Letter of Recommendation: Seed Catalogs

Feb 02, 2017 · 14 comments
Jessica Van Nuys (<br/>)
For anyone who is really interested in gardening, this is a banal piece full of obvious information. And why a piece on CA gardening in the NYT?
John C (Auckland)
What is wrong with so many of the commentators on this charming piece? The nitpicking, the negativity, the fault-finding and the whingeing about issues real or imagined, not to mention the prognostications of doom? And who cares if the guy is based in Los Angeles? - you don't get any extra kudos for being in a climate with more distinct seasons. Or do these self-appointed critics think that you have to live in say, England or Vermont to write about this subject authoritatively?

What many of the kvetches here ignore is that the author is writing, well, about an aspect of gardening that helps remind the reader about the wonders of nature and how rewarding it can be to pursue an interest. I hope to read more from Willy Blackmore and would say to him, don't get discouraged by these nay-sayers. The internet lets them get up on their hind legs, but you are the one who is writing for the New York Times! ;-)
Mel (<br/>)
I'd also recommend a shoutout to Baker Creek since I'm pretty sure they're the inspiration for the line about "rutabagas that grow to be the size of small children." That's not an exaggeration--Baker Creek actually grows rutabagas that rival the size of a small child! They also send a free seed packet of something seasonal with every order.
Karen Cormac-Jones (Oregon)
Gardening with the spectre of global warming is not nearly as fun as it was in the past, when we were blissfully unaware. I also check for "drought tolerant" in addition to the usual "shade" or "sun" requirements as I thumb through the delights of seed catalogs. Of course, the occasional deluge after a drought and the hotter summers/colder winters pose new challenges. We are creating a new type of "Victory Garden" in a scary new century.
Swampqueen (The country)
I am a lifetime home gardener. I can say we HAVE come a long way from using the most up to the minute chemical treatments for pests and for fertilizer, row placement and commercial seed in the 60's-80's as trained by Extension Offices to where we are now in learning to go organic when doing pest control and fertilizer treatments, looking at what seed actually works in our region rather than accepting standard commercial varieties, and using raised beds with proper soil. I can say I have gone from growing the standard tomatoes, sweet corn, bush green beans, and watermelons to a whole cornucopia of vegetables whose origins are in the south like greasy beans, Seminole pumpkin squash, Virginia white gourdseed corn (a grinding corn), collards, Florida 91 tomatoes and more. Southern Exposure Seed Exchange has been a boon for me. Baker Creek Seed has catalogues whose images are veggie porn and a wide array of choices. Seed Savers is the foundation for localized varieties and should always be considered when planning.

A gardener who believes they know it all is one who is fated to failure. Gardening should be considered a never-ending education.
Bill (IL)
I was talking with a friend on a day a couple weeks ago when the temperature was in the 50's. I mentioned that I was ready to start planting my garden. He suggested that gardening was my hobby. I responded that I had never thought of it as a hobby. I was reminded of that conversation while reading this article. It occurs to me that it is more of a ritual, beginning with the selection of the seeds & plants, the care & preparation of the soil, the plantings, tending the growth while eliminating the weeds, the joyful harvests, and the cleaning and preparations for next year. It increases my connection to the earth, my home.
Video Non Taceo (New York, NY)
Kentucky Wonder, Blue Lake, Rattlesnake -- those string-beans cultivars are just three of the marvelous terms with which a seed catalogue can conjure. Keep reading and start planting, and continue writing.
Bill Hartman (Vineland, New Jersey)
This has been a wonderful piece celebrating the blessings and bounty of growing beautiful vegetables & fruits. But, let me rain on this splendid parade of mother earth by sharing a warning by Wendell Berry: “I have no doubt at all that even if the global climate were getting better, our abuses of the land would still be the disaster most seriously threatening to the survival of humans and other creatures. Land abuse, I know, is pretty much a global phenomenon.But it is not happening in the whole world as climate change happens in the whole sky. It is happening, because if can happen,only locally, in small places, where the people who commit the abuses also live. And so my question has been, and continues to be, What can cause people to destroy the places where they live, the humans and other creatures who are their neighbors,
and ultimately themselves? How can humans willingly turn against the earth, of which they are made, from which they live? To treat that as a scientific and technological or political question is not enough, is even misleading. The question immediately and at least is economic: What is wrong with the way we are keeping house, the way we make our living, the way we live? (What is wrong with our minds?) And to take the economic question seriously enough is right away to ask another that is also but not only economic: What is happening to our souls?”
sage 55 (northwest ohio)
Please read Robin Wall Kimmerer's 'Braiding Sweetgrass'. It helps underline the urgency and beauty of our ecosystems under attack and how we can give back. Her insight as a scientist and Native American is extremely helpful for those of us who are exasperated with the 'accepted mindlessness' when it comes to caring about our environment.
Congratulations Mr. Blackmore on your first article here. When you grow your own food and a history geek, seed catalogues are a wonderful source of pleasure. Be sure to thank the companies who still print and mail. And of course recycle. The pages make great wrapping paper.
Hank (Santa Monica, CA)
Surely some sort of shout out to Seedsavers is in order? No mention of the amazing work that they and others do in making sure you have access to these seeds seems like an overlooked opportunity!
cindy (Maine)
This was Mr. Blackmore's essay, not yours. Why don't you write an essay about Seedsavers? There are nicer ways to bring up your pet idea without chiding the author.
Doug (Teaneck NJ.)
Here in the Northeast the arrival of seed catalogs is even more meaningful, because it's a sign in the depth of winter that spring will come again. The catalogs remind us that we are part of nature, at the same time godlike bringing new life to the world from tiny seeds. There are few things as edifying as successfully nurturing a plant from seed to a successful plant, perhaps ultimately sitting in the shade of a tree that you grew from a seedling
M. L. Chadwick (Portland, Maine)
And many of us here in Maine adore the Fedco catalog, which has an astonishing variety of heirloom seeds, complete with background info on them!
Max (Moscow)
While having good less romantic appeal than a seed catalog, the National Plant Germplasm System, administered by the USDA, maintains one of the largest repositories in the world of plant germplasm, includes seeds.