I have grown up with Paul Simon songs. Seeing him in Chicago two weeks ago was a culmination. I was struck by just how well his voice has held up. What an amazing concert and an amazing man.
6
I was at the show in Philadelphia last Saturday, and was blown away by how great it was! Kudos, Paul - you still got it in spades at 74!
2
Mr. Simon, retire if you wish, and have fun, too. Remember it's not so much what you have done in life directly, but what you have done indirectly to other people! Thanks for all the great tunes, no need to stop anything, in you're "retirement".
5
Thank you for making my life a little better and I amnot implying I have had a bad life. To the contrary I have been blessed and your music was part of that blessing. Thanks. "And here's to you Mr. Siimon...."
2
Steve Berlin must be deeply saddened to hear about Simon's alleged retirement.
2
I saw S&G live at Muhlenberg College in 1968. No one in music that I can think of has more neurosis than Paul Simon. If he's ready to hang it up, Do It. His music has been both wonderful and too self-absorbed and I personally am tired of his public kvetching.
2
My high school mentor taught me that pop culture can be every much as artistic as High Cul-tcha.
He showed me this in film with Stanley Kubrick's "2001: A Space Odyssey." (e.g., the shot late in the movie when the monolith is perpendicular to 3 or 4 moons of Jupiter lined up vertically, thus forming a cross into which Dave Bowman's pod is gliding. Then the "acid trip" sequence, and Bowman aging, seeing the monolith on his deathbed, and then born again.)
With pop music it was a few Simon & Garfunkel songs. "Scarborough Fair" with its contrapuntal anti-Vietnam war lyrics. "The Sound of Silence" with the great, great line "The words of the prophets are written on the subway walls, tenement halls, whispering the sounds of silence." And the commentary on our country in "Mrs. Robinson," fitting Mike Nichols' film "The Graduate" perfectly.
And then just for pure fun: The exuberance of "Call Me Al" in the 1980s.
So many great lyrics and melodies and vocal performances over the years.
Thank you, Paul!
He showed me this in film with Stanley Kubrick's "2001: A Space Odyssey." (e.g., the shot late in the movie when the monolith is perpendicular to 3 or 4 moons of Jupiter lined up vertically, thus forming a cross into which Dave Bowman's pod is gliding. Then the "acid trip" sequence, and Bowman aging, seeing the monolith on his deathbed, and then born again.)
With pop music it was a few Simon & Garfunkel songs. "Scarborough Fair" with its contrapuntal anti-Vietnam war lyrics. "The Sound of Silence" with the great, great line "The words of the prophets are written on the subway walls, tenement halls, whispering the sounds of silence." And the commentary on our country in "Mrs. Robinson," fitting Mike Nichols' film "The Graduate" perfectly.
And then just for pure fun: The exuberance of "Call Me Al" in the 1980s.
So many great lyrics and melodies and vocal performances over the years.
Thank you, Paul!
9
I just listened to Kina Grannis sing a cover of "Graceland" this morning and realized all over again just how amazing so many of Paul Simon's lyrics are. Have to check out his new record. We're here. We're gone. The world moves on. Find comfort in that. And there's always song.
2
Believe me, you will have to pry his cold dead fingers from the frets on his guitar. Paul may be tired of "showbiz", for which I cannot blame him in the least, but music is in his soul, in his blood and in his very essence. Paul won't ever stop his musical genius anymore than he can stop his own heart.
7
Graceland was the first and only album I memorized from beginning to end. I was in elementary school at the time, and sat on the floor in my parents' living room reading liner notes until I could sing every word of You Can Call Me Al, then all the rest. Then when I left for college, I packed the CD (without my parents knowing) because it was a reminder of who I was. Years in Seattle, San Francisco, then New York...and now back home, his music has brought me comfort, inspired me, and helped me feel connected to the world. Thank you, Paul. You're a good friend through the amazing work you do.
3
Simon is confused. Make David Chapman killed Lennon.
1
Continuing my thoughts on Paul Simon's apparent retirement from songwriting : it will be very strange for the next several years to realize that Mr. Simon will not have an imminent studio album on the horizon. My hope is that he will change his mind and 'surprise' us with a new creation. If that is not the case, the legacy he leaves is immeasurable. I'm convinced that his solo work after the S&G days will gain in stature in the coming years. Many die hard S&G fans prefer Simon's songs from the great duo's era, and their admiration for those songs and albums is understandable. But Paul's solo studio albums are extraordinary, every one of them. 'Paul Simon' is an outright classic, as timeless now as when it was first released. 'There Goes Rhymin' Simon' is a pop masterpiece, one of the most joyous, technically gorgeous albums ever recorded, and it contains that indelible, haunting masterpiece, 'American Tune'. From 'Hearts and Bones', 'Graceland' and each succeeding album the songs become more challenging. One could say that in his own way, Paul became the Stephen Sondheim of Pop. I've no doubt he could have turned out endless , hummable tunes if that was the direction he wanted to go in, but he took a different path. Most of his songs were of the non-linear variety in terms of lyric writing, story songs that bore into the brain the more one listened to them. And the music became more intricate and rewarding even after repeated playing of the albums.
A national treasure.
A national treasure.
