California Today: In San Francisco, Public Art Soars High Into the Skyline

May 22, 2018 · 23 comments
Ed Watters (San Francisco)
You could put lipstick and pearls on that building (which resembles more than anything else, a giant butt plug) and it will still be an eyesore.
Teller (SF)
Here are the facts in the "BBQ Becky" story: "Lake Merritt has six designated barbecue zones ― three that permit charcoal grills and three designated for “non-charcoal portable grills,” according to the Oakland city website. The family was in a barbecue-designated area, but had a charcoal grill in a “non-charcoal” zone." So the "white" woman was right and the "black" people were wrong. As usual, it was made into racism! when the truth is the woman is just your typical pain-in-the-ass busybody neighbor.
Lemar (CoastalDweller)
It's obnoxious. Looks like a giant penis marring what used to be a uniquely subdued and welcoming skyline. No upper floor art project of any kind is going to make it look better.
dolly patterson (Silicon Valley)
It is despicable that the Orange County DA won't allow the man on death row to at least have his DNA tested before the County puts him to death. Absolutely despicable and I hope there is a time when this DA is in great need of mercy or help and remembers his selfish actions.
Mark Weiss (Palo Alto)
Reminds me of the superchunk song “Detroit has a skyline too”
PRB (Walnut Creek CA)
In the article (and comments) about the Salesforce Tower, I read no mention of collateral damage to bird. Avian mortality by impact with man-made structures is, like light pollution, a widespread phenomena. I like to think that considerations were made and preventative measure put in place. Any information?
John Doe (Johnstown)
From the picture, the lit top of The Salesforce Tower looks as if there's someone running away from a predictor. If nothing else, the "art" is contemporary.
visualplant (Sunnyvale, CA)
You cannot see the installation clearly enough to make any sense of it from far away, and can't see it at all from near the building. Whoops. Design flaw. Simple, culturally thematic, flashing colors – as on the Empire State Building – work well. Video sounds so cool, but it doesn't work in this setting. Duh.
CGR (Laguna Beach)
I completely missed the BBQ Becky story in Oakland. Disgraceful. But then the Becky memes with Obama, ML King, and Rosa Parks just made me laugh out loud. Bravo BBQing Blacks! Making lemonade out of lemons.
Amy Sung (Palo Alto)
It’ll be cool for the soaring tower to chime visually on the hour, the way town center did in the olden days.
Mia (San Francisco)
Generally and despite a lot of pay for play adulatory hype in local media, the public is at most lukewarm to this tower and it’s ‘me me me look at me’ wide stance — and in many cases downright appalled by it.
Robert (San Francisco)
The fact that the "John Doe's " of America don't like it gives me hope it might be something. People used to hate Christo's work until it was up and they actually experienced it. I can see the building from my Kitchen and hope this instillation improves the Sales Force Tower visually. The bar ain't high, so I look forward to this evening.
b (san francisco)
Did you read the proposal and attendant cost? http://commissions.sfplanning.org/cpcpackets/2012.0257EBX.pdf "To date, the sponsor has spent approximately $4.5 million on the art installation, which equals approximately 1.35% of the total construction cost. The sponsor has also allocated an additional allowance of approximately $1 million to complete installation"
culprit (nyc)
Yay, more corporate "art." Kinda looks like a giant Apple ad.
alison (san francisco)
While observing the trial run I found it crass and intrusive. The building already overwhelms the city without subjecting everyone in a 30 mile radius to the whims of this particular artist. The source of funding is irrelevant.
Colonel Belvedere (San Francisco)
The Salesforce Tower is an oversized obnoxious addition to the City’s skyline. It looks like a missile silo. How long before the art is replaced with ads?
Stephen (Los Angeles)
Jim Campbell has a captivating and lovely installation in the San Diego airport. You can see it here: https://instagram.com/p/Bf37uMDBrBi/
Vt (SF, CA)
Perhaps the artist in charge hit a few points. Downtown SF itself is better viewed from a mile or 2 away. Pity the countless homeless who 'live' to close to enjoy the nightly show. My guess: in a few months the abstract exhibition - on a truly massive skyline changing building - will be met with glancing ambivalence.
Occupy Government (Oakland)
"... a party at Lake Merritt along a placid stretch of the San Francisco Bay?" Really? Lake Merritt is in downtown Oakland, pretty much surrounded by buildings that are miles from the Bay.
John Doe (Johnstown)
Thanks, but I'll stick with the blinking neon cowboy saying "howdy" with one hand flashing to wave and welcome me in. That's art. What do techies today know about art anyway. The only Rembrandt they've ever seen is in garish LCD on an iPad. Makes him look like Pop-Artist.
Mark Holmes (Twain Harte, CA)
Ah, nice. A giant LED TV on the top of Salesforce tower for all the homeless people to enjoy. All Amazon needs to do is create some kind of GPS-enabled fob so they can get deliveries without having an address. Tech to the rescue!
b (san francisco)
As a fourth-generation San Francisco native-born, I agree. This makes me want to vomit, it's like a fig leaf of techno-garbage art while homeless veterans perish on our streets. A disgrace.
Mark Holmes (Twain Harte, CA)
Yeah, I lived in the city for many years, and enjoyed it. I'm a 6-time Burningman attendee, and in the last 6 years have moved to the woods to build a house with my wife. I'm simultaneously far more personally libertarian than in the past, and increasingly convinced that if we don't find some way to seriously address income inequality, we're totally doomed. Strange times we live in.