racists, not exactly dormant but subdued with the election of Barack Obama in 2008, began to rise again in 2012. Leading the way was Donald J. Trump, chief spokesman for the “birther” movement. Behind the curtain were the right nationalists with their racist, nativist, misogynist, back-to-the-good-old-days, make-America-great-again views.
Trump is not Hitler redux. He lacks the discipline, the ideology and uniformed band of brown shirted thugs that loved to march. But make no mistake “the bitch is in heat again,” as Brecht wrote at the end of “Arturo Ui” his compelling play about the rise and fall of Adolph Hitler.
We are seeing in this sad and stunning election the rise of fascism in the United States. Hitler also failed to reach an electoral majority of voters in 1933, but just as Trump did after losing the popular vote to Hillary Clinton with the Electoral College he was given the power to form a government. Hitler lost no time in forming a Nazi government, starting with Goebbels his Minister of Propaganda. Does it sound familiar Mr. Bannon.
Are we that naïve that we are surprised that Trump is filling the White House with small men in search of a balcony, as Jimmy Breslin once described Rudolph Giuliani. The young people marching all over the Unites States and chanting that they do not accept the President elect, may have the right idea. Resistance is the only answer.
Trump is not Hitler redux. He lacks the discipline, the ideology and uniformed band of brown shirted thugs that loved to march. But make no mistake “the bitch is in heat again,” as Brecht wrote at the end of “Arturo Ui” his compelling play about the rise and fall of Adolph Hitler.
We are seeing in this sad and stunning election the rise of fascism in the United States. Hitler also failed to reach an electoral majority of voters in 1933, but just as Trump did after losing the popular vote to Hillary Clinton with the Electoral College he was given the power to form a government. Hitler lost no time in forming a Nazi government, starting with Goebbels his Minister of Propaganda. Does it sound familiar Mr. Bannon.
Are we that naïve that we are surprised that Trump is filling the White House with small men in search of a balcony, as Jimmy Breslin once described Rudolph Giuliani. The young people marching all over the Unites States and chanting that they do not accept the President elect, may have the right idea. Resistance is the only answer.
4
What a tribute, David. It was like a punch in the gut to learn this news yesterday. It's interesting how someone I've never met but have watched for decades could indirectly have such an impact on my life. What a shame I didn't fully realize this until Gwen was gone. The only thing I could compare this to would be when Tim Russert unexpectedly passed in 2008. I was concerned about her absence on the third debate night and then when she was missing in the days before the election and on election night I knew something was terribly wrong. I had been scouring the internet looking for information but could find none. Not a surprise to me at all that she would keep this private matter just that, private. The NewsHour and Washington Week have always been a haven for me when I can't take one more second of the partisan screaming and talking head panels. NewsHour will continue in the very capable hands of Judy Woodruff and I'm sure Washington Week will too, but what I wouldn't give to have just one more Friday evening for Gwen to try and make sense of this new political reality. Even if she couldn't make sense of it, she would sign off and rest assured be back at it again next week. What a loss.
2
I was shocked and saddened to hear of Ms. Ifills passing, piling on to the dark outcomes of this election. To this reader, your writing and insight in this matter are at their best. I, among many, will miss her wonderful smile and strength.
Brook's warm tribute allows those of us who didn't know Gwen personally a glimpse of the kind of strong connections she maintained with her colleagues. She has been a part of my life because the NewsHour is a regular part of my evening every night and I don't know what I will do without seeing Gwen or hearing her unique insight on a regular basis. Especially poignant is Brook's comment regarding the NYTimes photograph of Bannon with that of Gwen below. A stark reminder of how painful this low point in our history will be, especially since Gwen will not be there to help us make sense of it.
2
Thank you for this. Seeing the news that Gwen Ifill had passed amidst the news of the rise of Trump makes me ill too. I don't recognize the world we live in and we've lost one of the calm, intelligent, steady voice who worked to help us make sense of our world.
What will we do without Gwen Ifill? I think her colleagues should vow to carry on in her memory. Put aside the flash and graphics and start doing your jobs. The success of Donald Trump is due to a failure of the news media. Intelligent voices like Ms. Ifill got drowned out in the madness and now look where we are.
Rest in peace, Gwen. You will be sorely missed.
What will we do without Gwen Ifill? I think her colleagues should vow to carry on in her memory. Put aside the flash and graphics and start doing your jobs. The success of Donald Trump is due to a failure of the news media. Intelligent voices like Ms. Ifill got drowned out in the madness and now look where we are.
Rest in peace, Gwen. You will be sorely missed.
1
We so desperately need stories like this to give us a true perspective on what is important in life. We are definitely a lost nation. What struck me most about David's article was the fact that Gwen kept in touch frequently through just short little e-mails. Knowing that a friend is thinking of you has an amazing impact on one's day. I wish more people would follow her example, keep in touch, only if it is to share a story, send a photo or just a warm greeting. It's a hug in this new world.
1
Thank you, David. I often thought of the people I truly respect as human beings in addition to their craft, Gwen topped the list. She truly had that "it" quality to connect with me and so many others on what it is like to be in the presence of a well-rounded person.
What a lovely tribute to a friend. One more light gone from the world, which is becoming a dark place indeed. The juxtaposition of Gwen Ifill's photograph with that of Steven Bannon's was grotesque.
Thank you David for this column today. Gwen was a fighter and so should we be. We cannot give up. We cannot let the dark forces overtake this country. It will take all of us on the right and left who value decency working together to be a stalwart force against the evil to come.
Thank you David for this column today. Gwen was a fighter and so should we be. We cannot give up. We cannot let the dark forces overtake this country. It will take all of us on the right and left who value decency working together to be a stalwart force against the evil to come.
3
It isn't normal for me to grieve for people I only know from television, but I find myself doing just that for Gwen. Along the way, I noticed her absences and tried to see if she was doing ok. It is a tribute to her friends and colleagues that there was almost no information available, they protected her privacy like only close friends do.
I wonder about her mental state on the night of the election. Was she able to understand the result? Was she better off not knowing? At first I thought she would have been better off not, but then I realized that this was Gwen Ifill, and she would have wanted every detail even at the very end.
She will be missed.
I wonder about her mental state on the night of the election. Was she able to understand the result? Was she better off not knowing? At first I thought she would have been better off not, but then I realized that this was Gwen Ifill, and she would have wanted every detail even at the very end.
She will be missed.
4
I agree with your statement about wanting to throw up when seeing that the passing of Gwen Ifill was not given priority over a professional creep.
I remember hearing a particular nightly news broadcast mention Ms. Ifill then immediately turn to news of the President-elect and saying to myself "Don't even start." That guy, and really, none of those guys, belong in the same sentence with her let alone sharing a front page.
Is this real life?
I remember hearing a particular nightly news broadcast mention Ms. Ifill then immediately turn to news of the President-elect and saying to myself "Don't even start." That guy, and really, none of those guys, belong in the same sentence with her let alone sharing a front page.
Is this real life?
3
Thank you so much for this. Between this and last night's Newshour where grown men cried, it has helped me mourn this huge loss. She was a woman of prayer and I believe the light that shone through her was a result of her deep personal faith. There is no doubt in my mind that she is still busy and will watch out for our democracy as well as all the up and coming women in journalism she mentored over the years. God bless Gwen and may God grant her eternal rest.
4
In honor and memory of Gwen Ifill and in a week that has seen Bannon rise to a position in the White House, I have made a donation to the NAACP Legal Defense Fund, directed by Gwen's cousin. We need to take strong and steady action now.
278
Thanks for the idea. I will be doing so in her honor as well.
4
For once we agree on something, Mr. Brooks. Ms. Ifill's loss is a shock to the system in more ways than one. To say she'll be missed constitutes an understatement.
6
David, I watched you, Gwen, Judy, Mark Shields, and Amy Walter do analysis after the first presidential debate this year. It was fascinating and thought provoking - the best post-debate analysis hands down. She was an excellent moderator, and a whip smart journalist who will be sorely missed. What an honor it must've been to have worked with her. I appreciated your heartfelt tribute
7
I cried yesterday when I read of her death just as I am crying now. She is sorely missed. There is no one who can fill her shoes. May she rest in peace.
3
Stunning piece Mr. Brooks! A tragic loss for us all to loose such a beacon, a steadfast extraordinary listener, reporter, and commentator. My wife and I both gasped when we heard that Gwen had passed. Your words are most helpful, but also remind us so clearly of what and who we lost this week. Thank you from all of us.
5
When I heard the news last evening from my wife, I was stopped cold at the dinner table. Gwen was the ultimate in class, sincerity, insight and honesty. I never knew her, but I felt like she was a friend whom you could trust immediately. People with deep and good character like that cannot be replaced.
6
I've taken Gwen Ifill for granted it feels like forever. When did she start with the Newshour... it seems as if she was always there. I remember vaguely wondering about the visual incongruence - other than Judy Woodruff, she always seems to be surrounded by a sea of white male faces. Always broadly smiling faces. Your tribute here and so many others have filled in the gaps, and I now see the true rare brilliance of this woman. I thank you for that, agree with every word you wrote. There is just no one like her - and it is those people one takes for granted. I will try harder.
5
Rest in blessed peace Gwen Ifill - taken far too soon from our sight and sound on PBS. An unforgettable newswoman who brought grace to all of us who watched her for decades on PBS. David Brooks, there is a woman who has the singular grace of Gwen, but who was badly treated by CNN during the ghastly presidential debate season just passed - Donna Brazile. Donna Brazile deserves laurels for her work for the Democratic Party and for Georgetown University. She rose from Kenner, Louisiana, to the heights of Democratic politics and deserves honours and praise for her decades working for Al Gore's and Barack Obama's and Hillary Clinton's elections. Both Al Gore and Hillary Clinton won the popular vote, but alas, the Electoral College of 1846, an awful amendment in the Constitution that wisely should be repealed, gave the election to Donald Trump, and whomever he chooses for his cabinet and whom - anointed - will run his administration for him. Gwen Ifill earned the sweetest rest with amazing grace.
3
Thanks for these beautiful reflections. I always trusted in her as a newsperson and admired the job she did, and the personal side you've shown just adds to my respect for her.
Yes, our world is filled with the great and beautiful and also with the low and awful.
Yes, our world is filled with the great and beautiful and also with the low and awful.
In this saddest of weeks, this is the final blow. Recovery will take some time.
9
David, you are so on point.She overcame tremendous odds by being true to herself, authentic ,generous and respectful of others.She consequently won the respect and admiration of the Country.Few thinking Americans thought of her as black of female, she was simply regarded as a talent and role model.It is a shame we don't have many more people in public life like her.
2
Democracy requires journalists like Gwen Ifill. She will be missed, especially today.
6
Thank you for your very personal remembrance of Gwen Ifill. I didn't know her but felt that I did. It was that global smile of course and her unrelenting optimism. She was darned funny too and there were times when I wondered how she got away with it on screen. But that was part of her too. It's a terrible blow to loose her at all, but following immediately Trump's election, it feels like we've walked through a door to another country where stars that bright no longer shine. I will miss her greatly. Thanks again for your words.
