What’s Going On in This Picture? | Feb. 27, 2017

Feb 27, 2017 · 575 comments
n (f)
I think that it was a mid-air collision over a populated area, possibly Detroit or New York
Hello (New York )
I wish my teacher would call on me had my hand up whole time and I just get skipped!
Speech (Milwaukee, Wisconsin)
I saw ones half of the plane that actually crashed in one of the buildings but one survived the crash and died the next day. it was 60 years ago.
Tuesday group (MS 74)
This was in Lundan rip to the poilts :(
IC (MS 74)
I think the plane crashed in Manhattan in 1950. It was a United Airline plane, I saw smoke, there is dry ice everywhere, and there is a fire hose to keep the fire out. The picture is in black and white that tells us that it happened in the past in 1950.
Keirra (Memphis)
this article was amazing it was full of sadness and loneiness
Speech Group (NewYork)
6th grade: We think that there was an airplane crash in New York City in the middle of the winter. We noticed that there was the tail of the airplane. Also, we noticed that there was snow in the photo and the people were wearing heavy jackets and boots. We think that there was fire because there was smoke and a long hose. This photo is very old because it is in black and white and the street lights was very old.
Speech Group (NewYork)
we think that there was a plane crash in London. We see a hole on the ground and a oil spill. We think that there was a fire because there was smoke in the air. In our opinion this photograph happened in the old in days because it was black and white and the people where wearing old clothes.
Sandra (1L)
This picture attracts me enormously. Firstly this photo is in black and white. In the foreground I can se a lot of pipes on the floor. In the foreground I can observe that there are planty of people in circles. There are in front of a plane which is destroy
Ambie (Minnesota)
This looks like a plane crash in London, it looks like it might've hit the building because it's smoking and there's pieces of the plane scattered. It might've happen in the 1950's because the cars are old schooled and not like the modern cars we have today.
mike (HF)
I think this photo is about a plane crash in london on accident due to the weather or on purpose to crash into a building. I saw a part of a plane in the road. Then I saw snow on the ground, smoke from a building, and in the air. I thinks its from london because I saw long pointy buildings and those types of buildings are usually in london. I think the time period was 1950’s because the cars in the picture were a old type of car that we don’t use in 2017.
sophia (harborfields)
I think this photo is that a plane crashed in london. The plane crashed because the weather was bad and it was foggy.

In this photo i see fancy cars and snow on the ground and fog in the air. I see a half of a plane in the road.
I think the time period is 1997 because the cars look modern.
Alyanna Rodrigues (boston)
in this pic it looks like there are ppl are trying to put out fire bc it loooks like the plan ad crashed and it got on fire so they trying to put it out
Aaliyah D. tm2 (McKinley SEA Middle School)
This appears to be a plane crash. It looks like it's Winter time cause there's some snow on the ground. There are a bunch of pipes on the ground, and everyone is surrounding the plane. There's a bunch of steam and fog in the air.
bob the builder (school)
looks like 9?11 all ovedr again with liquid nitrogen
Thailer Ehrensbeck (Town of Webb)
What i see in this picture is a plane crash in a city. It seems to be winter because every one is where wearing big coats and there is snow on the ground. What is left of the plain is the tail and it says United on the back of it . There are fire hoses scattered about among the floor so there was an obvious effort to put out a fire . The streets have deris of other buildings and pieces of plane. The tail of the plane is in the middle of a intersection in a city. It's like a war scene.
VTS Moderator (Under your bed)
Nice, I love that you are researching to back up your thoughts. Do you think you could have found some more details about this photo?
student (ok)
On December 6, 1960, a deadly United Airlines plane crashed on the corner of Sterling Place and Seventh Avenue.
Tyler Rudolph (Old Forge, NY)
From this picture, it seems that a United Airlines flight crashed in some city. This crash was probably pretty bad, because of the wreckage seen in the photo. The whole back end of the plane was separated from the rest of the plane. Because the fire hose is strewn on the ground, I would guess that whatever fire there was has already been put out. This also makes sense because of the large crowd gathering around the wreckage.
anahis rodriguez (Rochester NY.)
Based on the details of the photo I infer that an airplane was flying and then something happened in the and as it was totally uncontrolled and crashed on the ground in the middle of the city of New York because i see a plane crash in the floor It is in New York because there is a building, there are towers, as there is a sign that I designed in English not parking and it is also very cold as you can see the snow on the floor along with the firemen there is a lot of smoke, fire, And car ...
Joseliz Rivera (Rochester NY)
Based on the details of the photo I infer that a airplane c rash in that city and crash a building and of the building is coming out smoke and I think that is winter because is snow in the floor and everybody is with a coat and I think to that was in New York because is snow in the street and it look like is very cold because everybody have a coat and I think that the airplane exploted because I see fireman there.
Rachel Smith (Old Forge)
In this black and white photo there is a end of a plane in the middle of the street. The plane is burnt and steaming, which means the firemen would have put the fire out. But the damage was already done, the people appear to be just watching, ie: the man with his arms behind his back looking relaxed. This must have been a long time ago due to the black and white and old fashioned truck.
Itzel Cienfuegos (Tempe AZ)
I see in the picture the wing of an airplane that fell down and is placed in the middle of the street; maybe someone injured.This photo looks like it happened in the past and we can say that because of how people is dressing. Also the cars don't look like the cars these days.
Window 8 (MHS)
We see a plane part in the middle of the street. We think it is in North London because of how the houses look. We think it may be a photo from the early 20th century. If it had been a plane crash, there would have been more buildings damaged. Perhaps just the tail fell. We think it may be from a war.
Shawn Hansen (Old Forge)
Wow, I didn't even think about war being a factor in the crash. Thanks for this fantastic comment.
Sebastian Contreras (School)
From what I can see, it is an airplane that crashed in the middle of a city. Also the wing of the plane says United which is/was an airplane company. Another comment that I want to say is that everyone is gathered around the plane and they are all wearing heavy coats which basically means that it is cold outside. Last but not least the picture also must have been taken a long time ago because not only is it in black and white but the clothes they are wearing don't seem up to date.
Chau Pham (Tempe, Arizona)
I see an United airplane's tail on the street. I think it was an airplane crash. It was burned, because there are many firefighters, smoke, water tapes, journalists, and the road is wet. I think it took place in England many many years ago.
parner's (Tempe,AZ)
In this photo we see a plane crash in winter. The tail of the plane is broken apart from the body and the firefighters put out what must have been a fire on the plane. We think this photo takes place somewhere in the late 50s. This is because not only is the photo in black and white, but the cars are older. Also the woman's on the photo are wearing out dated clothes.
Tyler Rudolph (Old Forge, NY)
I totally agree with what you've observed. This photo is probably from the early 1940's or 1950's, based on the cars and fashion pictured. And from the protective suits the firefighters are wearing.
Woodlands (Waterloo, Ontario)
We see a plane part in the middle of the street. We think it is in North America. We think it may be a photo from the early 20th century. If it had been a plane crash, there would have been more buildings damaged. Perhaps just the tail fell. We think it may be from a war.
cullenrose (tow)
I think this is a pictures of a plane crash in NY, because of the fire escapes, and the rental truck from NY. The way the people are dressed and the cars in the picture make me think it must be in the 50's or 60's. It looks like it was during the winter. because they are wearing coats and standing around snow. It looks like the crash is being investigated, because there are officers and firefighters, helping and looking around.
Itzel Cienfuegos (Tempe AZ)
I disagree with you cullenrose because it looks like a different city; it looks like London or something like that I say that because of the turrets.
Brittany (Old Forge)
In the photo its seems to be a devastating day. It looks like it's in the 50’s or sometime back because of the fire fighting uniforms. They are not like the common ones you see today. I think it's in the winter time because there is snow on the ground. Maybe more towards spring because there isn't a lot of snow. There is an airplanes that crashed in the middle of the street. It might have caught on fire because of the amount of smoke in the air as well as the firefighters. There might be more wreckage behind where the picture was take because there is a fire fighting hose stood up pointing away from the part of the plane in the picture.
Alex Sutherland (Old Forge, NY)
In this photo a United Airlines photo has crashed in New York City in winter. The tail of the plane is broken apart from the body and is show here while firefighters put out what must have been a fire on the plane. This photo takes place somewhere in the late 50s to early 60s. This is because not only is the photo in black and white, but the vehicles are older, but they can't be that old because women in the photo are wearing pants. The truck on the left side says NY, so this photo must be in New York City.
Rachel Smith (Old Forge)
You are right, but women started wearing pants earlier such as in the 1920s and 1930s.
Joseph Townsend (Old Forge, NY)
In the photo shows a crashed plane in the middle of the street with the words United on the tail fin. It is early winter or early spring since there is still snow all over the ground. People have gathered around to look at the crashed plane and firefighters are on the scene to possibly put out the fire and save any survivors. Judging by the image being in black and white and this was taken sometime in the 50s or 60s. Judging by how the car on the left side of the photo is parked on the right side of the road that this takes place in America and by the design of the building is would guess New York City. I would also guess the plane was a United Airline plane.
Sebastian Contreras (School)
I agree with your idea and all that but I don't agree with you when you say that it was on New York, I think it is England because of the shape of the buildings and the turrets.
Melissa (Hoffman)
Well there is a crashed plane in what looks like a city. The wing of the plane says United as well. Which to me looks like a United Airways plane. There is a truck in the left of the picture that says New York. Everyone is gathered around the plane and they are all wearing heavy coats like it is cold. Also underneath the fire hoses there is a snowbank which is off to the side of the road. This picture also must have been taken a long time ago because not only is it in black and white but the clothes they are wearing don't seem up to date.
Sebastian Contreras (School)
I love what you said and your idea. I'm completely agree with you :D
Abby (Old Forge, NY)
I think that this is a plane crash in the 1900s sometime. It is black and white, have older clothes and buildings. The smoke indicates a fire along with the firemen and hoses. The snow makes me think its the winter and everyone seems to be wearing coats.
parner's (Tempe,AZ)
I agree with you because the smoke show a plane crash. I also agree that the picture takes place in the 1900s. Also that the woman's are wearing a out dated clothes and also I agree that it was in winter season.
Shelby Mayeu (Old Forge)
In this picture there is a lot happening. I see a piece of a plane in the middle of the road. I think this means that there was a airplane crash. There is a fire truck hose lying on the ground all the way to the piece of the plane, there must of been a fire or some sort. There is a word on the plane that says United so this plane could have been from the United States. It looks really gloomy and dark. This picture is black and white so I’m guessing this photo was taken back in the day.
Britney Levi (Old Forge)
In this photo there seems to be a plane crash in the middle of a street of a town or city. All you can really see in the picture is the wing of the plane. On the wing there are large letters spelling “United” so I could assume that this is a United States airplane. It also must take place in somewhere with english language because all of the street signs are in english. Several people are gathered around the crash. There are also fire hoses on the ground along with firemen so you could assume the plane caught on fire. There is snow on the ground so it must take place in the winter. The photo is in black and white so it might have taken place in the 1900’s or earlier.
David Ehrensbeck (Old Forge, NY)
In this photo, I see what looks like a plane crash in a densely populated neighborhood. There appear to be fire crews, and police on the scene, fighting fires, and directing people. Also the photo is in black and white, and I don’t know what the weather or time of day is. Judging by the shape of the aircraft part, I would say that this took place in the late 50’s or the early 60’s.
Glasgow MS Lang/Lit Smith period 7 Students (Alexandria, VA)
Update from Period 1 - Thursday am. We think this is in America - New York. We know it is from the past because of the way the people are dressed, the car in the bottom right of the picture, the older street lamps, and the wide streets. Also, we were able to figure out it was New York because of the signage on the truck and the architecture of the city. We think something happened mid-air to cause the plane to fall to the ground - it could not have flown into the building - the damage would have been greater (the building would not still be standingl)...some think it may be a film set also.
What3231 (Illinois)
I'm wondering where the women are. I can't seem to find any. That makes me wonder about it being United Airlines debris in mid-century New York--my original guess.
Alyanna Rodrigues (boston)
in this picture its seems like there was a plane crash and ppl saw that it happened so all the ppl went to go see what happened and went to go help whoever was in the plane and who was hurt, but yeah that's my opinion and this is what i think is going on in the picture....
TBD (MA)
wreckage on 7th avenue from a 1960 mid-air plane crash
michele (Toronto)
I think it's the United plane crash in Brooklyn. I don't know the year, but would guess from the clothing that it might be the '60s. I remember hearing about a plane crash there when I lived in Brooklyn, and the silhouette of the buildings down the street is familiar to me - 7th Avenue? One of the avenues in Park Slope, anyway. The No Parking sign is definitely a New York sign, as it has those alternate side of the street parking hours that drive you crazy and eventually bring you to giving up your car.
Stephen Gonsalves (Wrightsville Beach, NC)
This is just after the 1960 mid-air collision of two planes over NY. It was winter, snow on the ground, and the plane shown here caused fires on the ground in Brooklyn, where it crashed.
Qader (teme)
It's seems like you know everything that happen in this picture. Did you read about this article from somewhere before?
Nick Jr (California)
it is a plane collision crash
Thomas Leto III (Wisconsin)
In this picture looks like a U.S.A plane that went down and landed on this road and I said this might be a plane because of the wing and and a piece of the plane right next it on the right and i said its a U.S.A plane cause it has the word UNITED on the wing but wait is this really a wing cause if you have ever gone to United airlines on the tail of the plain it says UNITED so this is most likely a tail of a UNITED plane
amberleighpederson (St.Germain WI)
In this picture, it looks like it's staged in London because of the ways the building look like. I think it kinda looks like the 9/11 with a part of a plane crashing into a building and with all the smoke and ash but in London. People look like there trying to see what happened but the firefighters and police won't let anyone past that big plane piece because they don't want to anyone to get hurt. I think it also looks like it's from the 19 hundreds because of the black and white.
Aubrey legler (williston elementary)
a plane got wrecked and a tube got everywhere
Sean (TOW)
I see what looks like a mess, maybe even a plane crash. I see a giant triangular shape which looks like a plane wing. I see fire hoses and various valves used for water flow through the hoses. I see building smoking most likely from the plane crashing into it and causing a fire. I see snow banks which means it is most likely winter.
Caitlin Russell (Old Forge, NY)
I believe that in this picture people are gathered around a recent airplane crash. There is a firehose and there seems to be smoke coming from one of the buildings. The photo is in black and white so it is hard to tell what time of day it is. But by looking at the clothing the people are wearing I assume that the picture was taken in the sixties. Also the streets are wide and the signs are in english. So the crash would have had to have happened in a city. Maybe New York City or Los Angeles. There is snow on the ground so this probably happened in March or April.
Eian Knudsen (New York)
What I see in the picture is a plane crash, maybe a United States airline, which people are concerned about. It could possibly be tensions with other countries, but this was or seems to be in the 1900's.
Saul (chico)
After of analyze this picture I think that this occurred in London for the type of constructions and is around the years 60's and I think this because the picture is in black and white also by the way they dressed. I think what happen in the picture was that some people wanted going to United States in times of Christmas but how the weather was not good the plane crashed when taking off and this is I think what happen in the picture.
Eian Knudsen (New York)
I would agree. This could've been during the cold war time period.
Jimmy (Huron)
In a cold day, it looks like a plane cashed. No one knows why it came out of no where.
Abby (Old Forge, NY)
I agree with this, the snow and smoke shows a cold day, and the plane is in half indicating a crash
John Reed (Brooklyn)
It's the tail section of the United DC-8 that crashed in the 1960 NYC airliner collision. It's sitting in a Park Slope intersection just outside of a school. 7th & Sterling Pl. There are pics of the crash inside nearby Gino's Pizza on Flatbush Ave. Here's the story: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1960_New_York_mid-air_collision
Nao (New York)
This is shook! The left wing of a airplane fell in a city and people are watching. The black and white image suggests that the incident occurred at least 50 years ago. It was in winter, supported by the snow in the left below of the picture.
wen (ny)
In this picture we can see a plane crash fall in the city. people went to see what happened there . and we also can see the snow doesn't melt down. some fire hoses lied down on the road.
Mercedesz (New York)
The picture shows a plane crash in New York City maybe at the beginning of the 1960's. The clothes of the people and the car at the right side of the picture are kind of old-school. The sign on the truck at the left side of the picture says Belfort Truck Renting Co. Bklyn, NY. There is a road sign at left says No Parking, and at right, there are street signs. One of them looks like 7 Ave. The road sign and street signs are the same that they use in NYC. The plane that crushed belonged to the United Airlines.
Michael Golder (New York City)
Good observations, Mercedesz! Have a good trip back to Hungary. But remember, you'll always be a New Yorker!
E.K (NY)
A united plane was crushed and there were many people showing it and I guess fire fighter put already out a fire because of smoke causing from fire. Also it occurred in winter because I saw snow in the street.
ayyya (ny)
A air craft crashed in one of the cities in winter of the United States more than 70 years ago. In the early morning, firefighters has done some of their jobs while people come there for working and are shocked at this situation.
pratya (nyc)
From the picture I assume, it was the plane exploded because it was the fire (seem happened on the right of the image).2 The plane belongs to United Airline. 3. It was happened in NY because the truck say that. It might be in the late 1990 because the people outfit, building and car design.4 It was winter because the snow.
yuri (NY)
United air plane crushed. There are many spectators, rescues and it looks like long time ago because it is black and white. People's outfit look also classic and it is in winter and snow. also there is a truck in the left side of the picture and it is written "Truck Renting Co. inc ". It looks like tragedy but not too much because the buildings are remained and things look small.
Oom (NY)
I see the tail of the airplane in the town, but I don't see the fuselage. I think the tail is being transported somewhere by a truck. The truck couldn't make a right turn, and crashed into some other cars.
Michael Golder (New York City)
Interesting theory, Oom! We'll find out tomorrow. Have a good day!
Rachel Smith (Old Forge)
That would be unlikely due to the fact that a truck, at that current time probably didn't have enough strength to hold an entire tail of a plane and fit through a jam packed city.
RJB (Brooklyn)
Plane crash over Park Slope in the 1950's. Two planes collided mid-air and debris rained down on Park Slope Brooklyn. You can see the "United" painted on the airplane tail and the brownstones all around.
Alexis (Old Forge)
In this picture there is a plane crash in a city. There are many people standing around the area to see the crash. There are also fire hoses laying on the ground in front of the crash. On the side of the street there is snow which means that this occurred in the winter. In the background of the picture you can see smoke that came from the plane crash.
Emily (Old Forge)
There appears to be a plane crash. I believe that this plane was involved with the government/air force. The plane crashed in a “large city” and appears to be attracting attention from all people. I say this because on the side of the wing, “United” is written in bold lettering. I think this plane belonged to the United States. This time may have been during a war or an ordinary United States airplane. The city is filled with smug and sum sort of liquid possibly water is flooding the ground. There are pipes everywhere along the ground to drain the water. People are gathering around the site of the plane crash. The full view of the plane is not in site. Mostly the wing is clear to the viewer.
Joy Raimondo (Portland, OR)
A grainy, 1940s photo features a gloomy day in England where a crowd has gathered at the scattered debris of a plane, while smoke billows from a nearby, smoldering laundromat. Emergency services attempt to clear the parts of the plane from the cold, wet streets and extinguish the flames from the laundromat.
Laura Levi (New York)
In this picture I see a lot going on. I see what appears to be an airplane wing. This makes me believe that what is going on is a plane crash. I see a hose on the ground making me think that the plane set on fire. This backs up my statement about the crash. The word united on the plane is very important because it could be a US plane or a United Airline Plane. i also see truck in the background that says New York. The fact that this is a black and white picture makes me think that this plane crash happened in the 1900’s or earlier.
Kaya Pratt (North Carolina)
plane crash in New York City. I think people are trying to see if any one got hurt or if they are any survivors. To tell you the truth, I never thought I'd ever see new York city so gloomy. its so sad
JG (Denver)
It is winter time. People are wearing coats. A United Airline plan crashed in New York City, in the early 60s.
Tate (Houston)
A United Airways plane crashed in the middle of New York City a couple of decades ago. I know the plane belongs to United Airways because of the United symbol on the wing of the plane. The crash happened a few decades ago because the picture is take in black ad white which as uncommon nowadays. Also the firemen and spectators have on clothing and uniforms that look outdated. Finally, the crash took place in New York City because the truck renting company in the background on the left has the words "New York" under the company name and the crash took place in a city based in the tall buildings on the sides of the streets. This picture shows a deadly plane crash in New York City a few decades ago.
chuhao wu (chico)
I saw a plane crashed on the street,and many policemen there.Some people is using the water hose to put out a fire.This place look like in Europe,and it's in the winter,because there's are snow on the ground.
mae (Rich, VA)
I don't see any surrounding damage in the neighborhood, so I'll guess that it is a plane crash scene being filmed for a movie.
Lydia-Grace Madding (Memphis, TN)
I'm assuming there was a plane crash around the fifties due to an ice storm (because of the ice all over the road) and there was a fire because of the hose laying on the ground.
Taylor Clark (Millington)
I cannot imagine that this was a real plane crash because there would have been more damage to the surrounding buildings, as well as more people panicking instead of crowding around it.
Joze Smith (TN)
A plane crashed in the middle of the city. It is destructed, people are gathered around it to see what happened. Smoke fills the air and there are fire hoses, suggesting the plan caught on fire when it crashed.
Daylee Barrom (TRA)
I see that there was a plane crash in the city. People are all around observing the situation. There are fire fighter hoses everywhere, but you don’t see many people helping out. Most of them are just watched and crowing the scenes. It looks cold and wet because it has been raining. There is a lot of smoke from the crash.
Bailey Pitsos (Memphis)
a plane crashed into a city. the firemen/policemen have older uniforms on, so it probably crashed in older times (1900's). there are water hoses. smoke is everywhere. the plane looks like it is in half. united is on the plane wing.
Branson Bitzer (Millington)
The plan went down in the late 50's early 60's its in New York because the moving tuck says Brooklyn New York. The crash also happened sometime in the winter because there is snow on the ground
Hannah Esgro (Memphis)
There is a United Airway plane that crashed in the middle of New York. I know that the plane crashed in New York because the truck in the background says New York. Everyone was probably in shock and that is why they are all gathered around.
Laura Levi (New York)
I totally agree! I think that this photo must have happened in the early 1900's because the picture is in black and white. the people gathered around seem very shocked. There is also a hose which proves the plane crash and a fire.
Adrian..G (Houston)
An airplane that was still new, and from that a plane crashed came a trail from the fallen plane, and lives that where in the plane are lost. Everyone ho was gathered at the site where in shocked that it landed that close to homes.
Mario De La Cruz (Galena Park)
this is probably when a plane crashed back in the old days when planes weren't constructed right so this plane blew up mid air and it hit a near by town
Grace Hurley (Houston)
This picture shows a United plane that has crashed in the middle of a street in New York City; there are a lot of people surrounding the crash, and there are water hoses on the ground close to the plane crash. The setting of this picture looks like New York because of the really tall, skinny, close together buildings surrounding the crash. There is also a street sign in the left of the picture that says, "NO Parking" which is in English, so the picture has to take place somewhere where the general spoken language is English. There is also snow close to the crash and smoke coming from the crash, which shows that the place is cold, and the smoke represents the hot air and cold air mixing, and creating steam. There are policeman circled around the wreakage to keep the many people crowded around out of the scene. There also seem to be fireman to the right next to the plane trying to scope out the crash. Finally there is a street sign on the right of the picture attached to the light post that says "7th Avenue" which is a popular street in New York City. All of these details help me conclude that a United Plane has crashed in New York City on 7th Avenue during winter time.
Taylor Clark (Millington)
I agree with you, because everything you have explained sounds through.
Yennifer (Long Island)
we believe an airplane exploded in NY. I see smoke .I see a lot of people. I see snow. I see a truck. I see a broken airplane. I see a hose to stop afire. i see fire fighters.
Yessica (Long Island)
we belieue an airplane exploded in NY.I see smoke.I see a lot of people.I see snow.I see atruck .I see a car.I see a broken airplane.I see a hose to stop a fire.I see fire fighters.
Nathaly (Long Islan)
we believe an airplane exploded in NY. i see smoke. i see a lot of people. i see snow. i see a track. i see a broken airplane. i see a hose to stop a fire. isee fire fighters.
Josue (Long Island)
We believe an airplane exploded in NY. First, I see the building burning. Next, I see the airplane destroyed. Finally, I see a poster with english words.
Jennifer (Long Island)
We believe an airplane exploded in NY. first, we see a airplane destroyed. Next, We see firefighters. Finally, We see a poster say NY and i think i New York.
Emerson (Long Island)
We believe an airplane exploded in NY. First , I see an airplane. I see smoke. I
see hose . I see firefighters. I see posters with english words.
Sebastian (Long Island)
we believe an airplane exploded in NY. fist, we see a airplane destroyed. Next, we see firefighters. First, We see a poster say NY so i think is New York.
Mariana (Long Island)
We believe an airplane exploded in NY. First the evidence is NY because in the car letters that says NY. Next the 2 evidence is maybe the gas fished an the airplane fell. Finally the 3 evidence is we see the fire fighters because stop fire.
Alex Sutherland (Old Forge, NY)
At first I didn't notice that the truck said NY, great observation!
Edwin (Bay Shore)
We believe an airplane exploded in NY. FIRST our evidence is there is NY because in the car there are the letters that says NY. NEXT maybe the gas finished and the airplane fell. FINALLY we see firefighters because they stop fires.
Joze Smith (TN)
I like that you notice the small details that could mean a lot in finding out what happened.
Jason.C (Houston)
It looks like some parts of a plane that was to torn into parts during it flights, cause there is no other parts or the entire plane there at all.
Daylee Barrom (TRA)
I agree, because I only see part of the wing and body of the plane.
Jose F (Memphis)
It probably crashed because the plane's equipment failed.
Destiny Sanchez (Galena park high school)
united airlines crashed in the middle of a snowy day and it was back in the days .
francisco g (houston texas)
two plains collided mid-air in new york city 134 people died happened on friday december 16 1960
BE (Houston)
there was an airplane crash
melany martinez (houston)
i think there has been a plane crash because we see what looks like the top of the wing of the airplane, and the firefighters are trying to rescue the people
Mia G. (Galena park)
This picture is black and white so I'm assuming this air plane crash was a long time ago in New York. It looks like the plane crash may have been deadly to those inside.
Isac Armenta (Houston)
An American plane that crashed some where in Europe due to fog, looking at the place it looks like it happen in 1940s or 50s due to the way it was took and how the people are dressed.
Branson Bitzer (Millington)
This is more likely in the 1960's due to the design of the plane and the truck says that it is in Brooklyn New York, but you have a good comment.
Isaac A (Houston Tx.)
In this picture, years ago there was a plane crash at New York. It was a snowie raining day. It was to foggy that the plane could not see so he or she lost control.
Bailey Pitsos (Memphis)
women were not allowed to fly aircraft until 1993, so a man was flying the plane
Toph D (Apex)
Not actually true, women were allowed to fly since 1908. It was 1993 a woman was allowed to fly a combat aircraft
kenya jackson (galena park)
in this picture, a very bad event accoured. a plane crashed in the middle of the street with alot of people are scared and devistated of what had happend to the people that was on the plane.
NOVA class (Cache, OK)
My students believe that it is a United Airlines plane crash. Because of the snow on the ground and the people wearing coats. it happened sometime during the winter. The old vehicles and they style of clothing and hats the people are wearing indicate that it was sometime in the 1940's or 1950's.
Jose Guerra (Galena park)
i think that there has been a plane crash because you can see that it looks like to be the top of the wing of the airplane and this picture looks like if its from the 1970.
HTSherlockers (Oakville, Canada)
We think there has been a plane crash because we see what looks like to be the top wing of an airplane, there are a lot of people surrounding the scene, there is a fire hose that looked like it was used to put out a fire, and we believe the plane to be from Canada because United is a Canadian airline. We believe it is in New York because the rental truck car has an address that says NY. We also think that there has been an explosion in the sky because only a small part of the plane crashed, and the buildings surrounded are not destroyed. It looks like it is during the day because the sky looks bright. based on the black and white photo, it looks as though it looks like it has been taken sometime in the 40s to 60s, as well as that there are people dressed in more formal attire. Also, based on the fact that there is snow, we think that it has taken place either mid-winter or spring.
shanku (mountain view)
a plane crashed in ny because it was to foggy
avacodo (somewhere)
a plane crashed and there is a water house is there for the water

