Peyton Manning is unmatched at reading defenses at the line of scrimmage and calling different plays as a result. Unfortunately, his body no longer lets him execute some of those plays well.
He could be the best quarterback coach ever. Either for a team, or as an independent operator teaching clinics full of aspiring quarterbacks. A tiny part of that training is to go down immediately when a sack is inevitable, thereby minimizing the chance for concomitant injury.
Of course a great offensive line is even more important.
He could be the best quarterback coach ever. Either for a team, or as an independent operator teaching clinics full of aspiring quarterbacks. A tiny part of that training is to go down immediately when a sack is inevitable, thereby minimizing the chance for concomitant injury.
Of course a great offensive line is even more important.
3
Peyton, I do admire you but please do control the advertising just a bit.
2
Why should he make an announcement about his retirement when he and his team just won Super Bowl? Last night was not about him and he knows about it. And why is it your business anyway? This is such an arrogant/silly article. All the media were talking about Peyton's retirement all past season. It's up to him to decide. Leave him alone.
3
It's not an "emotional" decision. It's entirely rational to decide that his body has taken enough punishment to render him a pedestrian QB who is one devastating hit away from spending his life a cripple. What better finale for a career than being on a Superbowl championship team even if his contribution was just a bit more than zero. Some have pointed to how Ted Williams departed professional baseball with a home run in his final at bat before an almost empty Fenway Park in a losing season. Williams had been advised after the previous (1959) season to retire after hitting in the mid-200s as he dealt with a bad back. He refused and batted 314 with 29 home runs. However, Williams did not have to worry about being crippled permanently nor about CTE. He'd be a fool to come back.
What a condescending article.
Manning got them down the field for a score on the first possession. A lot of people thought Carolina was going to crush them - and he proved from the get go that they could play.
Did he have a great game? No. Did he outplay Cam Newton? Yes.
He did what he needed to do to win. They won.
Did anybody think they were going to win? No. Did anybody think it would be close? Not really.
If I were him, I would retire on top. And stop picking on Cam Newton. The guy had an amazing season, got his team to the Super Bowl and ran into a team that played above their game on any given Sunday.
Manning got them down the field for a score on the first possession. A lot of people thought Carolina was going to crush them - and he proved from the get go that they could play.
Did he have a great game? No. Did he outplay Cam Newton? Yes.
He did what he needed to do to win. They won.
Did anybody think they were going to win? No. Did anybody think it would be close? Not really.
If I were him, I would retire on top. And stop picking on Cam Newton. The guy had an amazing season, got his team to the Super Bowl and ran into a team that played above their game on any given Sunday.
2
I'm baffled by the comments on Ms. Macur's mentioning HGH.
HGH is a banned substance because it is a performance enhancer.
It was delivered to the home of Peyton Manning, a fact he hasn't denied. He's denied all the other allegations but this one.
One of the greatest QB in the history of the game has HGH delivered to his house and it shouldn't be mentioned?
One can only imagine if the HGH shipment had been made to Mrs. Tom Brady, imagine the outrage...
HGH is a banned substance because it is a performance enhancer.
It was delivered to the home of Peyton Manning, a fact he hasn't denied. He's denied all the other allegations but this one.
One of the greatest QB in the history of the game has HGH delivered to his house and it shouldn't be mentioned?
One can only imagine if the HGH shipment had been made to Mrs. Tom Brady, imagine the outrage...
5
As a long time Colts fan I see the Manning of yore... sadly he is no longer that athlete and there is no better time or occasion to leave the stage. His last two games, most specifically the one against the Patriots, highlighted his ability and intelligence, factors that his soon-to-be successor could not have brought to bear at this point and which sparked the faltering Denver offense. This game was not his and he of all people would be the first to acknowledge that... a team player to the end. Thanks for the ride Peyton. Hope you continue to be a presence in some coaching or consultant capacity.
1
While it's certainly reasonable to make the argument that it's in the best interests of both Peyton Manning and his family for him to retire, the manner you've chosen to express it leaves something to be desired.
From the implication that the motivation for his return would be money or attention (that's not what "top ones like Manning" are about at all), to the implication that he is guilty of taking HGH (his reputation hasn't been "tainted" because he didn't do anything wrong, and I haven't seen a single reputable source suggest otherwise), to the implication that the primary reason he didn't announce a decision last night was in the hopes of attracting more media attention to himself later (that's odd, every commentator last night applauded him for being "classy" in not wanting to distract the media from celebrating his teammates accomplishments) your article reeks of ill informed judgement and personal animosity.
I won't risk insulting YOU by jumping to conclusions while hazarding a guess as to your motivations, but you should know that I find it offensive and disappointing to find in "Sports of the Times".
From the implication that the motivation for his return would be money or attention (that's not what "top ones like Manning" are about at all), to the implication that he is guilty of taking HGH (his reputation hasn't been "tainted" because he didn't do anything wrong, and I haven't seen a single reputable source suggest otherwise), to the implication that the primary reason he didn't announce a decision last night was in the hopes of attracting more media attention to himself later (that's odd, every commentator last night applauded him for being "classy" in not wanting to distract the media from celebrating his teammates accomplishments) your article reeks of ill informed judgement and personal animosity.
I won't risk insulting YOU by jumping to conclusions while hazarding a guess as to your motivations, but you should know that I find it offensive and disappointing to find in "Sports of the Times".
4
IMHO, Peyton has already made his decision, hopefully to retire. IF he was planning on playing another season I think he would have said so when asked. Personally, I think the media should just backoff & let Peyton enjoy the moment.
3
I think Mx Macur may be disappointed because ze hoped to have a narrative "quarterback beaten up and retires at last". All the News that Fits the Script. After all, we've had stories about anything but the Super Bowl. The times has been running hit pieces, with Ken Stabler as its poster child.
1
Wouldn't it have been wonderful if at that introduction of the Super Bowl MVPs, the lasting effects of injuries on their bodies were enumerated. Of course, it probably would have taken more time than the game itself but it still would have let people be aware that beneath those smiling faces there is a great deal of pain that came from playing the game.
1
Joe Namath's knees happened to him in college. They did not allow him to get surgery, and the Jets got a damaged product. That has nothing to do with the hate on with the NFL.
Silly article, demanding immediate retirement. It's not like there is anything to do till next Sept. He will announce when he is ready. Bribing up HGH really hurt's the writer's credibility, given that the accusations were withdrawn by the accuser himself and were found to be baseless. Nobody outside of NE would do this, because it makes them feel better about their proven cheating team.
4
HGH is banned by the NFL because it is a performance enhancer.
HGH shipped to one of the greatest QBs in the history is a major story, especially where Manning hasn't denied it.