6
A great tribute to a great lady, David.
I guess most of us just knew instinctively that there is no one that can take her place.
I guess most of us just knew instinctively that there is no one that can take her place.
6
From your Nov. 4th The Banality of Change - (the comments section there is closed) seems sea gulls can play billiards. Maybe speaking with the 40's looks 70 gentleman rather than speaking to him would be educational for you both.
Nice piece for Ms. Ifill, sorry for your loss.
Nice piece for Ms. Ifill, sorry for your loss.
The good die young and the evil live too long, but the amazing grace is that in the end, all through the history of humanity, good overcomes evil and is the victor. I was there when she took over Washington Week and that was the end of a usual turnover for that position. It spoke to her talent and hard work. Every profession needs a Gwen to keep the bar high. And they are always remembered. CNN and FOX have a lot to learn from her!
4
I spent many years appreciating and, yes, befriending, Gwen Ifill in her roles on McNeil/Leher cum News Hour and Washington Week. Her smile was disarming and lit up the studio whenever she flashed it. She had poise, class, civility and warmth. She knew the questions to ask and when to ask them. Thank you, David Brooks, for a beautiful eulogy. I'm going to miss her big time.
5
With the passing of Gwen Ifill, the world lost a giant which we desperately needed. Regardless of your political views, she was a powerful force with her reporting and an inspiration to all who followed her career. She will be hard to replace and impossible not to miss. You will be missed, Gwen.
4
A beautiful tribute to a joyous and special lady.
I have a special admiration for great people who didn't have the world dropped in their lap. They bring qualities like humanity and compassion to the top.
I have a special admiration for great people who didn't have the world dropped in their lap. They bring qualities like humanity and compassion to the top.
5
Ms. Ifill was the model of "going high." Throughout this very ugly campaign, I would watch PBS, just to see Ms. Ifill bring all of us up from the lows we had experienced in the past week. Tragically, with Trump's first appointments, his belief, that going low wins, is in full view.
7
One hell of a woman with her grace, class and scintillating brilliance. Would have loved to claim her as a pal.
2
We should remember Gwen as the epitome of the American ideal. Nothing she had was given to her without dogged hard work. She likely did not get things others would have gotten with one tenth the work, She held herself to the highest standards of generosity, supportiveness, accomplishment, wit and blazing trails for herself and others. I can't believe we are talking about her in the past tense. May those who follow in her footsteps emulate and honor her example.
6
Thank you, David, for the beautiful remembrance of Gwen If ill. I never felt so saddened by the loss of someone I didn't know personally. My sincere condolences go out to all of us whose lives she touched.
10
Ms. Ifill was definitely a force with which to be reckoned. Her integrity and dedication to iron-core journalism, so lost today, was rarely matched. I will miss her.
7
I was driving when the hourly news said, briefly, Gwen Ifill had died. I blurted out "What?" It was inconceivable. The news reporting continued but I heard nothing. I must have said, uncomprehending, "what?" out loud another five times.
The last time I saw her on air she seemed as radiant as ever. But then I thought back to a few times earlier in the year when she was having recurring patches of unusual difficulty in delivering her lines. Some phrases were garbled. It was a passing phase but it was a signal that all was not right. One can only give her our love and commiserate that she gave up her fight only after the election results had doomed the country and the world to a situation one could more easily chose to leave behind.
The last time I saw her on air she seemed as radiant as ever. But then I thought back to a few times earlier in the year when she was having recurring patches of unusual difficulty in delivering her lines. Some phrases were garbled. It was a passing phase but it was a signal that all was not right. One can only give her our love and commiserate that she gave up her fight only after the election results had doomed the country and the world to a situation one could more easily chose to leave behind.
10
At a time when the US media needs all the good journalists that it can get, this is a huge loss.
Best wishes to her family. This was unexpected and 61 is awfully young.
People all over the country will be mourning her loss and she'll be sorely missed.
Nothing like her calm, straightforward news presentation and her great grasp of subject matter and insight on current affairs.
RIP.
Best wishes to her family. This was unexpected and 61 is awfully young.
People all over the country will be mourning her loss and she'll be sorely missed.
Nothing like her calm, straightforward news presentation and her great grasp of subject matter and insight on current affairs.
RIP.
11
Ms. Ifil is sorely missed by my Wife and I. She was a welcom face at News Hour. It seems there is no one to take her place, and frankly, whenever we lose a person to the ravages of Cancer we have lost more than the person; we have lost hope to a certain extent.
It is resoundingly excellent, though, to read such wonderful accounts of Gwen's life as this. If you never experienced Ms. Ifil you have missed out on one of the rare and pure Jornalist left in our nation. We who knew her work have lost a great friend of The Truth.
It is resoundingly excellent, though, to read such wonderful accounts of Gwen's life as this. If you never experienced Ms. Ifil you have missed out on one of the rare and pure Jornalist left in our nation. We who knew her work have lost a great friend of The Truth.
122
Please google or see her on YouTube...she is a unique reporter and person and will be sorely missed by my wife and myself.
Watching the news hour last night was incredibly moving. It was plain that she was deeply loved by her collegues. I loved her for talent and obvious poise. Our president was right- she served her country well. We need more Gwen Ifills. I believe her example of striving for excellence without losing your own grace will live on and continue. She has left a wonderful legacy to all of those journalists who still fight for truth and are not afraid of speaking truth to power. She was a bright light.
Was stunned to hear that Gwen saw this populist/facist movement gathering steam back in 2012. It's as Plato said more than 2 millenia ago: The Republic reflects the education of the electorate - when the electorate is poorly educated, the Republic will fail (paraphrasing). Worse, the Hitler phenomenon was merely 75 years ago yet everyone has forgotten - little interest in serious history, it appears. Everyone needs to read the following bio: Hitler, by author Allan Bullock (1962). A shocking parallel to what is happening in front of our faces here in America.
5
"But I confess, when I looked at the front of The Times website on Monday and saw a photo of Stephen K. Bannon, on leave from Breitbart as chairman and rising in power, and then underneath it a photo of Gwen, who is passing from this world, I wanted to throw up. This is not progress and this is not good news."
Mr. Brooks ~ I'm sorry that our country has lost such an intelligent, tough journalist, one who could cut through the bull with a clarity that was disarming; she was a true patriot and she will be missed. And I'm sorry that you lost a friend.
That said, Bannon, the hatred he not only represents, but inspires, all of us, you included, owe it to the American people to see that this evil man is muffled, that any influence he hopes to have in shaping the future of our country is doused; the quicker the better as we will otherwise not to recover from the damage a Trump administration will unleash before our coastal cities fall into the oceans.
Mr. Brooks ~ I'm sorry that our country has lost such an intelligent, tough journalist, one who could cut through the bull with a clarity that was disarming; she was a true patriot and she will be missed. And I'm sorry that you lost a friend.
That said, Bannon, the hatred he not only represents, but inspires, all of us, you included, owe it to the American people to see that this evil man is muffled, that any influence he hopes to have in shaping the future of our country is doused; the quicker the better as we will otherwise not to recover from the damage a Trump administration will unleash before our coastal cities fall into the oceans.
2
Gwen Ifill stands among the greatest journalists, for her steady, honest reporting and always professional presentation. She will always represent the height of journalism and inspires others to strive for that level. She asks the tough questions, without throwing decorum out the door. She didn't race after money or fame, like too many newsreaders today, throwing the truth out for the sake of ratings. Our nation lost an important source of honest, informed, inquiry too soon, I feel like I lost a dear friend, one who always told it to me straight.
2
I'm very sorry for your loss, Mr. Brooks, as well a our own.
Like the majority of Americans, I never met Gwen in person, but came to admire and trust her implicitly through my "interactions" via the television screen. Her example of steadfastness, honesty, and positive nature will do well to guide us in the uncertainty to come.
Thank you for such a beautiful tribute.
Like the majority of Americans, I never met Gwen in person, but came to admire and trust her implicitly through my "interactions" via the television screen. Her example of steadfastness, honesty, and positive nature will do well to guide us in the uncertainty to come.
Thank you for such a beautiful tribute.
1
When people like Gwen are taken away from us, I feel totally betrayed by forces that I cannot understand, let alone explain. Why her and not the obsequious, the phonies, the egotists, the power hungry, the irrationals, that one easily finds in media and government? Notice, I did not put any names on my "deplorables", but others can. Her reporting never replaced my thinking; it added to it in more than one way. Her voice was like fresh air, so lacking in the parched deserts of Southern Utah. I, too, David, will miss her.
3
Decency and the truth are so very scarce; and Gwen's decency and truth seeking even rarer still.
My condolences to her family, friends and colleagues and to you too David, for the loss of your close friend.
Gwen will be missed her viewers, like me, who certainly felt she was our friend too every time we saw her.
My condolences to her family, friends and colleagues and to you too David, for the loss of your close friend.
Gwen will be missed her viewers, like me, who certainly felt she was our friend too every time we saw her.
2
I admired her greatly until the Presidential debates in 2008, softball questions to Obama and hard as nails questions to Clinton, and when he took Clinton's opinions as his own she didn't bother to question him. She was a maverick and a force to be reckoned with just didn't agree with her a whole lot of times.
2
My husband and I watched her every night. I am so saddened by her passing. I had such great respect for her and valued her honesty and unbiased interviews. I feel so sad that she passed knowing that the country was taking a step backwards.
2
My sadness at hearing of her death was followed by the thought that perhaps it was a blessing in disguise. She will not have to live through the dismantling of all that she lived and fought for. Or perhaps I am projecting my own pain at what is happening.
4
Since in reading the briefing report this morning in the Times about how girls were never allowed to do the jobs and reading a comment that Gwen Ifill was not a Walter Kronkite boggles one's mind.
Of course she was not a W. K. but we men easily and comfortably think of her as a girl.
What she achieved in a very real sense was greater than Kronkite because He was not a girl. Gwen had everything stacked against - she was a girl and she was black.
For us to continue to be a truly great nation for the next millennial, we men must put to rest the two problems that remain and have been with us for 400 years, namely, the racial issue and the issue of "girls" (women).
All of the rhetoric, all of the anger, all of the concern about relevancy should be put aside for work on a change of attitude that we need on these two issues.
Of course she was not a W. K. but we men easily and comfortably think of her as a girl.
What she achieved in a very real sense was greater than Kronkite because He was not a girl. Gwen had everything stacked against - she was a girl and she was black.
For us to continue to be a truly great nation for the next millennial, we men must put to rest the two problems that remain and have been with us for 400 years, namely, the racial issue and the issue of "girls" (women).
All of the rhetoric, all of the anger, all of the concern about relevancy should be put aside for work on a change of attitude that we need on these two issues.