ms flake its edgor
skye kennedy (texas)
an airplane crashed and it caused a fire and the people are looking at the crashed plane.

there is a firetruck water hose laying on the ground and smoke in the air, and it looks like its the wing of an airplane laying on the ground.

it is around buildings, and people are taking pictures of the mess.
makayla florence (tx)
looks like a plane has crashed that has caught on fire and there trying to put it out using a a firefighters hose

i see a plane in half with water hose scattered everywhere

i also see cars almost under the plane
Carson Levee (Winona Tx)
I think a plane crashed not long ago and now they put out the fire. I see smoke rising up behind the airplane and a fire hose which makes me say this. I can find this happened a while back because the picture is in black and white. I can see it took a lot of water to put the fire out from the plane because the street is wet. I can see it is winter because people have coats on and there is snow on the side of the road.
Sombrero (Mexico, Texas)
I think that what happened in the picture was that a plane crashed and then the firefighters are trying to save them by putting out the fire and then the people are terrified of what has happened. I see a plane with smoke coming out of it and then there is a hose probably to put out the water, and the people are gathered around with their hands on their mouth with shock. I can also see that there is no parking there because idek why but it is good because if the plane crashed on the cars people would be mad rather than sad.
Keithlin Dixon (My school)
what i think what happened was 9/11 happened
Toph D (Apex)
9/11 was 2001, but on the side of the truck it looks like 1966 or something along the lines of that.
Emma (Stout)
In this image people are gathering to see the aftermath of a plane that had crashed due to harsh weather in New York between 1957 and 1967. The truck on the left side says "Belfort Truck Renting Co." with "NY" printed on the side and the street sign says 7th ave. so we can assume it is in New York. You can tell the plane has crashed because it's body is smashed and there are fire hoses to most likely put out the fire caused by the crash. Additionally, there is snow on the ground and the sky is foggy so we can assume that the plane crashed due to the harsh weather. Allyn Baum, the photographer of the picture, was employed at the New York Times as a photographer from 1957 to 1967, and since most images selected for the "What's Going On in This Picture" are previously used images from the NYT, it is clear that this photograph was published when Baum was employed. It is clear that this is a stressful time given the crowd and plane wreck.
kaylon waits (class room)
a plane crash
a plane part
a moving truck
kohl benafield (my classroom)
a plane crash that looks like that happened a long time ago and they sprayed it down with the water hows that is in the snow
april chavez (houston)
in this picture you can see that whats happening in the picture was in the 50's or 60's it looks like a plane crash and people are all around the plane. it looks like i took place in new york
trenyce cleare fenton (boston)
In this picture what a see that is going on is that a plane crashed and it's in the olden days because it's black and white and everyone is standing around the plane and some people are coming towards the plane to see what happen.
Nikita.kleb.1234 (1326 Madison Avenue)
I see that the tail of the plane is on the street and many people are gathered on the street. The picture is in black and white and I say that we are in the 1960s or early 70s. There is snow one both sides of the sidewalk. In the corner of this picture we see firemen lined up and pulling the hose. These firemen are working together to put out the fire in the corner of this picture. I see a no parking sign and judging on the neighborhood I would take an educated guess and say that we are in Brooklyn because I do not see any buildings around. The tail of a plane says that it is from United. There must have been a crash in the air between two planes. I think that this Collision shows that in the shops next door there is a fire and it could be from the debris of the crash. There is a truck that says Belfort Truck Renting Co.
ND Life SKills (Burlington, ON, Canada)
We see a black and white picture that makes us think this was taken a long time ago. We also see an older model car to the right. Maybe from the 1950s or 1960s? We can also see a plane wing that says United on it. We know there is (or used to be) an airline called United Airlines. There is a lot of smoke in the air, which leads us to believe the plane crashed and caught fire. Furthermore, there are a lot of fire hoses on the ground and the plane wing is surrounded by individuals wearing what appear to be hard hats and police hats. We assume the individuals with the hard hats are firefighters. The plane crashed on a city street (we see the buildings, lamp posts and No Parking signs). There is a truck to the left that has N.Y. written on it. This tells us that this picture was most likely taken in New York State during winter because there is a lot of snow on the ground and people are wearing long winter coats.
Xavier peñalo (Dominican Republic)
I think that was an accident that happened in France. A United States airplane crashed in the the city
jasmine (MN)
We think it is a giant airplane that crashed into the Earth. A crowd of people is watching. They were scared
Roenty santos (Dominican Republic)
I think it was an accident in some european country and the plane was from the united states.
alissa (mn)
there was a plain crash. the year of the crash was 1990 or a different date. the people must lost of lot from the plain
nicole anderson (mn)
a plane crash and there was a fire?
fat bear (mm)
I think that there is a plane crash that crashed on the earth surface and i bet some people where killed
T M S (MN)
I think a plan crashed. It looks bad as well. my question is how many survived.
Ant & Kyle (harborfields high school, ny)
i think this takes place 3 time periods the 40s, 50s, and 60s. it could be a plane that felled down in united states in Massachusetts downtown Boston or somewhere in Russian town.
ss (MN)
I would say its a plain crash. but with the word "United" on the wing that is probably from ether the US or the UK. It's my opinion at least. But with the people around the crash sight they are getting the fire out so who ever is alive wont be burning to death.
TY baseball19 (harborfields)
I think there was air plane crashed in new york city in 1960. I believe it was on fire since there a firer hose and its in the winter.
Anthony (Houston)
The picture may be a plane crash in between the city and people are looking at it thinking if they were any survivors or looking for pieces that cam cause a fire.
Michael M. (Houston)
this is a plane crash is most likely in the 1960s and this is a big city most likely new York or Chicago.
Clayton S. (HTHS)
In this picture, a "united" plane has crashed inside a city, and a group of people have gathered around to investigate. I say this because i see a tail end of a plane that says "united" and i can see building that you would see in a tightly compacted city. I can also see a fire hose connected to water.
Arvin (houston)
it looks like a plane crashed in London
Antonio Herera (Houston)
I see a plaine crased on a city for a very long time and alot of wearing coats and circleling around the plaine crased being broken in half. The plaine looks like it was set on fire because i see alot of smoke around.
Vanessa Lopez (houston)
Theres a plane crash and people are looking at whats going on.
im anonymous (houstone tejas)
it looks like a plane crashed and firefighters put it out and left everything there and everyone went to go see what happened
Estrella Guerra (Houston)
From what i can see this happen between 1940's and 1950's. It looks like a plane crash down and killed a lot of people. It looks like its cold because the people are wearing coats and there is snow.The buildings look like if this happen in a big city.
Shamama (Long Island)
In today's VTS picture, we believe a plane crashed and there was a fire. First, there is a water hose. We use water hose when there is a fire. Next, there are firefight .Firefight came when there is a fire. Finally, there is white smoke. You see smoke when there is fire.
keila (houston)
es una ciudad y hay muchas personas afuera alparese a avido como un ataque o fue un avion quese estreyo esta muy humedo sebe nublado y nieve tambien en el suelo hay como una mangera y una barbula de agua.
Ramez (Long Isand)
A plane crashed and there was a fire. First we see a hose people use a hose to spray water on a fire.then we see pieces of broken airplane's that means a plane crashed. Finally we see smoke and Fire fighters. and we see them wen there was a fire.
c.o (houston tx)
in new york in the 1950s because of the rainy weather and a little snow there was a plane cash and people are watching the accident.
Jordan (Houston)
a scene where a plane crashed, I see a lot fire hoses. many people are there to see what happened
Areli (Houston TX)
is showing that a plane crashed and everybody is just staring at the whole scene.
bts jungkokie (new york)
a scene where ther isa crashed airplane and people talking with fire hoses all over the floor.
fat bear (mm)
I think your right
Bella Ramoin (NC)
The plane crash on seventh avenue in New York in the year 1960. This was in the winter. 134 people dies and was a domestic United flight.
Shamama (Long Island)
How do you know that?
Shamama (Long Island)
How do you know that?
Dominique (MN)
Ya a plane did crash about did it go on fire in air or did someone shoot it down.
SB Crew (Iowa)
This is a plane crash in Brooklyn, New York. It happened by two planes colliding. It was United Airlines Flight 826 and it collided with a TWA plane in the sky. It killed 134 people. It was December 16th of 1960; as you can tell it was winter because of the snow.
Ramez (Long Isand)
how do you no wen it is and were it is.
Campbell 6th Grade (California)
New York City -- 1950s
Plane Crash outside of a restaurant
Plane Crash in the 1920s in NYC; plane debris everywhere in the surrounding areas (glass, debris, smoke, etc.)
Donald Green (MA)
A scene of a plane crash in what looks like winter (although what looks like snow could be foam from the fire fighting effort). It also looks like this is perhaps hours, or the next day after the incident since there are a lot of people gawking, and the fire hoses are no longer in use. The time period looks like the late 1950's or 1960's based on the look of the car off on the right and the cab of the truck on the left. Also the dress of several of the people. Also, the piece of the aircraft is a tail, not a wing, and it could be from a jet, prop, or prop-jet style aircraft. Also, judging by what you can see of the condition of the buildings, it's possible that the tail fell here, and the rest of the aircraft ended up somewhere else, which suggests a mid-air incident. The "smoke" may also just be steam since it looks like the kind of weather where you'd see that as a result of building heating systems. Can't tell if it's real, or a movie scene as some have suggested.
Rowan42 (Los Angeles)
We think it is a giant airplane that crashed into the Earth. A crowd of people is watching. They are stunned.
Dominique (MN)
Yes the airplane did crash into the earth a crowd of people is wondering what is going on so they went to go see.
Darius (d)
We all know that it looks like a plane crashed on the streets in NYC.Looks like this took place in the 1920s or sometime else
Ramon (Walla Walla)
1. United airlines plane crashed in Brooklyn
2.Smoke is on the buildings
3.Snow is on the ground meaning its winter
4.People are surrounding the plane crash
5.A united airlines plane crashed in Brooklyn 1960
Taryn B (Walla Walla, WA)
1. I see a street sign and some type of store and a lot of smoke
2. There is a ton of smoke and a ticket booth or something to the right
3. Snow, fire hoses, water, and people
4. A lot of people and water
Perla (Washington)
1. In box 1 I believe that the truck says Brooklyn NY down below and a building it looks old.
2. In box 2 it looks like a lot of fog or smoke and buildings in the background.
3. In box 3 it looks like a lot of people staring at the plane the plane says united, and the plane is completely destroyed.
4. In box 4 I see a lot of more people doing the same thing as in box 3
There was plane accident and it probably is winter because of the snow on the floor and a hose on the road
Emoree L (Walla Walla Washington)
In this picture it seems like a plane crash because of the united airlines wing of a plane on the ground but it is only the wing so i don't know what happend to the rest of the plane. It seems to maybe be the end of winter because there is still snow on the ground but it looks to be melting. There are fire hoses all around the roads. They are in Brooklyn New York because there is a truck with an abbreviation of Brooklyn. It seems to be in the 1930s because the car on the side.
Lizett Gracia (walla walla)
i see that in the back there was a plane crash and people put it out with fire hoses. it might have been a national flying airline because of the writing on the wing of the plane.
gracie (walla walla)
so I see many people gathering around part of a plane and there is snow and firefighters trying to put the fire out because of the plane crashing but it could also be a movie scene like people filming the scene and all those people are actors and the plane is again part of the movie.
Gabe A. (walla wallla)
1. united airlines crashed
2. There is a lot of smoke in the air
3. its winter there because there is snow
4. people are surrounding the plane
In 1934 united airlines crashed in Brooklyn int he winter
Miguel (walla walla)
I think this picture is about an airplane crashed into the city and everybody is observing it and fire hoses are all over the ground.
Andrea (walla walla)
in the picture there are a lot people standing around something, it looks like a plane because there is a wing that says united on the side of it. there are hoses everywhere. I think that the plane might have crashed so they had to put the fire out. there is white stuff everywhere and I think that is snow on the ground.
Erick E. (Walla Walla)
This looks like a plane from united airlines has crashed in what appears to be Brooklyn, New York. This seems like it happened in the 1920's.
Xittlali (Walla Walla Wa.)
This seems like it was a united airline airplane crash in Brooklyn in the 1960s maybe two airplanes collided.
alissa (mn)
i think it was a boom that hit it
Melissa (Taco Cat)
In the picture, there is either some kind of natural disaster, rebellion, or rebellion of a natural disaster.
K-bug (ga)
The plane came crashing down a few blocks away from me and it hit me my life flashing in front of me. So many innocent people lost. As i walk towards it many people start surrounding it as if hell had come onto earth. There were many doctors nurses and firefighters along trying to see help the people if they survived but it doesn't seem likely. There were cops trying to keep the spectators from getting to close. Many people have theories of what happened but i think that they got lost in the fog and they didn't see the road so close.
Nishesh (10025)
I remember seeing this on TV (probably air disasters on NGC). There was a collision between a United Plane and a TWA plane. The planes crashed in park slope, Brooklyn and Staten Island. There was one 11 year old survivor who unfortunately died soon after.
Josh Huber (inlet)
wow, very interesting that you have seen this before.
MIguel (.)
In this picture it seems like people are walking towards the plane that crash landed.
Shamama (Long Island)
I agree with you because I see that to.
Anokuu (pleasanton)
A plane crashed, and a fire blew. The plane was on fire, and the firefighters came. I can infer that they were attempting to put out the flame because i can see the hoses which once probably contained water. The picture is in black and white, so it could mean the time period was before there was color. I can also tell that they are wearing old fashioned clothes. it might be 1960 because i see a 1960. The plane wing/tail says "united" and united could be united airlines. It might be in New York, and it is winter, or a snowy time of year. There is snow where the hoses are laid, and there is fog/smoke. I think the sign says "7th avenue,"
what i wonder is that why the buildings haven't taken damage if there was a crash. I think it was a mid-air collision if there was no building damage.
Annie Y. (Walla Walla WA.)
In New York, a plane crashed. It looks like it is an old photo. There was a fire, but it got put out and many people are surprised by the plane and are going towards it.
Eileen Horton (South carolina)
After noting that this appeared to be a United Airlines Plane that crashed sometime in 1950's or early 60's and reading that one person was quite sure it happened in New York City I did some research and determined that he was correct .. Searching internet made identification quite easy. I remember reading about the sole surviver when the crash occurred. He was a child and commented on how beautiful the city looked from his plane window just before the crash.
Deidra (Walla Walla, WA)
In box 1 there is part of a plane that is not connected to the rest of it. In box two I see a huge crowd of people that are looking at the crash. In box three there is snow and hoses on top of it. In box four there is the top of the hose that puts out the fire.
Juan (Walla Walla)
1. in the back there is a van that says in letters Brooklyn Ney york
2.the plane in the background is smoking because it just crashed
3.many people are gathered in a group to see what is going on
4.It's an airline that has fallen united states
5. i Think that this airline crashed because of the weather
emily (walla walla)
we can see that there is a plane wing in the middle of the street and we know that this was from a long time ago because of the car and that it is in black and white. we can see that it is in new york during winter because of the snow and the name on the delivery truck and because of all the fire hoses we know there was some kind of fire or explosion.
Faith (SMS)
This picture was taken in the 1900s. In the middle you will see some snow and people. On the right hand side of the picture you will see the fire department and a crashed down airplane. The people are trying to figure out what happened and trying to help.
Logan (SMS)
In this picture you will see a picture of a crashed plane more than like sixty years ago. The cars are really old and this also took place in New York City and the truck says Belford renting and the plane says United.
Jennifer H (Wisconsin)
I think everyone is gathering for a parade, or looking at a statue. Something that happened in the past.
masen (sms)
This is a plane crash in the middle of a city. It has recently snowed in this place. this is an old photo because it is in black and white. The old cars and the houses in the background are an older style.
Rodrigo Hernandez (.)
An accident happened and people were watching.
Cami/sms (sms)
In the picture there is a bunch of people standing around what looks like a plane that has crashed in the middle of the street. In the background there is tons of smoke. The street is filled with snow and water hoses.
Jennifer (Houston TX)
On this picture I see people looking the airplane crash trying to figure out what just happend, there is water hose everywhere to turn off the flames out of this plane. This plane is a united plane which I think Us citizens were on board.
Jesus Lopez (wisconsin)
This seems like a plane crash because of the united airlines wing on the ground and the water hose on the ground.
rocio ledezma (gphs)
i think that there was a plain crash because i see a part of the plane
VTS Moderator (Seattle, WA)
Wow we're at 502 comments already!! Great sleuthing today - I know I had to do keep revisiting the picture and using my zoom tool quite a bit. Thank you for making me look again and again.