HGH shipped to one of the greatest QBs in the history is a major story, especially where Manning hasn't denied it.
5
The utter lack of proof is no impediment to the smear. A report of an alleged event is withdrawn by the media that reports it and the smear is repeated. No context , just snark. Yellow journalism lives
6
Today's interviews with Peyton Manning were all about retiring. His answer was measured and full of wisdom. He said his former coach and friend, Tony Dungy, called him and told him that whatever decision he makes, if he makes it as a snap judgement, at the moment, he WILL regret it. Therefore Manning will take time with his family to vacation for a couple of weeks--I'm sure they'll hit a beach somewhere as the kids aren't school age yet, he'll talk to his wife, his brothers, and, of course, his mom and dad, the former Pro-Bowler, Archie Manning. Then I expect he'll announce his retirement.
I'm not actually a fan of Peyton Manning's, and, being a Progressive, it's hard to forget and forgive his endorsements for reactionary Papa John's Pizza, where I refuse to eat. But as a football player, Manning has always been a class act, a GREAT player and I have to respect that. I hope, in retirement, he can address all the lifetime pain and injuries players accrue. Most of the 49 MVPs yesterday, especially the older ones, were walking with difficulty.
Except Jerry Rice who STILL looks like he could out-cut a cornerback and run for the end-zone!
I'm not actually a fan of Peyton Manning's, and, being a Progressive, it's hard to forget and forgive his endorsements for reactionary Papa John's Pizza, where I refuse to eat. But as a football player, Manning has always been a class act, a GREAT player and I have to respect that. I hope, in retirement, he can address all the lifetime pain and injuries players accrue. Most of the 49 MVPs yesterday, especially the older ones, were walking with difficulty.
Except Jerry Rice who STILL looks like he could out-cut a cornerback and run for the end-zone!
3
You know what? Manning has too much class to announce his retirement in the middle of a super bowl victory celebration. It would have taken away from what the rest of the team did. It was not a night about Manning but about his team, and he acknowledged that by saying nothing. Good for him.
Also, he said he was going to have a few Budweisers at home with his family, for which he wasn't paid. I guess he likes bud.
Also, he said he was going to have a few Budweisers at home with his family, for which he wasn't paid. I guess he likes bud.
3
Give Peyton a month or two to enjoy the victory, and then let him make his retirement announcement. I truly hope he retires, for his sake, for his family, for the Broncos organization. Please retire, Peyton. It is time. Leave while you can still do simple math in your head and don't get lost driving around the block.
2
His jersey says it all -- 18 seasons for #18. He'll retire after the celebrating is over.
3
The bottom line is that the Peyton Manning did not follow the script that the media had outlined and DEMANDED that he follow: win the Super Bowl and announce your retirement. That's what the media had PREDICTED and PROMISED for the last two weeks. Peyton didn't follow the script, and this angry writer has spent the entire column bashing him for it!!!!
3
The manipulative, misplaced self-importance of this article is striking. What business is it of yours when a football player retires? Do you understand what the competitive mindset is like? Should the author of this article also consider early retirement, based on my thoughts?
5
Manning knows what football takes out of a player...he's been around it his whole life. Despite that, he has worked incredibly hard for decades to stay at the top of his game. And we think we offer new insights to him about how hard he'll have to work and what risks he is taking, and that we're in a position to tell him he's had enough? That hubris is ours, not his.
I'm guessing he wouldn't trade anything for the experiences he's had; otherwise he would have. He had the choice to exit, and the means to do it, yet didn't.
His career will end, as all do, at the moment when he, his teams, or both decide he no longer meets the measure of a top-flight quarterback in the NFL. I'm guessing we all witnessed that moment pass this season. As a long-time Broncos fan, often victimized by a younger Manning, I'm so happy for the team and for him that the team was able to carry him to a victory yesterday that was very sweet and is so rare.
I'm guessing he wouldn't trade anything for the experiences he's had; otherwise he would have. He had the choice to exit, and the means to do it, yet didn't.
His career will end, as all do, at the moment when he, his teams, or both decide he no longer meets the measure of a top-flight quarterback in the NFL. I'm guessing we all witnessed that moment pass this season. As a long-time Broncos fan, often victimized by a younger Manning, I'm so happy for the team and for him that the team was able to carry him to a victory yesterday that was very sweet and is so rare.
3
I appreciate using Manning's career as a vehicle for bringing up again the very serious health issues for those who play American football. But let's face it, whether Peyton plays or doesn't, does it really affect us? Isn't asking (over and over again) whether he's too old to play or should retire or not much ado about nothing? I noticed during an on-screen interview in the pre game CBS programming that Peyton got almost angry when a question began (again) "Given your age…" or something like that. Hey, if he's tired of talking about it, shouldn't we be too?
2
Peyton had little to do with the win, 140 yards passing, a pick and a fumble. The game was all about Denver's defense. Now we'll have to hear about whether or not he'll retire. He may be able to come back and play at 40 thanks to the HGH.
2
That he should retire. How presumptuous!
A football player who loves to play football should play football until it is fun no longer. May the gods bless him.
A football player who loves to play football should play football until it is fun no longer. May the gods bless him.
1
Why should he give any answer on the field? Manning has always been a careful, methodical student of the game. Let him and his teammates enjoy their celebration, they earned it.
5
This article has such an unpleasant tone to it. What's the point, Manning isn't a criminal, he's an athlete at the end of his career. Calm down a little, Ms. Macur.
4
This was a good article. What we don't need now is the coy quarterback toying with his pending retirement. He should pack it in now and be graceful about it. He is obviously done. Talib should also be taken to task for his exploits on the field and embarrassing his children.
1
Come on...Give Peyton a break.
It's his decision and he deserves the time he needs to do so.
Let him and the Broncos enjoy the moment!
It's his decision and he deserves the time he needs to do so.
Let him and the Broncos enjoy the moment!
24
Juliet,
I think the announcers did a good job of describing why Peyton Manning didn't do what you seem to think he obviously should have done last night; that is, announce his retirement.
It is not because athletes "drag[ging] out the answer. It's because last night was about victory, it was about the team; and Peyton Manning, (unlike Juliet Macur), understands that.
I believe you should, as well.
I think the announcers did a good job of describing why Peyton Manning didn't do what you seem to think he obviously should have done last night; that is, announce his retirement.
It is not because athletes "drag[ging] out the answer. It's because last night was about victory, it was about the team; and Peyton Manning, (unlike Juliet Macur), understands that.
I believe you should, as well.
23
After the race-based hype of Newton (we're all afraid of a black QB, he says), the times is trying to tear down the quarterback who had the presumption to beat The Great Black Hope, a (formerly) winning QB who goes the right way on political correctness.