5
I usually read and enjoy the Comments section almost more than the article itself; it is fascinating to hear opinions from every corner of the country and beyond. But, today, I just cannot continue to read. It's so extremely painful that I weep for myself and my loss, for these most meaningful and difficult losses of the last few days, and for my friends, loved ones and our country. I'm so fearful of what could possibly happen next, that I just want to stay in bed. What lessons are we supposed to learn, I wonder. I need to get busy and try to figure it out.
2
The PBS News Hour is my must see news program. Gwen Ifill was my go to journalist among the programs talented royal coterie. Washington Week was also my primary program for weekly political commentary.
Humble, humane, empathetic, curious, original, independent, wise, respectful, respectful and smart are great but rare virtues. Gwen Ifill had all of those qualities that were a credit to her profession and to her gender, color and race. None of the crass coarse commercialism that has marked the devolution of the news journalism business into entertainment, distraction and provocation.
Gwen Ifill seemed like a friend. She will be greatly missed by me. "Amazing Grace" so aptly described her and her life. Peace be still my friend in your soulful eternal rest.
Humble, humane, empathetic, curious, original, independent, wise, respectful, respectful and smart are great but rare virtues. Gwen Ifill had all of those qualities that were a credit to her profession and to her gender, color and race. None of the crass coarse commercialism that has marked the devolution of the news journalism business into entertainment, distraction and provocation.
Gwen Ifill seemed like a friend. She will be greatly missed by me. "Amazing Grace" so aptly described her and her life. Peace be still my friend in your soulful eternal rest.
180
I really enjoyed watching Ms. Ifill, but I really had no idea how much respect she commanded across the industry until the outpouring yesterday and today.
She lived an awesome life.
She lived an awesome life.
How awful, and ironic, but also very telling, that in the same period of time, Gwen Ifill dies, Hillary Clinton loses, and Steve Bannon and Donald Trump are moved into the White House. Out with the pros and humanity and in with the charlatans.
What terrible and sad time this is for our country.
What terrible and sad time this is for our country.
6
I loved the Saturday Night Live spoof of the VP debates that Gwen moderated. It was extremely funny. A classic. I always enjoyed her GPB broadcasts here in Atlanta.
Yes, two big losses for decency, dignity, integrity, generosity of spirit, and civility in one week. I felt like throwing up and crying at the same time.
1
This is perhaps my favorite piece by Mr Brooks.
Everything here is not a surprise after viewing her from afar and not knowing her personally, but it is wonderful for the actual confirmation from someone who new her.
A big thanks to Gwen Ifill and condolences to her friends and family. Rest in Peace.
Everything here is not a surprise after viewing her from afar and not knowing her personally, but it is wonderful for the actual confirmation from someone who new her.
A big thanks to Gwen Ifill and condolences to her friends and family. Rest in Peace.
2
I worked very briefly with Gwen. She left a lasting impression on me. She was wicked smart, tough minded and drily funny. She also suffered constant subtle prejudice. She richly deserves the universal recognition she is receiving upon her untimely death.
195
I share Gwen's first name and her profession (to a degree) I left journalism years ago but not my incessant need read the morning's NYT. There were many times I watched Ms. Ifill on News Hour and envied her professional demeanor - and that 1000 watt smile! As debate moderator I was enamored of her ability to ask the tough question without one hint of betraying her own emotions; something I could never do and why my degree in broadcast journalism collects dust somewhere in my file cabinet.
I too saw the sad irony of yesterday's headline above the news of Gwen's death. I am angry that with some unknown tilt of the universe our planet goes retrograde and bad is good is bad is good is bad.
Our great world is less so with her passing. May Gwen Ifill's life always be remembered for her spirit and righteous journalism. She will be missed.
I too saw the sad irony of yesterday's headline above the news of Gwen's death. I am angry that with some unknown tilt of the universe our planet goes retrograde and bad is good is bad is good is bad.
Our great world is less so with her passing. May Gwen Ifill's life always be remembered for her spirit and righteous journalism. She will be missed.
2
In her legacy, I will try to smile when my heart is breaking. Gwen Ifill's emotional intelligence is a model as we move forward in these very difficult times. Condolences to her family, friends and co- workers especially Judy Woodruff and David Brooks.
1
My only hope would be that she was unaware of the election results before she passed. I know she was there on the news leading up to it but she would be devastated to see so anger and vitriol. She would especially be insensed to see Steve Obannon in the White House. God look over her and help us survive.
1
Thank you Mr. Brooks - and who can forget Washington Week.? Gwen Ifill was the perfect example of an excellent journalist. Articulate, cultured, and not afraid to ask the hard questions. I was so sad to hear of her death and even sadder to hear of racial rhetoric against her. PBS is my news source and Friday nights will never be quite the same. This election brought out the worst in people - and the Trump attitude that the end result justifies the means is a repudiation of basic moral values. Gwen Ifill was a role model to all and stood in sharp contrast to these basest of instincts.
1
Thank you for this. I was truly saddened to learn of Ms Ifill's death. The depth of my feeling surprised me because I am only a viewer and reader; not a personal friend. I do think my filling arose from a sense of trust, appreciation of her value to the country and a sense that now, of all times, we needed Ms. Ifill to do what she does: Speak turth to power, hold people accountable and always remind us to be good humored and respectful. I see no heir apparent on the horizon but I dearly hope there is someone who can begin to approach her value.
196
PBS News Hour had a wonderful tribute to Ms. Ifill last night, lauding her as the best of the best in journalism as I'm sure she was.
David Brooks is lauded as one of the best.
So I just can't stop asking myself why these two pillars of journalism, and all the others, did not shout out warnings to the public about the villans who were/are behind The Con Don's "rise".
They knew. The entire journalism establishment knew. The top political establishment knew. The financial elite knew. Everyone that is anyone knew. And yet they let it happen. They let Steve Bannon and Roger Ailes, chief haters, direct this election and helped them along. Why? It really doesn't matter now.
Read for yourselves. Hate won. Heil America.
http://www.bloomberg.com/politics/graphics/2015-steve-bannon/
David Brooks is lauded as one of the best.
So I just can't stop asking myself why these two pillars of journalism, and all the others, did not shout out warnings to the public about the villans who were/are behind The Con Don's "rise".
They knew. The entire journalism establishment knew. The top political establishment knew. The financial elite knew. Everyone that is anyone knew. And yet they let it happen. They let Steve Bannon and Roger Ailes, chief haters, direct this election and helped them along. Why? It really doesn't matter now.
Read for yourselves. Hate won. Heil America.
http://www.bloomberg.com/politics/graphics/2015-steve-bannon/
9
I regret not being able to watch or listen to Gwen Ifill more often. She was smart, funny, had some of the best comments I've ever heard and, yes, she was every inch a lady. She had courage, grace, wit, and other qualities we tend associate with a bygone era. I enjoyed watching the debates this year because of her. She will be missed.
9
Ms Ifill was not my cup of tea, so not everybody was enamored of her.
I imagine she was a nice person and obviously worked hard, but represented the mindset among those in Washington that has pushed our politics to the low point it is at today. PBS NewsHour would have been better served if they had chosen someone other than Judy Woodruff and Gwen Ifill.
To those who knew and loved her my sympathies, but Walter Cronkite she was not.
I imagine she was a nice person and obviously worked hard, but represented the mindset among those in Washington that has pushed our politics to the low point it is at today. PBS NewsHour would have been better served if they had chosen someone other than Judy Woodruff and Gwen Ifill.
To those who knew and loved her my sympathies, but Walter Cronkite she was not.
4
I don't think she ever tried to be Walter Cronkite; I think she only tried to be Gwen Ifill, a strong, clear and honest voice in service to her listeners. Judy, too, for that matter. And she never pushed our politics down; she simply reported it professionally. That was good enough for me.
5
Thanks for including the first half of your last sentence, and good luck with the rest of the challenges you are experiencing.
2
How mean spirited. This is not the place for a political comment.
2
You are not stuck in the self-reflective quicksand swamp of the establishment Dem-Rup cabal D.C., but you have to get over your meritocratic educated elite bias----and recognize that Gwen Ifill would have been a better FIRST LADY than Michelle or Melania, or Barbara Bush or Hillary. And she should have been the one to honestly smash the glass ceiling, and become a wonderful FIRST PERSON as POTUS ELECT..... .(of course just a sentimental fantasy--- like Nader she was too good/sincere/honest to be a politician, much less a US Ruling Class President)
5
After last week's election, I said I would have to stop watching the news, because the sight of Trump and his toadies makes me actually feel sick. But I had this sort of silly feeling that I was abandoning two of my favorite women-- Gwen and Judy--and had an uncomfortable image of them sitting at their desk, talking to no one. Now Gwen has left us, and Mr. Brooks is right, she definitely can't be replaced. But she leaves us with her courage and conviction, and she makes it clear, you have to watch, you have to listen, and you have to deal. Imagine, anyone sending hate mail to Gwen? We have got to stop it.
31
Thank you, Mr. Brooks, for your thoughtful reflections on Gwen Ifill's passing. She was very good at her job, and her smile betrayed the love she had for her vocation and warmth for everyone. Her discussions with you and Mark Shields every Friday on the Newshour have always been a high point of my week, too. Now, more than ever, we need her spirit most.
25
While I have not agreed with your frequently -maybe even usually - over political and related issues, I will remember this article with admiration and appreciation. You summed up my view of Gwen Ifill and my visceral reaction to the state of this country fully.
20
Thank you David for this loving piece. Your juxtaposition of Gwen and Bannon says it all about today's America. It has been a difficult couple of weeks for many of us and this feels like a familial loss, only deepening our despair.
34
David Brooks has written a tribute in the death of Gwen Ifill that is both accurate and loving. He has described her so beautifully I only hope that there is someone in journalism today who can pick up where Gwen left off.
16
There may be someone to carry on, but it won't be Gwen.R.I.P. 2016
Condolences to those who knew and mourn her, but like all journalists who advance to the top, Gwen Ifil retailed the received wisdom and self-perpetuating pabulum of the people with whom she moved and most closely identified: the powerful. Not for her to challenge the myths of American exceptionalism and our public life -- myths which have helped facilitate the election of our worst citizens to high office.
Corporate journalism, including PBS corporate journalism, won't save a nation or anyone in it.
Corporate journalism, including PBS corporate journalism, won't save a nation or anyone in it.
1
Gwen Ifill was in a class by herself, the very, very best. Our world is diminished by the loss of such an honest, vibrant, talented woman. The supreme irony of the tributes that are flooding in to honor her is that she can't hear them.
7
I'm sorry for your personal loss, David. Thanks for a lovely column, and thanks Gwen for your good work and big smile.
9
RIP. She was my favorite newsperson these past few years.
8
Gwen Ifill was simply the best of the best of the best.
I always looked forward to her insightful reporting and amazing moderation of discussions. Fair, smart, uncompromising.
And you are right, David, her smile was brilliant. She shone like a star. What will we do without her in these troubling days?
I always looked forward to her insightful reporting and amazing moderation of discussions. Fair, smart, uncompromising.
And you are right, David, her smile was brilliant. She shone like a star. What will we do without her in these troubling days?
