Shopping for Fireplace Tools

Dec 02, 2019 · 18 comments
Tim (44231)
Ridiculous. Folderol for the 1%. No attempt to highlight even one set of tools, reasonably priced, that the majority of Americans and your readers could afford or value. Useless balderdash catering to the elite.
dwalker (San Francisco)
The New York Times is a leader in the cottage industry of publishing articles on "What can I do in my personal life to mitigate climate change?" And now this. Jeez.
Linda (Virginia)
Or, you could save a bundle by going to an estate sale and picking up a nice set for $25.
Elizabeth (Charlottesville)
Tractor Supply has the nicest 14” set...I’m an architect...
beaconps (CT)
The most useful tool is not offered, it is a small hoe for moving the coals forward when new logs are added. The radiant heat from the coals heats the house while the logs in the back burn down to coals. A medium size shovel with a short wooden handle and a small hoe with a short wooden handle are all you need. When it is time for a new log, pull coals forward, balance log between the shovel and hoe and gently slide it into position. Many new stove-fireplace combos are lined with fire brick including a top baffle so logs must be loaded gently.
Outsider in Utah (Teasdale, UT)
Years ago, I purchased a robust, hinged metal tool that is good for every fireplace need except sweeping and scooping the ashes. I believe it cost $35. It's had lots of use and still looks as good as the day I bought it. I wonder if that can be said for all the pretty products shown in the article.
B. (Brooklyn)
Re sweeping: Don't -- until the ashes are dead-cold. And if you do sweep, leave the ashes in the metal pail. Or take them way outdoors. I might be a bit pyrophobic, but that's better than the house burning down. It can take a couple of days before there's no risk of an ember.
nwsnowboarder (Everett, WA)
Wow, and to think I got a perfectly functional set at the Salvation Army for $5.
LexDad (Boston)
It would be helpful if you could have had a Peleton bike in each of the pictures so I could tell which expensive set will best match the aesthetic of my Peleton (which of course is the focal point of my room right in front of the fireplace, the other focal point). I mean seriously, why else have a fireplace?
Larry (Cape Cod, MA)
I agree with B. from Brooklyn. Having sold hundreds of pieces of antique and vintage fireplace equipment over the years the market has faded, replaced by battery remotes and a flames behind glass. Andirons I used to get $500 for go begging when trying to get $95 for them. Same for tools. Reuse and recycle!! Find something better for a lot less money and take yourself out to eat with the extra money!!!
pbilsky (Manchester Center, VT)
LL Bean. Way cheaper
JammieGirl (CT)
The only set with "tongs" that are hinged allowing one to securely grab, lift and reposition large pieces is the Henry set. Unfortunately, the Henry shovel is a joke and the handles aren't very comfortable looking.
Tuvw Xyz (Evanston, Illinois)
Thank you, Mr. McKeogh, for this reminder of a fireplace. Ours and the tools appertaining thereto came with the now 110-year-old house, probably passed on from even earlier owners, but used by us rarely.
B. (Brooklyn)
Antique stores have hundreds of them, better made. And, for those who care, "green" in that they're old and used. My fireplace tools came with the house, but the holder I purchased from an antiques barn. A good mantra: Buy old!
Mike (Ohio)
Lowes - $25.00
Ann (Virginia)
I am lucky enough to have the tools my grandfather made
what about the environment (MD)
Pinty 5 Pieces Rustic Fireplace Tools Set $46 delivered from Amazon.
C. Carpenter (Boston, MA)
We purchased the Eldvarm Emma Fireplace Tool Set and matching Log Basket a couple years ago from Lekker Home. The design and detail is beautiful. The rugged steel construction, brass hardware, leather wrapped and hardwood handles is stunning. Real attention to detail. We have it next to a Danish built Morso wood burning stove. It's the perfect design compliment. And it's not just nice to look at. Typical of Scandinavian design, the form has lots of function. We love the fact that the fire tool caddy has an ash trap at the bottom. So everything is organized, compact and tidy. Perfect.