1
I remember that in a previous article by Juliet Macur, she focused on how meticulous Peyton Manning was about combing his hair, and also in that same article insinuated that he was a druggie. So, she's prone to be critical of Peyton, no matter what the context. I have listened to many Peyton recaps of Broncos games, and he is always team centered and humble especially in loss, taking the blame. It is pretty obvious that if he had announced his retirement, he would have stolen the attention.
12
I took Manning's deflection of the inevitable post-game retirement questions as an effort to keep the focus on the Broncos' team win. And from his demeanor before, during and after the game, he's well aware of looming retirement: he seemed in pain most of the time. Why is it necessary for the media to call for him to step down with this dramatic emotional appeal (his children! his wife! remember Ken Stabler!)?
18
Hey Life Coach: You forgot to warn him about beer, it's horrible effects on the liver and the bad influence on his kids.
One question for you. Have you ever played organized football? So, perhaps there's something about it you don't understand. Players are not as dumb as you think. Many choose the highs of playing and accept the risk. Just like Formula I drivers, deep-divers and rock climbers.
One question for you. Have you ever played organized football? So, perhaps there's something about it you don't understand. Players are not as dumb as you think. Many choose the highs of playing and accept the risk. Just like Formula I drivers, deep-divers and rock climbers.
3
Hey Peyton: You're a lucky and telegenic guy who can pursue other careers as football pitches into a steep decline. Count your blessings and get out!
2
Payton Manning did perhaps announce his retirement on last night's broadcast; first, by his poor play...more like the old warrior being kept alive by his admiring cohort; second, by giving us a clear idea of what his future business may be. He prominently mentioned "Budweiser", the king of mediocre beer, multiple times to American television's largest audience. Budweiser, following their latest move to limit the distribution opportunity given to smaller high quality craft beer producers by offering large cash bounties to beer distributors (post prohibition law prevents the brewers themselves from distributing the products they make), is in need of a spokesman with a squeaky clean image (well, at least until this season's human growth hormone controversy). It seemed he gave as much air time to Budweiser as he did to his teammates, inviting all of us watching to either interpret it as a future career move or as a blatant product endorsement..."I'm going to...drink a lot of Budweiser".
2
Item 1: Heightened level of concern about the injury level in football.
Item 2: Peyton Manning suffers serious neck injury but returns to play.
Yes, Peyton Manning has had an incredible career. I would have admired him so much more if he had made the rational decision to retire after the neck injury.
Item 2: Peyton Manning suffers serious neck injury but returns to play.
Yes, Peyton Manning has had an incredible career. I would have admired him so much more if he had made the rational decision to retire after the neck injury.
1
Peyton will forever be your model quarterback. He's always gracious as the winner or a loser. His ego never gets in his way. The game is bigger than him and he plays it as such.
On the other hand Cam Newton was The opposite. Too slow of a delivery, too big of an ego, Big crybaby if he doesn't win. He played on one of the most solid teams in the Super Bowl and didn't get close to victory.
Ride into the sunset Peyton head held high you deserve that and earned it.
On the other hand Cam Newton was The opposite. Too slow of a delivery, too big of an ego, Big crybaby if he doesn't win. He played on one of the most solid teams in the Super Bowl and didn't get close to victory.
Ride into the sunset Peyton head held high you deserve that and earned it.
7
Not to mention Cam's "Oh! I dropped the football! Whatever shall I do? While I decide, I shall get out of the way of the 350 pounders who are fighting to get it. I hope they'll give it back to me."
2
Bread and circus indeed... And wounded gladiators. Have we really not evolved much from the Roman Empire? I recommend all to watch "Concussion" and then ask yourselves how can we continue to finance an activity that LITERALLY turns young men's brains to MUSH.
1
They willingly accept the risk for the big money.
How many NFL players had a neuroscience class in college? How can one "willingly" accept a risk without UNDERSTANDINGS what they are actually risking?
The agent can buy hot and cold running neurosurgeons, to explain it to the player.
Manning doesn't have to retire from football, but he should leave the field of play. He would make one hell of a coach.
7
Spots writers just can't give Peyton Manning credit. He led the Broncos to victory in the Superbowl against the formidable Panthers. The Broncos offense outscored the Panthers' offense and put up enough points for a W, but somehow according to this column, Manning is washed up, crippled and an illegal drug user despite a complete lack of evidence. This column even goes as far as to say that his ability to attract sponsors has been diminished. What an idiotic comment. Manning is the NFL's leader in endorsement earnings. How about some facts instead of throwing out whatever pops into your head? And why no talk of Brady retiring? He is nearly as old as Manning, and had a worse season, beaten by the Broncos twice. Manning is a leader. He leads and inspires his team to be the best. Age and injuries won't diminish that.
15
How would you compare yesterday's performance of Manning with Cam Newton? And remember the latter was deservedly the leagues MVP.
1
What game were you watching ... ?
2
I don't feel the need to compare the two quarterbacks statistically One won, one lost. Plainly the winner did better.
Ms. Macur:
Not sure if you read these, but this op ed masked as a news story is sure full of opinion and judgment. I think Peyton ought to have retired after his cervical surgery--and I think he should have retired last night too. But who am I to say? He has to make that call, with or without feeling in his fingers, and with or without Ken Stabler's diagnosis.
You come off as pompous which is very unlike you--a very thorough and great journalist IMO. Peyton could have had the fairy tale ending many hoped for last night, but there is absolutely nothing wrong with him taking time to discuss it, or better yet--probably decision was already made but he didn't want to distract from his TEAM victory. He was never a Me-First player and sure wasn't going to detract from them last night after D saved the day time and again.
Not sure if you read these, but this op ed masked as a news story is sure full of opinion and judgment. I think Peyton ought to have retired after his cervical surgery--and I think he should have retired last night too. But who am I to say? He has to make that call, with or without feeling in his fingers, and with or without Ken Stabler's diagnosis.
You come off as pompous which is very unlike you--a very thorough and great journalist IMO. Peyton could have had the fairy tale ending many hoped for last night, but there is absolutely nothing wrong with him taking time to discuss it, or better yet--probably decision was already made but he didn't want to distract from his TEAM victory. He was never a Me-First player and sure wasn't going to detract from them last night after D saved the day time and again.
8
What an odd, self-serving column. Why diss Peyton Manning if you really just wanted to rant about football injuries, seemingly a Times obsession. Manning didn't win the game for the Broncos, but neither did he lose it, and the win capped off a career of unquestioned excellence. If you want to pick on a QB, how about pointing your pen at the pampered millenial who refused to attempt to recover his own fumble with 4 minutes remaining in the Super Bowl and his team down by 6, and who then behaved like a spoiled 9 year old at the post game press conference?