Keep looking, reading each other comments and sharing your thoughts. Remember to think about:
"What's going on in this picture?"
"What do you see that make you say that?"
"What more can you/we find?"

On Thursday afternoon, the NYTimes team will add information about the content of this photo, but remember we can also learn other kinds of information simply by looking.
Gerard Moore (Ohio, USA)
In 1960 there was a mid-air collision and the wreckage landed in NY.
Deysi (Houston,TX)
This picture was taken back in the days, because the color of the picture plus the way the people are dressed. This picture was probably taken in the northern states because whats on the floor seem to be snow and the plane looks to be from united airline but it looks like its only half of the plane in the picture and everyone is crowded around to see what has happend
Irijah S. (LCMS)
In this picture it looks like it was taken a longtime ago because it is in black and white. It looks like there was a pal crash and there is a crowd of people around it looking at it and they are being observant. They all look like they don't know what cause it. It looks like it could be somewhere in England because if the buildings and the way they look.
twin 2 (LCMS)
this picture includes a whole bunch of people gathered around what looks like an airplane crash. the reason I say airplane crash is because the part that is on the ground is what connects to the back of the plane. Also because it says "united" which is an flight company. I can tell the plane was probably burning, reason being because the air is polluted with smoke, its really foggy. Also their are some fire hoses laying on the icy ground.
jada (lcms)
In this picture, there is a crashed plane with smoke coming out of it. The plane was probably on fire because there are fire hoses on the ground. This picture was probably taken a long time ago because it is in black and white. You can also tell by the way the people are dressed. Everyone is crowded around the plane because in whatever time this was they may not have known that it could be dangerous to get too close. I think that this picture was taken in a place called Belfort based on the sign in the back. It may be a United States airplane because it has the word United on the side of it.
Jennifer (lcms)
In this picture, I can tell that an airplane crashed. I know this because there is an airplane wing on the ground that says UNITED. This crash happened in France. I know this because even though the words on the sign are in English, the sign on the left says Belfort. Belfort is located in France. This occurred during winter. I know this because there is snow on the ground and people are wearing coats.
Anonymous (LCMS LCMS LCMS LCMS LCMS)
In this picture i notice that there was a bad plane crash. Evidence of this claim is that there is plane pieces in the middle of the road telling us something went wrong during flight. I also know that this photo was taken a long time ago becayse of the black and white and also this does not look like a modern area. I dont know if this is a real event though due to people not really freaking out. This photo is also taken in a english speaking country because of the english signs on the far left of the picture. This seems to be a very busy town in an eastern area like philadelphia or new york. That is the conclusion i drew from looking at this picture in depth.
Nicholas (Pennsylvania)
In this picture there is a horrible plane crash with parts of the plane that have fallen out. There are a lot of people in the background that look scared and terrified. The people had to have come after the crash since they are not scattered everywhere. The picture is in black and white. It had to be taken in the late 1960's since they didn't have color tv's or cameras. There is (What I think is) sand all over the street. This could have been a delivery plane sending sand for a show or something but the plane went down.
Twin 1 (LCMS)
This picture is from back then , I know this because the color of the picture and also if you look very closely at the people there fashion is different. What I think is going on is a plane crash becauss in the photo u can see a wing from the plane and also smoke in the background. The plane must have caught on fire because there are firefighters and so a hose to take out the fire. This photo must have been taking during the winter in a small town and i say it's winter because there is like icy/snow on the side also people are wearing coats.
john 88 (NC HTHS)
a united air lins plain crashed new jersey
Gabrielle (LCMS)
In the picture it looks like a plane crashed in France I know this is taking place in France because the truck in the background says Belfront truck renting and Belfront is located in France.This appears to be an older image so this must have happen a while ago. How I know the picture is pretty old is because it is taken in black and white also because of the style of clothing there wearing, the looks of the buildings, and the fire fighters suits dont look as protective as the ones we use now a days. It also seems as if this is taking place in the Winter because there is snow on the ground and people are dressed in layers with heavy coats on and long pants.
Eddie (Lcms)
A plane crashed into the street and now there are a lot of police men and fire fighters.I know that the fighter fighters are there because of the fire hoses. There are also a lot of people there crowding the area. This picture was taken a long time ago when there was no color in any pictures. because the picture is in black and white you can also see that parts of the plane is in a building and it is smoking. His happend in a city because there are tall apartment building.
savanna (HTHS)
A plane crashed and the fire department had to come because it caught on fire. I say this because there are lots of water hoses an people all around and there are parts. It looks like its New York and there is snow everywhere and its cold.
Mrs. Lang (South River, NJ)
We think this took place a long time ago. We know this because 1)the picture is black and white, 2)the people are wearing clothes and hats from a long time ago, 3)the cars are old fashioned, 4)if it happened now, people would not be allowed to be so close to the tail of the plane. We think the tail of the plane came off in the air and crashed to the ground in Brooklyn NY. There was a fire, and it is winter (because there is snow on the ground).
christopher r.j (n.c)
a plane crashed in a city
people are looking at a plane crash site
it was on fire
Aiden Z (HTHS)
a plane crashed and people are trying to figure out what happen to the plane and just what happen. there is a big plane in the middle of the road. there is fire ropes everywhere
Kayli Zakos (Heidi Trask)
In this picture there is parts of a plane on the ground like there was a plane crash and people around it like it was a surprise. This could be part of a war at one point. It looks cold in the picture and its taken in a city. I see this because there is snow/ice on the ground.
Ana P (North Carolina)
In this picture there seems to be a scene of an airplane crash. There seems to be a piece of an airplane on the ground. There what seems to be pipes on the ground.
Jessica Huerta (Houston tx)
there is plane in the middle of the street and there is a lot of people surrounding to see whats going on
Jahaira M (HTHS)
In this picture it looks like there is a plane crash. I say this because the object on the ground looks like a plane and it has United written on it. There is smoke on top of the plane so it looks like it might have been on fire. There are also people surrounding it so they might be taking a look on what's going on. There are buildings around where the plane crashed.
gage b (rocky point NC)
i think a plane crashed and the people surrounding the plane are just everyday normal people
Shannon M. (LCMS)
Clearly this picture has been taken a while ago because it is in black and white. The people standing around are wearing long coats and gowns. This picture shows some sort of plane crash with many people crowding around it. I know that this is a plane crash because in the background there is a plane with that says UNITED on it. There are parts of the inside of the plane laying around near the people who are standing near the accident. There is steam surrounding the small town and it could have been because of the plane. I know this because a plane has just crashed in the picture.
tyler l (nc hths)
tyler hths
a plane crashed on a road
a plane tail in the middle of the road
there is like snow in the middle of the road
ZacharyW (HTHS)
What I think that is going on in this picture is that a tail of a plane has broken off the plane and fell into a city street. this was taken along time ago during the winter time because there is snow on the ground and the people have on coats.
Rocio Requena (Houston)
This picture shows a plane that is crashed and theres a lot of of people crowded around it.
hailey (lcms)
In this picture, there are a lot of people standing around a old city. The picture has people dressed in gowns and in black and white. I know this because the picture was taken a long time ago. There is a lot of steam around the area and looks as if a plane has crashed. I know this because there is a wing from the plane and it's steaming There is a plane crash. I know this because they are policeman and firefighters
Megan (lcms)
The plane in the picture looks like crashed into the city. I know this because the plane looks broke and there are people surrounding the plane. The picture seems to be taken a long time ago. I know this because the buildings in the picture look older and run down. When the plane crashed into the city the plane caught on fire. I know this because there is a lot of smoke in the air and there is a fire hose near the plane. The picture must have been taken in the city. I know this because the houses are in rows and they are along a street.
Valerie (houston)
In this picture it shows a plane that crashed and people are getting closer to see what happened.
Kristin (LCMS)
In this picture, it looks like a very large plane has crashed. There seems to be a very long hose or pipe trailing towards the plane and there is a lot of smoke in the air. There also seems to be parts of the plane missing. The picture seems like something taken from the early 30's or 20's. I can tell that because of the filter on the picture and the fact that there are people who seem to be dressed in old clothes. The buildings seem old and European. The traffic lights and traffic signs seem different from what we have nowadays.
Chris (LCMS)
In this picture there was a plane crash in this town. In this picture the plane was on fire and some buildings. I can tell there was a big fire because there is a ton of water on the ground and there are fire houses on the ground. I can also tell this picture is a little old. I know this because of how the buildings and cars are made and the Picture is in black and white. Thsi plane crash probly got a lot of people hurt. I can tell this because the place it crashed seemed to be in a popular place, it seems to be in a popular place because there are a lot of people around the plane and there's a lot of buildings around it.
jessie (houston)
it looks like war is going on and that plane got shot down from the sky
will (lcms)
This picture is an old photo from the 1900's. I can tell because of the clothing the people are wearing. I can also tell this is an old photo by looking at the building structure it looks like an old style of a building. there is a plane in pieces in this picture. That is telling me as the person who is looking at the picture that it crashed maybe going off course or it is a terrorist attack that happened. This seems to be a big city that this happened in. I can tell because there is a big ground of people looking at the wrecked plane. There is also tall buildings in the backround.
Shane Collier (Log)
In this picture there was a plane that crashed. I can tell this because there is a plane in the middle of the street. There was a fire when the plane crashed. I can tell this because there is a lot of smoke and there is a fire hose in the picture. No one got hurt in the plane crash. I can tell this because there is no ambulance and no one looks like there hurt. Everyone in that picture is very calm. I can tell this because there are people walking and no one looks scared.
Jorden Oakes (lcms)
this a picture that was taken a while ago. i know this because the picture is in black and white. another reason i can tell is because the equipment that is being used is a lot less up to date then the equipment that is used to day. this is a very bad accident of some type of crash. i can tell it's a bad accident by all the commotion and emergency services around. the accident seems to be a type of aircraft. i say that because of the large wing sticking out of the ground which look like it belongs to a type of plane or space shuttle
Person (LCMS)
In this picture I can see people grouping around the scene of a bad crash. This picture was taken in the past. I know this because of the way people are dressed and the camera quality. The plane was on fire when it crashed. The long house in the the middle of the street supports that. This accident took place in a city. I can conclude that because of the streets, buildings and how many people are gathered.
mariah (sms)
Let me tell you about a story that i was in in the 19 maybe 18 hundreds a army plane crashed in the city of New York, it was snowing in December the 27 i was in the war at that time.Their was about 10 deaths,no survives.The plane was carrying a 2000 pound of bombs and weapons on board. I was surprised that the whole city didn't blow up. The people of New York came out to see the plane and found body's laying on the ground and the smoke that almost cover the city,the firefighters had to put out the fire and the smoke that drew everyone in.
Leigh s (hths)
there has been a plane crash. theres half a plane in the background.its in black in white.
KolbyL (NC HTHS)
There is a plane that crashed in the middle of a city.
Parts of the plane are in the middle of the street.
There is people standing around the plane.
JaNyah S. (North Carolina)
There is what it looks like a part of a plane in the street and a whole bunch of people are surrounding and its icy outside. There is a pile of ice on the side and there are fire hoses , there is a lot of smoke in the air. On the plane thing there is something next to it maybe another part of the plane. People are going near the plane, there is a truck stopped.
Nicholas (Pennsylvania)
In this picture, there is a horrible plane crash
Christian C (GPHS)
This picture shows a plane that crashed back then because you can see that the color camera id black and white.There are people that are crowded and probably want to see the damage and what happened.
Leslie (sms)
The plane crashed because the pilot fell asleep. The pilot fell asleep because he did not get enough sleep last night. The plane crashed in New york City. This happened in the 1990s.
Chloe (sms)
In this picture I think that it happen in the 50's or 60's by what they are wearing. The setting look likes it is in downtown. When I look at this picture I can see that a plane crashed into a street and I know that because I can see the fin (the back of the plane) in the street. It must have crashed then be set on fire because there is smoke in the air and on the streets there are hoses and usually hoses are used to put out fires. The firefighters are coming in there raincoats so maybe it had rained there before this picture got taken. Last but not least on the plane it says United and that might mean the company of that plane.
McKenna (SMS)
I'm a reporter from Texas. We are at the scene of New York City where a United airplane has crashed into a building. There was about 20 to 30 people on the plane and a few people were injured. About 19 people were killed on the plane. People surrounded around the plane and the firefighters were putting water on the plane so it wouldn't blow up.
maria perez (houston)
This picture looks like it was taken back in the old days because its black and white and the way the people are dressed. Also it looks like part of a plane is on fire maybe the plane crashed down people are around it they are trying to look at what had happened.
Lucas (sms)
Today I was walking down the street and then I saw a airplane coming straight at me. So I started running out of the way and then the airplane crashed and the fire department got here and started putting the fire out and it took a few hours for them to get and by then there was a lot of people there looking at it and by then i was freezing so i looked at it one more time then i went home.
Jack (SMS)
joe and his family have just watched this united states plane crash in the fire hydrant in england and it all most hit joe's family's shop well joe's was running like his pants were just lit on fire and cussing like a drunken sailor while his family run into the stream of water that's now gushing out of where the fire hydrant was. so when joe saw that the plane has just stopped sliding down the hill he went over to the plane part's to check for survivors but sadly there was no one in it the pilot must have evacuated and the passengers to.
Easton M (Arizona)
I think that there was a plane-crash, it looks brutal too. It was in a city, which probably made it worse. It was on fire at one point, cause there are fire-department hoses and smoke. It probably crashed on the street, caught on fire, then burnt until put out. there is a big crowd which could either be the survivors or the public.
Abigail (SMS)
I think this picture is about a plane crash into a city because the plane looks like because the plane is broken into pieces . The people is crowded around the plane because the people might want to know what happened to the plane or how the plane got in their city streets. There is a water hose because the plane was on fire when it crashed then one of the people took the water hose and sprayed the plane with the water. That is why the plane looks like it was on fire.
VTS Moderator (Seattle, WA)
@Thank you Abigail for looking all over the photo and sharing your thoughts. When you say "people" can you describe the different kinds of people you see and the different kinds of roles and responses that may have?
Dylan/sms (sms)
A plane crashed in the middle of the city killing everybody on board and a few more in the building The plane crashed because of engine failure.
VTS Moderator (Seattle, WA)
@Dylan/sms, what do you see that makes you say engine failure may have caused this?
VTS Moderator (Seattle, WA)
@Caleb agree something went NOT according to plan, but has a different interpretation from a plane crash from the sky. He writes that perhaps,"they were transporting a plane from one place to another (possibly from one hangar to another) and on the way, something went wrong while being moved and it caught on fire. The reason that I think it didn't crash is because there is no damage to the surrounding buildings. It is impossible to crash a plane in a thirty-foot wide street without hitting any buildings..."