4
Lennon's assassin would love to use these words as a defense the next time his parole comes up. "Fame. It killed Presley. It killed Lennon. It killed Michael Jackson." Unlike Bob Dylan, Paul McCartney, and quite a few more names, it's hard not to sense he doesn't keep himself up for it on any of the three big fronts: spiritually, mentally, and physically. ... Yes, Mr. Simon, our egos will dissolve. No matter how big we are, we are all destined for that worst of things: forgotten. Over centuries. Time works its bit. But, instead of worrying about such things, why not embrace the love of those around you who worship you in whatever way. Instead of clearing your eyes to see tents in the horizon, see the eyes of your fans. In each eye, you will see far sorrier fates than the one you have found. More sadness than you even you have felt. You're right that ego dissolves and we must face the big curtain. But, it seems to me, instead of embracing the morose aspect, embrace what is REAL. The talent that coursed through YOU and found its way to fans. The LOVE shared. You might find it revivifying.
11
Love the new CD! Wristband is a great tune and is both wise, current, and sophisticated lyrically. Paul Simon still has the notes and the words, and knows what to do with them. Hope he is enjoying his well earned respect as an American great. If he retires, Ill listen to his existing canon, and think of him having a good time with his friends and family, which he deserves. If he writes something new, Ill buy it and listen to it with appreciation and admiration. If he has a concert, I'll eagerly try and attend. Thanks, Paul.
4
Best of luck to you, Mr. Simon. You are an American treasure.
8
Oh wow. Well thank you for everything Paul Simon. You've been the bedrock music of my life for 4 decades. The poetry and the music, combined to perfectly explain being human.
I have only two regrets :
1] That Paul Simon never aimed his talent at Indian Music. We got his take on the blues, latin music, african music, rock, etc. Imagine a Paul Simon album combining his brilliant lyrics on the human condition backed with his take on the melodies and beat of India.
2] Never hearing live anything from the criminally underrated The Capeman soundtrack. I am ssure the experience pained you but trust the music is brilliant.
"
.... Everybody loves the sound of a train in the distance
.... Everybody thinks it's true
"
I have only two regrets :
1] That Paul Simon never aimed his talent at Indian Music. We got his take on the blues, latin music, african music, rock, etc. Imagine a Paul Simon album combining his brilliant lyrics on the human condition backed with his take on the melodies and beat of India.
2] Never hearing live anything from the criminally underrated The Capeman soundtrack. I am ssure the experience pained you but trust the music is brilliant.
"
.... Everybody loves the sound of a train in the distance
.... Everybody thinks it's true
"
2
I got to see Paul about three years ago at MSG playing w Sting. Absolutely remarkable. I've spend 50 years listening to his music;)
3
Some of these negative comments are amazing. The Internet has really brought out the trolls in us. I'm not expecting all praise. But cmon this guy is a genius. All those great songs.
A soundtrack for growing up in Amerika.
A soundtrack for growing up in Amerika.
8
If Paul is interested in neuro science and spirituality, here is a website he might find interesting. It has an article called The Parable of the Hemispheres that explores such issues. www.cwlpub.com/brain.htm.
Seems like he's talking about touring, music as product, and the biz in general. All of which a full artistic life can do without entirely. He's an excellent guitar player, and doing that on the porch all day seems like heaven to me.
3
In the early 1970s he was my favorite songwriter. I knew the lyrics to some songs by heart. He is almost like an old friend.
4
15 hours of sleep at a "stretch"? What does this mean? Per night? Ambiguous.
3
Genius. Absolute, pure genius.
Song after song after song that turn back the calendar 50 years and freeze time. I can't carry a tune in a bucket, but I can't not sing along at the top of my lungs whenever I hear Bridge Over Troubled Water. Kodachrome. The Boxer. The Sound of Silence was the first. The list is long.
Thank you, Paul, for a lifetime of pure listening pleasure.
Song after song after song that turn back the calendar 50 years and freeze time. I can't carry a tune in a bucket, but I can't not sing along at the top of my lungs whenever I hear Bridge Over Troubled Water. Kodachrome. The Boxer. The Sound of Silence was the first. The list is long.
Thank you, Paul, for a lifetime of pure listening pleasure.
11
If 'Stranger to Stranger' truly stands as Paul Simon's final album, he is leaving on a very high note. My admiration for Mr.Simon really began with his first solo effort following the Simon and Garfunkel years, simply titled 'Paul Simon'. That album heralded a new beginning for Simon ; as meticulously produced as his previous works were, there was an edge and grittiness to the new album that eschewed the prettiness and occasional pretentiousness that at times threatened to overwhelm some of those early songs, however remarkable the S&G albums were.
And with each new release creativity and inspiration went hand in hand, with albums as diverse as they were remarkable. "There Goes R
And with each new release creativity and inspiration went hand in hand, with albums as diverse as they were remarkable. "There Goes R
10
Paul has written some beautiful music. Being retired at 71, I think I understand some of what he's going through. I love and listen to lectures in theology, neuroscience and history. I am very careful about the use of my time knowing I may not get up tomorrow morining. At some point late in my career I realized life was too precious now to do the "scutwork" or cover the details few enjoy. My target is to become more loving and less angry with the help of God. It drives me and brings true meaning to my life. I suspect he's feeling something like that coming to the surface of his soul. God bless him.
14
Well said sir!