12
It is dishonest to revive the accusation of HGH use. Even the accuser retracted it!
8
Because Peyton's PR guy sent his goons over to intimidate him. Check out the wife's 911 call. He admits having it delivered to his wife which was not very creative on his part. He's not as pure as you think.
2
For people who think he's squeaky clean, don't forget about the assault charge Manning faced in college and how he ruined the career of the woman making the accusations.
It bears an eerily resemblance to how Manning sent thugs over to Charles Sly's parents house.
Squeaky clean? Not so sure about that...
It bears an eerily resemblance to how Manning sent thugs over to Charles Sly's parents house.
Squeaky clean? Not so sure about that...
3
Great career, but the Broncos won DESPITE the poor play of Manning. If the panthers held on to the ball better, and perhaps scored there is no way Manning could have played catch up. BUT they did not have to and they won. But even with the win it is hard to watch Manning any more--he has nothing left. At all
Manning played fine. He didn't need to pull miracles to win, that's all.
2
There were two things on display after the game. A quarterback who showed our young athletes how to act when you win......and a quarterback who showed them how not to act when you lose.
15
Good column.
Payton Manning's day has come and gone, as it does for all athletes. What we saw was a patched up, battered 40 year old man playing a young man's game. In the final minutes he was unable or unwilling to throw a pass and he and his coach chose to just hang on and try to run the clock out.
It was a bittersweet performance to watch. This was a man who so dominated his position in his salad days that he seemed a god. Yesterday, his mental skills, not his physical, prevailed, but just barely.
Payton, it's time.
Payton Manning's day has come and gone, as it does for all athletes. What we saw was a patched up, battered 40 year old man playing a young man's game. In the final minutes he was unable or unwilling to throw a pass and he and his coach chose to just hang on and try to run the clock out.
It was a bittersweet performance to watch. This was a man who so dominated his position in his salad days that he seemed a god. Yesterday, his mental skills, not his physical, prevailed, but just barely.
Payton, it's time.
This article was written with an eye towards history, the author having learned the important lessons that Major League Baseball taught us.
When we look back in 5-10 years and the widespread PED use in the NFL is in clearer focus, we'll wonder why writers weren't more critical. Call Ms. Macur ahead of the curve.
This Broncos team won in spite of Manning, not because of him.
When we look back in 5-10 years and the widespread PED use in the NFL is in clearer focus, we'll wonder why writers weren't more critical. Call Ms. Macur ahead of the curve.
This Broncos team won in spite of Manning, not because of him.
1
Without a quarterback you don't get to the Super Bowl. On top of the offense they contribute to, they provide leadership (compare Cam's behavior last night to him). They won the Super Bowl! Without him and what he provided as a leader they wouldn't have made it at all. This is what should be written about this morning, not when he will retire and why he didn't last night. He and his family are class acts despite the Bud plug at the end.
2
"The situation hasn’t helped Manning’s reputation as the squeaky-clean guy next door, and it didn’t boost his appeal as a product pitchman, either."
Neither did sending thugs pretending to be cops to Al Jazeera's source's *parents*. That Peyton, he's a regular Joe I really want to buy his pizza.
Neither did sending thugs pretending to be cops to Al Jazeera's source's *parents*. That Peyton, he's a regular Joe I really want to buy his pizza.
3
Peyton Manning is no longer claiming he is retiring, because he has found the magic formula: Human growth hormone (HGH).
3
Wow did anyone watch the Al jazzera You Tube video about doping that was referenced in this article? Seems pretty obvious there is a drug problem in these athletic boys and girls all over the world. Sports fanatics unite!
3
The tomorrow of Peyton Manning and his family is now here, today, at Disney World!
1
Honestly, why does the NYT's continue to cover the sport of football?
You have article after article about all the damage done to the players bodies and brains. You have this article taking Manning to task for not announcing his retirement right after his team won the Super Bowl. You then proceed to rehash the allegations against Manning from a news organization that is soon shutting down.
Please just stop covering the sport and put your resources to better use.
You have article after article about all the damage done to the players bodies and brains. You have this article taking Manning to task for not announcing his retirement right after his team won the Super Bowl. You then proceed to rehash the allegations against Manning from a news organization that is soon shutting down.
Please just stop covering the sport and put your resources to better use.
11
They keep writing this stuff just to anger you. Suggestion: read something else.
5
Did it ever occur to this writer that Peyton Manning did not tell everyone his plans because he did not want to distract from the fact that the Denver Broncos won the SB????! That, maybe, just maybe he wanted to enjoy the moment with his team mates and fans? It's a long off season. There's time for him to decide.........and to Juliet Macur (the writer of this article) I say...get over it!!!!!!!!
31
The saddest part of sports reporting these days is the fact that no one can discuss football withOUT another sales presentation on how all the players brains get damaged! And shouldn't you feel bad that they choose to take this chance? And shouldn't the elites simply stop such things from happening?
And Times-ers wonder why the readers have left them.
And Times-ers wonder why the readers have left them.
11
The way you milk every play out of the clock. How
you can manipulate defenses to be where you need
them to be, with a look, with a snap count, with
the mere inflection of your voice, Mastery of the
game, sheer brilliance. If that were all there
were to playing quarterback, I'd say go to a
hundred.
You had a catapult, cocked and ready, see the throw,
make the throw, complete, first down or touchdown.
Like Farve, the catapult became more of a sling
shot, see the throw, cock the arm, make the throw.
Balls that were in the hands of a receiver before
the defender could react, are now being deflected
and intercepted. That last interception to a Lineman
up field was There, by the time the lineman could turn
for the ball, it would have already been in the
hands of the receiver and gone. With all respect,
the play was there, the velocity to make the play,
was not.
I can't help but think about Farve. I know you were
playing and couldn't see his last two years, but
they were brutal. Still had the vision, the will,
could see what needed to be done, but just couldn't
get it there when it needed to get there. Lost a tick
on the release, yesteryear the ball would be gone,
before it could be knocked out of his hand. How many
of the scars we can't see were earned in those
last two years?
You're a father, leave your children with more than
just the vague memories of their father. You're a
legend, leave the game your legend.
you can manipulate defenses to be where you need
them to be, with a look, with a snap count, with
the mere inflection of your voice, Mastery of the
game, sheer brilliance. If that were all there
were to playing quarterback, I'd say go to a
hundred.
You had a catapult, cocked and ready, see the throw,
make the throw, complete, first down or touchdown.
Like Farve, the catapult became more of a sling
shot, see the throw, cock the arm, make the throw.