What do you think? What more can we find?
Devin (SMS)
i think this is a plane crash that happened during the 40s in London cause of the way the buildings look and the way the people are dressed.It looks like the plane crashed into that near by building and there might have been a few casualties.
Lee Saunders (Houston)
In this picture a plane has crashed somewhere in a city and people are coming to see the damage. The city looks fairly urban and there seems to be a church in the background. If you look at the plane it looks to be the back of a United Airlines plane. It looks like it is winter time in the city and there are firehose everywhere so the plane must have been on fire. The picture is in black and white and the people are wearing old fashioned clothes so the crash must have happened years ago. This Untied Airlines flight crashed into a fairly urban city many years ago. The plane caught on fire but the fire was contained and the people of the city came to see what had happened.
Duryn Dunbar (Houston)
A mass tradjety had occurred while this picture was shot. Hundreds of people swarmed around a piece of a plane wing. Smoke is still floating in the air, and water from the fire hoses started flowing down the newly crowded streets. On the truck in the back, you can see the word Beljori, which seems french, but the plane is United, which is a American airline. In this urban place, captured in black and white, civilians gather around what they might have thought could only happen in a movie:
Marley (H-TOWN)
This appears to have been a plane crash, in an urban setting in America, such as New York, New York, because the plane is United, an American Airline. The grainy black and white photography indicates that this picture was most likely taken in the 1950's or earlier. The smoke in the air also leads to the conclusion of a plan crash, and would explain the hose and fire fighters, as the crash may have started a fire. This photo is important, because it is an extremely unlikely event to have a plane crash in the middle of the street in the city, but it has happened, and it can happen.
William (Houston)
This image displays several things that are catching to the eye. One being the large piece of what seems to be an airplane in the middle of the street. So by looking at this and the people huddled and gathered around I am immediately thinking of a plane crash in this city. It appears to be cold based the large pile of snow on the ground and the way that the people are dressed. There is some sort of smoke or steam of some sort rising out of the inside of the airplane piece. It is drawing much attention causing large amounts of people walking to the site from all directions. I believe that this is definitely a plane crash.
Jasmine (Houston)
A United plane has just accidently fallen. There was such a huge accident with the plane in the sky that the plane did not fall in one piece; hence, only the wing of the plane being seen. The water hose like item in the front of the picture suggests that there was previously a fire from the plane.There are pedestrians gathered around the plane, which signifies that this plane falling was an uncontrollable accident. The men in similar uniforms could be some sort of medical help meaning that there were people hurt in this accident. The snow on the ground and the fog in the air probably suggest that this happened around the colder months of the year. The black and white photo might also suggest that this was taken before color photography was invented.
Isha (Houston)
I think that in this picture a plane crash has happened in a city in an English speaking country. There was snow outside so I’m assuming it is somewhere North. I see signs in English. The plane is United. The people are surrounding the plane. I can tell that the firemen have extinguished the crash by looking a the abandoned hose on the snow.
Riley O. (LCMS)
In this picture there is a large crowd around a plane crash. This picture looks to be from the 1960s this is because of the car, truck, the people and the color of the picture. There seems to be a united plane that crashed. I know this because of the wing of the plane says UNITED on it and that is the only part that isn't destroyed. Also this seems to be under control. I know this because the firemen are walking around calm and don't have hoses in their hands. WIth the firemen not having hoses in their hands it leads me to believe that the fire that happened was extinguished. This seems to be a city manner of a neighborhood since the houses are close together and the road is very crowded. It seems like they recently had a snowstorm and then rain. I know this because of the snow pile in the road and the wet road. These bad weather conditions could have led to the reason that the plane had crashed.
Android Z (LCMS)
First thing you can notice when you look at the picture is that this is a plane crash in the winter. How do I know it's the winter? Well I know it is winter because there is snow on the ground, and the people are dressed in winter clothing. In the picture you can notice that most of the plane that crashed is missing, so this suggests that it is being blocked or is on the other side of the building. Also there is not any emergency vehicles but there is firemen. This suggests that it happened before the picture was taken just because people would also have been evacuated. This picture was definitely taken in the 20th century due to the fact the picture is not in color and the street lights don't look to modern. It doesn't make since why people are gathered around the plane. I know that in modern times if there is some type of event/accident that people have to stay away from the event/accident. Like a car crash you need to stay away from, even if it is modern. So this tells us that the image is from an older time when security was not so strict, because if this was modern you would not see people gathered that close to the object.
Charlie (Houston)
In this picture I see a United States plane wing in the street and smoke rising from a few different directions. The people do not seem to be freaking out as if the plane had crashed but more as if they were drawn to the scene to see what happened. There is a fire hose and some ice on the ground. I believe that maybe a plane crashed durring the night and the wing is all that is left and the hose is left from over night and people are around it because it is no longer dangerous.
Loading... (USA)
A plane crashed in the middle of an urban area. The plane belonged to United AIrlines, the telling sign is the logo on the plane's tail. The plane crash most happened after 1926 and before 1980 as those were the times when United Airlines became a company and color photography became widespread. The season was winter as there is much slow laying on the ground. The plane most likely crashed in the city of Belfort, France as one of the trucks has the name Belfort on it. There is also evidence of the city being located in England or America as the characters on the truck and the road sign are written in English. The plane crashed a while ago as the crowd stares at it, unsurprised and emergency services are standing around. The hose lays on the ground unused.
Kelly (B.Y)
This picture is people gathering around a plane that has crashed
Matt (LCMS)
In this picture is see some wreckage of some plane like structure. It has the word United on it which can either mean United Airlines, USA, or the UK. There is a lot of smoke as if this happened recently. It seems like emergency vehicles are arriving now to put out the fire. The hoses from the firefighters are running across the ripped up ground. The ground is ripped up because the wreckage dragged across the ground before stopping. The people are around the wreck trying to see what is happening. This picture was taken in the 1800s before colored pictures were invented.
Jenna (LCMS)
This is a dated photo of a plane that crashed. This photo was taken in England. I know this because of the buildings' very old styles and the No Parking sign on the left being structured to point at drivers. This accident occurred a while before the photo was taken. I know this because there is no ambulance truck and the people are gathering to see the wreck rather than running to protect themselves. There is also a hose on the ground that appears to be from a nearby firetruck. This photo was taken in the 1930s or 40s. I know this because WW2 was going on during this time and planes flying overhead or being shot out of the sky was more common. The outfits the people are wearing also match that time period.
Anonymous (Lcms)
In this picture, there was an unfortunate plane crash that occurred around winter time. I know this because there is snow on the ground and people are wearing coats. There was most likely a fire on the plane or when it crashed. I know this because there is smoke everywhere and I can see firemen and the long fire hose. I cannot see any other parts of the plane or the fire truck. The other parts of the plane are nowhere around, so the other parts of the plane must have landed in another place. I know this because the buildings in the picture don't look very damaged. This picture was taken in the mid 1900s based on the black and white picture and the clothing the people are wearing looks old fashioned.
Anastasia (LCMS)
Looking at the picture, I can tell that there was an airplane carsh. It took place in the end of winter in England. There is a large scrap of metal that seems to be the back wing of an airplane with the word United on it. I can infer that this takes place in winter because of the snow and the heavy clothes people are wearing. I can tell that this is England because there english words and its extremly foggy. This took place in the 1940s. I can tell because of the old fashioned cars.
Casey.AOSE (Academy of Saint Elizabeth)
This is a picture of one of the wings of an airplane from united airlines, based on the name on the wing, that has landed in the middle of a town called Belfort, based on the truck in the left of the picture. This may be a small town because there are people gathered all around it, so maybe they have never seen anything like this. There is smoke coming from the window of a building and there is a fire hose on the ground, so there could have been a fire from the crash of the plane wing. Since the photo is in black and white, and there is snow on the ground, I can infer that it was taken in the winter a long time ago.
Andrew (Is Cool)
This looks to be an item from a plane that fallen off of it. The reason i think it wasn't a plane crash is because there are no ambulances for the people in the plane. It seemed to happen the United States or where people from the United States were traveling to. The planes fin says "UNITED" on it, like United Airlines that was founded in Boise, Idaho and it looks like the DC-8 Jet Mainliner. The text on the sign is also in english. The picture looks like it was taken in the mid 1900's because of the black and white image and the car toward the right side of the image.The crowd is gathered around the plane's fin because it is unordinary for that event to happen. It also look like winter due to the snow.
Rachel (Houston)
It looks like there is a plane that crashed and the first letters on it look like it would spell United Airlines. The writing at the left is in english so it’s probably in a an english-speaking country. The picture is also in black and white so it is probably in the 1920s. There is a fire hose to put out the plane crash fire. The clothes that the people are wearing means that it’s cold outside, so they are probably in New York or a northern country. There is snow on the ground also.
Davan (LCMS)
In this picture i notice that it is the scene of a crash sight. Some evidence of this is that there is a commercial airflight fin in the middle of the road telling us instantly something went wrong. I also know that this photo was taken somewhere above 1954 which is the year the belfort truck renting company changed there name telling us that this was after 1954. I assume that this could be maybe a movie scene because of the extremely calm expressions of all the people in the photo. This photo is also taken in a english speaking country because of the english signs on the far left of the picture. I looked up the Belfort truck renting company and found out that they are in New York City putting this photo in New york .
Charles (H)
In this picture, broken pieces of a United States plane are lying in the middle of a somewhat urban area. I feel like because there is snow and it is very foggy it could likely be in a northern part of the US or possibly Europe. Surprisingly, I do not see too much destruction for a full plane crash. It seems that the crash did not just occur, as many people are walking toward the crash site slowly and seemingly in a calm way rather than panicking or acting surprised. I see a sign for no parking and one for a building, and both are in English so I believe this is probably either in the United States or maybe England. This crash brings a lot of interest to the people in the picture and they seem to be trying to gain knowledge of what happened to this plane. The crash occurred likely earlier that day or possibly the day before because it seems that they are still trying to help people and revive the buildings and maybe put out fires because I see a hose. I think this is a northern US city or somewhere in England and they are observing a crashed American plane with interest.
xtaforster (Houston, TX)
Nice analytical format, @charles! I agree with you that the juxtaposition of the charred airplane and the intact buildings seems surprising. I also appreciate how you cite the specific gestures of the people, as if they are "trying to gain knowledge of what happened to this plane." Your comment makes me think about how photography can make experience strange: similar to the viewers in the photograph who approach the plane, WE try to gain knowledge of what happened to this plane by approaching the photo of the viewers approaching the plane, sort of like an infinity mirror.
Matthew Bale (The 713 area)
I'm going to tell the audience what I think is going on in this picture. I think a plane crashed in a big city. I think this is in the 1940s-50s. The reason I think this is because there is a large tail of United plane sitting in the middle of a road. I see smoke coming off a part of the plane in the distance. As displayed in the foreground, many hoses are carefully placed on the white snow. There are many citizens of this city observing the plane, and the outstanding work the firemen have done to put out this monster of a fire. So, I think this crash was a big deal back then, and the news spread fast across the country.
Zack (Houston)
I think that this is a picture that this is a picture of a plane that his crashed in a city. I think the city is either London or Chicago because I don't remember of hearing about another fatal plane crash in NYC besides 9/11. I also think that this was done in the 1930's-50's because of the clothes that are being worn by the people on the street. I believe that this was an accidental plane crash that was fatal to the pilot.
VTS Moderator (Seattle, WA)
@Zack, yes, thank you -- figuring out something mysterious requires both our background knowledge, memory and also observation skill of what we see before us. What do you see that makes you say this accident may have been fatal to the pilot?
Charlie (Houston)
Nice
Michaela (LCMS)
The picture is in black and white and the people are dressed in clothes from what looks like a while ago. I think that this picture is from years ago. I see the wing of a plane in the middle of the street and smoke, so there must've been a plane crash. I can tell that it's on the winter because there is a pile of snow and everyone is wearing jackets. There must have been a fire because there is smoke, hoses and in the crowd there is a man with a fire fighter hat on. There is no police holding people back from getting too close to the destroyed plane or directing traffic. The wing must have fallen off into the city and the rest of the plane landed somewhere else.
Brianna (lcms)
In this picture it looks like there was a plane crash. I know there was a plane crash becasue there is a plane with the inside opened and laying across a street with people around it. I can also tell that there is only half of the plane. The other part of the plane isn't near it and the front is missing. There seemed to be a fire as well. I can tell there was a fire because of the hose on the ground. I also can tell ther was a fire because the plane looks burnt. I can also tell its winter in this picture. I can tell its winter because of the snow on the ground and all the heavy coats the people are wearing. The picture was taken probably in the late 1900os. I can tell it was taken then because of the color of the picture and all the old and vintage cars.
Caleb (Arizona)
My opinion on what is happening is that they were transporting a plane from one place to another (possibly from one hangar to another) and on the way, something went wrong while being moved and it caught on fire. The reason that I think it didn't crash is because there is no damage to the surrounding buildings. It is impossible to crash a plane in a thirty-foot wide street without hitting any buildings. I think that it was on fire because there are fire hoses in the foreground.
Michael (LCMS)
In this picture there was an obvious unfortunate event that happened. It looks like there was a plane that fell in the middle of the street. I know this because of the wing and and the smoke in the street. I also think that this was a huge accident that happened. I know this because of the amount of people that are gathered around the mess. Another thing i see is the way the picture was taken, it had to be taken in the 1900s. I know because of the black and white color of this picture. Although one thing I noticed was there was no responders at the scene. I know this because there are no cars or trucks. Maybe this was taken right after the accident.
Bryce Duke (Japan)
This picture first of all looks like it's as old as Albert Einstein. I think that this was maybe the first plane that was created, this plane was the test run of the experiment. Based on what i see in this picture, plan looks like it was original and still had some things missing. So this caused the plane to sadly crash. This is an example of a paper airplane, you throw it in the air and it stays for awhile but then falls to the ground. Luckily engineers fixed the problems and planes are able to fly without any problems. That is how us people travel around the world and sometimes from one state to the other. This is what I think this picture looks like to me.
Glasgow MS Lang/Lit Smith period 7 Students (Alexandria, VA)
We notice that the picture looks dated. We think this was in the past because the photo is black and white, the car, and the way people dress look older - not as modern. The streets are wider than today and the light posts look older. We infer that the location is in New York because we can see the information on the truck that says "New York" and "66". We also know that the architecture would be similar to New York. We think that the plane had an issue in mid-air and has fallen into the street. We are wondering what happened to cause the plane to explode or fall apart in the air. It looks like the fire has been put out because there are spectators and the fire hoses are not in use.
Kevin S (cnhs)
it is a piece of a united airlines flight that crashed into the empire state building in the 40s.
bet (bet)
plane in the road, people looking at it, smoke
jared ebert (place)
this took place in britain during world war 2 and a friendly plane has been shot down over this city
Abby A (CNHS)
It looks like it was from a long time ago, since the picture is in black and white. I think it's in the U.S. because the writing on signs are in english. It shows a plane crash in the middle of a city street with fire fighters and people surrounding it.
RR (School)
It looks like a plane crash in 1940
Graham E. (chs)
i think this was a plane crash in a town or city in America, I think it is in America because the plane says united on the side. It must have caught on fire because there r industrial hoses everywhere and water shooting into the building.
Dominic S (LCMS)
In this picture, I see what looks like a plane that crashed into a street. I can tell it is a plane because I can see part of the plane's body and one of it's wings. It also looks like it is in a city in the U.K. because of the architecture in the back. I also noticed the hoses on the ground. That means that the plane probably caught on fire went it crashed and they needed the hoses to put out the fire. By the black and white color of the picture, I can also tell it was taken in the 1940s. So I think the plane crashed into a city in the U.K. and caught on fire when it crashed in the 1940s.
Nick (K.)
I think that this is somewhere in New York. Based on things in the background like the car parked on the street, I'm guessing that it took place in the 40s-50s.
Leighland (LCMS)
In this picture, a plane has crashed a while ago into a street in France in the far past. This scene happened in the past. I know this because of the black and white photo, which means this picture was taking quite a while ago. The scene takes place in France because of the name "Belfort" on a rental truck to the left of the crash. I know this because Belfort is a city in France. This photo was taken a while after the crash because the people are calm, the emergency services are gone, the fire hose is not in use, and the people are quite calm about the situation.
Joe Scholle (don't need to know)
its some of your average every day plane debri
Erica (Chanhassen)
It looks like there is a plane in the middle of the street. It looks like they speak english because there is a sign in english and there is a lot of people surrounding it because it looks like it just crashed.
Wyatt (Chs)
Plane crashes down in city, looks like passenger plane, maybe in 1940's or '50's.
Matthew Bale (The 713 area)
agreed
Luke (Chan)
Mr grandpa actually told me about this, it is the 1960 new york mid air collision, 2 planes crashed into eachother and they fell down all over new york city, My grandpa was 13 years old, and he thought it was crazy. The plain was a united airlines plane.
Emily (chanhassen)
it looks like a city somewhere in Europe possibly the united kingdom hence the "united" decaled on the plane. The pilot probably lost control of the plane
Jonah P (I don't know)
Probably a plane that crashed
benn (LCMS)
in this picture i see crowd of people near a plane. First off this picture was taken long ago. I know this because the picture is in black and white and has no color. Also in this picture a plane has crashed just a small bit ago. I know this because of the torn part of the plane in a bad position. I also know this picture was taken in the cold weather. I know this because of the snow on the ground.
Justin I (LCMS)
The picture is the recent aftermath of a plane crash. The people are gathering around the wing of a pane that has crashed. What I believe to be the wing of the plane has the word "United" meaning that it could come from the travel company united airlines. The picture was taken soon after the plane crashed. The smoke from the plane crashing is still in the air and authorities have not cleaned up the mess the plane caused yet. The picture was taken in the United States before 1860. All the words in the photo are in English including signs, and trucks. The photo is in black and white because at the time the photo was taken, colored photography has not been invented yet.
Makena (LCMS)
This picture is taking place in a town, which seems to be an older picture due to the black and white picture. In the picture a plane has crashed in the middle of the street and town. I know this due to the part of the airplanes wing in the street. There is also lots of smoke coming from the plane and ground, which could also indicate a plane crash. Although there is sight of a crashed plane, it doesn't seem like an urgent emergency. I can say this because there is no sight of any type of medical or emergency equipment or people. Also there is no evidence of a worried citizen, they all seem very calm considering there is a plane in the middle of town. Although there is a hose which could mean the plane caused some sort of fire or such, but it doesn't seem like anybody was hurt, which is odd due to the damage of the plane.
VTS Moderator (Seattle, WA)
Many of you are wondering not only when this scene took place, but where: NYC, a city, a small town in America, England, Germany, Europe. What visual clues and evidence can you all find to support any of these suggestions. Or perhaps you have another idea?