3
When I returned home from Vietnam in November, 1970, one of the first albums, if not THE first, I bought to play on the Panasonic stereo system I had shipped in my hold baggage ("hold baggage" was just that, sent across the Pacific in the hold of a ship, arriving weeks later) was "Bridge Over Troubled Water." I wore that record out.
18
Paul Simon's best music is behind him, way behind him. Not that you'd know it from all the critical hosannas. But despite what the Times and many of the posters below may say, he's overrated, and has been for a long time. Perhaps it's because of the "literary" style of his music, which many people seem to think is important, and elevates him to a higher status. He's more than a musician; he's a "poet," etc. But it's bad poetry and boring music, and way too self-important.
13
Why would you want to write such a hateful comment? If you can't say something nice...
5
Farewell! God bless. Congratulation on knowing the time.
8
How many 74 year old rockers have a recent song that's spinned on college radio stations today? That in itself says a lot about the timeless appeal of this genius' music. Wristband is a brilliant song. It ain't Bridge Over Troubled Water but hey he's still got 'it' going on. And not as embarrassing to watch in concert as Mick Jagger.
6
To say Paul will be missed is to say the climate as we knew it will be missed. A giant among giants. He deserves to ride it out any way that suits him. He's been bringing art and light into a dark world for a long time. Godspeed, Paul. We love you! History will never forget you!
11
This up-and-comer seems like one to watch out for!
2
I can't count the number of times I saw Paul Simon in concert. From Carnegie Hall around 1975 to being in the audience for the third SNL when he was the host to re-opening the Beacon in 2009. He deserves a rest.
1
Paul Simon ... still relevant after all these years.
5
Reading about Paul Simon's impending retirement (if there is such a thing), I'm remind of two things. The first, the first time I heard "Bridge Over Troubled Water." I borrowed the LP from my local library. I remember the feeling. Something I hadn't experienced before. The second is that as people whose art I grew up listening to hang it up, or simply pass away, I'm reminded of my own mortality and begin to wonder if I've done anything that was meaningful. I think I have and I think Mr. Simon believes he has.
3
No matter what you do from now on, Paul Simon, you made my life better because your music was there for me, touching on the soft spots the world hardens all too quickly. Thanks to you, I found them early and appreciated them for the rest of my life.
8
Adrift in the foam of time - lost in a current of talent - timeless and perfected.
2
I had the great fortune of attending the Simon and Garfunkel Concert In Central Park around 1980. It was a wonderful experience all around. The crowd, the weather, the music...
Paul Simon, the individual, always seemed like a nasty brooding fellow.
Buy I choose to give him a pass, as he has written songs that are absolute poetic gems.
His songs make me feel so good inside and bring me back to a time of innocence lost.
I wish him well.
"Where have you gone Joe DiMaggio? Our nation turns it's lonely eyes to you..."
Paul Simon, the individual, always seemed like a nasty brooding fellow.
Buy I choose to give him a pass, as he has written songs that are absolute poetic gems.
His songs make me feel so good inside and bring me back to a time of innocence lost.
I wish him well.
"Where have you gone Joe DiMaggio? Our nation turns it's lonely eyes to you..."
4
nice to hear someone like Paul being honest about his limitations - so many performers feel they need to keep going forever, as if they owe us something more
1
Not to be a stickler for the facts or anything (and Elvis and Michael's tragic demises aside), but Mark David Chapman killed John Lennon, not fame. That may have caused him conflict — torment, even, as an artist — but the world was robbed of Lennon and the beauty he created by having been murdered, just at the unbelievably sweet moment of his re-emerging.
5
One special thank you to Mr Simon is his love of world music and ability to bring all sorts of music into his own compositions so fluently. This has, I know, been controversial, but regardless, it has enriched his music, our ears, and other musicians. I actually saw Tom & Jerry when I was in elementary school: Paul's mother was a substitute teacher there and brought them to play for us. They were imitating the Everly Brothers and Doo Wop then. No artists aren't great imitators but some go beyond "mere" imitation. Simon is one.
7
Music, and Paul Simon's in particular, is a byproduct. It represents something much deeper within the musician; what we hear is only half the conversation. His music wasn't a gift to us, it was an invitation into his world, and that's what I thank him for. That world is precious to me, and I'm never too far from it.
Only Paul can decide when it's time to hang up his spurs, but I can't imagine what he hasn't accomplished. Like always, his voice comes from a place we won't ever have a wristband for. Thanks, Paul, all best, and I'm raising a glass to you.
Only Paul can decide when it's time to hang up his spurs, but I can't imagine what he hasn't accomplished. Like always, his voice comes from a place we won't ever have a wristband for. Thanks, Paul, all best, and I'm raising a glass to you.
5
Approximately 17 or so years ago Paul Simon was touring with Bob Dylan. They would alternate nights opening and closing the show. I was (and still am, in some respects) a big fan of both of them. This particular evening at Madison Square Garden, Dylan opened and Simon closed. Dylan was great even though as usual you had to wade through the first several chords before you were able to recognize what he was playing. He was backed by three or four musicians and they played hard, driving, great Rock and Roll. Intermission came and it took almost half an hour to set up for Simon. It appeared as though he was backed by what seemed like am orchestra. Had to be 30 or so musicians. They began to play and after two or three songs I felt as though I was watching some spectacle in a Las Vegas gambling palace. It seemed phony, staged and the contrast between what he was doing and what Dylan had done could not have been more stark. I left after the third song with no regrets at all. Dylan lived up to every expectation. Paul Simon on the other hand just did not do it for me that night at all.