Balls that were in the hands of a receiver before
the defender could react, are now being deflected
and intercepted. That last interception to a Lineman
up field was There, by the time the lineman could turn
for the ball, it would have already been in the
hands of the receiver and gone. With all respect,
the play was there, the velocity to make the play,
was not.
I can't help but think about Farve. I know you were
playing and couldn't see his last two years, but
they were brutal. Still had the vision, the will,
could see what needed to be done, but just couldn't
get it there when it needed to get there. Lost a tick
on the release, yesteryear the ball would be gone,
before it could be knocked out of his hand. How many
of the scars we can't see were earned in those
last two years?
You're a father, leave your children with more than
just the vague memories of their father. You're a
legend, leave the game your legend.
15
It's F A V R E......at least spell the mans' name correctly.
4
C'mon, Susan. If you're going to scold, at least use correct punctuation: "man's" ;)
1
Congrats to Peyton Manning on the victory in what was a pretty lackluster game. The plug for Budweiser (twice!) was shameless and uninspired.
11
Well, Peyton is a great QB for sure, but what he also is a great Adman. the products love him--from insurance to food to media and so on. (I am not naming his sponsorships to avoid bias).
When he named the brand of beer twice, all I could think of was "what a shill" rather than what a great QB he is/was. And for such an "upstanding citizen", wouldn't he have fit his public face by saying he would celebrate quietly without alcohol? What kind of message would that send? With 4 year old twins to boot?
When he named the brand of beer twice, all I could think of was "what a shill" rather than what a great QB he is/was. And for such an "upstanding citizen", wouldn't he have fit his public face by saying he would celebrate quietly without alcohol? What kind of message would that send? With 4 year old twins to boot?
3
Broncos and Peyton Manning had a terrific super bowl 50. Congratulations to the world Football champions and their fans. It is the only time of the year I watch foot ball and the game was more exciting than the half time. Briniging back the MVPs of previous super bowls was brought back memories of the all time greats of footballs. Most GOP candidates thought the panthers would win during the recent ABC debate and they were wrong. I would not hold them responsible for failing to predict who would win. I suspect they said Carolinas because the South Carolina primary is just after the New Hampshire primary of tomorrow.
4
You probably think the game was "terrific" because "it is the only time of the year . . you watch football." Super Bowl 50 was bad, very bad, and it is somewhat fortunate that Manning threw a touchdown pass, so this would have been the only team to win the game based upon an overly aggressive defense.
* Your opinion as to why fans "said Carolinas" would win is very, very funny!
* Your opinion as to why fans "said Carolinas" would win is very, very funny!
Peyton Manning is a class act. Period. He sure does not deserve this writer's thinly-veiled contempt.
66
"Thinly-veiled contempt."
Something Ms. Macur gleefully suspends when writing about Tom Brady.
One can only imagine the condemnation she and most other Times sports writers would have released had Giselle received that package in the mail.
The obligation to write a single paragraph about Al Jazeera's story on Manning must have stuck in this writer's throat like a chicken bone.
Something Ms. Macur gleefully suspends when writing about Tom Brady.
One can only imagine the condemnation she and most other Times sports writers would have released had Giselle received that package in the mail.
The obligation to write a single paragraph about Al Jazeera's story on Manning must have stuck in this writer's throat like a chicken bone.
1
--more class than the Panthers' quarterback or the halftime show.
"To end Sunday night, he should have stood at the center of Levi’s Stadium and dropped the mike.
But players don’t think that way. Especially top ones like Manning. They like to drag out their answer when deciding whether to retire. They ponder and consult and consider. They make everyone else ponder and consider, too."
First, what is wrong with putting some thought into this and/or not upstaging his teammates victory, especially considering he wasn't a key factor in its success (which you clearly noted).
Secondly, since when is it commonplace for an athlete to ponder, consult, consider, foregoing the thoughtless, attention-grabbing comments and tweets?
But players don’t think that way. Especially top ones like Manning. They like to drag out their answer when deciding whether to retire. They ponder and consult and consider. They make everyone else ponder and consider, too."
First, what is wrong with putting some thought into this and/or not upstaging his teammates victory, especially considering he wasn't a key factor in its success (which you clearly noted).
Secondly, since when is it commonplace for an athlete to ponder, consult, consider, foregoing the thoughtless, attention-grabbing comments and tweets?
29
I believe the primary reason Peyton is waiting is very Peyton-like - to ensure he is not detracting from the team. The attention and focus should be on the team winning, the team celebration, and savoring the season with his teammates. For Peyton it's all about team... he will make his announcement at the right time, and I believe he will make the correct decision. He probably already has...
73
Manning announced at the AFC Championship game that this was his "last-rodeo." In other words the game was his last. Generally, that means he would be retiring . . . but, then he becomes secretive. Was he playing head-games with the opposing Coach? The media picked it up in Denver and broadcast it. There is no secret to what he said, just as there is no secret to the HGH being delivered to his home. Facts are facts.
1
I don't get all the criticism of Payton Manning. He did what was necessary to win the Superbowl--make sure your team has the most points at the final gun.
This game was "boring" because it was a defensive battle--unless you realize that defense it the key to winning, not spectacular showy plays. Defense. And the two best defenses in the NFL strutted their stuff last night, forcing fumbles, interceptions, shutting down runners, and, finally, intimidating the year's MVP, Cam Newton.
So he didn't announce retirement when it would have stolen his teammates' thunder, when he hadn't FIRST told his employer, or discussed it with his family. There's plenty of time for that. Meanwhile, he's won more games than any quarterback, and, as far as I know, he's the only quarterback to lead 2 different teams to win the Superbowl. Time to hang up the cleats.
This game was "boring" because it was a defensive battle--unless you realize that defense it the key to winning, not spectacular showy plays. Defense. And the two best defenses in the NFL strutted their stuff last night, forcing fumbles, interceptions, shutting down runners, and, finally, intimidating the year's MVP, Cam Newton.
So he didn't announce retirement when it would have stolen his teammates' thunder, when he hadn't FIRST told his employer, or discussed it with his family. There's plenty of time for that. Meanwhile, he's won more games than any quarterback, and, as far as I know, he's the only quarterback to lead 2 different teams to win the Superbowl. Time to hang up the cleats.
51
I agree completely. However you are forgetting that Kurt Warner won Superbowls with the Rams and the Cardinals. Nevertheless Manning's career is remarkable and must be appreciated in its totality rather than stupidly nitpicking statistics as sportswriters are wont to do.
Just fact-checked myself and learned I was wrong about Kurt Warner. He won a SB with the Rams but lost one with the Cardinals. Like the old carpenter's rule: think twice, write once.