We love seeing your interpretations, but remember to also share the details of how you came to your conclusion so we can gain a better understanding.

What more can we find?
VTS Moderator (Seattle, WA)
You're noticing different types of people in the crowd...police, firefighters, men, perhaps residents from the buildings. What more? Who is there and who is NOT there? Can you read more into their different reactions to tell us more about what's happening?
yuli (sms)
It was a plane that was flying and the person who was driving it lost control of the plane or maybe the plane had a problem. And the plane fell to a city. After the plane fell into the city the people who were there tried to run and some people died and others were kept safe. After that happened the police and firefighters arrived and tried to see If the people who were on the plane were alive. There was a lot of smoke everywhere.
EML (SMS)
One day a United States airplane was going to another place with lots of people aboard. As they were high in the sky the airplane was making funny noises. It suddenly stopped flying and fell down really fast to the ground. It landed in a small town where there was snow and it split in half. There was a lot of fire and the firefighters came really fast. They got out their long hose to put out the fire. Once the fire was out they started looking for people. Lots of other people started to gather around the airplane. While the firefighters were looking for people,they found none.
bruh (texes)
It looks to be a plane crash during the winter because it looks to be snow on the ground. also it looks to be in the united kingdom because of the buildings
carol (sms)
So, what exactly happened to the plane and what happened to the buildings? Well, it happened today around noon. everybody in the whole city was settled and ready to chill out for the day when the tragic incident happened. There was a plane that crashed and hit the side of the building and fell to the ground. There was smoke everywhere.
VTS Moderator (Seattle, WA)
@Carol, that sounds like the start of an intriguing novel...keep going : )
Study Lab (Leander, TX)
We think it's a plane crash and maybe it hit a building. It could also be that a plane hit a truck. People are standing very close to the scene. We believe it happened in New York.
Unicorn (Rainbows)
It looks like a plane crash in the early 1900's, I know this because of the outfits the bystanders and wearing and what looks to be a firemen's hose. I also in it is in the time period because the picture is in black and white and that in the late 1800's the camera were very big and bulking and the wouldn't be very clear as the picture is. It looks to be in either United Kingdom or in Manhatten New York because of the building shape and the writing on the side of the truck that is on the left side of the picture.
Dylan (sms)
Wow it looks as if this plane had engine failures.That's the only thing that would make it come down.There was not much to go on but we can get somebody to check this out.They find something it was engine failures and it ended the worst way.Two people died, Paul Sampan and Phil Revare, they were two good people. They have been working at the airline 20 years.
A day later they got all the remains cleaned up. We repaired the plane and we use it now for every thing. That day we started checking the engines it saved a lot of lives.
Casey.AOSE (Academy of Saint Elizabeth)
It is interesting that you noted the possible cause of the crash, but why engine failure? Couldn't it have been other things?
Hayden_CR7_Lomeli (WWW)
It looks like the picture was taken is Brooklyn, NY because of the renting company that shows something like Gentk-B-NY. Also, I think that the time period is winter there. Also, there is a plane that looks like the company United Eco-Skies. The city looks like it is and isn't in the united states because of the shape of the building in the background, but it does look like it's in the united states because of the language on the airplane and the sign.
Garcia (HI)
n the picture it looks like a piece of a plane must have fallen off and the rest crash somewhere else. Firefighters are taken the piece away it might be winter due to all the snow and how people are dressed it might be in Brooklyn.
Gustavo (SMS)
There is an accident, plane crashed on a city street. There are many people and there are police around there is a great deal of smoke. Hose put out the fire.
Schab (ww)
1. There is a big piece of a plane crashed on the ground. 2. There is a big crowd looking at the plane. 3. It is during winter based on the snow on the ground. 4. There is a classic car so it is probaly a long time ago All. There is a plane crash probaly in New York, during winter and a bunch of people are looking at it.
McKenzie (SMS)
We are on the scene of an airplane crash. All people are coming around to the plane. Over to you; 250 had died who was on the plane and 125 people who was walking on the sidewalk on a normal day, like they always do. Over 450 was hurt. We had to see way the plane crashed and it was because the pilot had fallen asleep from reading all night; he was tired.
joey (walla walla)
In this picture, i see a plane crash in a city in NY and it looks old due to the cars and outfits. And it looks like Winter due to how they are dressing and the snow. The plane must have been on fire cause the fire hose on the snow
Emily (LCMS)
This image seems as if there is a tragic event going on. This picture looks like there is a plane crash in the middle of the street. I know this because there is a burning plane crashed with a firehose to put the fire out. I know this because there is smoke and plane shrapnel everywhere. The picture looks like it was taken in the 1920s on a cold day in a city. I know this because there are people in winter jackets crowded all over the plane. I know this because the buildings look like they were made many of years ago.
Caitlin (LCMS)
It seems as if a plane had caught on fire and a piece of debri crashed in the town. It looks like the plane caught on fire because the wing that fell is blackened and covered in ashes, there is also smoke in the background. Another piece of evidence that supports the plane being on fire is the fire hose on the ground. There are firemen walking towards the scene in the background, so they could have been using that house to put out the fire. You can tell the object is a piece of a plane because it has the words "United" on it which is a airline. Also the object is definitely the shape of a wing. The event looks as if it was happening on a cold tell in a city or town. I know this because the people are wearing heavy jackets and there seems to be stores and restuarants in the background.
Sarah Z (LCMS)
I can see a what looks to me to be a part of a plane that looks like it has just crashed in a town and a bunch of people crowded around the plane part. I think that the plane crashed and the people used the fire hose to put out a possible fire that was from the plane crash. I know this because in the picture there is what looks like a detached plane wing and smoke. I know the people used the fire hose because the hose is uncoiled and looks like it has just been used. I think this picture was taken a long time ago and the event happened a long time ago. i know this because the picture is in black and white. I also know this because the people in the picture seem to be in old fashioned clothes such as trench coats.
Cara (LCMS)
In this picture it is a sight of a plane crash, in a town. I think the plane caught on fire. I know this because there is a fire hose and firemen walking around. There is also smoke hovering around the plane and the buildings. I think this happened in the winter because there is snow and ice on the ground. There are also many people with heavy coats and hats on. The plane must have fallen apart in the air. The wing of the plane is at this sight so the other parts of the plane must be somewhere else. This picture was taken in the 1950s or around there. I know this because the picture is taken in black and white.
Ashley Woiblet (ww)
Box 1- There is an airplane wing of some sort that says ''United'' on it. so this might take place in New York.
Box 2- There are buildings and other people gathered around the plane crash in a city.
Box 3- There is snow and a ''No Parking'' sign so this is obviously in the US.
Box 4- There are just more people standing around.
Overall- Overall I think this is in New York city and there was a plane crash on one of the streets. People gathered around the crash to see what happened.
adele (my happy place)
Box 1: It looks like there is a plane crash in a city and the sign looks like it says something about NYC
Box 2: By the shape of the building it looks like downtown part of a city and i see a lot of smoke so the piece of the plane must have been on fire
Box 3: i see a lot of people gathering around the scene of a crash
Box 4: I see a fire hose that they must have used to put out the flames on the plane i also soo a big pile of snow so that means it must be in the winter time
Lyndsay (lcms)
In this picture it looks like there has just been a plane crash. The picture looks like it is taking place around the 1950's because of the clothes the people are wearing. The plane must have just recently crashed due to all the smoke still in the air. SInce the doctors and police men look like they are taking their time, there were probably no severe injuries. The picture looks like the event took place in a city with many people. That is because of the buildings and all the people surrounding the part of the road where the plane crashed. Due to the fire hose it looks like the plane may have been on fire when it crashed.
Caroline (LMCS)
In this picture an unfortunate event took place. There was a plane crash that happened in the city. I know this because of the huge plane wing is sticking up on the street and people are gathered round.I know that this is a city based of the buildings and all the people. There was also a huge fire that took place. You can tell this because the plane wing is black, there is smoke and you can see a fire hose. This picture was taken in 1950s-1960s based off the black and white photo and how the people are dressed.
josh (lc)
This picture seems to take place in the United States. I know this because the No Parking sign is in all english, and many countries are not predominantly english. This photo is obviously taken a long time ago. I know this because the picture is in black and white, and most pictures these days are in full color. I believe this picture is of the 1960 New York mid-air crash with United airlines. I know this because in 1960 a United Airlines flight crashed in Brooklyn and the event matches the image well such as how it is a United Airline plane, in an english country, and in a city. This is what I believe the picture is of based on my background knowledge from the photograph and of the 1960 Mid-air crash.
Hannah Bagley (California)
In box 1 I see some buildings and a plane crash.
In box 2 I see some people surrounding the plane crash
In box 3 I see maybe like some ice/snow and a hose
In box 4 I see streets and more people inspecting the plane crash
In all i think that there was a plane crash and people came to see what was going on
Emma (ww)
1. it looks like a united airplane crashed
2. it looks like a german type building in the background
3. it looks snow, so itś winter time, with firehoses
4.it looks like a crowd of people that are trying to see what happened
5. I think that a plane was shot down and only the tail falls, that's not in the picture, on a road in a german culture town.
Anya (LCMS)
In this photo, there is a plane crash on a crowded street. This could be from a movie scene. The buildings around the area look very much undamaged. The photo was taken in the early 1900's. The photo is in black and white, and the people are dressed differently. There was a fire in the plane and people were rushing to put it out. Smoke is still around the plane and part of it looks burnt and charred. The plane crashed during the middle of winter. Most of the wreckage is strewn in the street and on the snow.
LCMS (LCMS)
The picture takes place in a city in winter, where a plane crash took place. In this picture it is winter. To show it is winter there is a pile of snow on the ground, and the style of the people's clothing. In this setting there is a plane crash that takes place which caused a fire. You can tell fire by the burnt plane wing, smoke in the air, and the fire hoses on the ground. I believe that this picture was set up because of the people. In real life situations people would not go that close to a plane crash right after there was a fire. This picture was most likely taken in the 1910s to 1930s due to the black and white of the picture. Also a person can tell by the style of the clothing from the firefighters.
Brianna (www)
I think that this took place in the Ney York because in the car it has NY that probably stands for New York. I believe that this is an airplane that crashed and it seems that firefighters are putting out the flames. IT seems that it was snowing since there is snow on the ground where the hose is placed. There are people surrounding the airplane that crashed
Jorge Abundis (WW)
I think a plane crashed in the middle of the city and everyone is looking of what it is. There are fire hoses on the floor because some people (fire men) are taking the fire out. This taking place in winter at New York in the olden days. I say this because the writing is in english.
Abi Bielski (LCMS)
Obviously, in the picture there is part of a plane in the middle of street, with a crowd of people around it. The part has the word "UNITED" on it, so I can safely assume this is United Airlines we're talking about. There also fire hoses on the ground and smoke in the air, implying that the part was on fire, with the smoke being the remains and the hoses being used to put it out. I also noticed snow on the ground, possibly implying that in the picture, it is either late fall, winter, or early spring (ex. November, December, March). The background, and I don't know if this is just me, but it doesn't look like America. I don't know how to describe it, but this city in the picture doesn't quite look like a city in America that I can think of. I'm thinking this more took place in England or somewhere around that section of Europe, but England is the most likely, just by looking at the signs, which are all in English. I'm thinking this picture was most likely taken some time after 1914, due to the black and white picture.
Casey.AOSE (Academy of Saint Elizabeth)
I agree that the buildings do not look American, and there is a truck on the left that states the name of a place called Belfort, which could be anywhere, such as France where there is a town named Belfort.
itz_ya_boi_michael (walla walla)
1. There is a building
2. There are more big buildings
3. People are gathered around
4. There are mo0re people
5. There is a plane crash maybe in the uk
colin (ww)
Box 1: there is a truck renting company called Belfort which is in Brooklyn New York.
Box 2: it seems very old and the buildings are different
Box 3: there is snow on the ground so this is probably during the winter time.
Box 4: there are people gathering around the plane that crashed.
madison (sms)
One day in fall in New York, the day was going normal until a big BOOM! came across the city silence and it was everywhere. In the corner of the Time Square a huge airplane was just setting there while smoke filled the air. Firefighters was spraying the plane down and people/ reporters were filling the streets; while on one side on the plane there was a little ridge of snow with a hose on it .
Diego Jaques (ww)
looks like the old days with a plane crash maybe new york city and it looks like winter because you can see snow
VTS Moderator (Seattle, WA)
Thank you @Diego Jaques. Can you tell us more about what you see that makes you say NYC?
Elizabeth (Sms)
There is an airplane from the United States and it has crashed into the city. It is a winter day and there was a fire. Everything is wet. Hoses are scattered around everywhere on the ground. This is a place in China. Also, the airplane crashed because the pilot wasn't paying any attention until they were in an accident.
Victoria (Tadino)
The picture looks very tragic. For what I think happened an accident with an airplane, it seems that an airplane accident happened because you can see that there are people around and a plane all destroyed, there are also firefighters around trying not to pass anything to the gene that is around Of the accident. We can also see that there is smoke in the streets and there are also fire hoses on the floor.
Zoe (sms)
A plane crashed on the ground and there is a bunch of people watching it. There is a bunch of people surrounding the crash of the plane. There is some smoke in the air. There is fire fighters and police there to try to see what is going on and there is some detectives. They are in New York.
Y.C.L (hths)
What's going on in this picture? Well that looks like a piece of an airplane so it must mean a plane crash has occurred and the people are gathering around it. Also those long rope/hose might have been used by the firefighter to put out any fire. Also it looks like the firefighter are telling the people who wants to know what exactly happen to back up and to not come any closer.

What do you see that makes you say that? It looks like it didn't hit any building cause the house doesn't look like it been hit or the piece aren't on the floor beside the plane.

What more can you find? It looks more like a neighborhood then in a city
Justin M (HTHS)
In this picture it looks like a plane has crashed in a town, a bunch of people are standing around what it looks like a plane. It looks like there are hoses that people have used to put the fire out. The building behind the plane is smoking from the crash im guessing.
Nicholas Lewis (HTHS)
it looks like a a plane crashed in a city, with people around it looking at what happened. And form the hose on the ground it looks like some firefighters have put the flame out. And it seems like it took place in america.
HTHS Maddie (North carolina)
It looks like a plane has crashed. There people from the towns gathering around to look. But it looks like the firefighters used the hose in the picture to stop the fire before it got to bad. I see a plane with black ash on it . I see a sign that says NO Parking.
M James (HTHS)
It looks like a plane or a rocket ship crashed in the middle of a city.