13
Brooks dedication to his column to Ms. Ifill is extremely Gracious. She is one of a kind news anchor with voice and quality.
Unfortunately times again as disgusting as 1930 Germany.
Unfortunately times again as disgusting as 1930 Germany.
15
Very beautiful David. She will be missed dearly.
7
Even David Brooks cannot find a way to limit full-bore praise for such an amazing woman as Gwen Ifill. This was lovely. However it seems we are now to be treated to his newly learned lessons at the Donald Trump University course in Superlatives 101: "...which was totalistic and unrestrained."
3
Gwen Ifill was a class act. I looked forward to her presence on the PBS NewsHour and Washington Week. I will miss her tremendously, especially as we move into the uncharted waters of the Trump administration.
Mr. Brooks, thank you for reminiscing with us about Gwen Ifill. I felt the same as you did seeing the juxtaposition of the photos of Stephen Bannon and Gwen Ifill.
Mr. Brooks, thank you for reminiscing with us about Gwen Ifill. I felt the same as you did seeing the juxtaposition of the photos of Stephen Bannon and Gwen Ifill.
11
During this long election season, I compared Gwen's handling of the past debates with this season's and every moderator came up short. I tuned to Judy and Gwen and always found them both smart and smartly put together. Such a contrast to the over-done sheath encased young women that are passing for journalists today.
"I confess, when I looked at the front of The Times website on Monday and saw a photo of Stephen K. Bannon, on leave from Breitbart as chairman and rising in power, and then underneath it a photo of Gwen, who is passing from this world, I wanted to throw up. This is not progress and this is not good news."
Well, Mr. Brooks, what are you going to do about this? You have a megaphone and bully pulpit that millions of us don't have. I look forward to great vigilance on your part, and not the kind of inward-looking moralism you've been publishing lately. Your country and compatriots need all decent journalists, including the conservative ones, to prevent Bannon and his like from becoming the "new normal" in discourse. We need you to investigate conflicts of interest between this incoming administration and Trump's family business interests with at least the same gusto with which you all pursued the Clinton emails. It's time to ENGAGE!
Well, Mr. Brooks, what are you going to do about this? You have a megaphone and bully pulpit that millions of us don't have. I look forward to great vigilance on your part, and not the kind of inward-looking moralism you've been publishing lately. Your country and compatriots need all decent journalists, including the conservative ones, to prevent Bannon and his like from becoming the "new normal" in discourse. We need you to investigate conflicts of interest between this incoming administration and Trump's family business interests with at least the same gusto with which you all pursued the Clinton emails. It's time to ENGAGE!
29
A beautiful tribute a gifted life gone too soon, and I did not know Gwen was ill but felt her absence in her news hour with Judy Woodruff
10
Gwen even managed to make you, David Brooks, more honest in your assessment of issues and events each Friday when you chaired a discussion with her and Mark Shields.
One sensed that you knew there were limits to what she would tolerate of your usual 'advocacy'.
You should reflect on that and bring more of it to your columns.
Sorry for your loss and ours.
Respectfully.
One sensed that you knew there were limits to what she would tolerate of your usual 'advocacy'.
You should reflect on that and bring more of it to your columns.
Sorry for your loss and ours.
Respectfully.
5
Thank you David for sharing your personal reflections and friendship with Gwen. She will be missed by many readers and journalists. Very sad that her picture in this mornings Times had to be shared with Stephen Bannon! RIP sweet Gwen.
6
A voice of reason, strength, humour is gone. I read the news today and my eyes filled with tears. Then I read David Brooks column and the tears spilled over into my morning coffee. I had noticed her absence from the news hour and Washington week but thought she was on a well deserved break after last week. Gwen you were an international star.
235
Thank you for this wonderful, heartfelt tribute, Mr. Brooks.
I, too, felt like vomiting when I saw Gwen Ifill and Stephen Bannon sharing space on the front of the NYTimes website.
But what is sticking with me in the face of what is coming is Ms. Ifill's advice to Jeffrey Goldberg: "Keep your head down and keep writing; it's what they don't want you to do."
I think we'd all be well advised to be persistent in doing what we care about and for what we believe is right and good in the face of what's coming - even if they don't want us to do it.
And Mr. Brooks, this liberal democrat hopes that you keep writing in the face of what's to come. I, for one, want you to do it.
I, too, felt like vomiting when I saw Gwen Ifill and Stephen Bannon sharing space on the front of the NYTimes website.
But what is sticking with me in the face of what is coming is Ms. Ifill's advice to Jeffrey Goldberg: "Keep your head down and keep writing; it's what they don't want you to do."
I think we'd all be well advised to be persistent in doing what we care about and for what we believe is right and good in the face of what's coming - even if they don't want us to do it.
And Mr. Brooks, this liberal democrat hopes that you keep writing in the face of what's to come. I, for one, want you to do it.
27
Gwen was a shining light in a storm filled profession. Always thoughtful, open, and intellectually curious.
I will miss her.
I will miss her.
7
Do not do not dispare, we have lived in the times of the grace and the toughness of Gwen Ifill, we have watched her mighty mind and strength of character. Take the lessons she shared through her ideas and her example, and now go forward, pick up her mantle and fill the void. She would expect no less wouldn't she?
8
David, you are one lucky basted. Not only did you work and socialize with Gwen Ifill, you got to hear her sing. What I would give to have had that.
5
Thank You David.
A wonderful reflection of what many of us feel...thank you David.
Goodbye old friend...rest with God in peace!
Goodbye old friend...rest with God in peace!
Gwen Ifill brought so much conviction, professionalism and respect for truth to the news business at a time when this feels increasingly rare and more important than ever. Thank you David for your heartfelt tribute to this prodigiously talented, formidable, amazingly graceful, beautiful woman.
5
A bright star had dimmed from our darkening sky...
The fact that this talented, top-of-her-game journalist took the time to mentor others shows her quality of character. My condolences to Judy and Gwen's other PBS family members, including, you, David. My thoughts are with Gwen's family and friends at this very tough time. We loyal viewers have also lost a friend. I wish I had some candid photos on my cell phone to remember Gwen and her beautiful smile.
5
With the passing of Gwen Ifill I feel I have lost yet a personal friend and a journalist I never met in person. I loved Andy Rooney of 60 Minutes fame. He also passed in the month of November 2011. May the souls of these admirable journalists 'my friends' rest in peace.
This is the David Brooks I have always wanted to read and despaired over ever finding. The election seems to have opened his memories of more hopeful days and better people. In doing so, it relaxed his very style, it seems. Well-done, David, I am happy to see your candor and deep affection here. Long may it wave.
9
Gwen Ifill simply could not live in an America she could no longer recognize.
With her strong faith, I know she is sitting around with the greatest journalists in history, and having a ball.
May you have the peace Gwen that we will know none of, here.
With her strong faith, I know she is sitting around with the greatest journalists in history, and having a ball.
May you have the peace Gwen that we will know none of, here.
162
Gwen Ifill and reporters like you, David Brooks, make me feel safer as an American. Thank you, for all you do.
4
Thank you, David. Once again you write with feeling as well as fact. In my mind, when I picture our country it is the pictures of Gwen and Judy in the role of journalistic partners, the Obama family and the push for a Muslim man, Keith Ellison, for Democratic chair. Those are the way we must go. Sorry, I can't see the picture of Bannon. Disappearing ink, I trust.
1
I think sometimes God just gets lonely and wants people like Gwen closer.
7
The death of Gwen Ifill and the pending retirement of Diane Rehm will deprive America of two journalists whose rigorous intellects and deeply humane outlooks could have helped us endure with some equanimity the potential horrors of the next four years. At the same time, the capacity of our country to produce these two women suggests that integrity and good sense have not entirely disappeared from these shores. That will be something comforting to remember in the Age of Trump.
10
Condolences sir. Ms. Ifill was a joy to watch and learn from.
Carry on.
Carry on.
Thank you for this view from a friend. Gwen Ifill was a strong, graceful and intelligent voice. I also loved seeing her smile during Washington Week panels. We will miss her very much.
1
For years several of my friends have had the Gwen Ifill fan club within our running group. Many times our running buddies would giggle about our chats about Gwen and her magnificent presence--until they took the challenge to watch Washington Week, to tune in regularly to NewsHour. They were in awe. She will be missed, sorely.
Thank you, David Brooks, for your lovely profile.
Thank you, David Brooks, for your lovely profile.
4
Really nice column, David. I will really miss Gwen on the NewsHour.
After her segment on the new African American Museum in D.C., I sent Gwen a tweet about how much I enjoyed it. I never imagined she was so sick. I'm glad that I let her know how much I appreciated her work.
After her segment on the new African American Museum in D.C., I sent Gwen a tweet about how much I enjoyed it. I never imagined she was so sick. I'm glad that I let her know how much I appreciated her work.
2
Gwen was a beacon of light in a troubled world and that light will be sorely missed. I never met Gwen, but I knew as did anyone who saw her on TV that she was a magnificent human being and a beacon of light in the darkness. People like her are sorely needed in this world to help keep us sane and compassionate to each other. Thanks Gwen for being with us for awhile, gracing us with your smile and wisdom, rest in peace.
246
The tributes to Gwen Ifill are already legion. Adding to them here seems trivial. Leaving tributes aside for a moment, if her life isn't proof of the idea that when members of marginalized groups (minorities, women) are empowered, everyone and everything around them is also empowered.
My trivial tribute: Gwen Ifill was a superb human being in an era when such generous brilliance is increasingly hard to find. Ms. Ifill herself was the exact opposite of trivial.
www.endthemadnessnow.org
My trivial tribute: Gwen Ifill was a superb human being in an era when such generous brilliance is increasingly hard to find. Ms. Ifill herself was the exact opposite of trivial.
www.endthemadnessnow.org
6
David, Thank you for sharing your remembrances of Gwen Ifill. Although I only knew Gwen through her reporting, I've found my eyes tearing each time I've read or heard about her passing and her amazing life. At a time when so many Americans have their own versions of the "facts" and there is a dearth of civil discourse, the importance of journalism as practiced by such consummate professionals as Gwen is of critical importance. My condolences to her family, friends, and colleagues. Gwen Ifill truly embodied integrity, tenacity, strength, and warmth.
4
Thank you, David Brooks, for an excellent and heartfelt piece.
Not surprisingly, there is no mention of Gwen Ifill's death on Breitbart News Network.
Not surprisingly, there is no mention of Gwen Ifill's death on Breitbart News Network.
1
Thank you David.
I am very sorry for your loss. We've lost an excellent journalist, but you've lost a friend and colleague.
I am very sorry for your loss. We've lost an excellent journalist, but you've lost a friend and colleague.
Thank you.
The proximate cause of Ms. Ifill's death was cancer. But I can well imagine that the election results last week broke her heart, although she never would have admittted it on the air
6
Besides being good at the most professional aspects of her job, she was also a comfort. I loved her vibe and I believed what she had to say. She seemed smart and decent, and her smile lit up the TV screen. I will miss her so much.