I still love the great albums, Bookends, Graceland, Still Crazy....but, that night at least Paul Simon was a huge disappointment to me.
I still love the great albums, Bookends, Graceland, Still Crazy....but, that night at least Paul Simon was a huge disappointment to me.
1
I hope he's truly made peace with Art Garfunkel. I saw him perform a number of year ago, and the hurt he still felt over their break up was very evident although he in no way spoke disparagingly of Simon.
4
Paul Simon is one of the greatest troubadours in American letters. His only equal in musical and lyrical composition is Bob Dylan.
As far as I'm concerned his greatest album, among a litany of great albums, is "There Goes Rhymin' Simon" which was issued in 1973, in a time of great pain for a nation recovering from Vietnam and Nixon. It was healing poetry set to song, as powerful, in its own way, as the Stones mighty "Exile on Main Street", issued in 1972, which channeled the anger my generation felt still experiencing Vietnam and Nixon.
My favorite song on the album is "American Tune", the last stanza of which I have always felt a deep affinity with because it so beautifully and heart-breakingly describes the arc of my family's experience:
"We come on the ship they call the Mayflower
We come on the ship that sailed the moon
We come in the age's most uncertain hour
and sing an American tune
But it's all right, it's all right
You can't be forever blessed
Still, tomorrow's going to be another working day
And I'm trying to get some rest
That's all, I'm trying to get some rest"
American Tune, 1973
Thank you Paul.
As far as I'm concerned his greatest album, among a litany of great albums, is "There Goes Rhymin' Simon" which was issued in 1973, in a time of great pain for a nation recovering from Vietnam and Nixon. It was healing poetry set to song, as powerful, in its own way, as the Stones mighty "Exile on Main Street", issued in 1972, which channeled the anger my generation felt still experiencing Vietnam and Nixon.
My favorite song on the album is "American Tune", the last stanza of which I have always felt a deep affinity with because it so beautifully and heart-breakingly describes the arc of my family's experience:
"We come on the ship they call the Mayflower
We come on the ship that sailed the moon
We come in the age's most uncertain hour
and sing an American tune
But it's all right, it's all right
You can't be forever blessed
Still, tomorrow's going to be another working day
And I'm trying to get some rest
That's all, I'm trying to get some rest"
American Tune, 1973
Thank you Paul.
5
Just as a point of information, the "tune" for American Tune comes directly from Johann Sebastian Bach.
1
Thanks for all the great music. If you had stopped at many places along the way - "it would have been enough'. But you continued and produced even better music - so thanks. You deserve to stop if that's what you want. Enjoy whatever you decide to do.
3
I was an engineer at both Columbia and Warner Bros Records and worked on Paul's records. In fact, I'm looking at a gold record for the record "Paul Simon" right now.
I wish you happiness in the rest of your life.
I wish you happiness in the rest of your life.
14
Paul Simon, you are a wonder. Do go on.
"I'm sailing right behind, like a bridge over troubled waters I will ease your mind" That song and those lyrics helped me make it through some very thorny evenings during my teen years and in my twenties. But I loved "Wake up Little Susie" the way he and Garfunkel sang it. And the one that does it for me now is "Old Friends". The line, how suddenly strange to be 70..." tears at my heart. So, I may be "still crazy after all these years" but I was not alone when I listened to or hummed the music of Paul Simon.
8
It may be time to hang it up. I bought the latest CD, yes I'm 65 and still buy CD's. It was pleasant, but boring. He has lots of very good solo albums, but his best music is still with Garfunkel.
Sorry.
Sorry.
7
Nice try, Artie.
8
I agree ... He has had his generous amount of time in the spot lite ... He needs to take up gardening or be more active in philanthropy ... I'm 63 myself but must say his 74 looks closer to 84 ...
Beg to differ. "Graceland" and "Rhythm of the Saints" are two of the greatest albums ever made. No Garfunkel.
11
Note to Mr. Simon: You don't need to question who you are. Music is your heart and soul. It is a gift to all your fans. Bach composed music within a year of his death due to failed eye surgery. I don't think you will be able to stop writing and playing. Now maybe you could slow down a bit and not do so many tours or performances. But when music is such a huge part of your life you won't be able to let it go entirely.
I'm 74 too and have been singing in choirs since I was a teen. I've had to take a break because of an injury, and every time I hear one of the choirs I've been part of, I cry because I'm not there. I'm hoping to return to singing this fall. If I, a mere choral singer can't give it up, how can you?
You don't need to worry about running out of material. Tunes will still enter your head. If you are worried about your voice, take a few voice lessons. But please don't quit. If ever the world needed your music, it's now.
O.K. Maybe I'm just sad you plan on stopping, so sorry for the "lecture". But I'm planning on going to England next year for my 75th birthday. Maybe I'll be able to catch a performance if I'm near where you're performing. I hope so. And if you do decide to quit, leave knowing you've created a beautiful legacy.
I'm 74 too and have been singing in choirs since I was a teen. I've had to take a break because of an injury, and every time I hear one of the choirs I've been part of, I cry because I'm not there. I'm hoping to return to singing this fall. If I, a mere choral singer can't give it up, how can you?