An airplane wing on the ground and people surrounding it.

snow on the ground so it's cold outside
Zachary B (HTHS)
In this picture, I can tell the corner wing of an airplane has crashed in the middle of the street. This image is black and white, so it is most likely old, however if you look carefully you can see what looks to be some sort of wooden structures holding up what is left of the inside of the plane. I think that because it looks wooden, this plane is fake, making this have to be part of a movie or something. The realism of the shot seems to make sense with the theory, because people surrounding the plane might make sense in real life. However, the person taking this picture would have needed to put in alot of work to take it at a time of black and white, especially because of the crowds blocking the image.
Dylan (HTHS)
I see its a snowy day and it seems that there was a plane crash in this area. The emergency services have responded to the wreckage. For a reason, I think the plane may have exploded in flight because I can only see the tail of the plane and no sign of the rest of the fuselage. There isn't as much collateral damage as expected for a crash to be. May have taken place in the mid 50s, early 60s.
hunter (hths)
1) It looks like the site of a plane or space shuttle crash
2) cause theres a wing or something on the ground that looks like its supposed to be on a plane or space shuttle and theres fire hose on the ground because usually there is a fire when planes crash
3) The picture is in black and white so its older and it kinda looks like its in Germany but it could be in the US.
Aunesty (HTHS)
It looks like a plane might have crashed in the middle of the street, its a plan wing. You can tell the plane caught fire because of the marks on it and ash. It looks like it could be winter because it looks like Ice or snow on the ground. firefighters tried to put fire out, water hose are on the ground.
Jalen Brown (HTHS)
It looks like a plane crash in some city, It kind of looks like New York and there Is a lot of people gathered around.
Izayah W. (HTHS)
It looks like a plane was falling apart while crashing down. Because there is a piece of a plane in the middle of the street. There are people standing around it with the fireman and the ambulance.
VTS Moderator (Seattle, WA)
At what point of this event are we looking at? Before or after a fire? Right after a crash/fall or a good few hours afterwards. What do you think and what do you see that makes you say that?
Daniel (Wisconsin)
I see many peoples.
I see a plane crash
I think the plane crashed in bad weather because many accidents happen in bad weather
I think it happened a long time ago
Christa (JMHS)
It looks like something after 9/11, after all the building that were on fire were put out, they find this piece somewhere on a different street in New York. Since there is snow on the ground, I think it's an event similar to 9/11 because New York did not have snow in September, the tail of the airplane is on the ground, and there are hoses everywhere. It must be in the U.S because of the street signs, the parking sign, and the truck in the back does have English on it. This could also possibly be something totally unrelated to 9/11 and it could just be the first time they were testing out airplanes and one crashed. It does look to be in the U.S, but probably roughly around the late 1800's to the early 1900's.
Christa (JMHS)
I take back what i said, its not the late 1800s to the early 1900s
amayajmhs (jackson,nj)
Because the picture is in black and white and the style of the people is dated, I know this happened between the 40s and the 60s. Upon further inspection I noticed the "Belfort" sign and when i looked it up it was a rental company in New York. Then, I looked up United Plane crashes in New York and found out that this is a picture of the wreckage from the 1960 mid air crash.
ErinJMHS (NJ)
In this picture, a plane crashed in the middle of the street. A wing of the airplane lies there as smoke fills the streets. The people of the town gathered around the wreck, trying to help put out the fires. The fire seems to mostly be put out so the photo would be the aftermath of the crash.
Jim BYrd (North Carolina)
jim byrd - hths it looks like a plane crash with a bunch of people gathered around it
Chase H (HTHS)
A plane crashed and they just put out the fires.
the fire hoses, the big piece of metal that looks like a plane.
ash water
Fabian (Wisconsin)
I see a plan crashed.
I think it happened a long time ago because this picture has black and white color.
I think many peoples died.
I think the peoples are helping.
Julia (JMHS)
This picture immediately gives off tones that are bleak, dismal, and dark. The first noticeable attention-grabbing detail is the sole plane wing resting in the street where it seems it has crashed. Evidence of crash is seen through the large crowd aburptly gathered, as if everyone were enjoying their typical day before it crashed. The photo is in black and white, so some age is inferred about the time it occurred, some time in the past where color was not popular/used/available. There are large piles of snow on the side of the street, plowed, so it seems it has been accumulated, also with the attire of the crowd in long jackets,it's assumed it is mid-winter. The smoke and fog looks like it's originating from the plane, perhaps it had been on fire because there is also a long fire hose laying across the snow. The "no parking" sign is in english, hinting that this is somewhere in the United States, however the buildings are older and victorian looking.
caitlin (HTHS)
I think that there was some type of accident or wreck , People are crowding around and there looks to be a big plane on the ground that didn't land correctly.
I looks to be cold like its winter, there are a lot of pipes on the ground and looks icy.
Dylan (JMHS)
This appears to be from a United Airlines plane crash. The picture is from awhile ago as it is in black and white with people dressed as in they would in the olden days. There are fire hoses and foam from the fire extinguisher The truck on the left of the picture says "Belfort Truck Renting Co." and the street sign says "7th Ave" which by research would mean this could be in New York City.
Zach F. (Jackson memorial)
This appears to take place perhaps during the WWII era. More specifically, the Battle of Britain. There is a fatal plane crash in the middle of the street, supposedly in London. It could also be somewhere in the United States, but the gloominess and bleak weather conditions suggest otherwise. The plane is so demolished, that it's almost unrecognizable and is in two fragments. The crash may have been caused by an attempted or successful terrorist attack, or it possibly malfunctioned. A profusion of people are encompassing the plane, curious as to what happened or to help. The only logical conclusion I can conjure up from this archaic photo is it's either in the United States or Britain with a destroyed plane.
MP D (HTHS)
It looks to have been a very bad plane crash or some sort of crash. There are fir hoses, lots of people around the spot, and there is lots of smoke. There is snow all on the ground, it seems to be an older picture in time, and there are lots of firemen.
Brandee (JMHS)
This photo is clearly dated. The black and white make that statement clear. Yet, the situation is quite interesting. A bunch of people are gathered around what appears to be a plane crash. Written on the plane is "United" most likely leading to the fact that it is a US airline. A sign in the left corner states "No Parking" meaning that it is an English-speaking location. The buildings in the background are clearly dated, as seen by the layout and fashion of the establishments. Snow is decorating the ground, hinting that the picture is taken during the winter. Smoke proving that the plan had been on fire and were being put out. From what is provided, I can safely assume that this was a major event in the early to mid 1900s, where a plane had crashed and broken into pieces. Most likely in the United States, but it could be in the UK or any other English speaking country. Perhaps it was one of the first airplane airlines and had crashed in a quiet town.
Emily (JMHS)
This seems to be a picture from the 1950s or 60s based on the style of clothing and the fact that the photo is in black and white. The center of the photo is a crashed plane with the word 'united' on the wing. Wherever this is it is an English speaking country as the sign to the left and the store in the back both are in English. The spire-like building tops remind me of England, so perhaps this photo was taken there. It is the winter time as there is snow on the ground and it looks like the crashed plane was once on fire because there is a hose on the ground, the streets look wet, and their are firefighters.
FionaJMHS (Jackson)
In this picture there is what looks like a piece of a plane, and it says united on it so I'm guessing its United Airlines. This piece of plane seems to have landed in the middle of this town or city and many people have gathered around. There could have been a fire because there is a big hose on the ground, people dressed in firefighter clothes, and smoke or steam all around in the air. From the picture I cant tell where this is taking place but based on the buildings in the back it looks like a older town or city and there are signs with english writing on them.
TylerJMHS (Jackson, NJ)
There appears to be a detached wing of a plane lying right in the middle of the road, with smoke surrounding the entire area. People are all gathered up around the wing, presumably because the wing had dropped right in the middle of the road from a plane crash. Long tubes are all around the road and sidewalk, which are connected to hoses. The Fire Department had came to put out a fire that came from the detached wing, causing all the smoke. Because the picture is in black and white, this must have been from one of the much older plane models.
Kathleen (JMHS)
The first thing I see when I look at this picture is the wing of a United Airplane. This must be the crash from Illinois in 1972. I believe it was this crash as the plane is in half and it looks like the clock tower in Illinois is in the background. It shows everyone coming together to save the ones who could be stuck in debris and trying to rescue them.
VTS Moderator (Seattle, WA)
@Braxton is noticing what is there int he photo as well as what is NOT there: "there seems to be no kids." Can the absence of kids indicate anything about the scene?