1
A lovely tribute. I wish PBS had let us know what was coming so we all could have let her know how much we valued her.
1
She is an American treasure. After hearing so much more about the details of her life, the devotion to her profession and support of her colleagues we can only hope that her light shines on in others at a time when we need it so much.
1
This is a beautiful remembrance of Gwen Ifill, a national treasure gone too soon. I admired her journalistic skill and her warmth that came across on television to millions of strangers sitting in our homes trusting PBS to bring us news with integrity in a world where that is in short supply. I will miss her on the NewsHour and Washington Week. These days the grief in our world seems so heavy to bear. The way the NewsHour honored Gwen Ifill last night was so beautiful and performed the labor of providing a place for many of us who were stunned to learn of her death to join in and remember her.
396
Good morning David: Thank you for the reflection and tribute to Gwen Ifill, she was a wonderful human being!!!
Bless you, David Brooks. Keep writing. It's what we want you to do.
2
What a beautiful and poignant piece of writing which left me in tears at several points. Gwen's heart and your heart leaped off the page and filled me with joy and sadness. Yes, I will miss her. She was grace personified, combined with intellect and passion.
Keep writing, David Brooks. You bring me hope each week, with your insight, love, and searching heart.
Keep writing, David Brooks. You bring me hope each week, with your insight, love, and searching heart.
1
Gwen Ifill is the first journalist for whom I shed tears when I heard of her passing. In a profession that is sorely in need of true professionals, her passing leaves a huge hole. Thanks Gwen for your diligence, tenacity, intelligence, high standards and most of all your integrity.
5
Mr. Brooks, thank you for the thoughts and memories. The happy ones comfort me, knowing she had a full and happy life filled with friendship and good times. Gwen Ifill has been my hero for many years. I wish I could have told her how much I admired her courage, her intelligence, her humor and her incredible strength. The last few weeks have not been happy ones for me and this was a blow that made me cry, that felt surprisingly personal. I looked up to her so much and will miss her terribly. If someone had ever asked me to play the game of "who would you want to have dinner with" it would definitely have been Gwen Ifill. You were lucky to have been her friend. I send best wishes and hopes for comfort to her loved ones, she left us far too soon.
7
We can only hope that budding journalists look to Gwen Ifill for road maps on how to do it right. We can only hope that present journalists take a breath, sit back and reflect on where they have gone so wrong, where Ifill got it so right, and try to measure up to her. What a loss for all of us who seek good journalism.
7
When you wanted to here the real truth, the real facts you went to the PBS news hour or Washington Week. I thought God called Janet Reno home so she wouldn't have to see Donald Trump get elected. I think he called Gwen Ifill home so she wouldn't have to see what he is going to do. Sadly, we need her more than ever.
570
I am not a believer really, though I just thanked God for the beautiful sunrise I saw just as I began to read David's wonderful tribute. But I think the passing of these two grandes dames is no coincidence. May they send power and justice this direction, during this perilous time.
1
"When I saw a photo of Bannon (arriving) and a photo of Gwen (departing).... I wanted to throw up.... " Wow! One powerful passage. Some great writing David and powerful and extremely sad commentary
12
I was sickened when I heard the news. You are right, David, there is no one who will fill the void. She wasn't just great at what she did, she was absolutely unique.
4
Compassion and integrity; humor and a zest for life; "ambition for quality" (as you describe it) do NOT often fit within one person. Top that with the smile you also describe so well only reinforces this casual screen-observer's impression of a person larger-than-life, but with the humanness and inner balance to rise above the vast majority. This also describes a person who, while we never took for granted when doing her job with panache and excellence, we did not consciously and obsessively think "gee, she is special." I, for one, just had this quiet confidence that when she was reporting, or jesting, or commenting; it was coming from a place I could trust. That she was there made it trustworthy and without hyperbole and self-importance. That Gwen will no longer be in that seat makes it worse. Thank you Mr. Brooks for a personal and professional tribute that wonderfully sums up our thoughts and deep sorrow at her passing.
370
Some years ago at one of the anniversaries of JFK's assassination, I wrote to Gwen Ifill about my father. At the end of that terrible day, November 22, 1963, I sat on the sofa in our living room between my mother and my father as we watched the news on television. My father was nearest the wall and the darker part of the room. At one point, I looked over to him and i saw him quietly, ever so gently crying. I had never seen my father cry before. So I wrote to Gwen Ifiil about this memory of that day. On the next Washington Week in Review broadcast, she spoke of President Kennedy's assassination and how it had brought tears even to men's eyes. Wow! I thought, Gwen Ifill read my note. Wow! We connected.
Sadly, last night we connected again... sort of... but this time I was crying...
Sadly, last night we connected again... sort of... but this time I was crying...
521
Thank you Mr. Brooks. She was a paragon in your profession, and a good friend we invited into our living rooms every evening to help us make sense of this increasingly bizarre world we're living in. I will miss her terribly. I wish her family, friends and colleagues some measure of peace and comfort in facing her loss.
2
David, coupled with analysis, we desperately need in this country at this time humanizing voices. You have served us well with your tribute to Gwen.
2
This was a very moving tribute David. Thank you. But alas, you will never be in the same ballpark as Gwen Ifill
2
A wonderful tribute to a wonderful person.
1
Thank you thank you David for talking to her public about her I was shocked when I heard yesterday she and Judy are apart of our lives as we watch the News Hour every night as you and Mark are on Fridays we will miss Gwen mightily!
4
I especially appreciate the fact that you mentioned the material sacrifice she made to ply her talents on public television when she obviously could have had her pick of higher paying positions. A classy tribute to a classy lady.
5
Another chance for Brooks to avoid the nation's current crisis, Trump placing a White Nationalist steps away from the Oval Office.
Up next, a book review about an obscure, discredited right wing social scientist.
Up next, a book review about an obscure, discredited right wing social scientist.
No one can be Gwen but those who are still here need to try. That includes you, Mr. Brooks. You are an op/ed writer, a known Republican and a Jew. In this climate, you need to step back from party affiliation and, in the face of increasing racist and religious bigotry, make sure that you write to keep the press free. Make sure you follow Gwen's advice to Jeffrey Goldberg and make sure you urge your colleagues to follow it. It's a traditional function of the press and it may be all we have.
9
Thank you for the lovely memories of your friend. She was extraordinary.
2
David, I feel for you.
A friend,
Carol
A friend,
Carol
Gwen Ifill is truely someone who exemplifies what is right about this country.
Mother Nature clearly needs her energy in these uncertain times and chose a day when the moon shown her true splendor to receive this remarkable ladies energy to begin her eternal life.
Mother Nature clearly needs her energy in these uncertain times and chose a day when the moon shown her true splendor to receive this remarkable ladies energy to begin her eternal life.
4
If only we had known to voice our appreciation beforehand.
David, we don't always agree, but this one puts me to tears. How many Friday nights have we spent with Gwen Ifill? First Friday night fish fry, and then hurry get home to see her show. Nothing will be able to quite fill that void.
She calmed us down. She gave us perspective. She showed us what class is in the media world.
Thanks for your article. I feel for you reminiscing. It must be hard. Be glad you knew her so well.
David, we don't always agree, but this one puts me to tears. How many Friday nights have we spent with Gwen Ifill? First Friday night fish fry, and then hurry get home to see her show. Nothing will be able to quite fill that void.
She calmed us down. She gave us perspective. She showed us what class is in the media world.
Thanks for your article. I feel for you reminiscing. It must be hard. Be glad you knew her so well.
6
We will never forget how Ms. Ifill was so badly disrespected by GOP'er women during their 2008 convention in Minneapolis - she was so graceful and dignified in front of the camera when confronted with despicable behavior.
13
In 2004, Gwen Ifill moderated the debate in which Senator John Edwards criticized Vice President Dick Cheney’s former employer, the Halliburton Company.
Mr. Cheney responded by pleading to Gwen Ifell for extra time to dissemble the truth, “I can respond, Gwen, but it’s going to take more than 30 seconds.”
“Well,” Ms. Ifill replied, “that’s all you’ve got.”'
------
Gwen Ifill, telling Dick Cheney how it's gonna' be.
America needs a million more Gwen Ifill's to talk truth to right-wing Greedy Old Psychopaths and Grand Old Power.
Follow Gwen Ifill's lead, America.
Mr. Cheney responded by pleading to Gwen Ifell for extra time to dissemble the truth, “I can respond, Gwen, but it’s going to take more than 30 seconds.”
“Well,” Ms. Ifill replied, “that’s all you’ve got.”'
------
Gwen Ifill, telling Dick Cheney how it's gonna' be.
America needs a million more Gwen Ifill's to talk truth to right-wing Greedy Old Psychopaths and Grand Old Power.
Follow Gwen Ifill's lead, America.
443
And for telling Cheney that that's all the time you have she was hated by some who voted for our new president elect and never forgiven for her standing up to him in that vice presidential debate. The small mindedness of some were very unfair to her.
8
AS an Afro-American, I can only wish that Ifill had succeeded in getting John Edwards into the Oval Office.
If Edwards is free, he'd make a great moral foil against Trump in 2020
If Edwards is free, he'd make a great moral foil against Trump in 2020
2
David, exactly. The photos of Bannon and Gwen on the same page showed how much America has lost its way. On the one hand, quality objective journalism and on the other? We lamented the election results but knew we would muddle through. The loss of Gwen is deep and lasting sadness.
130
For me, the real accomplishment of Gwen Ifill is that her very essence was so much larger than being either Black or a woman in journalism. She was unstintingly revered for her craft, and she modeled what we ultimately value in most people: a generous heart, a modest bearing, and a focus on excellence.
Some day, we will be able to look at fellow human beings without the qualifier of their racial, gender or ethnic group. People like Gwen, who so stunningly model goodness and outstanding achievement steal your heart for which we want only to leave a note of gratitude. It is a virtuous circle that requires no coercion of us, no scolding, no recriminations, and leaves no regret. Only loss and longing that the dance could not go on forever.
God bless you, Gwen.
Some day, we will be able to look at fellow human beings without the qualifier of their racial, gender or ethnic group. People like Gwen, who so stunningly model goodness and outstanding achievement steal your heart for which we want only to leave a note of gratitude. It is a virtuous circle that requires no coercion of us, no scolding, no recriminations, and leaves no regret. Only loss and longing that the dance could not go on forever.
God bless you, Gwen.
19
I didn't know her and never met her but always knew as a reader or viewer there was nobody better at being the best of journalism. She didn't put up with Don Imus and his pretense that hate and racism is funny. Would that the rest of "respectable" journalists had not pretended Imus is okay. But they did and now here we are in the Trump era, and without Gwen Ifill to explain. RIP Gwen Ifill. Thank you David Brooks.
11
A consummate professional who did not leave you thinking more about her and her performance but more about what she was able extract in her interviews. Afterwards, on reflection, there was equal satisfaction in her as a person. A most gracious woman.