You don't need to worry about running out of material. Tunes will still enter your head. If you are worried about your voice, take a few voice lessons. But please don't quit. If ever the world needed your music, it's now.
O.K. Maybe I'm just sad you plan on stopping, so sorry for the "lecture". But I'm planning on going to England next year for my 75th birthday. Maybe I'll be able to catch a performance if I'm near where you're performing. I hope so. And if you do decide to quit, leave knowing you've created a beautiful legacy.
5
Paul Simon's music and lyrics have been a part of my life for over fifty years. What a wonderful man and what a gift he has given me and countless others.
12
SImon is a rarity in popular music-- a mature adult. And by mature, I don't mean old. He's been that way his entire career--thoughtful, meticulous, self aware. Sure he "thinks too much" and can write like an English major sometimes, but his musicality, his vocal phrasing, his intelligence and wit always win out in the end.
25
Just listened to Stranger to Stranger.
Puts Simon in the same category as Woody Allen: great artists who lost it since 2000.
Puts Simon in the same category as Woody Allen: great artists who lost it since 2000.
9
Paul Simon is definitely not in the same "class" as Woody Allen. His lifetime achievement is stupendous and will be with us for years to come. You do not ever "lose" that.
4
He should have quit while he was ahead. Nothing more sad than a great one running on fumes.
1
Aw, c'mon now Lisa Fremont, be fair! Running on fumes? Hang it up in 2000? Here is Paul Simon in 2011, on the 10th anniversary of 9/11, singing and picking, beautifully and movingly, "Sounds of Silence":
https://youtu.be/yZGzdT4EKYY
Alas, his fumes at age 70 our more powerful than my full tank turbo 20s!
I think Jeff Jefferies hijacked Lisa Fremont's NYT account and wrote this comment.
https://youtu.be/yZGzdT4EKYY
Alas, his fumes at age 70 our more powerful than my full tank turbo 20s!
I think Jeff Jefferies hijacked Lisa Fremont's NYT account and wrote this comment.
1
For some artists there is never an end. They don't know when something will inspire.
3
Simon has had, hands down, the best second career of any of the 60's legends. No one, not even (or particularly not) Paul McCartney, comes close. Very impressive! Paul Simon is the Philip Roth of Pop, and like Roth, has apparently decided to give it up.
5
Thanks for all the music, Mr. Simon. Sleep well.
8
I always felt he was a poet with musical talent. So many of his songs are pure feeling. No one has come close in my books. Wish him the very best however the rest of his life unfolds.
24
Song lyrics can be great without being necessarily 'literary'. Mr. Simon is one of those songwriters whose lyrics are often 'literary'' as well. I refer to just one example among many, perhaps one of the greatest similes in the history of American rock:
"The Mississippi Delta was shining
Like a National guitar"
A summing up of the early years of the Blues in two lines!
"The Mississippi Delta was shining
Like a National guitar"
A summing up of the early years of the Blues in two lines!
27
Yes, a stunning line, just like "wehn I look back on all those years...it a wonder I can think at all"
7
Thanks for the music young man. Still listening, after all these years.
14
What other American pop artist has mastered all facets of the craft: writing lyrics and melody; singing and playing his instrument (Simon is a master guitarist who hides his light under a bushel); exploring and adapting from other musical cultures to create something new and unique; arranging and performing live concerts with a large retinue of supporting musicians.
Some famous names come to mind but after evaluation, none have reached Simon's level of brilliance across the board. We will not see his like again.
Some famous names come to mind but after evaluation, none have reached Simon's level of brilliance across the board. We will not see his like again.
31
Paul, may I have some of your God-given talent? I am near your age, and I've always been envious of people who could stand there and sing. I never played my violin or guitar very well, but still played in a rock-and-roll band in the late 50's and early 60's. What I would do with some of your talent is to teach young people to write beautiful songs without any toilet or cesspool lyrics. You know, stuff that is uplifting, and complimentary of the human condition, no matter how flawed most of us are. I've always admired you, and I will patiently await your positive response. Thank you.
3
I always like Paul from his earliest to the latest with all the African influence.
Also appreciate him being a lefty keeps for the most part away from politics.
My friend has a picture of him and Donald Trump at a dinner party together sitting at a gigantic round table with more dinnerware than I have in my entire kitchen.
Also appreciate him being a lefty keeps for the most part away from politics.
My friend has a picture of him and Donald Trump at a dinner party together sitting at a gigantic round table with more dinnerware than I have in my entire kitchen.
1
Saw Paul Simon in concert (my first) for the first time in Central Park in '81 and the second (last?!) this week at Wolf Trap outside of DC. At the latter was a chalkboard on which we were asked to leave our favorite PS lyric. How to choose? I went with "A pocket full of mumbles, such are promises. All lies and jest. Still a man hears what he wants to hear, and disregards the rest."
26
A huge fan of your rhythms and rhymes since I was a little girl. Thank you for all the grace and humanity that you bring through the sounds of your cultural travels. CU Friday
7
What a puff piece. There is quite a dark side to Simon and his time in the music industry that isn't even vaguely addressed here. He has quite a bad reputation amongst people he has worked with in the past including a couple of instances where he was accused of stealing other band's material (just Google "Los Lobos Paul Simon"). I grew up loving his music until I realized that the so called "genius" was really just a cypher for ripping other people off. And if you think I'm just being cold and callused about a much beloved song writer then all I ask is do some research and you will find out for yourselves. As far as this piece is concerned I really couldn't call it journalism because it is so beholden and uncritical of its subject.