What more can we find?
Irish Tens 3b (Burlington, Ontario, Canada)
We see a large crowd of people moving to the intersection where a United Airline rudder has crashed. We see snow on the ground that tells us this picture was probably took in the winter. We see writing on the side of the truck that says “N.Y.” This makes us think that the picture was took in New York State or close to it. We see police officers and a firefighter in old-fashioned uniforms, a very decorative old-fashioned lamppost and a very old car, which makes us think this picture was, took a long time ago. We see white substance of some sort in the air. We are not sure if this is smoke, fog, steam, mist or something else. We see buildings, a church steeple, parking signs and street signs. This makes us think that this picture was taken in the middle of the city. Finally, we see fire hoses on the ground but they are empty. This tells us the picture was taken after they were used which might mean that the white substance is smoke or steam.
VTS Moderator (Seattle, WA)
@Irish Tens 3b, thank you for your many observation and ideas. Can you be more specific about what it is about the uniforms that make them "old-fashioned"?
Lizzie (jmhs)
In this picture, there is a throng of people gathering around what seams to be a crash of some sorts. There is a shroud of smoke gathering around the Victorian style and (at the time) modern modern buildings. There are firemen and policemen at this scene and their equipment. The most noticeable thing about this picture is that it is in black and white, which means that it was taken a long time ago. What I think happened is that a plane crashed in the middle of a street in a busy city, and all the people came to help or see what was going on.
Tom (JMHS)
It looks like the site of a plane crash, with the townsfolk gathered around trying to help and get a better idea of what has happened. It also looks like firefighters used the hose to tame the fire. As far as where exactly this is taking place, my best guess is Germany due to the look of the buildings around.
VTS Moderator (Seattle, WA)
@Tom, what about the building indicate that this could be in Germany?
MarionJMHS (Jackson, NJ)
Looking at this photo, the first thing that caught my eye was the item that appears to look like a planes wing. The word that states, UNITED, on the front reminds of United Airlines. I assume that the country is in France because of the truck that is in the background that says, Bonjour on the front of it. Also, the difference in architecture makes me think that the location is in a foreign country.
Shaun (JMHS)
In this picture there is obvious panic. I presume it is an airplane crash. I think this because from the United label on the plane and the size of the object. I also assume this is in a major city because of the large crowd it grew wouldn't be in a small town.
Jadon (JMHS)
I see an airplane that has obviously crashed into the streets of some city. I initially thought it might be in a different country but I saw that the signs in the street were written in English. It definitely looks like it took place in maybe the 1940's or somewhere around there. By the burns on the plane I can tell it caught fire and I would imagine it damaged the buildings surrounding it in some way. It looks like a total disaster and I'm really surprised that this picture is not more well known because it looks like something that would be talked about for years and years after it happened.
VTS Moderator (Seattle, WA)
Just a reminder that you can use your zoom tool to hone in on details. What more can we find just by looking longer and closer?
VTS Moderator (Seattle, WA)
Film set or actual plane crash? Is this a constructed scene or a documentary photograph? I'm seeing both ideas in the comments. What are your thoughts - either way (or perhaps there are other ideas), please provide the visual evidence for your interpretations and claims.
Braxton (vancouver w.a)
It looks like a plane crash and because the picture is black and white it has to take place in 1950-1970. The people there look older and there seems to be no kids.
Julianna P <3 (Vancouver WA)
I see ice on the ground so most likely winter... I can see a shape that looks like a plane wing...and a fire hose on the ground as well so maybe the fire fighters tried to put the fire out.... an now there are people crowding!?!?!?!?!??!?!?!?!?!?!??!?!?!?!?!??!?!?!?
Room20 (Califonia)
We think that this picture was taken in the past in perhaps Germany. We think it was taken in Germany because the sign hanging outside and the architecture looks different than America. We think that a plane crashed in the middle of the street and the people of the town are trying to help and firefighters are using a hose to put out a fire from the crash.
VTS Moderator (Seattle, WA)
Hello @Room20, thank you for joining the discussion. What specifically about the architecture is different than what you might expect in an American setting? Thank you.
Fabian (Wisconsin)
I disagree because I see the parking sign is written in English and the words on the truck are in English, as well.
Jose L.C. (Houston)
This crash had to take place around the 1950's or up. The peoples clothes look from 50-60 years ago. The signs are in English, the top of those far buildings look medieval a style used in western hemisphere, I don't see anything like those around here. The Airplane tail says United, I don't know anything about plane history but I'm guessing it was one of the first Airlines.
VTS Moderator (Seattle, WA)
@Jose L.C., thank you for sharing your close looking. What specifically about the tops of the buildings makes you say they are a medieval style? For those of us who may not be familiar with architectural styles, it helps us to learn from each other when you can share what exactly you are noticing.
Destinie (Texas)
This picture shows an airplane crash in what looks like England because of the buildings in the background. The plane has "UNITED' which is obviously from the US. I believe this picture was taken to show a tragedy between Europe and US.
Alonso M (Houston)
Plane crash maybe in the 1960's in a big city of the United states looks like many casualties did happen big fire etc caused big chaos
Damian Salinas (Houston)
a plane must have a had a critical failure causing it to fall and ultimately land in the streets of what i can assume is new york and well you can see the results of it
Jennifer (Houston)
The image is from s catastrophe in England, a plane crash by united airlines. The image seems to be from England because of the Gothic architecture and the lamppost. And also because the signs are in English, snow is present, and the clothing is intended for snow. The picture is from mid 1900s due to the lack of color in the photograph. When the picture was taken, the fire had already been turned off, and only smoked remained.
Alex G. (Houston)
This picture Is part of a movie trailer that is set to come out four years from now, and it is reenacting a plane crash from the late 1950's. The crowd are trying to figure where the rest of the plane is whilst aiding any harmed survivors or passerby.
Kassandra V (Galena park, tx)
it is in new York because Belfort truck renting company was founded in new york and also the wolf of wall street last name is belforts (hints he baisically owns new york) it could be in 1940 or 1960 because of the clothing
Jocelyn M (Galena Park)
It looks like a horrible accident that took place a long time ago. It looks like a wing of a plane and it looks like the plane exploded and landed what looks like England.
Bailey (Texas)
This looks like a plane crash in the middle of a town. This might be in a European country or New York. Based on their clothing and it was in the winter maybe 1950-60s. Emergency crew is around helping people, and putting out fires.
VTS Moderator (Seattle, WA)
Hi @Bailey - you're thinking about setting, time period and the activity...what specifically do you see that makes you say this could be Europe or NY? Thank you!
Brianna (Houston)
In this picture there seems to be a United Airlines plane that has crashed. People are surrounding the plane while smoke and rain is clouding the street. This picture seems to be taken place in America since the street signs are in English, however the buildings seem to be European, but it also looks like New York. On the ground there seems to be water hoses which probably put out the fire from the crash. I believe this picture was taken at least an hour after the plane struck since there isn't that much commotion going on.
Brandonn (HTX)
The most eye-catching item in the picture is the plane. It appears to be crashed, and is a US plane. There is a huge crowd of people already at the scene, which I would assume is in a very populated town. It looks like an older picture, and could maybe be a sort of attack.
Nat (Houston)
There appears to be an airplane wing in the middle of the rode and everyone surrounding it. It was probably in the 50's or 60's because of the clothing.
jaz (texas)
It looks like there's been a destruction or accident. Like a plane crash, the plane says United on it, it might be in England. there's people observing what happened. There's like smoke or fog around, so you can't really see the buildings clearly. There's also some sort of white thing on the ground, and it looks like there is some water hoses on the ground.
Victoria AOSE (AOSE)
The first thing I notice in this photo is the wing of a plane that crashed and a crowd of people surrounding the wreckage. Since this picture was taken in black and white, I can infer that this was taken in the early 1900s. There is smoke in the background with the foggy outline of buildings. This most likely takes place in a large city such as London because the writing on the plane says "United," a well-known airline. Also, there is a "No Parking" sign, in English as well. It looks like this takes place in the winter season because of what looks like snow on the ground. There are hoses on the ground to put out the fire from the plane. People are wearing raincoats, hats, and other old-fashioned clothing. Some are walking over to the scene and talking to each other. There are also lampposts which look like they were built in the past.
VTS Moderator (Seattle, WA)
@Victoria AOSE, thank you for sharing your careful observations. Besides the color of the photograph which suggests perhaps older technology and time period...are there details in the photo that place this scene in the early 1900s.
Savannah (lcms)
There was some sort of crash, looks like a plane crash in the town. There is a part of the plane in the ground. There is also a bunch of people surrounding the incident and smoke coming around the accident. There's a hose leading up to the plane. The plane says "United", so i think the plane is from the U.S.A. I think this picture happened a while ago. I think so because of the way the buildings look. I also think so because the way the cars and the clothing people are wearing look.
anonymous (pa)
In this picture it looks like something like a plane wing fell. Everyone is surrounded looking. It looks like firemen were there because of the hoses on the road. The town they are in looks old from the way the buildings look like and the pictureis in black and white.. The atmospher looks cold and rainy and that could've caused the plane to crash. There are it seems to be cops blocking people from getting to close or to make sure everyone is safe. This event could have taken place a long time ago.
Ashauni (Lcms)
In this picture it looks like a plane crashed. I see everyone standing around it to see what happened. I think this photo is older because it is in black and white. Older day they didn't use color for photos. I also think this photo is older because of the buildings in the background.It also looks like a cold winter day. I can tell by the heavy jackets and snow on the ground.
Luke A. (LCMS)
In this picture there seems to be a tail of a united airlines plane that crashed. Based on the cars and clothing you can infer that the picture was taken in the late 50s, early 60s. There are fire hoses on the ground and the tail looks burnt so you can infer that the tail was on fire. This must of happened during the school day because there are no kids in the picture. The plane must of broke apart in air because the rest of the plane is not in the picture.
Anonymous (Anonymous)
I see a plane wing on the streets. Maybe there was a crash that happened and then a fire broke out because i see a fire house also in the picture. Maybe the airline in United Airlines. They must have crashed into something or ran out of fuel. There also seems to be snow on the ground. So maybe they crash because of a snow storm. Where is the rest of the plane why is it only the wing. Maybe the plane hit something when it was falling and the rest of the plane is somewwhere in the city.
DrakeB (Peoria)
What happened to the rest of the plane? This United airplane must have crashed about 15-years ago. I think the people on the ground are people that live in the buildings next to the plane.
Ambie (Minnesota)
It looks like there was a tragic airplane crash that caused a fire and people are worried and scared in possibly the 1900's due to their clothes style and the black and white picture
VTS Moderator (Seattle, WA)
Hello @Ambie, can you be more specific about what it is about their clothes that places them in the 1900s? Thank you.
Dan D (Lcms)
This is a severe plane crash in the 1900's somewhere in America. It seems to take place in America. It takes place in America because of the english writing on the sign or if it takes place anywhere else it could be somewhere in England. This is a severe plane crash that has happened. Hoses running up to the crash with the firemen. This also could be in the 1900's. I say this because of the black and white color of the picture where black and white pictures and film took place. Also it is a plane that crashed in the middle of the road. There is a plane wing and other debris across the road.
Alex (LCMS)
It looks like a united plane crashed in a city. I know this because on the plane's tail it has the word united on it. And the debri of the plane is all over the place. The photo was taken in the late 1900's because of the people being dressed in suits and dresses. And i also know that because the photo's color is black and white. The people don't look scared. I know this because they don't look like they are panicking or worried.
Madisyn (LCMS)
In this picture I see a united plane that has crashed in a small town. Many people are surrounding the reck. The plane has caused a fire I know this because there are fire hoses. This picture is very old considering the black and white the clothes and old timey buildings make is seem like it was taken is the 40's. The people dont seem very shocked by the way there faces look. i don't see any other part of the plane is it somewhere else? Is it stuck on the house? in conclusion it seems as if the plane crashed and people arent is shock.
VTS Moderator (Washington, DC)
Can you talk more about what you see that makes you say that the plane crashed 'in a small town' @Madisyn?
VTS Moderator (Seattle, WA)
@Madysyn, thank you for joining the discussion. Can you share what you see that makes you say the setting looks like a small town?
Anonymous (LCMS)
This was a plane crash that happened in somewhere in the United States. I know that because on the wings of the airplane, "United" is titled on there indicating it's an American airline. Judging the looks of the city, it looks different than modern cities today so the picture had to have been took in the late 50's. More I can find to this picture is the atmosphere looks cold, judging by people wearing coats, the fog in the sky, and the winter slush on the ground. There is also a giant fire hose on the ground indicating that help came right away so that no further disaster occurred. Noticing all the people, it definitely makes sense why they're all accumulated around the plane and questioning what was the cause of this horrific event. Further observing the looks of the plane, the wings are the only parts present in this picture. The body of the plane could've burned to ashes or flung elsewhere when the plane came down.
VTS Moderator (Washington, DC)
Keep up the good work of looking closely and supporting your inferences with visual evidence!
justin nye (log college)
In the photograph, a plane has crashed. I know this because there is a tail of a plane in the road. This photo also takes place in the mid 1900's. This is a reasonable time period guess because of the style of the cars and style of architecture. This photo is probably took in Britain. I can tell because there is English on the truck but the style of the city is not very American.
Anoymous (LCMS)
A United airplane fell from the sky. I know this because all of the people from the town are surrounding the plane. There is also a mess on the ground. One thing that is confusing is that the people don't seem all that scared. Is this a movie set? This picture has been taken a long time ago and the town is old. I know this because the picture is in black and white. Also if you take a look at the people's clothing it seems to be not in style. I also notice that they're no kids!
anon (LCMS)
This picture seems to be in the 1950's and 60's time period. I know this becuase if you look at he surroundings in the picture you can see things seem to be very old fashioned, like the cars in the background and the street lights with the building structure. Everything seems a little different from this time now. The event seems to have happened in a city of sorts maybe New Orleans or New york because with the looks of it heavily populated. Even if this is occuring in America, America is involved because the plane wing says 'United' which could be The plane company United airlines or something along those lines.
Jp (LCMS)
This plane crash looks like it is apart of a movie scene. This is because no one is looking scared. Also, this looks like it was from a long time ago. This is because the picture is in black and white. There is a hose sitting behind the plane. There is also smoke on the plane. The hose could be used to put out the smoke. Also, there is no damage to anything. This could also explain why this could be a movie.
Emma (Pennsylvania)
This photo shows a U.S plane crashed into the middle of a busy road. I can tell it's U.S because of the word "UNITED" on the wing of the plane. It's also a busy road because there are large crowds of people surrounding the crash, most likely to see what is going on. The city or town looks to be vintage and old. I can tell this because the building shapes in the background, seem to be pointed, and gradually get more slim as they go up, like how they built in the older times. Also the black and white, gives off that vintage, olden time vibe. It also looks cold out judging by the visible smoke, how people seem to be wearing coats, and the snow/slush left on the road. And people are also crowded by the accident, most likely to see what the commotion, or the cause of the commotion was. I also see a fire hose on the ground, most likely used to extinguish the fire that probably happened when the impact took place of the plane crashing into the ground.
Corey (LCMS)
The picture seems to have been taken from a long time ago, around the early 1900's. The plane must have been crashed for a while. I know this because the people are not panicking. Since the picture was taken in the early 1900's, plane crashes could have been a regular thing back then. I know this because the people are calm and not panicking, they are just gathered around the scene. The picture also seems to have been taken in a European country. Nowhere in the U.S. do houses look like that, not even in the 1900's.
Anon (Lcms)
In this picture it seems to be in the 1950's or 1960's. The cars look very different from how they look now, more oldfashioned. The buliding structures also look like were built awhile ago, like more modern. Also the people in the picture clothes don't look like something people would where today like there is more jackets and hats. This could have been a plane crash. I see a plane wing sitting in the middle of the road. It also has the word 'united' written on the wing, which is a plane company. Its weird though because where is the rest of the plane?
Noelle (Lcms)
in this picture it looks like a united plane fell from the sky. I know this because the wing is pointing up and it says united on it which is probably a logo. There are long hoses and smoke so it must of caught on fire. firefighters probably had to put a fire out. There are many people around but they don't look scared they look sad or worried because they are just standing looking around. everything looks very old fashion so this might have been a while ago. It could be a movie set or something like that but I think it looks pretty real.
Mackenzie McCarty (Log College)
Obviously this is a plane crash. Because there is a wing in the middle of the street. This also most likely takes place in a European country. Or the united kingdom because the wing says United. This could also take place back in the day, oh like maybe the 40's. Because of the way there clothes look.
VTS Moderator (Washington, DC)
@Mackenzie McCarty is there additional evidence in the photograph that supports your theory that this photograph was taken in a European country? Evidence that call into question that theory? What more can you find?
sara (sms)
I Think that a plane as crashed and a lot of people are trapped in the plane. There are snakes all around the people.
Victoria AOSE (AOSE)
@sara, are you sure those are "snakes"? They look more like inanimate objects such as hoses. Also, how do you know that there are people trapped in the plane? Please give more evidence to support your answer.
megan (sms)
I think in this picture there was a crash in the town.The crash was a plane because there is a plane wing on the road. There was a fire too becasue there is smoke everywhere in the town. Someone shot the plane or smacked right into it. The plane tail is half gone.
Rivaldo (SMS)
What i think is going on in this picture is that a United states plane crashed into what seem like new york city. The people are trying to get the plane out of the city by spraying water onto it. The reason why the plane crashed is beacause it may have had a problem in th epilot that's why.
Jesse (sms)
i think that a plane that has crashed and it went into a building and it has a lot of destroyed
Ashten (SMS)
thair is a plane crashed on the in America. it looks like on the plane said united mabey it means unties airlines . it lookes like it hade snowed and it looke like thair is a big hose so mabey they put out the fier .
Ben (SMS)
A war plane has crashed into the city of New York. I think that the it was taken down by another plane. The fire department was putting the fire out.
k (sms)
I think that a plane has crashed and the fireman came and everyone came and stold around.
Jesse (sms)
So i think that a air plane crashed into a building and they ar eximateding of what happen.
Bridget (LCMS)
It looks like a United states plane crashed down in a city probably in New York. I think this because of the lamp posts. I also know this because of the buildings. It also looks like it is in the past. I know this because of the style of the cars and the sign in the background that says "LAUNDRY". I also know this because of the clothes that everyone is wearing. The hoses indicate that the pane was on fire. i know this because of the hoses and the smoke above the plane.
Spenser (SMS)
A United airplane fell from the sky. People don't seen scared, people are surrounding the plane. the buildings, cars, and plane logo are old maybe not from this time. There is snow on the ground and a fire house. Maybe it's a movie set.
Nick (SMS)
I think a plane crashed into the middle of a city. All the people are gathering around it because they wanna see the plane and see if the people inside survived. They might also be taking pictures. There is also a lot of smoke coming out of the plane. The plane is from the United States because it says United on the plane.
kaitlyn l. (hths)
1. This picture is old picture of the results of the plane crash.
2. I say that because the picture is in black and white and part of a plane is on the ground.
3. The plane is probably from the United States because United is on it.
Lindsey Fontaine (SMS)
There was a plane crash in America. The plane was from United Airlines. The hoses on the ground are from the fire department.The plane crashed in a well known area because it is by a laundry mat. This picture was taken in the old times!
VTS Moderator (Washington, DC)
Several comments today have drawn our attention to words in this picture which give us hints as to where and when this may have been taken--we have identified "no parking" signs, the "7th AVE" street sign, the "Belfort" truck, and the "United" plane tail. @Lindsey Fontaine is now drawing our attention to a laundromat sign on right side of the photo below the street lamp and smoke.
Ms. Mansfield's Class (Renton, WA)
A United airplane fell from the sky. People don’t seen scared, people are surrounding the plane. The buildings, cars, and plane logo are old maybe not from this time. There is snow on the ground and a fire hose. Maybe it’s a movie set?
VTS Moderator (Washington, DC)
Hello @Ms. Mansfield's Class! Can your class come up with:
1. Possible explanations for why, assuming it was an actual crash, those on the street don't seem scared?
2. If it is a movie set, visual evidence to support that theory?
VTS Moderator (Washington, DC)
While most agree that they think this is a picture of a plane crash, some wonder if this photo depicts an actual accident or a staging of a crash for a movie. What evidence can we find to support these contrasting interpretations?
kaitlyn l. (hths)
Good job its very descriptive, good luck and keep up the good work.
ford (michigan)
I think that during WWII the germans shot down an USA airline passenger plane, and it crashed into the middle of the city. They have all the snow there to try to stop the fire from spreading in it.
Fia (Hudsonville)
This photo shows a crashed planes in somewhere like Brooklyn, I think this because of the trucking co truck in the background.
Maya (Michigan)
I think a plane had crashed and landed into this city, people are all around observing what had happened. I also think something had started on fire because of the plane because there is a fire truck hose. It looks like it happened a long time ago because the picture is in black and white. Also it looks like it in the winter time because there is snow on the ground. It seems like two planes came together and parts went flying different places in new york. The look of the old city and the snow on the ground with all the people around a wing of the plane makes me say that a plane had crashed.
Barnaby Willis (Michigan)
This looks like an American plane that crashed in a British city.
VTS Moderator (Washington, DC)
Hi @Barnaby, what do you see that makes you say "British city"?
VTS Moderator (Washington, DC)
A few of you are wondering about the architectural style(s) of the buildings in the background of this picture. What more can we discover about the built environment shown here?
ruby lehmann (none)
I think that a plan crashed in the middle of a busy road and everyone came out to see it
Aubree (Michigan)
Observing this picture, I think a U.S plane has crashed and landed into a vintage city. Also, I see people gathered around and scared for hurt others. I say this because the wing of the plane reads "UNITED". And judging the looks of the city, it looks a little older and different than newer cities today so I think maybe this event has been at least a few years ago. It definitely makes sense why people are accumulated around and worrying about this horrific event and wondering what's the cause of this too. More I can find to this picture is the atmosphere looks cold, judging by people wearing coats, the fog in the sky, and the winter slush on the ground. I also see a giant water hose placed on the ground, so I think help came right away and got the fire out that the plane crash has caused.
irineo Avalos (Houston)
A plain crashed in a city along time ago.
Maycie T (Hudsonville, MI)
It looks like a plane from the United States or a United Airlines plane crashed in the middle of the street in a city. The city doesn't look like it's in the United States because of the style of the building, but the picture doesn't appear to happen recently because it's in black and white. The whole plane doesn't seem to be there, just the wing. But the other parts of the plane could've burned to ash and now people are gathered to observe what happened.
Chris K (Hudsonville Mi)
The police are there to give the plane driver a ticket because they are in a no parking zone, as you can see if you look at the far left of the picture
Makenna (H)
It looks like a plane or something crashed into a city and people were curious on what happened so they gathered around. Also i believe if its a plane its United Airline Because its "United" And this picture was from a long time ago because its black and white.
Chris K (Mi)
I think a plane crashed and there trying to keep people away from it because there are police and firefighters surounding it keeping people at a distance
ford (michigan)
A united plane crashed into a building, and caused panic in the city. Many of the people did not know what was going on at all and ran there to see what was going on, or there is a movie being filmed and this is all a scene. I think this because theres no police or fire. I don't know why they would have a snow bank in the middle of the street.
Maddy (Michigan)
It looks like a United Airlines airplane crashed in the city, although I don't know where the rest of the plane is. It also looks like a European city, rather than American. There's smoke from the crash, and since it's black and white, I think this wasn't recent, although it could've been and they just used a black and white camera for some reason.
Aidan W. (Michigan)
I think someone mistook a street for a landing strip. The pilot might have been blind because I don't know how you mistake New York for an airport.
Avery V (Hudsonville MI)
A plane crash has happened in a popular city in the winter. As you can observe by the picture the tail of the plane has the word "united" on it making it most likely from the United States. You can infer from the fire hose on the ground and the smoke in the air that the plane possibly went up in flames after the crash.
priscila herrera (houston)
It looks like the old ties and it looks like a airplane fell off and all the people are scared
VTS Moderator (Washington, DC)
@priscila herrera -- What do you see that makes you say that people are scared in this photo?
Eva Orbock (Athens, GA)
In this picture I see the ruined remains of a crashed United Airlines planes in the middle of a street. A crowd of a lot of people is gathered around the rare spectacle, watching smoke rise in mesmerizing patterns from the fallen vesicle. The back of the plane is clearly visible, as is the United logo. On the ground you can see hoses, presumably from fire trucks, that have littered the ground with water. I can see what appears to be ice collected on the side of the road, from this and the fact that the crowd is dressed in warm clothing, allows to conclude that it is winter, and quite a bitter one at that.
Paige (TOW)
In this picture, it appears to be a plane that has crashed. The plane says "united" on it so I am guessing the picture takes place in the United States. To the left of the plane there is a truck that says Belfort on it. The truck also says NY on the side of it so I am thinking that the picture was taken in New York. Judging by the snow and the way people are dressed, you can infer that it is winter. I am only seeing men in this picture. The street lights look very old. And the way people are dressed shows that it takes place over 50 years ago. The buildings also look very old and so does the hose nozzle in the front middle of the picture.
Victoria AOSE (AOSE)
Good observations and evidence supporting your New York theory!
Kendra Carnell (Tow)
In this picture I see part of a plane. This part looks to be the tail of the plane. There are also a truck that says Brooklyn Ny, 1966. This corresponds with the dress of all the men. There are also old fashioned street lamps and car. There is snow on the ground and the building on the right looks like it maybe on fire because of the smoke or it could just be fog. There are also old looking fire hoses.
Jesus G (Houston)
It looks like an airplane falls on a street of some city of Europe, i think its Europe because how the streets light looks and looks like was on the 60's or 70's.
Kaylen (Hudsonville Michigan)
I think that this picture is showing a tragic event of a plane crash on a winter day in a city. I know that it is a plane because United is an airline company. I also notice a white pile on the ground, that could be snow. There are also fire hoses on the ground because the plane could've went into flames during the crash. I can also infer that the event must have happened awhile ago because the image is in black and white.