13
GWEN IFILL Was a friend we welcomed into our home via PBS as often as we could, along with the rest of the PBS Nightly New team. I was impressed with her command of the facts, clear, concise, analysis, honing in on what she formulated as logical conclusions, amply supported and vetted. I felt great that she was a leader among women of color, showing them that she had proudly and gladly had broken media's glass ceiling. Last night, as the PBS news team presented a moving tribute to Gwen, the sadness was present, but greatly outshown by Gwen's incandescent personality, fierce convictions and overflowing, enveloping warmth. When I saw her smile, I knew that I had a friend who would speak truth to power and to the rest of us who were fortunate enough to be enlightened by the light she let shine during her life, tragically shortened. Gwen's light was not the "little light," or the "light under a basket." No, it was a full blast, blinding spotlight of brilliance that characterized her persona. I know we'll all miss our dear friend very much.
21
I am so sorry for your loss; our loss. May she rest in peace.
8
Thank you for your insider's view of a woman who, from my outsider's view epitomized professionalism and thoughtfulness. Gwen Ifill's life and work stand as examples of what is possible in our society, if we all keep moving toward our ideals.
20
I so admired Gwen Ifill on the Newshour. And I will miss her.
15
Gwen Ifill was the epitome of effective and empathetic journalism. More than that she was one of the rare human beings whom you'd wish to have as a part of your life. To say that hers was an example of a life well spent is an understatement. Our loss is great, especially during times such as these.
24
To have lost this beacon for truth and humanity in a time of such raw ugliness is gut-wrenching. Thank you for letting us know a bit more of her. She will always remain one of the people I most admire.
53
Such sad news. And for those of us outside of the world, disbelievable. It threw my mind into a tizzy, as I immediately thought, "no", and started to question my mind, thinking maybe I had somehow mixed up names and faces. So sad. PBS News Hours as always been special to me as it always followed the children's programming, and as a young wife, years ago trying to adjust to staying home, the musical score itself, became a sort of "five bells". It was Jim Lehr back in those days, but as the grandkids came along, it became Gwen and Judy. So sad. We need more people like Gwen --- people on an even keel - we need more news anchors. So sorry.
23
I wish I were more like Gwen Ifill and when the time comes you would write my obituary.
10
Thank you for a very lovely, thoughtful and honest paean to Gwen Ifill. You were very lucky to know her in person as opposed to those of us who only knew her through television. I have no doubt she rests in peace.
22
i have never felt a loss so deeply as gwen ifill's.
18
David, as soon I got the NYT news alert of gwen's passing, I thought of you! How you must feel her loss. Yesterday, watching the PBS newshour tribute to Gwen, once again our thoughts went to you and Mark. It is so good you have saved the personal treasure of her memories, photos, email, text messages. But this tribute to her in your column is for all of us, the public, her admirers, her fans. We will miss her so much! Back in 2009 we got rid of cable TV. Since then PBS has been our source, reliable and consistent, of quality, of objectivity. Thank you so much. As much as you appreciate her, we are very sure she appreciated you, and gathered you in her genuine friendship arms. She is watching over you, David.
41
Wonderful tribute. Thank-you so much.
28
A very nice piece. Good job.
15
"Any man's death diminishes me, for I am involved in mankind."
But boy, some diminish us more.
Integrity and joy are not qualities most would assign to journalists right now. The elevation of Stephen Bannon being one explanation. Gwen Ifill is one of the old school, working to keep truth and fact real.
Thank you David Brooks, on a day in which I have lost a little faith in our own national integrity, for taking some time to give Ms. Ifill a sendoff.I wish her a peaceful journey and thank her for the reminder that we can be better than we sometimes are.
But boy, some diminish us more.
Integrity and joy are not qualities most would assign to journalists right now. The elevation of Stephen Bannon being one explanation. Gwen Ifill is one of the old school, working to keep truth and fact real.
Thank you David Brooks, on a day in which I have lost a little faith in our own national integrity, for taking some time to give Ms. Ifill a sendoff.I wish her a peaceful journey and thank her for the reminder that we can be better than we sometimes are.
149
I agree with everything this writer says. Gwen and Judy a team of gracious, sharp journalists , I followed them every evening with pride in my heart. They represent what makes America Great -love of truth, facts and freedom to see and tell the TRUTH. We lost a shining star in her we need her even more.
1
I agree with many of the other commenters that this is one of the most beautiful, heartfelt columns I've ever read from David Brooks.
Also, like a few others, I was particularly struck by the paragraph contrasting the deep sadness of Gwen Ifill's passing with the horror of Stephen K. Bannon's potential rise to power.
I wonder, David, how much the depth of sadness you feel is affected by a sense of shame in the part you may have - no doubt, unintentionally - played in helping to bring about our current situation.
Also, like a few others, I was particularly struck by the paragraph contrasting the deep sadness of Gwen Ifill's passing with the horror of Stephen K. Bannon's potential rise to power.
I wonder, David, how much the depth of sadness you feel is affected by a sense of shame in the part you may have - no doubt, unintentionally - played in helping to bring about our current situation.
39
I think it's time to cut Mr. Brooks a break...the Republican party he once knew isn't the Republican party we see now...
7
Yes, a real loss for real reporting. What I saw this election season was truly bad and biased. I excoriated the NYT when they had a headline that sunk to the depths of non-reporting. Trump backs away from Birther THEORY. They called his racist lies a theory...Gwen we could really use you now, but you are in a better place.
4
Yes it is. Only on steroids.
What makes these dark days even darker is the loss of those we most need right now, like Ms. Ifil. Feels like they were killed off by some evil spirit that was ushered in with the election.
We need good journalism now more than ever, they will need to be the counterweight to the lack of balance of power in Washington.
The rest of you had really step it up.
We need good journalism now more than ever, they will need to be the counterweight to the lack of balance of power in Washington.
The rest of you had really step it up.
83
Gwen Ifill was the very worthy successor to Lehrer. No one is indispensable but it's hard to see how they will replace her.
33
Van Jones?
2
Thank you for sharing the Gwen Ifill we didn't get to know. This is no doubt a terrible loss to those nearest and dearest to the person we viewers really only thought we knew. I would have loved to have seen the photos.
There is a Journalistic vacuum, a void I fear which this election seems to say there is no need to be filled. What matters when a majority of those who voted for Trump believe he is either unqualified for, or has the temperament to be POTUS?
The PBS Newshour is the last bastion of real News coverage, journalist integrity and unbiased reporting. ( Sorry Gray Lady) This is a tragic loss for the 4th Estate
There is a Journalistic vacuum, a void I fear which this election seems to say there is no need to be filled. What matters when a majority of those who voted for Trump believe he is either unqualified for, or has the temperament to be POTUS?
The PBS Newshour is the last bastion of real News coverage, journalist integrity and unbiased reporting. ( Sorry Gray Lady) This is a tragic loss for the 4th Estate
82
No NewsHour has become Villager Central. There right wing guests on a panel is not balance.
Please clarify. What is "Villager Central"?
1
This is only the second time I've cried reading a tribute to someone in the New York Times (Bill Cunningham was the other). Thank you for putting into such beautiful words how many of us who didn't even know her personally feel on hearing the news of her passing. She was a treasure, and she will be deeply missed. I also appreciate that gorgeous photo of Gwen, looking radiant and smiling, that was chosen to go with this piece.
929
@Lilywise
With you in tears reading tributes to Gwen Ifill today and previously Bill Cunningham. I add David Michael Carr of a few years back.
With you in tears reading tributes to Gwen Ifill today and previously Bill Cunningham. I add David Michael Carr of a few years back.
In the swamp of pretty faces and ratings races that define too much of TV news, Gwen stood out because she started as a writer--a real journalist. It's not sexist to talk about her smile--it's a metaphor. The news could often be grim, but after and even while she delivered it, we knew that beneath her somber demeanor was that smile. She was unique and I hate having to face the Trump presidency without her.
1153
To me Gwen had a beautiful face, her smile and inner soul always would light up a room.
4
Thank you for this heartfelt and personal column David, I am so sorry that you have lost this dear friend Gwen. My heart is hurting too, the timing of her passing seems just too cruel - we need her calm, sage ways now more than ever. Gwen was a quiet hero for so many - I'm going to go look up and learn the lyrics to Amazing Grace, she was Amazing Grace. Peace and strength to us all - what are her messages that we can take forward now?
1091
It has been a very tough year for pioneering quality black professional journalists. First we lost George E. Curry and now Gwen Ifill. Curry was much lesser known among the broad American public. But he was an exemplar of the same qualities that so brightly shined in Gwen Ifill. I'll be doggone!
3
you are so right! she had and was amazing grace!!
1
Not only was Gwen Ifill a tower of journalistic truth, integrity and perseverance beloved by her countrymen, she was also a vintage American Horatio Alger success story.
Gwen, whose family hailed from Barbados and Panama and presumably from Africa, lifted herself up from poverty as a black American female in a very white-male-American-dominated world.
And millions looked at her for honest news reporting as she tried her patriotic, Jeffersonian best to educate and inform the American citizenry.
She gave her life to honest journalism, working for a reduced wage at PBS to more honestly and plain tell the truth to the American people...that same PBS that Grand Old Propagandists want to despicably defund because of its institutional honesty.
Meanwhile the ghost of Samuel Johnson's other sapient words - "patriotism is the last refuge of a scoundrel" - lurks darkly and viciously all throughout Republistan, as Stephen Bannon, Donald Trump, Rudy Giuliani, Christie Christie and other assorted Princes of Republican Darkness celebrate the privileged white Birther Liar King, who lifted himself up with million dollar loans from a rich daddy, White Privilege and flag-waving Caucasian nationalism.
We know what made America great and what will make it great again.
People like Gwen Ifill.
“When she shall die,
Take her and cut her out in little stars,
And she will make the face of heaven so fine
That all the world will be in love with night
And pay no worship to the garish sun.”
Gwen, whose family hailed from Barbados and Panama and presumably from Africa, lifted herself up from poverty as a black American female in a very white-male-American-dominated world.
And millions looked at her for honest news reporting as she tried her patriotic, Jeffersonian best to educate and inform the American citizenry.
She gave her life to honest journalism, working for a reduced wage at PBS to more honestly and plain tell the truth to the American people...that same PBS that Grand Old Propagandists want to despicably defund because of its institutional honesty.
Meanwhile the ghost of Samuel Johnson's other sapient words - "patriotism is the last refuge of a scoundrel" - lurks darkly and viciously all throughout Republistan, as Stephen Bannon, Donald Trump, Rudy Giuliani, Christie Christie and other assorted Princes of Republican Darkness celebrate the privileged white Birther Liar King, who lifted himself up with million dollar loans from a rich daddy, White Privilege and flag-waving Caucasian nationalism.
We know what made America great and what will make it great again.
People like Gwen Ifill.
“When she shall die,
Take her and cut her out in little stars,
And she will make the face of heaven so fine
That all the world will be in love with night
And pay no worship to the garish sun.”