What about the consumption of HGH? According to the Mayo Clinic web-site, “Studies have revealed that Human Growth Hormone (HGH) does have a potent effect on muscle and bone tissue and encourages faster healing in cases of sprains, injuries, and fractures. Additionally HGH provides athletes with greater stamina, better staying power and endurance, enhanced performance, augmented levels of energy and attaining optimum lean muscle mass:” Manning initially claimed his wife was ordering HGH for her personal use: Now, Manning is feigning disgust and brushing off press questions about illicit drug use claiming the questions are “insulting” to him. There is no evidence the League tested Manning for HGH and no indication drug testing is being considered: The League allowed Manning to play in the AFC Championship game. On February 4, 2016, The Washington Post reported two men hired by Manning’s lawyers visited the parents of the documentary’s key witness the night of Dec. 22, 2015: Both men dressed in black overcoats and jeans and, according to a 911 call from the house that evening, one initially said he was a law enforcement officer but didn’t have a badge. Their son, Charlie Sly, a 31 year old pharmacist recanted his accusations following their visit. So, what happened: threatened the pharmacist with a law suit or bought him off?
As much as we admire Peyton and his two rings and his Hall-of-fame status, remember his brother also has two rings, won by lesser teams as in 'wild card' champs!
3
I don't admire Peyton Manning.
http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/sports/football/nfl/colts/2003-11-04-mann...
http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/sports/football/nfl/colts/2003-11-04-mann...
3
One has to go pretty low to belittle Peyton Manning, yet this writer has done it. Gee, thank you, NY Times.
37
Manning showed once again that he is above all a team player. It would seem unlikely he will go to another team. If he stays, then what happens with Brock Osweiler? That apparent conflict could lead to Manning doing one more, last, thing for the team. Retire. Here in Denver I expect people will go along with what ever he wants.
7
[[But players don’t think that way. Especially top ones like Manning. They like to drag out their answer when deciding whether to retire. They ponder and consult and consider. They make everyone else ponder and consider, too.]]
Your need for a storybook, drop the mike ending is meaningless. I'm sure he has an army of people at CAA to meet with before he announces anything. Endorsements, broadcast jobs, whatever. And he doesn't want to pull a Favre or a Jordan and un-retire.
Your need for a storybook, drop the mike ending is meaningless. I'm sure he has an army of people at CAA to meet with before he announces anything. Endorsements, broadcast jobs, whatever. And he doesn't want to pull a Favre or a Jordan and un-retire.
10
Tonight was not the time for a retirement announcement. Tonight was a night for celebration.
28
I get the idea that Macur really, really wanted Cam Newton and the "NFL fans are afraid of a black quarterback" meme to win, and is bitterly disappointed to be beaten by an old white guy. So she tears down Manning by any means possible.
13
Ms. Macur seems to make the same somewhat arrogant mistake so many other fans and sports writers commit, in saying how she agonizes so badly and that Manning will "make everyone else ponder and consider" just because he did not hog the spotlight. Why is she so concerned over his decision...when, why or where he will make it? She, and the fans, have no "skin" in the decision, and their interest will be zero after a few days, or a few minutes, whenever the next trivial sports incident will pop up. Mr. Manning showed complete poise along with respect for all of his fellow team members by not acting as if the game and the moment was all about him. He knew who the MVP would, and would not, be; his admirable actions earned respect for who he is as a gentleman (and a winner, btw), something that no amount of showboating and blathering self-importance would ever attain.
26
I couldn't disagree more. I think Manning's retirement is a forgone conclusion, ad he knows it, and he has enormous class and respect for his team. It wasn't "his" night. He didn't want to be a distraction from what was important at the moment, the TEAM winning the Super Bowl. I anticipate when the time is appropriate, in the next few days, Manning will announce his retirement.
41
Exactly.
1
This Super Bowl win was about the Broncos. Peyton can announce his decision after the team that got him there enjoys the limelight for a few weeks. I hope that he does the right thing now and does hang it up.
7
Cam should watch and learn some humility from Peyton.
29
Oh Cam had ALL the humility lessons he needed as he threw the ball away repeatedly and lost the ball without going for it. I'm sure he was humbled quite a bit last night.
His ego won't allow.
Personally, I don't care when he announces his retirement, just as long as he does it before football practice for the 2016-2017 season starts.
Other comments and Ms Macur have given the reasons it's time for him to leave. Perhaps his second Super Bowl win and the health issues he faces every day will be enough for him to accept aging and to go out after a winning season.
Other comments and Ms Macur have given the reasons it's time for him to leave. Perhaps his second Super Bowl win and the health issues he faces every day will be enough for him to accept aging and to go out after a winning season.
4
I was disappointed he did not just say it was a perfect ending for his career. I think it is the end, whether Peyton sees it or not, he contributed very little to the game. That defense was the best I have ever seen. I don't think I realized until last night that a defense really can win!!
I doubt he will have a job offer, even with the win. But it would be so much better if he just thanks America graciously and walks away on top.
I doubt he will have a job offer, even with the win. But it would be so much better if he just thanks America graciously and walks away on top.
4
And why would anyone think that he won't retire? He did everything last night to make it very clear that he was retiring except saying the word "retire". References to the effect of "capping off a career" and "reflecting back." Of course he is going to talk to his family and team first, and he wouldn't do that before the game out of respect for them and the distractions it would cause.
This snarky article sounds like it was written as a hit piece by a politician's campaign manager instead of a sports journalist.
This snarky article sounds like it was written as a hit piece by a politician's campaign manager instead of a sports journalist.
6
Jean-Paul Sartre wrote something Cam should think about:
“In football everything is complicated by the presence of the opposite team.”
“In football everything is complicated by the presence of the opposite team.”
15
He never took any drugs. Not that guy. You can scratch that off your list of worries. Good column, yes he should resign at the top. Why not coach, if he wants to stay involved. He'd be a heck of a quarterbacks coach.
7
Nope - Manning didn't take the HGH that was delivered to his home, it was his wife:
So, "average guy" show me a woman married to a professional foot-ball player in the US who would take HGH to bulk-up?
So, "average guy" show me a woman married to a professional foot-ball player in the US who would take HGH to bulk-up?
If one looks critically at Superbowl 50, it can be said that the Denver Broncos won the game without using a quarterback. For as much as Peyton Manning helped the cause, Gary Kubiak might have traded his headset for a helmet and taken snaps. Sentimentalists will scoff at such a critique, but, for all athletes, Father Time gets the ball last, and he always scores. Even against Peyton.
I don't quite understand what Peyton sees when he watches the film of his performances for the last several years? Does he think this stagger to the finish line burnishes his resume? He must, because still he doesn't feel a need to say, "It's been great, I'm finished." But, just as one is not to speak ill of the dead, one must hold his tongue when a legend insists "he still has it."