Keaton (M)
A united airlines flight crashed in the middle of Brooklyn NY.
Erika (Houston TX)
This image looks like it was back in the 40's or 50's knowing that they're old fashion cars and the clothing that the people are wearing and this image was probably located New Jersey or New York...it looks like there was a plane crash but parts of the plane were broken due to the tail of the plane that is in the middle of the streets.
Nathan St. John (Hudsonville Mi)
The truck on the left side says Belfort Truck Renting Co."with NY printed on the side so i think it is in New York. You can tell there is a plane crashed because it's body is smashed and there are fire hoses to most likely put out the fire caused by the crash. Also, there is snow on the ground so there was probably a storm that took down the plane.
VTS Moderator (Washington, DC)
Thank you for looking very closely at the details to reveal clues as to where this photograph may have be taken. @Nathan St. John is drawing our attention to the truck in the middle ground on the left side.
Rebecca h. (Hudsonville)
1. A plane crashed in a city
2. There is a plane wing that is broken in the street.
3. The picture is old because the picture is black and white. Also the picture was taken in Belfort. People are curious and gathered around the crash. Maybe the plane crashed because it was foggy. The picture looks very foggy. The buildings are old fashioned.
Dylan M (Hudsonville, MI)
In the picture it looks like a Inited airlines plane crashed in a big city, then blew up. I think this because I see a destroyed plane in a city. Also, I see a big crowd and a fire hose which makes me infer that firemen put out a fire.
VTS Moderator (Washington, DC)
Some think that the word "United" on the plane tail references the Unites States of America, and therefore that the plane was an American government or military aircraft. Would anyone like to share other interpretations of what "United" might reference?
Juan Rodriguez (Houston Tx)
This plane looks like it crash some where in another country because of the buildings around and it was on the old days because it is on black and white and the cars look old
Carter H. (United States)
I think what happened in this image was a plane crash in the city and the people are trying to find out what had happened. I also noticed that this photo was taken sometime in the 1960s.
VTS Moderator (Washington, DC)
What do you see in this photo that helps you date it to the 1960s @Carter H.?
Shawn Hansen (Old Forge)
In this picture there is the tail of a plane that is on the street. All of the hoses are either for putting a fire out, or getting oil out of the crashed plane. There is a truck that says Brooklyn New York, so I am going to assume this picture is in Brooklyn. I believe that this is the tail of the plane because of the flap that is on the left side. And I have seen planes with the “United” on the tail of planes. A plane has gasoline and oil in it, so I think that they are trying to pump oil out of the plane incase there is a fire. There is snow on the ground, which makes me think that this crash was during the winter or spring. The clothing has a 60’s look to it, the police uniforms/hats are very vintage and not modern. The picture is also in black and white, which makes me believe it is from the 60’s.
Max H (Chaska High)
I think that this plane obviously crash landed and the people around it are trying to find out what is going on and how it happened. I looks to me like it was an older picture based on clothing and the fire hose.
Kendra Carnell (Tow)
I agree with the older looking clothes and fire hose. I did also notice what appears to be fire fighters running to the right of the picture down that street. The plane had to of crash landed because the plane is in pieces.
VTS Moderator (Washington, DC)
The figures in this photograph are dwarfed by the scene itself but warrant a second look. Some have pointed out first responders like firefighters, and others have noticed bystanders. Take another look at the people in this picture. What more can we find?
Tatianna (sms)
In this picture there is a big accident going on. This happened 12 hours after 911 happened. The airplane is on the ground broken into pieces,and it hit a building. When it hit the building, the plane broke into pieces, and then fell from the sky; hit the ground and cracked. This happened in 1982,and this took place in London. The piece in the middle on the right is small, and it is in the middle of the crowd of people,but looks like a lion. When the airplane fell it killed about 100 people that day.
VTS Moderator (Washington, DC)
@Tatianna is providing us with some specifics, "this happened 12 hours after 911 happened" (Sept. 11, 2001), "this happened in 1982" and "it killed about 100 people." Can you share more about what you see in the photo that makes you think these things?
Noah (Chaska High School)
To me it looks like a plane just crashed and they are cleaning it up
Claire Ganske (chaska high school)
United states tail plane part came CRASHING DOWN causing ruckus
Diego (Houston)
This photograph, taken by Allyn Baum, depicts a scary scene in which the tail of a United Airlines plane has come off and fallen into the street; many people gather around to witness the scene for themselves and firefighters have come in to put out the fires on the tail. One of the most prominent features of the picture is the long firehose snaking through the street. This hose serves as a sign that there was a fire which has since been put out by the fire department. Also visible in the picture is a word on the battered tail of the plane: United. This indicates that the plane is very likely one of United Airlines' flights, and the broken tail shows that the rest of the plane has definitely crashed as well (as a plane cannot fly without its tail). This picture shows what is probably a tragic event in history from the perspective of an eyewitness.
xtaforster (Houston, TX)
@diego: I like how you've tagged the photographer in your claim, giving credit to the documentarian of this scene. I love your use of the compound sentence to extend your claim! Your word choice is also strong; for example, by using the word "snaking" to describe the hose, you emphasize that an ominous, even "tragic," event has occurred. The snake is such a powerful and universal symbol, and by aligning the hose with a snake, your also inferring something about the powerful artfulness of the photographer's eye.
River (Chaska High)
There's a crashed plane... and it looks like it's winter time.... I don't know if it's recent - I mean it -is- in black and white.
A (A)
1950's plane crash in america
Ryan (SMS)
RUN!! WE WILL ALL DIE!! The TERRORISTS ARE TAKING OVER. They took down a passenger plane! It is very icy and rainy therefore they put the salt down and the passenger plane came down it the middle of the city where they put the MOST SALT. The salt stopped the passenger plane! After the passenger plane stopped the EMTs got to it.
VTS Moderator (Washington, DC)
Is there something you see in this photograph that makes you think the plane crashed due to a terrorist attack? Can you consider other reasons a plane might crash?
Morgan (Chaska)
In this image it appears that a plane crashed in a city and this is where the back end of the plane ended up. There are hoses on the ground and firefighters around. So the plane must have started on fire and they had to put it out.
n.a.p (Minnesota)
In this picture it look likes a plan crash and there were firemen to put the fire off that the plane could be on fire. It could be in the US because of the english writing and how on the plan it says UNITED on it.
hi (chaska)
This looks like a United Airlines plane crashed into a bigger city and the firefighters had to show up going by the hoses. The surrounding people are trying to figure out what happened.
Cindy Flores (Hoiuston)
This picture shows the wing of a airplane. It looks like it crashed in the middle or the main road. A lot of people from the 1940's are watching how bad it crashed.
Georgia (SMS)
I think it is happening in New York because of the truck has NY on it. The United Kingdom off of a plane because of the shape of it. It looks like a lot of people. It was a cold day and tons of cars where backed up and people where injured and the pipe/hose is to stop the oil from spreading.
Ashley (MN)
I think that this is a plane that crashed in the middle of the city and citizens are looking at the damage.
Stephanie (F.)
This picture is of a plane crash that happened somewhere that is broken and crashed in a street. It is a United Airlines plane that crashed in 1970s. It was a huge deal because those planes don't normally crash.
VTS Moderator (Washington, DC)
@Stephanie can you back up your claim that this plane crashed in the 1970s? Was there something you saw in the photo that helped you come to that conclusion?
19quinteroponceg (High school)
In this picture I see a piece of a plan has broken and landed in a city road. There are many people surrounding it. I think the piece of the plan was on fire or maybe going to start because it has smoking coming out and there are firefighters that have a long hose to put out the fire.
Sierra (SMS)
It seems that a tail of a plane has crashed into the city. The tail of the plane crashed really close to the buildings. It's a good thing the tail did not catch fire because there is a big hose lying on the ground. There is a big herd of people. The side of the tail of the plane stands for U.S.
Wayne Gretzky (Edmonton)
I think that is is the site of a plane crash in New York. It appears that the plane wing had caught on fire and the fire department had broken the fire.
Jose (Houston)
I think the airplane crashed there because of a engine failure.
VTS Moderator (Washington, DC)
What do you see in the picture that makes you think the airplane crashed because of engine failure? What are some other possible reasons a plane might crash?
Kolby (Barry IL)
A plane crashed and people are gathering around looking at the crash.
Claire (M.)
It appears that a plane's wing fell from the sign and landed in the middle of the street. The wing is most likely the only thing that fell because the rest of the plan isn't in the picture and there would be more of a commotion if the entire plane fell. I think it fell somewhere in Europe based on the architecture.
figueroa (galena park)
the picture happeneds that the plane and people are looking about what happened to the plane if some people are inside and they are okay . its look a misterious picture because you want to know everything about what happened in the picture
VTS Moderator (Washington, DC)
Thanks for sharing, @figueroa. This photo does beg a lot of questions and makes me wonder too. If you were curious to learn more, where might you go to find information about this picture and the story it tells?
Justin A (Galena Park, TX)
This picture shows the plane of United Nations crashing down in somewhere in Britain or Europe because the street posts are unique and people are wearing fancy clothes and nice jackets. No one wears nice clothes to go out anymore, so this picture is really old because its black and white. There's snow on the ground so it must be really cold,
Tera H (Barry, IL)
I think a plane crashed in the middle of the city and people are surrounding because they are nosiey and want to know what happen, the roads are wet because most likely the plane caught fire when it crashed and they had to stop the fire.
JACOB W (Under your bed)
I think a plane had crash-landed in this city and people are observing, or trying to find out what happened. The plane could have came from the US because it says United on the wing, but that could just been the name, like "United Airlines" if that were to be the name of the plane it must have came from American Airlines. I just researched United Airlines plane crashes, and I have seen images that look exactly like this image from what I had searched, so I come to conclusion thinking that this could be United Airlines flight 533 plane crash that had crash landed while it was approaching Chicago in 1972.
VTS Moderator (Washington, DC)
Thank you @JACOB W. I like how you are researching this, can you find more about this? Keep up the good work!
w clay (az)
What i believe is going on in this picture is that a plane hit a building or the tail detached from the plane in mid air and at the time it was snowing at the time and then people came around to see what happen but they really could not do anything about it so people cleaned up the mess and then went back to work, but the firefighters stayed behind to help the people that got injured during the crash.
Corinne (warminster)
In this picture its set back in the 30s or 40s. The quality of the photo taken and the clothes the people are wearing in the photo give away from period of time its from. All what looks like clouds is steam or exhaust from the fire of the crashed plane. There is a long rope covering the ground that is a hose to take out the fire. there is water covering the ground as well which shows the hose has already been used. The plane has a giant bold letters printed "UNITED" so this is an American planed possibly from the time frame of WW2. The plane looks blown up from the angle of the photo.
Tianna (sms)
I think the plane got hit by a bomb or someone planned an attack. I wonder why this picture is in black and white? It looks like there is snow on the ground and a fire hose is laying on the cold hard snow. The people look really concerned and maybe it was because there were loved ones on the plane. People might have been killed and the people are wondering what happened to their loved ones. It looks like there is fog or a mist from the water that got sprayed on the plane because it was on fire. This may have happened a long time ago because of the black and white photo. It happened in the US because United is an American plane.
Kailee (sms)
I think the people are in the 20th century and there was an army plane crash. People came to see what happened. There was a fire so the people had to put it out with a fire hydrant. They are in New York. I say this because there are the letters, NY on the side of the truck.
David Valdez (Galena Park High School)
David v. looks like there was a plane reck in the street or a piece of the plane broke off on the road.
jacob (sms)
I think it is the first plane crash which ever happened and people are scared and amazed at the same time. They wonder what happened to the rest of the plane. Was it blown up or did it get destroyed and blown away? No matter how it happened they will always remember it in their minds. They were very scared to fly a plane so no-one ever asked, until they made new ones which are safer.
VTS Moderator (Washington, DC)
Keep up the good work responding to each others' comments and asking follow-up questions. I appreciate the respect we are showing each other, especially when we don't see what someone else does or we don't necessarily agree. Well done!
Chapa is Daddy (HTX)
Ouch!! It looks like a plane crashed onto the road, people scared surrounded the plane, not knowing how the plane had crashed, this tragic disaster remains anonymous
Janine AOSE (AOSE)
I appreciate your sense of humor for this event, @Chapa is Daddy, but is there any information you can offer up to this situation, such as where/when the picture was taken, what kind of plane it was, etc.
Pablo Leos (Galena Park ,Texas)
this looks like the ww2 period and maybe thats a united states plane and is crashed some where in Europe and people are looking at the tail of the plane
Citlaly (SMS)
I might not say truth about this picture but in my site, this kind of looks like a piece of a plane and people are surrounding these objects. I can say that it can be a tail of US plane that have might of broken off and probably the rest of the plane could've crashed somewhere else. I'm pretty sure that the tail was on fire and fire fighters came. I predicted that because there is smoke and a hose on the ground to put the fire out.
Loading... (Loading...)
I think the Plane in the picture crashed and the people are looking for survivors. I say this because of the broken tail wing in the center of the photo. The white trail might be fire retardant foam from a fire extinguisher. This is because of the huge trail of foam in the left side of the screen. This picture seems to be old. This is because it is black and white and grainy and the people are wearing older fashion clothes. I think this photo is mainly about the Plane though.
Jonathan (LCMS)
in this picture it appears that an airplane crashed in a town. i say this because the is the tail portion of the plane in the middle of an intersection. it looks like the town that the plane crashed in has a decent population. i say this because of all the people surrounding the crash site. it looks like the plane crashed in a town in England because of how the houses are made and set up, also it looks like the truck in the background is an company in England. it also looks like firefighters have the fire under control because in the picture its just smoke. it also looks like a snow storm has just hit but the snow is starting to melt. since the picture is in black and white, the crash probably was in the 1900s. i say this because the people look like there're wearing older types of clothing.
Jack (Houston)
This picture taken by Allyn Baum is showing a crash site for a United Airlines plane that must have crashed possibly decades ago. It is clear that the plane is from United Airlines due to the large "United" logo on the chunk of the destroyed pane. This crash probably did not happen in the United States which can be proven by the style of the buildings in the city that would most likely be European. If this did happen in the United States, it probably happened in the Northeast somewhere. It is evident that this picture was taken at least couple of decades ago due to the moving truck which is a very old model that would not be used any time now. My final analysis is that this was a plane crash that happened in a country that is probably not the United States and this crash happened some time ago.
Nick C (LCMS)
The thing that is going on in this picture is that there was a plane crash happened on a street. People are watching the burning plane? I know this because it happened on a street where people live. There was a fire when the plane crashed. There are hoses on the ground to take down the fire. It's in black and white because it happened during WW2. There was a lot of war during that time.
VTS Moderator (Washington, DC)
@Nick C agrees with a few others that this may have occurred during World War II (1939-1945). Other than the black and white quality of the photograph, what do you see that makes you say that?
VTS Moderator (Washington, DC)
Many of us are wondering where this photo was taken. Some think a large city in the US, like NYC or Chicago, others think this may have been photographed in a city in Europe. What more can we find to help us infer where this took place?
Bodie (Log)
What's happening in this picture is showing us a peice of a plane that broke off and fell into the street in a town/city. The hose laying nearby tells us that the peice of the plane was on fire. The black and white coloring of the picture tells us that this was not something that happend recently. It looks to be cold out since everyone seems to be wearing heavy jackets and there looks to be snow on the ground.
Hailey Grengel (Lcms)
there is a broken off piece of a tail of a plane in a middle of a city. there is also snow on the ground so it is winter time. there is people crowded around the broken plane piece most likely in shock that this happened. this picture is in black and white so i can infer that this was taken in the 1900's. there is a huge hose on the ground so there was a fire that the fireman had to put out. there is also a lot of debris on the ground. there is also a lot of smoke in the air so there had to have something burning.
Brook B. (Ethiopia)
This is an image of a plane which crashed into a city somewhere in the U.S. This is an older crash, with one obvious showing of that being the color and quality of the image, so this was probably between the 40s and the 60s, and another reason is the height of the buildings. Buildings were much smaller back then due to the in-building transportation, such as elevators, which probably were much more unsafe back then. The cause of the crash could have been anything, but it probably was some issue in the manufacturing of the plane, as planes were obviously less advanced back then.
awesam (an area)
It looks like in the picture there has been some sort of terrible plane crash. The shape on the misplaced object has the shape of a teared apart plane tail. The people seem very serious but not worried (unless its not shown). I know that in the world if something is out of place humans are always curious about whats happening so these people were confused of possibly a giant noise from a crash in the street so natually came to check it out. The mound of snow and the side leads me to think that it is winter time. The hoses on the ground are most likely there because you can see fire fighters and they thought there was a fire. But because its winter and the plane may have had an overheating engine the warm air mixed with the cold would make it steam making it seem like a fire.
Christian (Houston)
Mr. Baum's photo looks to portray a United Airlines plane crash in the early 20th century in a big metropolitan city. First, the black and white color of the photograph, the vintage automobiles, and the citizens' attire photo leads one to believe that this takes place in the 20th century. Moreover, the key subject in this photo is of course, the airplane that has been demolished. The back wing is visible in the perspective of Mr. Baum, and one can see that it reads "United." United is a major American airline company. There is smoke coming from the area of the crash and firelighters on the far right of the photo trying to fight the fire originating from the plane.
Remy Kalai (Houston)
This picture depicts a crashed United plane in Brooklyn during the early 1960s. This is obviously a United plane because of the logo written on the tail that had fallen over the street intersection. Its is possible that it is in Brooklyn based on the look of the city and the old truck in the back says, "B-N.Y." which most likely means Brooklyn. This happened during the early 1960s because there is an old truck in the back left of the picture with old writing on the side, the street lights are from a different generation, the fire hose looks very dated, and the picture quality is that of the 1960s (similar to that of many pictures taken during the civil rights movement). Also, United has not had a passenger plane crash in decades therefore it must be somewhat old.
P.J. (LCMS)
There is a plane tail that says "united" so i'm thinking it probably has to do with united airlines. I'm gonna go out on a limb here and say that the hose-like debri was probably from some sort of fire. which resulting from the plane crash, is why the house next to it is smoking.there are a lot of people circled around, meaning it's a big town."No Parking " sign means it's somewhere that they speak english. Snow means it's winter.firefighters,referring to sentence #2
Emma Gilliam (Texas)
I think that this is a picture of the United plane that crashed in New York City in 1960. The wing clearly says "United" on it and the way the wing has been separated from the rest of the plane looks like it isn't an exhibit where the wing was separated from the plane on purpose, but a crash. The snow indicates that it is winter, supporting that this would be a picture from the 1960 crash in New York, as it happened in December. In addition, the people's clothing shows that this isn't a recent picture and that this was taken decades ago.
Isabella (Wisconsin)
In the picture there seems to have been a plane crash in a small city/town in France. I know it is in France because the sign for one of the stores says "Belfort Truck Renting Co." Then I looked up Belfort and it said that is was a town in France. There is also a fire hose in the picture. This shows that the plane could have caught on fire/blown up because of the crash. This would result in the passengers being killed. Which could be why so many people are crowded around the plane.
Jeffers Shaper (Houston)
This picture is of a plane, presumably a passenger plane, that crashed somewhere inboxed New York in the 1900's. The plane says "United" on the side, so it could be of United Airlines. USA military planes, which was my first guess, do not say "United" only without at least "States" written after. So, it has to be a passenger plane. The snow on the ground, the english writing on all of the street signs, the American firefighter uniforms on all of the firemen, and the Belfort Truck Renting Company truck all suggest that this crash happened in New York, or at least in the Northeast. The Belfort truck says N.Y. on it, so the company is stationed in New York, but someone could have driven it a long way while they moved. All this leads to conclude that this passenger plane has crashed into the Northeastern region of the US, so hopefully nobody was on the plane at the time.
Hudson (Houston)
In Allyn Baum's picture you can see that a plane has crashed in a cold snowy city street. This plane tail once belonged to a United Airways flight and it has somehow gone down and crashed in a city street. I am guessing this is in New York because on the truck rental car it says N.Y. on it. Also this seems like it is in the `960's due to the cars and the overall quality and color of the picture. This picture shows a horrible event that has occurred in New York in the 1960's and has impacted many people in the past and soon the future.
xtaforster (Houston, TX)
@hudson: Good job tagging the photographer! I like how your diction (word choice) implies the mystery inherent in the picture: the plane has "somehow gone down and crashed in a city street." That word "somehow" captures the enigma in the picture; so many questions arise in the viewer's mind. Not just, "what happened," but also "who?" "where?" "when?" "why?" and "how?" I'm happy to see you use specific details to hypothesize about the "when" and "where" —New York, 1960s, the cars, the B&W. Without a doubt, this appears to be a "horrible event" that occurred; doubtless, too, it impacted many people, as you say. I wonder what you mean by that last phrase, "in the past and soon in the future." Which future are your referring to: the one we are living toward or the one in the photograph?
Nicolas Contreras (Texas)
This is a picture of a United Airlines plane that has crashed in Brooklyn sometime around the 1960-1970's. In the very back there is a truck that that states "Belfort Truck Renting Co. BKYLN. NY. Plus, I know that this picture was taken in the 1960's or 1970's because of the clothes the people are wearing, the picture is black and white, and because commercial airlines like "United," exist. This picture shows us the aftermath of what might have been an extremely deadly accident.
louisa (houston)
This is an old picture of a the aftermath of a united airlines plane crash in the US or England in the winter time. In the photo, everything is in english, but the buildings make me think this is in England because of the architecture. The plane crashed a while ago because no one is putting out the previous fire suggested by the smoke and ambulances are all gone. No one is holding the fire hose, instead the firefighters seem very calm. The people look curious instead of concerned and no one is rushing anywhere. You can't see the rest of the plane, so I don't think anyone was hurt here considering we only see the tail and not the section where passengers were actually sitting. The shot of only the tail adds a bit of mystery that makes the audience wonder where the rest of the plane is.
Michael (LCMS)
In the picture a plane has crashed in a road. I know this because part of the plane is sticking out of the road. This setting is in Europe. I know this because in Europe the buildings have the pointed things on the roof. This crash made a huge disaster in the road. I know this because there is fire hoses in the road. The road is damaged really bad. There is white stuff in the road.
Hannah (Houston)
A United plane has crashed into an Belfort, a city in France, and onlookers are horrified at the scene. In the middle of the street a piece of the plane labeled "United" is smoking, which indicates it has just recently crashed. Also, the truck in the background says "Belfort Truck Renting Co.", which leads us to believe that this city is in Belfort, France. This photo captures an unfortunate event where a plane has fallen in Belfort, and the spectators there are gaping at the unbelievably horrible reality.
xtaforster (Houston, TX)
@hannah, I love how your claim is so assertive! I'm wondering how you placed the scene of the crash in France, especially because the words in the photo (on the street signs, the storefront, the truck) are in English. Perhaps you used the internet and searched terms like "plane crash" and "Belfort," a strategy that our technology makes easy to do, so easy that we may even overlook some of the details that we see when we look further into the text. Look closer, linger a little longer. Use your own powers of critical thinking more before turning to the "authority" of the internet to tell you what's going on! :)
Emma (Stout)
In this image people are gathering to see the aftermath of a plane that had crashed due to harsh weather in New York between 1957 and 1967. The truck on the left side says "Belfort Truck Renting Co." with "NY" printed on the side and the street sign says 7th ave. so we can assume it is in New York. You can tell the plane has crashed because it's body is smashed and there are fire hoses to most likely put out the fire caused by the crash. Additionally, there is snow on the ground and the sky is foggy so we can assume that the plane crashed due to the harsh weather. Allyn Baum, the photographer of the picture, was employed at the New York Times as a photographer from 1957 to 1967, and since most images selected for the "What's Going On in This Picture" are previously used images from the NYT, it is clear that this photograph was published when Baum was employed. It is clear that this is a stressful time given the crowd and plane wreck.
Madi (Texas)
There is a tail of a United Airline plane that has crashed down in a large city; I think this crash took place around the 1900's. There is smoke in the air and long hoses on the ground which makes me think that the plane was on fire. Many people have gathered around and the tall building makes be think that this is not just a random old small town. This picture is taken in black and white so it must be an older photograph. There are also old cars in the picture. I see policemen; this was an unexpected crash.
Leon ($)
I think this is the fire department putting out a plane crash fire.I think this because I see men in old time fire men gear and I see hoses and I think this a plane crash because I see a tail of a aircraft thing that says united and thats a airplane brand.
Sam (mexico)
in this picture it looks like there was a plane crash, everyone is gathered around the tail of the plane and there is fire hoses which means it must have crashed and caught on fire.
Kennedy H (Wisconsin)
There was a big plane crash and everybody noticed it got help.
Joe (Zimbabwe)
This looks like a picture of a United States plane because on the tail it says "United". It also looks like an older picture because it is in black and white and the font on the truck isn't something you see today, the people are wearing clothes that I've also seen in other older pictures. I think that it's in Europe because of the way the buildings are built.
andrew krause (milwaukee)
It is a plane tail that crashed into a street and it started to burn because you can see a hose and firefighters. You can see smoke in the backround. It looks like it could he been in the late 1800's because it is in black and white. It looks like it was in France because it loos like the writing on the truck in the back round is french and the buildings are so the plane could have got cut of from the tail.
Olivia F (My imgination)
I think this is the tail of a united plane that crashed elsewhere and possibly was blown up because if the tail is in a different place then the rest of the plane must be somewhere else. This picture is either set up to look like it's old or it is an old picture. Nobody is holding up phones taking pictures or live streaming, and the background buildings look very victorian aged. The clothes that they are wearing are also more aged. You can see it is in winter or early spring time because of the snow and obviously there was some sort of fire, because the fire hose is laid out on the snow.