537
Thank you for that beautiful poem and your words along with David Brooks' that we are all feeling. The poem reminds me of Leonard Cohen's Ring the Bells, "there is a crack in everything, that's how the light gets in", he is another beautiful soul we just lost. These two souls' light will continue to shine from the Light that has not been extinguished but is around and within us all. We must lift ourselves to be the Light that helps balance the darkness we see.
3
Leela12....that 'poem' belongs to the great William Shakespeare, just for the record.
3
Socrates,
This week we lost Leonard Cohen and our our friend and benefactor on the other side of the border.
Today we are celebrating the 40th anniversary of the election of Rene Levesque's Parti Quebecois government.
Forty years ago we elected a government dedicated to the break-up of Canada. Forty years ago Quebec voted for real change and we really got it. Nobody said the answer is No! or Hell No. We talked and we talked and we talked and we talked and today Canada and her constitution is the model for the world especially for democracies and heterogenous societies. Our democracy is strong and our people are optimistic.
I too will miss Gwen Ifill but the country she loved died before she did.
The hammer of justice is made of foam, the bell of freedom rings no more and somebody changed the words to the song about the love between my brothers and sisters all over this land. Almost half of the American electorate has rejected my wife's America. My wife is still in despair and much of my day is spent trying to find words of consolation.
America has no Rene Levesque whose love of people was greater than his dream of a sovereign Quebec. Today I am proud to call myself a Quebecer, I may be an Anglophone but Quebec looks and feels like my kind of country.
There are many people who like Gwen Ifill believed in the promise of America but sometimes irreconcilable difference is irreconcilable.
This week we lost Leonard Cohen and our our friend and benefactor on the other side of the border.
Today we are celebrating the 40th anniversary of the election of Rene Levesque's Parti Quebecois government.
Forty years ago we elected a government dedicated to the break-up of Canada. Forty years ago Quebec voted for real change and we really got it. Nobody said the answer is No! or Hell No. We talked and we talked and we talked and we talked and today Canada and her constitution is the model for the world especially for democracies and heterogenous societies. Our democracy is strong and our people are optimistic.
I too will miss Gwen Ifill but the country she loved died before she did.
The hammer of justice is made of foam, the bell of freedom rings no more and somebody changed the words to the song about the love between my brothers and sisters all over this land. Almost half of the American electorate has rejected my wife's America. My wife is still in despair and much of my day is spent trying to find words of consolation.
America has no Rene Levesque whose love of people was greater than his dream of a sovereign Quebec. Today I am proud to call myself a Quebecer, I may be an Anglophone but Quebec looks and feels like my kind of country.
There are many people who like Gwen Ifill believed in the promise of America but sometimes irreconcilable difference is irreconcilable.
1
Thank you for this tribute to Gwen Ifill, David. She was a superb and principled journalist and communicator, and I will remember her with respect and affection.
We are much the poorer for her loss.
We are much the poorer for her loss.
50
Thank you, David Brooks, for your lovely tribute to your friend Gwen Ifill. Your encomium brought me to tears for the 7th time today. I must admit that it took me a second before the penny dropped: but of course, you KNEW Gwen! You worked with her nearly every Friday for the past three years, and more often in election season. What an opportunity you had!
And in that realization I was envious -- but in the nicest possible way. You are fortunate to have been loved by her (and I would love to see some of your photos of Gwen!.
And in that realization I was envious -- but in the nicest possible way. You are fortunate to have been loved by her (and I would love to see some of your photos of Gwen!.
32
I am shocked and saddened to hear of Gwen's passing. I took her level headed, insightful, professional approach to journalism for granted for many years. She harkened back to the old days , when it was just the facts, thank you very much, and the viewer could come to their own conclusions. She was a much welcomed respite from some of the twisted trash that populates ubiquitous media. I will miss her so much. Rest in peace Gwen.
27
"But I confess, when I looked at the front of The Times website on Monday and saw a photo of Stephen K. Bannon, on leave from Breitbart as chairman and rising in power, and then underneath it a photo of Gwen, who is passing from this world, I wanted to throw up. This is not progress and this is not good news."
Thank you David for that vivid picture. Sadly many Trumpeters will see this as progress and good news, when Breitbart replaces the PBS News Hour as the agent of information and influence.
Thank you David for that vivid picture. Sadly many Trumpeters will see this as progress and good news, when Breitbart replaces the PBS News Hour as the agent of information and influence.
35
I've been wanting to throw up since last Tuesday night. The only plus side is all the weight I'll lose.
I'd like to think these four years will be our darkest hours after which I hope the reality tv presidency fever will break.
I'd like to think these four years will be our darkest hours after which I hope the reality tv presidency fever will break.
4
I can't remember when I've been this sad at losing someone I never met. I cried when I heard the news, and cried through the News Hour last night, most of which was devoted to Gwen. Now you've got me going again today! The more I learn about Gwen from her colleagues and friends like you, the deeper my loss feels. We have all lost someone wonderful--but how lucky we were to have her! Thank you.
122
Yes, thank you, David Brooks.... and yes, lots of crying this past week.
2
Gwen will be missed - enjoyed seeing her on the Newshour!
10
Such a shock, and condolences to her family, friends, and to you, Mr. Brooks.
I'm a regular PBS viewer, and when she joined the team, I was captured by her intelligence and professionalism. It's telling that she kept a distance from the Obamas, as it would've been so easy to to be in their orbit of friendship and lose some of that journalistic edge.
When I saw that she was the host of Washington Week, I started recording and viewing that. If she wasn't hosting, I simply didn't watch.
You just knew that there was a lot going on behind that big smile of hers.
Another collective shot to the country's gut.
I'm a regular PBS viewer, and when she joined the team, I was captured by her intelligence and professionalism. It's telling that she kept a distance from the Obamas, as it would've been so easy to to be in their orbit of friendship and lose some of that journalistic edge.
When I saw that she was the host of Washington Week, I started recording and viewing that. If she wasn't hosting, I simply didn't watch.
You just knew that there was a lot going on behind that big smile of hers.
Another collective shot to the country's gut.
35
I loved Gwen. She was so smart. Even though you knew she had a bias, she did not show it on Washington Week. Thank you for your personal tribute. You were lucky to have her as a friend.
19
Ever since I have heard, and been deeply saddened, by Gwen Ifil's death I, too, keep thinking of that contrast....her death and Donald Trump''s rise....life is just not fair.
My heart goes out to her family, friends and colleagues....
My heart goes out to her family, friends and colleagues....
39
Thank you David. Beautiful.
29
Mr. Brooks, that was one of the most wonderful columns you've ever written. Thank you for putting a loving touch on an incredibly sad loss.
366
I agree wholeheartedly.
My deepest condolences to you and your professional family. I have only known Gwen Ifill on the screen. Still it feels as though a friend has died.
65
She was one of the best and we were the better for having her in our lives. She will be missed.
28
I liked Gwen Ifill and I will miss her. She reported the news and I was never quite sure what her personal politics were. That is as it should be.
28
What a tribute. I'm teary eyed and feel your loss. Peace.
41
Congratulations, it was great.
9
Thank you for a thoughtful and introspective tribute to an incredible woman and journalist. Especially poignant were those shared intimate moments which showed the Gwen we her readers and viewers never had the privilege of seeing. It seems every time I am ready to be done with you Mr. Brooks for being to conservative, or not harsh or critical enough of the GOP and especially the deepest , darkest issues they champion you show us that indeed you are a deep and thoughtful thinker with an eye towards what is right and best for America. Indeed as you point out, Gwen Ifill was all that was best and hopeful about America, whereas Steve Bannon is what we need to be most vigilant and guard against. I must admit, it sounds much more effective coming form someone like you as opposed to those of us on the left., and for that I again thank you.
60
It defies imagination that you could do anything to diminish "The NewsHour," so Gwen woul want us to ask, "Like what?"
12
Thank you for your loving tribute, David. The contrast on the homepage of NYT yesterday could not have been greater, as you stated. But I think there are young African-American journalists who are on their way to follow Ms. Ifill's path and example, and some are even at your own newspaper. Let's support them.
49
thanks David.... a giant was among us....
15
A light has gone out in the void but fear not. It has sparked and kindled others to carry on. The light never goes out, it just moves on as well the darkness knows. The battle, if you wish to think of it this way, is eternal. My best to the Ifill family.
John~
American Net'Zen
John~
American Net'Zen
16
Thank you David for your heart-wrenching article. Gwen was a classy person, and truly in a class of her own. Our deepest condolences to the PBS Newshour family, and to journalists everywhere who are grieving for a loss of one of your best, and of a good and kind soul.
51
I got the wonderful opportunity to met her. She was gracious, intelligent, articulate, professional, attractive and an inspiration to me and so many others. She lived a purpose driving life!. GOD is most certainly smiling.
17
Gwen Ifill probably did not know how much of a fixture she had become in the homes of white families across America. She was comforting because of her competence, her uncompromising integrity and her smile. My wife and I will miss Gwen Ifill. She was a dear friend we never met.
As David Brooks notes, what a contrast between Gwen Ifill, a valuable national asset, and newly appointed Stephen Bannon, the self-important protector of racists and purveyor of fake news.
As David Brooks notes, what a contrast between Gwen Ifill, a valuable national asset, and newly appointed Stephen Bannon, the self-important protector of racists and purveyor of fake news.
201
@sdw: When I read David Brooks' column today, I didn't think of Bannon. I thought of Trump. This narcissisitc, mean-spirited man of no substance desperately wants to be worshipped. Gwen Ifill was the real thing. She didn't seek fame; it found her as a result of real accomplishment, and she wore it lightly. The enormous praise she is receiving from a huge number of good people who genuinely admired her is well deserved. What a contrast.
18
Beautifully said.
11
Once again, Mr. Brooks, you remind us of what is best in humanity. Ms. Ifill was certainly that. Thank you.
16
On election nite, I was tuned in to PBS to follow the returns and became increasingly irked at the shock shown by PBS journalists and pundits. The line that was the most difficult to stomach was, "what do these people want?", meaning, the Trump voters.
I wondered, where is Gwen Ifill? We needed HER questions, HER insights and musings to balance the stone deaf utterances of the people leading the news hour program.
Well, now we know. She was living her last days on this earth, and her light was going out of this realm. How symbolic. How tragic for us. How disappointing for her to not be able to participate in covering this mass revolt against the Washington/NYTimes tribes.
David, this is absolutely the best column you have ever written of which I am aware. You have been quite genuine and soul-searching in a much more "real" way of late. I so appreciate the way that you have honored the life of this amazing person with whom we have observed events of the world. Yes she will be terribly, terribly missed. There is emptiness, a bleak void absent Gwen.
I have searched for role models and have been at a loss for being able to name a single one, nearly all of my life. But I now realize...Gwen is exactly the role model I sought. The smile, the real joy and sunny outlook that she exuded, along with that tough demand for excellence. I tuned into PBS to listen to her, above everyone else.
We love you Gwen, individually and collectively. Grief beyond words, truly.
I wondered, where is Gwen Ifill? We needed HER questions, HER insights and musings to balance the stone deaf utterances of the people leading the news hour program.