I don't quite understand what Peyton sees when he watches the film of his performances for the last several years? Does he think this stagger to the finish line burnishes his resume? He must, because still he doesn't feel a need to say, "It's been great, I'm finished." But, just as one is not to speak ill of the dead, one must hold his tongue when a legend insists "he still has it."
11
In that case I guess Newton should retire too? He was outplayed by Manning.
1
Maybe you missed Mr. Manning's 2013 season. Apparently you did, or you would not have said that he is staggering to the end.
Trash Peyton all you wish, but only one NFL starting QB ended the season with a win. The other 28 were losers.
Trash Peyton all you wish, but only one NFL starting QB ended the season with a win. The other 28 were losers.
1
"Last several years". ?????????
The entirety of the Broncos considerable success in 2012-14 was because of him. Several of their big name free agent signees stated that they came for the opportunity to play with He was the MVP of the league the season before last! He was terrific for much of last season as well - until suffering a lower body injury. This season he had other lower body injuries. He adapted to his neck injury just fine, it's the secondary injuries that have limited him.
It would be unreasonable for anyone to expect a team to be willing to enter the season with him as QB in his current condition, but it is reasonable for him to assume that - if healthy - he is NOT finished. The question is whether similar secondary injuries will recur frequently due to his age. Impossible to predict, and the decision is not subject to the ill informed whims of fans or media.
The entirety of the Broncos considerable success in 2012-14 was because of him. Several of their big name free agent signees stated that they came for the opportunity to play with He was the MVP of the league the season before last! He was terrific for much of last season as well - until suffering a lower body injury. This season he had other lower body injuries. He adapted to his neck injury just fine, it's the secondary injuries that have limited him.
It would be unreasonable for anyone to expect a team to be willing to enter the season with him as QB in his current condition, but it is reasonable for him to assume that - if healthy - he is NOT finished. The question is whether similar secondary injuries will recur frequently due to his age. Impossible to predict, and the decision is not subject to the ill informed whims of fans or media.
2
He should retire. The Denver defense was more of a factor in getting to the Super Bowl. Without them, the Broncos would've had an average year. Quit while the going to good, Peyton!
7
The Panrher defense was much more of a factor than Newton.
He should have announced his retirement.
He should have announced his retirement.
At least Manning is smart enough to see how he could help his team. Demoted to the bench, restored to the starting position, having just enough to not lose the game and keep Carolina guessing.
3
By the way, I am proud of myself, I read and wrote and did not watch at all. I love sports, but the Superbowl is too much for me.
And, did Peyton Manning actually personally advertise a certain beer during an interview after the game? Could this really have happened? Makes me even more pleased not to have watched, if so.
And, did Peyton Manning actually personally advertise a certain beer during an interview after the game? Could this really have happened? Makes me even more pleased not to have watched, if so.
3
He specifically named Budweiser. Surprised he's not going to Disneyland, too.
3
The things that friends tweet or post about what they see on TV are going to be right one time in twenty. Blogger reports from political people are even less reliable.
Yes, you said that you were proud of yourself for not watching in another article here on the Superbowl today. That, of course, begs the question why you comment on an article about the Superbowl that you were proud not to watch. Not interested? Cool. Leave the fun to us then.
6
I love the way Ms. Macur writes.
5
Well well, so there you have it. Juliet Macur is obviously a good journalist, but one can't help but wonder whether she's secretly hoping for the cheating stories about Peyton Manning to be true. Because there's no other explanation for this dismissive piece about one of the sports' greats. Tonight Peyton Manning clearly was not (or hasn't been) his great self, but that doesn't mean he deserve this kind of sendoff. But hey, I'm sure future the pieces referencing Peyton Mannings achievements won't include this one.
30
Yes a journalist. Not a fanboy.
1
Juliet Macur writes a fine article about why Peyton should retire, Absolutely spot on. Trouble is she seems to not have a "classiness" bone in her body. Peyton realizes that winning the SB is about the Bronco's team Juliet, it's not about him. How many times in how many ways does he have to tell YOU that? On center stage after the TEAM won, he is not stupid enough to announce his retirement.
8
Why not? He announced it at the AFC Championship game in Denver. He told the Patriots Coach and the media overheard and broadcast it. Where were you? Obviously not watching the game.
Manning probably said nothing because he did not want to shift the spotlight from his team and teammates victory onto him. It is too bad that this writer has to put a negative construction on his saying he would wait a while to decide. It is what any classy person should have done. And he did.
79
I totally disagree w the author of this story....it would have been inappropriate for Manning to announce his retirement after the Bronco's win....it would have taken away the glory and limelight that all of the Bronco players deserve.
109
Amen , A true sports writer would have seen through Peyton's responses and understood he was humbling himself for the sake of the team and the moment.
17
Surely, you jest: PM is viciously competitive, loves the adoration of the Denver whooping fans, and his wife admits she does not share the limelight with him. He is a one man show.
The writer makes it sound as Manning's future fate to suffer CTE is a fait accompli. In fact, many former football players don't display symptoms. Manning avoided a lot of head hits during his career unlike the hard charging lead with your ancient plastic helmet Kenny Stabler. There's a good chance Manning won't get it.
It is obviously important that CTE has been discovered. A sideline research question though is why so many former football players don't exhibit symptoms. Why some get it and many others don't is a key unknown in traumatic brain injury research.
There are many unanswered questions like this in concussion and TBI. The reason is that brain research into what's called the "silent epidemic" is 50 years behind other areas such as cancer and cardiovascular. Much more research is needed in order to answer this and other fundamental unanswered questions in concussion and TBI. With two million kids and adults going to hospital annually for concussion, this is not a minor question that affects only pro football players.
It is obviously important that CTE has been discovered. A sideline research question though is why so many former football players don't exhibit symptoms. Why some get it and many others don't is a key unknown in traumatic brain injury research.
There are many unanswered questions like this in concussion and TBI. The reason is that brain research into what's called the "silent epidemic" is 50 years behind other areas such as cancer and cardiovascular. Much more research is needed in order to answer this and other fundamental unanswered questions in concussion and TBI. With two million kids and adults going to hospital annually for concussion, this is not a minor question that affects only pro football players.
14
Given that some estimates are that more than 80% of NFL players suffer from some level of CTE, I would say that there is a great chance that Manning will encounter that down the road. How much it will affect his life is to be determined, as not all those who have ultimately been diagnosed (always after death) have had the same level of consequences.