5
Not "callused"; callous.
Art?
1
This article first made my jaw drop and then tears fill my eyes. A couple of hours earlier, I had been reading reviews of his recent performances in anticipation of his tour-closing performance on Friday night, which I will see with my mom in her/Simon's/Garfunkel's hometown of Forest Hills. The concert will now be even more poignant than I thought it would be.
In college a few years ago, laptop dysfunction made it impossible for me to listen to any music other than the Concert in Central Park CD that was in the disc drive. I played it all year and never got even a little tired of it. No matter what music I start listening to, I always end up listening to Paul.
In college a few years ago, laptop dysfunction made it impossible for me to listen to any music other than the Concert in Central Park CD that was in the disc drive. I played it all year and never got even a little tired of it. No matter what music I start listening to, I always end up listening to Paul.
7
The loss of Paul Simon and the earlier loss of Billy Joel have left big gaps in American music and a terrible loss of NYC icons. Yes, there are many very talented younger artists but these are two of absolute best pop songwriters ever.
4
I'm only twenty-five, but like almost everyone in the world, I grew up with Paul Simon. And I, like almost everyone in the world, will be sad to see him go. Thank you for everything you've given us, Mr. Simon. Your voice will be missed but forever well remembered.
10
I admire Paul Simon all the more, and I admired him plenty before reading this article. It's a wise man who knows when to sit down at the end of his performing years and just take in the world around him. I can't imagine someone like... oh, any of the Rolling Stones knowing when to quit, although I'd imagine they'll sit down when the money stops rolling in.
I've always consider Paul Simon more a poet than a pop star - he was never an ordinary pop star - so I wonder if, when he does decide to stop performing, he might consider putting out a ballad or two in book form?
I've always consider Paul Simon more a poet than a pop star - he was never an ordinary pop star - so I wonder if, when he does decide to stop performing, he might consider putting out a ballad or two in book form?
4
Most days, I listen to dead men sing....Sinatra and Presley and Jackson and Pavarotti...gone, but well recorded.
It makes me feel old, as does this article, remembering the melancholy of a teenager's room and a turntable with an album playing "Bridge over Troubled Waters."
Time flies.
It makes me feel old, as does this article, remembering the melancholy of a teenager's room and a turntable with an album playing "Bridge over Troubled Waters."
Time flies.
14
I know what you mean. My own turntable spun James Taylor for hours on end.
2
Though we've never met, I am grateful to have had Paul Simon as a virtual companion on my "road trip". It has been written that we walk sightless among miracles. Thanks, Paul, for illuminating the sights along the way. It's been a great ride.
8
Paul Simon has been a gift..... may this new chapter be a blessing to him and to his family....
5
People burn out and need rest and change. I wish him success in his new journey.
3
Art, real art, is a mystery. He's managed to swim in that river, the Mystery River.
9
This brings to mind Mr. Simon's lyric from the live version of "The Boxer": "After changes upon changes, we are more or less the same." Cheers and thank you for the music, particularly that beautiful summer night in 1991 when my friends put a blanket under a tree and watched you play in Central Park.
17
An amazing artist. My dad used to listen to him when growing up in India. Used to play his music at home and in the car all the time. Paul Simon is a poet first and foremost! Haunting and beautiful music. He is Jewish and that influenced his views...he fought to end apartheid in South Africa and supported black South African musicians...a wonderful man!
12
Eventually, we all need to transition into the next phase of our lives. Good luck to Paul, you've made the world a better place.
44
A beautiful story about a new song...
Paul Simon premiered "Wristband" on Prairie Home Companion
and I was there... I shared my excitement with my grandchildren....
who found his performance on You Tube...
They danced and clapped and never wanted the music to end...
Thank you, Paul Simon for the gift to my grandchildren!
Paul Simon premiered "Wristband" on Prairie Home Companion
and I was there... I shared my excitement with my grandchildren....
who found his performance on You Tube...
They danced and clapped and never wanted the music to end...
Thank you, Paul Simon for the gift to my grandchildren!
9
In 1968 at a Military Academy during the Vietnam War, Simon and Garfunkel music reinforced our souls and helped us get thru the crazy/deadly days. My daughter is in the music business in Nashville. I gave her some Paul Simon advice about writing music: start with the music, then the lyrics will come. It's worked well for her. Paul Simon has helped all of us over the years come to a better understanding and respect for the world around us. He has also been able to pass on this knowledge to our future generations. Paul: thanks for the ride, go in peace where ever you may tread.
20
kudos to ps. a pro. Surviving the 60's is an interesting meat grinder, but like all silly musicians, the politics, drugs and self-absorption tempt even the best. Mr. Simon, for all his humanness, was never really a musician, but a consumate songwriter, which is the only thing, and a noble thing, to be remembered for. RIP
3
Actually, Simon is very much a musician. He is a superb guitarist. His approach to arranging is to have other guitarists play lead.
5
RIP?
1
A surprising turn of events. A May New Yorker article has Simon planning to, as Matthew McConaughey puts it, "keep on living." Seemed to have no desire to hang it up. Could it be he is still crazy after all these years? Hoping a quick fifteen hour nap will revive him.