Well, now we know. She was living her last days on this earth, and her light was going out of this realm. How symbolic. How tragic for us. How disappointing for her to not be able to participate in covering this mass revolt against the Washington/NYTimes tribes.
David, this is absolutely the best column you have ever written of which I am aware. You have been quite genuine and soul-searching in a much more "real" way of late. I so appreciate the way that you have honored the life of this amazing person with whom we have observed events of the world. Yes she will be terribly, terribly missed. There is emptiness, a bleak void absent Gwen.
I have searched for role models and have been at a loss for being able to name a single one, nearly all of my life. But I now realize...Gwen is exactly the role model I sought. The smile, the real joy and sunny outlook that she exuded, along with that tough demand for excellence. I tuned into PBS to listen to her, above everyone else.
We love you Gwen, individually and collectively. Grief beyond words, truly.
248
I share your outrage at their collective befuddlement and confusion at her absence. It appears that they relied on her to do their jobs.
1
Thank you, David, for this gracious memoriam.
18
An intelligent light has gone out, just when we need it most.
50
Thank you for sharing your personal memories and feelings about Gwen Ifill in a beautiful eulogy. My husband and I appreciate the whole team at the NewsHour, but you really captured Gwen's special contribution to it. What a smile! We wondered why she had been absent and worried it might be illness. Still, we were shocked and saddened to read of her death. We will miss her.
31
Yeah. Thanks.
4
Amen. Intelligent, Charming, and that Smile.
9
"...when I looked at the front of the Times website on Monday and saw a photo of Stephen K. Bannon, on leave from Breitbart as chairman and rising in power, and then underneath it a photo of Gwen, who is passing from this world, I wanted to throw up."
Amen!
Amen!
469
I have been sickened ever since last Tuesday.
3
as people celebrate the life of Gwen Ifill, no one seems to mention Charlene Hunter Gault who broke many more racial barriers, at greater personal risk, than did ms. Ifill. It seems unfair to both individuals not to mention her.
2
I love Charlayne Hunter Gault. She is very much alive, thankfully, and spoke about her loss last night on the Newshour. She is still very much able to speak for herself.
This is a tribute to Gwen Ifill, gone from us too soon, by David Brooks, who worked with her for many years and was her friend.
It is not unfair to pay tribute to one's friend.
This is a tribute to Gwen Ifill, gone from us too soon, by David Brooks, who worked with her for many years and was her friend.
It is not unfair to pay tribute to one's friend.
17
Thank you for remembering Gwen Ifil. As one of the many who only knew her from afar, it is good to hear that she was even more appreciated by those knew her as a colleague. I really valued her ability to simultaneously be insightful, level headed and open.
25
But I confess, when I looked at the front of The Times website on Monday and saw a photo of Stephen K. Bannon, on leave from Breitbart as chairman and rising in power, and then underneath it a photo of Gwen, who is passing from this world, I wanted to throw up. This is not progress and this is not good news.
David, I couldn't agree with you more. I'm sorry for the loss of your friend. I'm sorry for all of us. Gwen Ifill was a class act.
David, I couldn't agree with you more. I'm sorry for the loss of your friend. I'm sorry for all of us. Gwen Ifill was a class act.
162
One can only hope that she was not aware enough her last few days to know the results of the election or of the Bannon appointment....I prefer to think of her not having to know....rest in peace, what a smile!
4
Superb eulogy of an exceptional woman and journalist. Thank you, David.
164
Gwen Ifill will be missed.
8
Thank You David, this is some tribute and it inspires me. Many is the day, while in the US, that I spent the evening watching quality news anchoring, ala Ifill Style. She will be sorely missed and needed. Gwen transcended the bickering that took place at other networks and seemed ideal for the PBS News. It is with some sadness that I never had the opportunity to see Ms. Ifill really enjoying herself and letting it all hang out. May she be graciously be received in the hereafter with a firm welcome statement, "Welcome Gwen, you did a great job."
Mr. Brooks, you have proven that truly educated intelligent people are the ones who truly appreciate real knowledge. The ignorant and foolish know not what they do and will carry even the best of the rest to the same hell with them. As Mayor Michael Bloomberg said, "Heaven help us."
Mr. Brooks, you have proven that truly educated intelligent people are the ones who truly appreciate real knowledge. The ignorant and foolish know not what they do and will carry even the best of the rest to the same hell with them. As Mayor Michael Bloomberg said, "Heaven help us."
46
I love Gwen Ifill. It was the only moment in TV journalism I felt really safe, like when I'm really stressed and my two cats make their nest on my lap and the stress dissolves with their purrs. The Newshour panels are about the only ones I can watch without having to brace myself from the sheer ignorance and arrogance spewing. When Gwen smiled, I would smile without even realizing it. I love Judy too, but oh how to move on without the other side of that polished gold coin? It will be harder to elevate ourselves above the stinking mud bog of distorted leadership metastasizing before our eyes. But Gwen showed us it is possible.
45
@SF Patte: " the stinking mud bog of distorted leadership metastasizing before our eyes."
Thank you for this perfect statement of what we have to face. I'm reminded of Claudius in I, Claudius, who says "Let all of the poisons that lurk in the mud hatch out." And they are. For a tiny bit of solace, perhaps Gwen has been shielded from this.
Thank you for this perfect statement of what we have to face. I'm reminded of Claudius in I, Claudius, who says "Let all of the poisons that lurk in the mud hatch out." And they are. For a tiny bit of solace, perhaps Gwen has been shielded from this.
17
Thank you Gwen. Thank you so much.
19
Thank you for this, David. Your personal and obvious affection for Gwen Ifel is moving, and your clear-eyed understanding of the threshold we have crossed is devastating. Indeed, journalistic poise has left the building. Words that inform are replaced by words that incite. Phrases that uplift are replaced by memes that slap down. Sentences that clarify are replaced by tweets that vilify.
The age of Bannon has arrived. Gwen Ifel, you will be missed.
The age of Bannon has arrived. Gwen Ifel, you will be missed.
35
Thank you God for Gwen...
13
Before crying yesterday upon hearing the sad news, I don't know when I had last cried about the death of a famous person. Maybe never. I think there was no one living whom I admired more.
32
Thank you, David Brooks, for this most touching and beautifully written -- and funny, like Gwen Ifill herself. Now you have to write about how we can honor her in the future. She was not just an inspiration to black and female journalists but to all those who felt they didn't quite fit into the mold but knew they had something to give. Bless you, Mr. Brooks. Please write more about her.
22
Mr. Brooks, what a handsome tribute! I must confess that I...no, I won't sully this with a snarky Shakespearean "aside" that rips open a wound that it was, on its face, meant to close.
I envy very much your relationship with Ms. Ifill. With her you were able to reap many riches of the sort unattainable by the most of the rest of us. You have the talent that put you in her orbit, or she in yours; I'm not sure which is more (politically) correct, but I hope that you take my meaning.
I once worked as a researcher at a major Midwestern newspaper, one of the Times's great competitors. Isabel Wilkerson, in 1994, won a Pulitzer prize for feature writing about the devastating floods, right under our noses. The organizational humiliation was palpable.
This reference to Ms. Wilkerson is also testament to the departed Ms. Ifill for it demonstrated that African-American women could, indeed, contribute stories and songs about the great American experience, the great tapestry. Both ladies jump-started the careers of countless young women of color--and not only in the United States--to think and to write. They had stories to tell, too, and they were determined, in spite of all obstacles, to have them told, push-back executives and editors be damned.
On this long downward slope on which we, as a nation, seem deeply engaged, the loss of your friend Gwen, is particularly disturbing. I mourn for her family and for you, her beloved colleague.
It is we who should envy her. God bless you.
I envy very much your relationship with Ms. Ifill. With her you were able to reap many riches of the sort unattainable by the most of the rest of us. You have the talent that put you in her orbit, or she in yours; I'm not sure which is more (politically) correct, but I hope that you take my meaning.
I once worked as a researcher at a major Midwestern newspaper, one of the Times's great competitors. Isabel Wilkerson, in 1994, won a Pulitzer prize for feature writing about the devastating floods, right under our noses. The organizational humiliation was palpable.
This reference to Ms. Wilkerson is also testament to the departed Ms. Ifill for it demonstrated that African-American women could, indeed, contribute stories and songs about the great American experience, the great tapestry. Both ladies jump-started the careers of countless young women of color--and not only in the United States--to think and to write. They had stories to tell, too, and they were determined, in spite of all obstacles, to have them told, push-back executives and editors be damned.
On this long downward slope on which we, as a nation, seem deeply engaged, the loss of your friend Gwen, is particularly disturbing. I mourn for her family and for you, her beloved colleague.
It is we who should envy her. God bless you.
19
A very heart-warming piece on this evidently strong, dedicated and professional woman. As long as there are even a few people like her left in your profession, the Bannons of the world will fade in history.
14
Thank you David... I also trust that many of your readers saw the beautiful nearly hour long "News Hour" eulogy by the many of our most articulate and brilliant journalists who spoke lovingly, eloquently, and in great detail about Ms Ifell's spirit, friendship, and lasting legacy. I pray that she was beyond consciousness when the results of this election were being announced, and that she died believing that our "better angels" prevailed during this tragic election season, made more so by her untimely passing. James Landi
65
I was blindsided by the news that Gwen Ifill had died. After the initial shock, my reaction was a selfish one. I thought, not now. We need her. With the chaos that is hurtling toward us, there aren't many solid, rational voices that we can depend on not to pander to an audience or sensationalize the news to boost ratings. The nightly news programs have little depth, and exist mostly to run ads for prescription drugs. But the programs Gwen Ifill presided over consisted of news, in depth, rationally discussed and professionally presented.
In reading about her experiences starting out as an African-American newswoman, it was no surprise to hear that she had had to get over hurdles that made it harder for her to achieve the success that she so rightly deserved, and that she ultimately obtained.
There's a grim irony to the timing of her passing, as those same forces are once more on the rise. Her very presence demonstrated that they were wrong then, and they're wrong now. As we mourn her loss, we also mourn the recrudescence of a vile element that we thought was on the wane.
We'll never know how many other Barack Obamas and Gwen Ifills were unfairly denied a chance to flourish. We can only be grateful for those who made it through the gauntlet, and hope that by their example the passage will be easier for those who follow.
In reading about her experiences starting out as an African-American newswoman, it was no surprise to hear that she had had to get over hurdles that made it harder for her to achieve the success that she so rightly deserved, and that she ultimately obtained.
There's a grim irony to the timing of her passing, as those same forces are once more on the rise. Her very presence demonstrated that they were wrong then, and they're wrong now. As we mourn her loss, we also mourn the recrudescence of a vile element that we thought was on the wane.
We'll never know how many other Barack Obamas and Gwen Ifills were unfairly denied a chance to flourish. We can only be grateful for those who made it through the gauntlet, and hope that by their example the passage will be easier for those who follow.
735
Thank you.
14
Thank you so much, David
5
WEEP for America! Bereft of one. Saddled with the other.