1
Kudos to Manning for winning the Super Bowl. He's 2-2, has many of the QB records, and now it's time to go. He showed a lack of command of the offense tonight, little arm strength, and very limited mobility. Save your body, save your brain, so you can be with your boys and your family in as much an intact condition as possible. You have nothing more to accomplish on the field (you would never get to Brady's 4 and most likely 5 Super Bowl rings no matter how much longer you played. Say goodbye and push pizzas full-time.
11
I gather SG is a Patriots fan. So easy to be a Patriots fan.
1
If yos look at the box score you will see that he and Newton and very similar statistics with Manning having the better quarterback rating. He had all the command required to beat the highest scoring and 2nd best defensive team in the league. It is a team sport and winning is everything. Newton showed no command of the offense, mobility that go him sacked six times versus Manning's five and arm strength that resulted in no touchdowns and an interception. Newton failed and his team lost. Maybe Newton should be delivering the pizza Manning pushes. Never too late for a career change.
5
But don't forget that Tom Brady is only one year younger than Manning.
1
Thank you, NYT. And also looks like your 4th Down Bot has been quite wrong in the playoffs if that is what you were using to predict the scores. The latest one being Super Bowl which said 27-17 in favor of Carolina!
8
What I liked seeing during this year's Super Bowl was the gathering of Super Bowl MVP's dating back 50 years. Namath, Swann, Montana--it just went on and on. For all of NYT's bleating about CTE in the week leading up to the game, they seemed to be having a good time. They were all smiling. There was, perish the thought, obvious comraderie.
Do they have arthritis and aching knees and debilitating injuries? Yes, I'm sure that some of them do. But they are men. They are adults. Telling, the author does not say whether Montana would have done things any differently if he had the chance. And that is the absolute nut of all this. Would they have done things differently?
Football made these men wealthy. It brought them joy. Was Mike Webster lying when he talked about how much he loved the game? "He loved football, and that was life for him." That's what Ken Stabler's grandson said upon his election to the Hall of Fame. Was he lying?
Yes, football is dangerous. We all know that. The men who play the game know that. So give it a rest, NYT, and let grown ups make decisions for themselves. Manning is a grown up. He knows, much better than any newspaper writer, what is best for him.
Do they have arthritis and aching knees and debilitating injuries? Yes, I'm sure that some of them do. But they are men. They are adults. Telling, the author does not say whether Montana would have done things any differently if he had the chance. And that is the absolute nut of all this. Would they have done things differently?
Football made these men wealthy. It brought them joy. Was Mike Webster lying when he talked about how much he loved the game? "He loved football, and that was life for him." That's what Ken Stabler's grandson said upon his election to the Hall of Fame. Was he lying?
Yes, football is dangerous. We all know that. The men who play the game know that. So give it a rest, NYT, and let grown ups make decisions for themselves. Manning is a grown up. He knows, much better than any newspaper writer, what is best for him.
39
I saw how confused and crippled they seemed. Smiling yes, limping yes.
2
Great to see Joe Namath in particular. One of my all-time favorites. By the way, here's how he answered the question "Would you play football again?" earlier this year in an ABC News interview:
"No. I hate to say that because if I had a child who wanted to play I'd let them play ... but I'd wait 'til he developed a little more.
"This instrument that we have, that we have been blessed with ... it's not designed for the kind of contact or physical abuse your body gets playing this sport."
"No. I hate to say that because if I had a child who wanted to play I'd let them play ... but I'd wait 'til he developed a little more.
"This instrument that we have, that we have been blessed with ... it's not designed for the kind of contact or physical abuse your body gets playing this sport."
2
Ordinarily, I would agree with you. What makes this issue more complicated is that we, the spectators, are complicit in what happens to these players. Its not simply a question of playing a sport, it's because they perform for us.
2
He doesn't announce at the end of the game because he has class. Don't take the spotlight away from everyone else. Soak it in. Enjoy the last moments on the field. Looks like everyone knew it was his last game anyway.
93
Not enough class to omit the beer endorsement (twice), alas.
4
You almost wonder if he's setting himself up for a Budweiser distributorship in the future. Making sure to mention the type of beer he was going to be drinking was very odd.
2
According to Beer Business Daily (yes, there is apparently such a thing), Manning already is heavily invested in several Bud distributorships in Louisiana. And, I suspect, he will invest in several more. But, according to NFL rules, players are not allowed to endorse alcohol brands. So, does that mean he is not coming back, since he definitely "endorsed" Bud. And, according to a tweet from a Bud spokeswoman, he was not paid for the comments.
Bye - Bye Cam....
MVP-light... who couldn't complete a pass to save his life
Dab that Superbowl Ring
MVP-light... who couldn't complete a pass to save his life
Dab that Superbowl Ring
9
Some blogger types tried to make this a black guy white guy competition. No, it was a black guy, Von Miller, black guy Cam Newton competition. What I found striking was that the MVPs were mostly white guys. Was that a QB thing, based on the notion that black guys weren't smart enough to be QBs. Thank goodness that myth is over. Cam's day will come. He's got so much going for him. He's in the next generation of great NFL QBs.
2
Newton: "Why should I try to recover that fumble? Me, media darling might get hurt!"
3
The appropriate ending. .
A non-factor in a (terrible) game, won by his defense. .
But he can still go out "on top"- one of the greatest in-season players, but Certainly not post-season. .
And we won't have to hear about it anymore!
A non-factor in a (terrible) game, won by his defense. .
But he can still go out "on top"- one of the greatest in-season players, but Certainly not post-season. .
And we won't have to hear about it anymore!
4
You treat one of the greatest quarterbacks of all time with derision. Clearly you just hate football. Stop writing about it and write about tiddlywinks and whatever other games you love. The inability to appreciate Peyton Manning reflects an utter disdain for the game. Why write about a game you hate? You're out of touch with sports fans and out of touch with America. You've got plenty of readers, though, who are equally out of touch. Write about something they like. Write about hopscotch and jump rope and other great American sports.
48
The writer has every right to hate the game. And to hate our obsession with it.
She is simply outlining how vanity and hubris destroy lives.
Even the lives of the men who had enjoyed themselves in the glory of their youth.
She's just being honest. She's just doing her job. You don't like it? Then put go read a children's book. But not a fairy tale. Those can be kind of grim too.
She is simply outlining how vanity and hubris destroy lives.
Even the lives of the men who had enjoyed themselves in the glory of their youth.
She's just being honest. She's just doing her job. You don't like it? Then put go read a children's book. But not a fairy tale. Those can be kind of grim too.
26
Perfectly said.
8
Many people who highlight the dangers of playing football don't hate it. They love it, and wish it were safer for the players who put themselves at risk for our entertainment. To deny those dangers is the very definition of "out of touch."
2
Is the fame and money worth it?