6
2 great philosopher, to be sure
keep on living
as opposed to what
how profound can you get
keep on living
as opposed to what
how profound can you get
1
"how terribly strange to be 70"--remember that from "Old Friends", who
"sat on the park bench like bookends"?
These lines from Paul Simon are still in my memory "after all these years".
Thank you, Paul Simon
"sat on the park bench like bookends"?
These lines from Paul Simon are still in my memory "after all these years".
Thank you, Paul Simon
9
He has a way of being that is so private while being so public. Simon always makes you feel that you are seeing into the very essence of what makes a person human and alone.
14
Amazing to me that a man who has seen so much life and success is still able to question who he is and why he does what he does.....that is Paul Simon
5
Just Sad if True....
Music is so dead right now..
Music is so dead right now..
2
I thought this already happened...right after You Can Call Me Al.
All the best to Mr. Simon! Sometimes you have to let go of something in order to find the fun again. Retirement has been doog that way -- a chance to rediscover the joy in playing, writing, building, whatever.
1
I cannot recall a road trip without Paul Simon's music. If you are heading out on the open road alone, with friends or family, take some P.S. with you. No one will ask you to turn it down or switch to someone else. Never, ever gets old.
49
what doesnt get old is th nostalgia for your lost youth, never to come back, evoked by his music
i prefer mozart
that really never gets old
i prefer mozart
that really never gets old
3
The article is about Paul Simon. What is the point of you saying you prefer another artist?
7
It's said the journey from the head to the heart is the longest one, but the heart knows what it wants and fills us overflowing in a flash. Hardly anyone talks about this, but Paul Simon embodies it. Thank you Paul for giving us all so very much. You've shown where we're bound.
21
I don't know why, but I'm sitting at my desk in a foundry crying after reading this piece. Maybe I feel like I'm losing an old friend, even though I know his music will continue to live on in my head until I'm gone. Thank you, Paul Simon.
62
Bravo, Paul !!!
You have been more than a brilliant inspiration - all of these years.
Your work will shine, and will raise people's hearts, as long as there ears to hear.
Thank you, for more than I can say.
You have been more than a brilliant inspiration - all of these years.
Your work will shine, and will raise people's hearts, as long as there ears to hear.
Thank you, for more than I can say.
17
Like Philip Roth, Paul Simon is retiring while still creatively alive and vital. As with Roth, who can deny them the right to put down their pen (or in Simon's case, his guitar)? But who won't regret their silence?
Thank you Paul Simon for all you've done.
Thank you Paul Simon for all you've done.
10
Paul Simon is the soundtrack of my childhood and adulthood. If I'm headed to a desert island and can only pack songs from one writer, Paul Simon it is, no contest. IMO he's the greatest songwriter of the 20th century, and thus, in history. Whether he stays on stage or moves on to other things, I am grateful for his existence and wish him a long fulfilling life.
Here's some lyrics of his (from "American Tune") that got me through some tough moments this year :
I don't know a soul who's not been battered
I don't have a friend who feels at ease
I don't know a dream that's not been shattered
Or driven to its knees
Oh, but it's all right, it's all right
For we lived so well so long
Still, when I think of the road
We're traveling on
I wonder what went wrong
I can't help it, I wonder what's gone wrong
---
Thank you Paul!
Here's some lyrics of his (from "American Tune") that got me through some tough moments this year :
I don't know a soul who's not been battered
I don't have a friend who feels at ease
I don't know a dream that's not been shattered
Or driven to its knees
Oh, but it's all right, it's all right
For we lived so well so long
Still, when I think of the road
We're traveling on
I wonder what went wrong
I can't help it, I wonder what's gone wrong
---
Thank you Paul!
74
Dear music lovers,
SPOILER ALERT
I hate to break the bad news to you.
I, like many of you, grew up listening to Simon and Garfunkel.
But Paul Simon will stop writing and playing music.
Life will go on...until either you, I or Paul Simon die.
C'est la vie.
SPOILER ALERT
I hate to break the bad news to you.
I, like many of you, grew up listening to Simon and Garfunkel.
But Paul Simon will stop writing and playing music.
Life will go on...until either you, I or Paul Simon die.
C'est la vie.
1
Artists die, but the art never dies. Perhaps you are being too literal.
5
What a gift he has been to our culture, our society!
23
This is a great article and interview. Completely devoid of the usual rock/pop star banalities - very real, honest and direct about music, the music business, success, and fame. A friend of mine approached Paul Simon after a symposium where he was on the panel and complimented his acoustic guitar playing - Mr. Simon quickly dismissed the praise. Hey, Paul - listen to Mrs. Robinson! I still marvel at it today as I did the day it was released.
14
Oh, my. So many wonderful memories of first Simon & Garfunkel and then just Simon. "Kodachrome" was a huge hit when I was in 8th grade, and it is the background music by which I remember that time of my life. But I really loved Paul's moodier songs, like "Only Living Boy in New York" or "The Boxer". He just kept changing and innovating over the years, refusing to rely on the old hits, but never abandoning them, either.
If Paul is ready to bid adieu to making music and touring, I say go for it. Do whatever makes your heart sing. And my heavens, thank you. Thank you for all the wonderful, moving music.
Thank you also to the author of this article. The story behind "the wristband" was fascinating and gave me a tiny peek into how a creative mind like Paul Simon's works.
If Paul is ready to bid adieu to making music and touring, I say go for it. Do whatever makes your heart sing. And my heavens, thank you. Thank you for all the wonderful, moving music.
Thank you also to the author of this article. The story behind "the wristband" was fascinating and gave me a tiny peek into how a creative mind like Paul Simon's works.
29
I love those moody songs too. Please add "Rene and Georgette Magritte with Their Dog after the War." Chills. Every time.
4
Just saw Mr Simon perform at the New Orleans Jazz fest. I was gobsmacked at how deeply his performance resonated for me. It was total feel good. The crowd was ageless and happy - the 20 somethings singing along to "you can call me Al" ... Wristband has been an earworm for me since the fest. While I am of a certain age, I am not so much an "oldies" fan and was so pleased to not hear just another oldies but goodies repertoire.
24
I am beyond fortunate that my father took me to see Simon & Garfunkel on their reunion tour about 10 years ago. My father brought me up listening to Simon, and my love for his music grew as I became older; as I matured, so did my understanding of the depth of his music and lyrics.
We should all feel grateful to what Simon has accomplished throughout his career and journey. It certainly helped me out in some trying times.
We should all feel grateful to what Simon has accomplished throughout his career and journey. It certainly helped me out in some trying times.
13
Losing Garrison Keillor and Paul Simon in the same week?
25
Thankfully, we haven't "lost" either of them...they're just "Movin' On"...and who knows what might come next.
2
As someone who "Loves to Hate The New York Times" (there is actually a book by that name), I have to commend Mr. Dwyer. This article brings out the essence of the person destined in future generations to be considered the true artistic representation of our times. Very inspiring.
9
First Roth, now Simon? We want our geniuses to continue producing, but they deserve to put down the pen and the guitar and savor the rest of life. Thank you for all you've created to enrich ours.
34
All due respect to David Lee Roth, he really can't be mentioned in the same breath as Paul Simon.
12
She was talking about Phillip, not David Lee, I'm pretty sure.
11
He meant the writer Philip Roth.
1
Truly one of a kind.
18
It is always good to go out at the top of your game. People will remember that.
14
That thought strikes me every time I hear Paul McCartney attempt to sing these days.
American Tune. Duncan. It did not get any better.
I remember him playing one on one basketball on SNL against an NBA player. Always had a sense of humor.
I remember him playing one on one basketball on SNL against an NBA player. Always had a sense of humor.
18
I remember him in Annie Hall. Definitely had a sense of humor!
7
And dressed as a turkey singing Still Crazy After All These Years on a Thanksgiving SNL in 1976. Classic!
1
He had been there, done that, and realized the cesspool it had become... People do not make music anymore; government media-agencies do!... I support Paul!
3
"One Trick Pony" has had an amazing ride against the tide. Peace.
9
Our boys are now in their 40s with children of their own. So many of our precious family memories were made with Simon's music as the back and foreground, loved equally by parents and children. Hope he decides to continue with his creative career, maybe after a well deserved break.
21
Sometimes even music cannot substitute for tears
16
So many memories tied to Paul Simon songs - would hate to see that stop, and would love for him to go out singing. If he wishes it. I'll understand and respect him no matter what. He's an artist: Freedom is paramount.
10
I'd just like to add that making music doesn't necessarily mean performing in public. I can imagine Paul Simon making music at home, using his creative talents to write, sing, and play in the privacy of his own space: it could be a new sort of music for him - although I think it would be hard for PS to be more intimate, more connected on a personal level to those of us who listen to him. But I think he could do it. Hoping.
5
Thank you for your new album and touring again.
You have every right to have your own life, and make and play music if you want to, for your friends and family, or not.
You have every right to have your own life, and make and play music if you want to, for your friends and family, or not.
8
How beautiful and yet how sad. Sad for me not to have Paul Simon making his hauntingly elegant music, but beautiful to see such a famous artist not bewitched by his fame. There is a wisdom in knowing when to stop living in bright lights to enable oneself to catch the passing glimmers of shadows that enrich old age.
36
Since I was in my early teens, his brooding lyrics and melodies have captivated me. How may hours have been filled by his music in my life? Far more than I could ever count. S&G inspired the most creative in me and still does.
31
I am still utterly amazed at Mr. Simon's seemingly unending font of musical inventiveness, most particularly because it has been so consistent for so long. At a time when many 60's-era performers are just doing tours as a money grab and rehashing their long-ago hits, he dares to strike out in new ways.
In my town, we still fondly remember the lyric, "Kathy I said as we boarded a Greyhound in Pittsburgh...."
In my town, we still fondly remember the lyric, "Kathy I said as we boarded a Greyhound in Pittsburgh...."
78
A song that has some special meaning for my wife and me.
"Well it's all right, even if you're old and gray
Well it's all right, you still got something to say" Traveling Wilburys
"Well it's all right, even if you're old and gray
Well it's all right, you still got something to say" Traveling Wilburys
4
"Countin' the cars on the New Jersey Turnpike" thrilled my friends and me! :)
7
While Diamonds on the Soles of Her Shoes is my favorite (I think), the lyrics that always spoke to me were, "A good day ain't got no rain and a bad day is when I lie in bed and think about what might have been." It was the soundtrack to my 40s.
Thank you, Mr. Simon, for the way you have enriched my life.
Thank you, Mr. Simon, for the way you have enriched my life.
6